89 réponses à ce sujet

[Radwar]

I personally like the novels and hope some character's from them will appear in ME3.

[vader da slayer]

MysticMage44 wrote...

The problem I have with the books is that they make canon some of the choices from the games. Meaning that if you did not choose a choice in the game that coincides with the books it all seems a little off. I did not read the books but I heard that *Spoilers* Shep keeps the reaper base *end spoilers* among other things. Since I didn't not do these things in my game I feel like the books are not even relevant to my playthoughs. I wish the books would have stayed completely away from Sheps decisions. That being said, It would be interesting to meet some of these book characters and see how they react to MY decisions.

book doesn't make anything canon. in the newest book (the only book that comes after the events of ME2) it is said that Shepard "destroyed the operations" at the Collector base. if you didn't blow it up you killed all the collectors there and thus destroyed what they are doing by proxy and if you blew it up you litterally destroyed operations there.

Modifié par vader da slayer, 11 juillet 2011 - 05:59 .

[mulder1199]

eh, perhaps bioware goes for the happy medium...you get a namedrop/email from/of gillian and/or kahlee....they've been mentioned for those that want to see them....they don't appear for those that don't.....

for the faults of her idealized character, one of the steadfast mentions of kahlee is her knowledge of AI....she may be useful...

[dantares83]

AwesomeName wrote...

Regardless of whether or not she's a rubbish character, Sanders should be really important to the whole story, so I'd actually be annoyed if she didn't show up in ME3. Isn't she supposed to be one of the foremost experts on AI? Plus she's studying stuff that could be significant to our fight against the Reapers. As for Gillian, isn't she supposed to be the most powerful human biotic in existence? I'd be quite disappointed if we didn't see her in the quarian fleet.

yah, I agree... these 2 characters received too much attention to not make an appearance in the game (unless they die in the coming book because I presume the events of the books will happened before ME3).

the only canon from the book/comics is that

1) Udina is make counciler
2) Shepard will live no matter what (which is the only way for ME3 to continue anyway)
3) the base is destroyed (but it could also meant that all collectors are dead)

[HighMoon]

I'll be really angry (and sad) if Gillian dies. :[

Like Hendel, I couldn't help but feel protective of her throughout ascension, even though I don't have a daughter of my own. Speaking of Hendel, I also hope he makes an appearance. And Kahlee, who has played such a major part in all 3 novels. It will suck if any of them die.

[Kidd]

I doubt Kahlee will join our squad. If anyone from the books would be joining us on the Normandy, I bet that would be Gillian. Or perhaps that's just what I hope for, since I love Gillian ^^

[Sjaddix]

Kahlee could join certainly her skills could be useful. On the issue of Gillian it would be nice but how many biotics do u need?

[Lunatic LK47]

Golden-Rose wrote...

I'll be really angry (and sad) if Gillian dies. :[

Like Hendel, I couldn't help but feel protective of her throughout ascension, even though I don't have a daughter of my own. Speaking of Hendel, I also hope he makes an appearance. And Kahlee, who has played such a major part in all 3 novels. It will suck if any of them die.

I'd actually be happy if the novel characters are in their little part of the story, but I do not want them interacting with the game because I hate them that much. Horribly written character= death on sight.

[dantares83]

Lunatic LK47 wrote...

Golden-Rose wrote...

I'll be really angry (and sad) if Gillian dies. :[

Like Hendel, I couldn't help but feel protective of her throughout ascension, even though I don't have a daughter of my own. Speaking of Hendel, I also hope he makes an appearance. And Kahlee, who has played such a major part in all 3 novels. It will suck if any of them die.

I'd actually be happy if the novel characters are in their little part of the story, but I do not want them interacting with the game because I hate them that much. Horribly written character= death on sight.

not all the characters r horribly written... besides, Drew and Marc (for comic series ) are part of the writing team for ME (game series), if you don't like their writing, I can't see you liking the game either..

Modifié par dantares83, 13 juillet 2011 - 04:46 .

[shepskisaac]

Didn't read the books, but Gillian being an autistic biotic sounds like a very interesting premise for a character with potential for tons of development.

[Lunatic LK47]

dantares83 wrote...



I'd actually be happy if the novel characters are in their little part of the story, but I do not want them interacting with the game because I hate them that much. Horribly written character= death on sight.

not all the characters r horribly written... besides, Drew and Marc (for comic series ) are part of the writing team for ME (game series), if you don't like their writing, I can't see you liking the game either..

Uh, Mac was responsible for Garrus and Wrex, and I liked those two over everyone Drew wrote, including ME1 Liara. Only one I remotely liked was Anderson, but that's not saying much.

Modifié par Lunatic LK47, 18 juillet 2011 - 01:55 .

[AVPen]

dantares83 wrote...

the only canon from the book/comics is that

1) Udina is make counciler
2) Shepard will live no matter what (which is the only way for ME3 to continue anyway)
3) the base is destroyed (but it could also meant that all collectors are dead)

A decision which I hope to god isn't made the "official" canon for ME3. <_<

Modifié par AVPen, 18 juillet 2011 - 05:22 .

[SchnityMcGee]

I genuinely liked the books. I think Kahlee would be underwhelming as a squad mate simply because she isn't as powerful as the people we are used to getting as squad mates. Gillian is powerful enough but WAY too young... and she's autistic. I think the book characters should have brief cameos but not much more.