Aller au contenu

Photo

I'll Be the First to Complain: What was the point in destroying the Collector Base?


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
1939 réponses à ce sujet

#1126
nhsk

nhsk
  • Members
  • 1 382 messages

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Cerberus isn't anti-aliens, but Pro-humans. Big difference. TIM doesn't hate or want other aliens exterminated.
He just wants a very sensible thing politicly - for humans to have enough power and influence that no one can dominate them. Because that's how things simply work in the real world. We humans are more similar to eachother than we are to any potential aliens, and take a look at the political landscape. I'm no nationalist, but the world and political/power structures in the end always are. The strong always have more power and influence than the weak.

Cooperation and holding hands is nice - but only if you have a big stick to make sure you're not being dragged by that hand.


"To ensure human dominance"

Dominance.. Hmmm, my interpretation of that: He wants to be the one dragging the others...

#1127
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages
Then again, you'll only have rivals if you make them so.

You think the volus and the turians would be working together if they had the same stubbornness and determination to be independent and dominant like the humans? No, they'd be way in over their heads.

#1128
nhsk

nhsk
  • Members
  • 1 382 messages
People should stop treating the other species as aliens but instead as humans from another culture, we are all sapient beings capable of understanding, learning, emotion.

#1129
Guest_Luc0s_*

Guest_Luc0s_*
  • Guests

Saphra Deden wrote...

It's not an exact analogy, I know. Why do you people have to overanalyze analogies like that? ****ing hell.

I only meant it was our WWII in the sense that it would leave the aliens weaker and humanity stronger. You could apply this to the entire series really.


That's ****ing bull**** and you know it. If you haven't noticed, the reapers are targeting EARTH and HUMANITY.

By the time the reapers are done with us, there hardly is any humanity left. Maybe they'll leave enough humans alive to build a new human reaper, but if I see the trailers from ME3 I get the feeling that they don't even care about a human reaper anymore, they just want revenge.

Seriously, we humans are F*CKED and we NEED the help of the other races if we want to survive this reaper armada.

#1130
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages
[quote]Saphra Deden wrote...
Maybe. keep in mind this happens if they lost the Destiny Ascension which represented something like half of the asari military's firepower all by itself. They are not a militant people either.[/quote]

I don't recall reading this in the codex or seeing it in-game. Was it in one of the books?

[quote]So which is more likely? That they're building up a huge force on their own or that they just decided to pull out all together and cede their responsibility to the turians? [/quote]

As much as the asari are about singining and holding hands, I think it works best for humanity if we assume a military build-up and use the potential of that threat to build up our fleets. Even if the asari don't actually have the industrial capacity, as Shepard says to Udina at the end of ME1, "we'll need to use our fleets". 

[quote]Which is exactly what is happening. If you hang around the Citadel after the Collector Ship but before the IFF mission you can hear a report about the 5th Fleet stopping by Patavig. The response is volus independence movements staging protests.[/quote]

I missed that. That's a good development for humanity.

[quote]An excellent development for humanity and a forboding one for the turians.[/quote]

Indeed. And we if we extend a branch to the volus, crop them up and help them expand economically at the expense of the former Council races, we can use that to make overtures to the salarians to show them the benefit to a human galaxy.

[quote]No, it was not. The Normandy SR1 is an Alliance ship. Once Shepard becomes a Spectre and starts commanding it the SR1 is said to be "on loan" to the Council. It should be obvious who owns the ship judging by the crew which is all Alliance and Admiral Mikhailovic's statement that had it not been for Shepard being made a Spectre he and the SR1 would have been assigned to Mikhailovic's squadron/fleet/whatever. [/quote]

When I say it was a Council ship, I don't mean the SR1 was part of the Citadal fleet. I mean the Citadel took part in its development, and it doesn't not make sense for them (especially the turians) to knowingly give humanity a technical advantage.

[quote]It isn't even evident that the blue prints were given to the Council, or "surrendered". The Council sponsored working with the turians to improve relations and towards that end they paid for some of the construction/development. It isn't apparent how much of the bill they covered but judging by Mikhailovic's complaints about how many ships they could have had in place of the Normandy, and the fact that the Normandy is an Alliance ship and not a Council one, we can safely assume the Alliance covered most of the costs.[/quote]

We don't know how much the Normandy cost; the total may have been twice as high. 

