Aaleel wrote...
You're not understanding what I said.
Fair enough. I thought were claiming that the Darkspawn hadn't actually been in the prison for all that time, merely that the prison existed, or something similar.
I said that the Grey Wardens built the prison to hold that darkspawn, and put in place magic that will last and hold it 2000 years. But if the darkspawn has not left the prison, the magic must still be in place. So 2000 years has not passed. The darkspawn says if I can't leave with you, I'll leave through you, so it's still in prison the magic is still in place.
It doesn't actually say this. It is said that the Grey Wardens built the prison, and that whatever measures they took are now fading. The 2000 figure is only ever mentioned by what is presumably the Prisoner - so it's hardly a bad assumption to make that he's been stuck in there for that time. Why would he know how long it lasts? You think Grandpa Hawke told him just before turning the key?
I guess there is the possibility that the Grey Wardens used some well known and highly precise magical binding that lasts exactly 2000 years and the Conductor knew this, but frankly this sounds a little silly and doesn't really fit with the tone of the Grey warden's mention earlier on. It's far more likely the Conductor is talking about how long he's been stuck in there.
Someone in the trailer says 2000 the years the magic holds, but it's been broken, but you hold the key to its death. So the magic seal never reached it's 2000 year time limit, so the 2000 year timeline people are using is wrong. It could only be 1000 years into seal for all we know.
As I said, given that the impression given by the wardens is that it's fading, this idea of a hard limit that hasn't been reached yet (and presumably won't be reached until several hundred years have passed) doesn't really make any sense. If whatever ancient evil is good for safekeeping for another few centuries, does it really make any sense for the Wardens to suddenly try and meddle with it a few years after a blight? What's the point? Why not just leave him where he is?
The whole DLC only actually makes any sense if whatever is wrong with the prison
is going to come to a head imminently.