Aller au contenu

Photo

The Onion's AV Club wasn't impressed with the demo...


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
176 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Mr.Dioneo

Mr.Dioneo
  • Members
  • 41 messages
http://www.avclub.co...-clubs-p,57432/

Judged in light of this game’s huge potential—Mass Effect was reasonably good, and Mass Effect 2 was The A.V. Club’s top game of 2010—the Mass Effect 3
demo was the most disappointing on the show floor. It was awful. The
low point was a scene shown at the end of the presentation. Attendees
were warned beforehand that this sequence would pack an emotional
wallop. It showed the hero of the series, Commander Shepard, trying to
save a boy from an alien invasion. Put it this way: If the scene were
submitted to the Hallmark Channel as a treatment for a Christmas
special, it would be rejected with the note “Too hokey.”
The old: The sad-little-boy sequence was the worst of the
demo, but the rest was almost as bad, as director Casey Hudson prattled
on about combat features like mêlée assassinations and hand grenades as
if they were exciting innovations, rather than mundane
third-person-shooter staples that gamers have seen countless times
before.
The new-ish: The traditional Mass Effect dialogue wheel remains, but with Mass Effect 3,
if you have a Kinect, you can yell your dialogue choices at the TV
rather than using the controller. Jesus Christ, BioWare. Please do not
screw this game up.


Yikes!

I just replayed ME2, and enjoyed it more this time (with the DLC) than I think I did the first two times I played.  Please don't have ME3 be another DA2...

Modifié par Mr.Dioneo, 06 juillet 2011 - 07:12 .


#2
TheKillerAngel

TheKillerAngel
  • Members
  • 3 608 messages
Proof?

#3
Mr.Dioneo

Mr.Dioneo
  • Members
  • 41 messages
Sorry, I originally submitted the thread before adding the quote from the AV Club...

#4
therussianviking

therussianviking
  • Members
  • 203 messages
well with a name like the Onion I feel like they NEED to be pricks.

#5
Mister Mida

Mister Mida
  • Members
  • 3 239 messages
Well, they have a right to their opinion. It's up to you if you want to take it seriously.

#6
exskeeny

exskeeny
  • Members
  • 499 messages
And so we see one persons opinion doom a whole franchise. That's right people you saw it happen here.

#7
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

exskeeny wrote...

And so we see one persons opinion doom a whole franchise. That's right people you saw it happen here.


The Bioware Defense Force leaps into action!

#8
AngelicMachinery

AngelicMachinery
  • Members
  • 4 300 messages
I can't wait to scream "i've had enough of your disingenuous assertions." It'll be awesome.

#9
Siansonea

Siansonea
  • Members
  • 7 281 messages
You can't judge a game by its demo.

#10
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Siansonea II wrote...

You can't judge a game by its demo.


Actually you can. That's the entire point of a demo.

#11
TheKillerAngel

TheKillerAngel
  • Members
  • 3 608 messages
We saw everything they saw and our reactions were generally not as negative. I showed some footage to a friend yesterday who was on the fence about ME3 and now he wants to buy it.

A lot of people here actually liked the boy. I was indifferent to it but I guess it's reasonable some people would dislike it.

#12
Cainne Chapel

Cainne Chapel
  • Members
  • 2 301 messages
So a guy didn't like a Demo for the game *shrug* not really news here I dont think.

I didn't play the demo... i watched it, but I had no problems with it. I thought it looked good and was left wanting more, this guy went the opposite route.

I really dont see what was SO BAD about the demo but to each their own. It does seem as if he had a BIT of a chip on his shoulder though...

#13
exskeeny

exskeeny
  • Members
  • 499 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

exskeeny wrote...

And so we see one persons opinion doom a whole franchise. That's right people you saw it happen here.


The Bioware Defense Force leaps into action!

Not at all, but you cannot judge a whole game on a demo and marketing speak.I always reserve full opinion on a game until I play it.

You will find that this demo is long before the game goes gold so is likely to change. If it doesn't I will judge the entire scene in context.