[quote]The truth is that behind the scenes it was The Illusive Man/Cerberus who pushed the Alliance to reach out to the turians in the first place. The goal being of-course to see how turians build ships. However this further reinforces the idea that the real guts of the ship are human innovations and not turian ones. [/quote]

Now that we're on this, I think the real role behind the SR1 was to asssess turian engineering. Think about it: we can develop technology faster than we can. If we get access to most of their blueprients, ship designs, etc. in return for the turians having access to ours, we are ahead of the game. In 10 years, we can retrofit our fleet and have newer designs of cruisers and fighters. The turians won't, becuae they haven't in 1000 years. 

To get back to what I said originally, I'm not saying the SR1 and steal technology isn't an advantage; I'm saying that it can't form the basis, because it looks like we traded away an early technological edge for intel on a group of species that simply have stagnated technologically. 

[quote]Remember: the turians helping build it was little more than PR and some light espionage. [/quote]

Kaidan was convinced Nihilus was on-board to oversee the investment of the Normandy. 

[quote]The Battle of the Citadel changed everything and even if that battle had never taken place humanity was still growing. The attack on the Citadel just let us skip forward in power and influence a few years. It would have happened anyway. Humanity was already important enough to have an embassy and a Spectre and they hadn't even really begun to tap all the resources available to them in the Traverse. [/quote]

The Battle of the Citadel decimated the Citadel races militarily and gave us a chance to show our power - we won a political victory over them without ever having to fight a war. Just like defeating the turians ships in the First Contact war gave them their first loss since the krogan rebellions, the Battle of the Citadel showed the galaxy the Council alone can't protect them, but humanity can.

[quote]The Council isn't the source of power; the Citadel is. It is the most important trading hub in the galaxy and is an impenetrable fortress. That's what gives the Council a lot of its power. Humanity having the Council in its pocket means it also has the Citadel. With it we can hamper trade for the other races if they give us trouble. Of-course that is a double edged sword in many ways, but our possession of the station greatly enhances humanity's power and influence beyond what it would normally be. [/quote]

I didn't think of it that way. That's a very good point.

[quote]The Citadel is the literal hub of the mass relay network and the mass relays are what allows galactic commerce in the first place. [/quote]

Like I said: good point. I didn't consider the strategic value to us. 

#1131
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

Phaedon wrote...
That's incredibly naive. Do you think that every time an independence movement pops up among the trillions of people it changes anything?

How exactly will the volus protect themselves without the turians?

Let's be realistic here.

 

Political instability. We don't need the volus to actually be independent... we just need the turians to crack down on them. At that point, humanity can step in and apply greater political pressure. 

As the Council, we can pass a resolution (or whatever it is the Council does legally, edicts. etc) to affirm that all species should be self-governing and autonomous as a principle of fundamental justice. We don't have client states and we are, esentially, the galactic government so all races should be a client state to us. 

#1132
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Cerberus isn't anti-aliens, but Pro-humans. Big difference.


Cerberus says they're pro-human... but they're not. They're pro-ubermensch.

TIM wants a race of genettically superior biotics. He looks at Jack and Miranda and thinks every future human should be like that. We don't need to fundamentally rebuild or re-alter the fabric of our species to rise to the top of the galaxy. 

He just wants a very sensible thing politicly - for humans to have enough power and influence that no one can dominate them. 


That's not what makes Cerberus abhorent. It's what TIM thinks Cerberus needs to do to humanity to make them powerful (and not in the nonsense 'sacrifice our soul' sense) but rather in the practical, genetic engineering sense.

#1133
Guest_Luc0s_*

Guest_Luc0s_*
  • Guests
Basically TIM is a little bit like the Adolf Hitler of the future.

Modifié par Luc0s, 17 juillet 2011 - 03:34 .


#1134
Chewin

Chewin
  • Members
  • 8 478 messages
^Eh?

#1135
Lotion Soronarr

Lotion Soronarr
  • Members
  • 14 481 messages

nhsk wrote...

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Cerberus isn't anti-aliens, but Pro-humans. Big difference. TIM doesn't hate or want other aliens exterminated.
He just wants a very sensible thing politicly - for humans to have enough power and influence that no one can dominate them. Because that's how things simply work in the real world. We humans are more similar to eachother than we are to any potential aliens, and take a look at the political landscape. I'm no nationalist, but the world and political/power structures in the end always are. The strong always have more power and influence than the weak.

Cooperation and holding hands is nice - but only if you have a big stick to make sure you're not being dragged by that hand.


"To ensure human dominance"

Dominance.. Hmmm, my interpretation of that: He wants to be the one dragging the others...


Well, the only way to ensure others are not dragging you is to have enough power. As a side-effect of that, you also have the power to drag them. That's the nature of the beast.
Take a look at US, Russia, China - they are dominating nations. Every other nation wants to take their place. TI's rather natural.

#1136
Lotion Soronarr

Lotion Soronarr
  • Members
  • 14 481 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

Then again, you'll only have rivals if you make them so.

You think the volus and the turians would be working together if they had the same stubbornness and determination to be independent and dominant like the humans? No, they'd be way in over their heads.


Rivalry can be a healthy thing. Why do you immediatly apply hostility and agression to it?
Go ahed, tell the US they should disband their army, dismantle their nukes and share their best tech will all lesser nations. Tehy them they should stop thrying ot be the top dog. See how they will laugh.
and yeah...the US, despite beign dominant, seems to have plenty of allies. So I fail to see your point, if you had any.



nhsk wrote...

People should stop treating the other
species as aliens but instead as humans from another culture, we are all
sapient beings capable of understanding, learning, emotion.


But they aren't humans. They're aliens. Treating someone as something he is not is even MOIRE racist!



In Exile wrote...

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Cerberus isn't anti-aliens, but Pro-humans. Big difference.


Cerberus says they're pro-human... but they're not. They're pro-ubermensch.

TIM
wants a race of genettically superior biotics. He looks at Jack and
Miranda and thinks every future human should be like that. We don't need
to fundamentally rebuild or re-alter the fabric of our species to rise
to the top of the galaxy. 

He just wants a very sensible thing politicly - for humans to have enough power and influence that no one can dominate them. 


That's
not what makes Cerberus abhorent. It's what TIM thinks Cerberus needs
to do to humanity to make them powerful (and not in the nonsense
'sacrifice our soul' sense) but rather in the practical, genetic
engineering sense.



Some exact quote or proof of TIM's wishes?
We know TIM knows abut the Repaers and is trying to prepare humanity for war.
At no point did I run into anything that states he want's a race of ubermench..

And even if he did..so what?

#1137
Dean_the_Young

Dean_the_Young
  • Members
  • 20 684 messages
(Walks back to thread after half-week absence to find 46 pages why not keep the base, as opposed to whether if reasons for destroying it have been subverted by all the newest post-ME2 literature.)

Well, that sort of went off the topic I intended.

(Walks back out.)

#1138
string3r

string3r
  • Members
  • 461 messages
To ****** of TIM.

#1139
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Rivalry can be a healthy thing. Why do you immediatly apply hostility and agression to it?
Go ahed, tell the US they should disband their army, dismantle their nukes and share their best tech will all lesser nations. Tehy them they should stop thrying ot be the top dog. See how they will laugh.
and yeah...the US, despite beign dominant, seems to have plenty of allies. So I fail to see your point, if you had any.


I can't care less about what the US is doing, since it's not about them.

Point is that humanity could more than likely benefit more from partnership than rivallry, since it's more about aliens with unknown and relatively untapped potentials when it comes to technical and perhaps political advances.

Not to mention that there are some things aliens like the asari or the quarians are clearly better than the humans at. Creating tension between us and those groups like Cerberus is constantly doing won't solve anything. 