Modifié par exskeeny, 06 juillet 2011 - 07:25 .


#14
Guest_Zeta030_*

Guest_Zeta030_*
  • Guests
Last time I checked, the game had around a year left of development. I'm sure they can make it at least a little better than the demo, don't you think?

Modifié par Zeta030, 06 juillet 2011 - 07:26 .


#15
DCarter

DCarter
  • Members
  • 406 messages
They make a decent point. Melee kills and grenades are hardly revolutionary and the kinect system seems like just another redundant gimmick. However for me and i believe most people the mass effect series lives or dies by it's storyline. This being the conclusion of this storyline, there's a lot to do and very little room to hide.

#16
Guest_Puddi III_*

Guest_Puddi III_*
  • Guests
*cancels preorder*

#17
the_one_54321

the_one_54321
  • Members
  • 6 112 messages

exskeeny wrote...

Saphra Deden wrote...

exskeeny wrote...
And so we see one persons opinion doom a whole franchise. That's right people you saw it happen here.

The Bioware Defense Force leaps into action!

Not at all, but you cannot judge a whole game on a demo and marketing speak.I always reserve full opinion on a game until I play it.

The current bar has been set by DAII. That bar was set at "the doom sayers were right."

#18
Cainne Chapel

Cainne Chapel
  • Members
  • 2 301 messages
If you read the whole piece he actually criticizes...pretty much everything from ME3, to Uncharted 3 to Skyrim. Some not as snarky as others but it does seem like an "Angry" gamer type editorial

#19
rft

rft
  • Members
  • 286 messages
I didn't find it that bad....It Wasn't best on the floor but it still wasn't terrible. On the ME3 website, it even says that Bioware won awards for being the best of E3. Weird opinion. 

Modifié par rft, 06 juillet 2011 - 07:30 .


#20
HBC Dresden

HBC Dresden
  • Members
  • 1 707 messages
They weren't impressed with the presentation of the demo. And their writing style favors a scathing tone. The two mixed together is not a pretty picture. But when they eventually review the game, all these "third person staples" that were presented as "fresh" in the demo (which they didn't like) can only be pros for the game. This is more or less a result of what BioWare chose to show and what they could not show. But I don't know why the article did not mention the Reaper invasion of Vancouver, that was spectacular.

#21
DWH1982

DWH1982
  • Members
  • 2 619 messages
Yeah, whatever.

I've liked what I've seen so far. Enough to pre-order the collector's edition, in fact.

#22
BatmanPWNS

BatmanPWNS
  • Members
  • 6 392 messages
It's their opinion so no big deal.

#23
exskeeny

exskeeny
  • Members
  • 499 messages

the_one_54321 wrote...

exskeeny wrote...

Saphra Deden wrote...

exskeeny wrote...
And so we see one persons opinion doom a whole franchise. That's right people you saw it happen here.

The Bioware Defense Force leaps into action!

Not at all, but you cannot judge a whole game on a demo and marketing speak.I always reserve full opinion on a game until I play it.

The current bar has been set by DAII. That bar was set at "the doom sayers were right."

true. I really enjoyed DA2 to start but I lost my way with it after a few playthroughs. I hope sincerely that it isn't the same with ME3

#24
Captain Crash

Captain Crash
  • Members
  • 6 933 messages

rft wrote...

I didn't find it that bad....It Wasn't best on the floor but it still wasn't terrible. On the ME3 website, it even says that Bioware won awards for being the best of E3. Weird opinion. 


Did it now? :whistle:  http://social.biowar...3/index/7814025  


Anyway it seems odd they say ME2 was there top game and then slam an innovative combat system in the Demo. Yeah sure it may be staple in other games, but its a vast improvement on ME2!!  

ME3 will be story driven and the demo of course provides very little info.   Im not at all worried

#25
CroGamer002

CroGamer002
  • Members
  • 20 672 messages
My question is, why?

They don't explain why is bad. They just say it is.