#1140
Lotion Soronarr

Lotion Soronarr
  • Members
  • 14 481 messages
It is about relation, hence the US comparison. There is NOTHING, I repeat, NOTHING wrong with wanting to be the top dog or taking care of your own first.
Cerberus want's humanity to be strong independent, which is a good goal.
By separating from the Alliance, they can continue to work on their goal (making humanity stronger) without restrictions, while the Alliance can continue to strengthen relations. Win-win.

Makes you wonder is Cerberus went rouge for that specific reason - so the Alliance cannot be blaimed.

#1141
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

In Exile wrote...

I don't recall reading this in the codex or seeing it in-game. Was it in one of the books?


It's dialogue when you're looking at the Destiny Ascension. I don't remember if this takes place on the Normandy or on the Citadel. Also I'll come right up and admit that this is largely hyperbole, but there is probably some truth to it. A lot of truth, even. I mean, just look at the thing. It's huge, bigger than the dreadnought we can see guarding the Citadel in ME2.

So the destruction the Destiny Ascension was a huge loss for them as that one ship alone represented a significant proportion of their firepower.


In Exile wrote...

As much as the asari are about singining and holding hands, I think it works best for humanity if we assume a military build-up and use the potential of that threat to build up our fleets.


Well no argument there.


In Exile wrote...

...if we extend a branch to the volus, crop them up and help them expand economically at the expense of the former Council races, we can use that to make overtures to the salarians to show them the benefit to a human galaxy.


Exactly.

In Exile wrote...

I mean the Citadel took part in its development, and it doesn't not make sense for them (especially the turians) to knowingly give humanity a technical advantage.


...and they didn't. Humanity invented that technology on its own. They just helped us cover some of the costs of building the thing and improved relations. Both sides have an interest in improved relations after all. The Council wants a less independent humanity that will be more willing to blend in with the rest of galactic society. Humanity wants to look good and wants more influence with the Council.

It's entirely possible the Council and turians have the full blue prints of the Normandy, but it's not certain and I don't think humanity would ever give up that kind of advantage willingly. If the Council demanded that we turn over that kind of secret we'd just refuse to take part in the deal. Remember, the whole thing is on the surface it's just public relations.


Considering Cerberus managed to build a bigger, more advanced replica of the Normandy I don't think the cost was much higher than what Mikhailovic implied. Otherwise I don't think even Cerberus could afford it. Not with the expense spent on Shepard and their other projects as well. There's only so much money Cerberus can hide. That many huge expenditures at once would be easy for hostile agencies to uncover.

In Exile wrote...

To get back to what I said originally, I'm not saying the SR1 and steal technology isn't an advantage; I'm saying that it can't form the basis, because it looks like we traded away an early technological edge for intel on a group of species that simply have stagnated technologically.


Sure, it's possible. Either way we're just speculating. Unless we see evidence of non-human stealth ships I'm going to assume there aren't any.


Another a few thoughts about the Council and Citadel...

The other races have been using the Citadel for thousands of years now. The Council, especially for the old Council races, has become the center of galactic power and government. For them I think it is safe to say that the Council was in many ways an extension of their own individual governments. Everything they did centered around the Citadel.

What this means for us is that we can cause them a lot of inconvenience by restricting access to it if necessary. Ultimately restricting trade can hurt us more than it does them in the end because they have larger economies, but, it can still be a big enough hassle for them that they won't want to provoke us. Even if they know that in the long term we'll have to cave first, they also know that in the mean-time their economies will be hurting. What that means is that they'll have lots of interests on their side pushing them not to rock the boat. Rocking the boat costs money.

Another thing is that the truth is the human Council is weaker than the old Council. It has to be, because it has a smaller military all total and it has worse diplomatic ties with the rest of the galaxy. What this means is that it will sooner or later have to reach out to the other races to increase it standing. The "lesser races" make good candidates because they have no real reason to be angry with the new Council. After all, they neither gained nor lost anything on the surface. This presents an opportunity for the human Council to reach out to them and gain their widespread support.

The old Council races can then more easily be pitted against each-other. The goal is to make everybody compete for the human Council's favor. That environment would greatly inflate the human Council's influence.

It is similar to the situation the asari had going for them on the old Council. If you read the codex it talks about how the asari like to keep the galaxy "balanced". However "balance" has a peculiar definition. It does not mean everybody is equal, all it means is that the galaxy is stable and in this case it emans the galaxy is perched in such a way that the asari can cast their vote and have it almost always be the deciding one. This coaxes (or coaxed) everyone else to compete for the asari's favor and basically lets them run the galaxy.

Humanity can do the same. We don't need to necessarily always be the strongest vote; just being in the position to decide which way the wind turns would be a large boon.

EDIT

Oh, and credit to Dean_the_Young for the thoughts about the new Council having to reach out and get more involved with the other races.

Modifié par Saphra Deden, 17 juillet 2011 - 07:37 .


#1142
Kaiser Shepard

Kaiser Shepard
  • Members
  • 7 890 messages
Seems like Godwin's Law has been invoked.

To get back to a topic that was talked about yesterday, has anyone found any footage of Commando Shiala in ME2 yet?

Modifié par Kaiser Shepard, 17 juillet 2011 - 07:51 .


#1143
Inverness Moon

Inverness Moon
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

nhsk wrote...

People should stop treating the other species as aliens but instead as humans from another culture, we are all sapient beings capable of understanding, learning, emotion.

No, that is entirely the wrong idea. You should treat quarians as quarians and turians as turians. Not all races are the same and should be judged on their own merits. Legion says this at the beginning of his loyalty mission if you try to treat the herect geth like they're organics.

#1144
nhsk

nhsk
  • Members
  • 1 382 messages

Inverness Moon wrote...

nhsk wrote...

People should stop treating the other species as aliens but instead as humans from another culture, we are all sapient beings capable of understanding, learning, emotion.

No, that is entirely the wrong idea. You should treat quarians as quarians and turians as turians. Not all races are the same and should be judged on their own merits. Legion says this at the beginning of his loyalty mission if you try to treat the herect geth like they're organics.


I might have gotten off wrong, what I meant is that every race is equal. I'm so tired of the "pro" in front of human etc.

Equal rights, equal opportunities etc.

#1145
Inverness Moon

Inverness Moon
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

nhsk wrote...

I might have gotten off wrong, what I meant is that every race is equal. I'm so tired of the "pro" in front of human etc.

Equal rights, equal opportunities etc.

And everyone is equal here where I live, yet I still look out for my family first before others.

#1146
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

nhsk wrote...

I might have gotten off wrong, what I meant is that every race is equal. I'm so tired of the "pro" in front of human etc.

Equal rights, equal opportunities etc.


Haven't you heard? Being a blatant racist in the future is totally cool.

#1147
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests
The universe isn't fair and never will be. We have to put ourselves first or we'll be overcome by species not hampered by compassion and equality. Those who turn their swords into shovels are killed by those who don't.

#1148
Inverness Moon

Inverness Moon
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

The universe isn't fair and never will be. We have to put ourselves first or we'll be overcome by species not hampered by compassion and equality. Those who turn their swords into shovels are killed by those who don't.

Basically, this.

You can preach about equality all you want, but that isn't reality in the Mass Effect universe. A single look at the quarian situation should tell you this. Life isn't fair.

Humanity needs to make sure it isn't pushed around by other species. Military strength is a significant aspect of this as demonstrated in Revelation.

#1149
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

The universe isn't fair and never will be. We have to put ourselves first or we'll be overcome by species not hampered by compassion and equality. Those who turn their swords into shovels are killed by those who don't.


That's the mentality that makes enemies.

Just because equality is difficult to achieve doesn't mean we shouldn't try and immediately resort to cavemen mentality.

#1150
Inverness Moon

Inverness Moon
  • Members
  • 1 721 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

That's the mentality that makes enemies.

Just because equality is difficult to achieve doesn't mean we shouldn't try and immediately resort to cavemen mentality.

Except, if you haven't noticed, not everyone has the whole equality mentality. Unless you want to go conquer other species and force them to adopt your mentality of equality, you're just going to have to deal with it.

If you think looking out for yourself is cavemen mentality, then you must despair at how every government on Earth is run by cavemen.

Modifié par Inverness Moon, 17 juillet 2011 - 09:12 .