Aller au contenu

Photo

ME Invasion - "Cerberus experiments go wrong" - have they run out of ideas?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
303 réponses à ce sujet

#101
Bad King

Bad King
  • Members
  • 3 133 messages

The Twilight God wrote...

Bad King wrote...

All DLC is extra cash for BioWare (from big packs like LotSB to small packs like the Incisor) I still consider it part of the game's lore. And as I've said a few times this DLC does play a role in the games lore (not just gameplay)- BioWare went to the trouble of making sure they fit into the game lore-wise (read the descriptions and emails) and also the Cerberus troops in ME3 are wearing ME2's Cerberus Assault armor and are wielding the eviscerator. And while everyone makes weapons, do they all dabble in technology as advanced and as risky as Cerberus? We're talking collector tech, AI research, and field experiments against geth here.


LotSb, Arrival, Overlord, Stolen Memory and The Price of Vengence are more than irrelevent fluff.

Cerberus assault armor, eviscerator and almost all the weapons and armor are just that: Weapons and Armor. They aren't out of this world feats of engineering nor technological breakthroughs. They made some weapons and armor based on current technology. Big deal. We can make "out of this world" weapons right now. They just aren't economical. When Cerberus starts performing real feats of engineering (i.e. making superior weapons that can be mass produced so that humanity can actually benefit from them) they can be counted as more. As it stands those weapons are about as much a success as Cerberus personnel being able to tie their own shoes.

Some of those DLC armors weren't even developed by Cerberus. Like the mattock, Eviscerator, Phalanx, Plasma Shotgun, Terminus armor, etc. were attained on the open market. Others liek the archon visor, incisor rifle, kestrel armor and capacitor helmet are unclear (it's not said how Cerbeus got it). So giving them credit is erroneous.

My point about the collector armor is that it is a gimmick. It doesn't even make since within the timeline or lore of the game. Bioware needed to put something in the codex/mailbox to explain the existence of the item. But they failed IMO. Collector armor contradicts the lore.

Shepard,

Our researchers have been working with captured Collector technology for some time now. They've developed an experimental armor suit in your size and an assault rifle that the techs say should take a standard thermal clip. I had the items delivered to the Normandy's armory.

Good hunting.


For some time now? Really?

The amount of energy required to create a destructive beam is several orders of magnitude more than the amount needed to launch a high-velocity projectile via a mass effect field.
The weapon you've retrieved appears to be a beam weapon of Collector origin, but efforts to understand the technology and replicate it have failed. With enough research, Normandy's engineers may be able to produce beam weapons, perhaps on a large scale.


So either the collector DLC items aren't too different than the weapons we already have or Cerberus has a time machine. They don't have a time machine. So whats so great about the collector weapons and armor since it's no different than any other tech we alreayd possess?



1. Actually a lot of them are technological breakthroughs:

Shepard,
We recently had an incident involving the geth at one of our
outposts in the Skyllian Verge. Don't worry; I'm not sending you off to
chase anything down. Our operatives waged a highly successful battle
against a geth scouting party and credited their success to a new
advanced electrical attack device that we finally let them take out of
the lab
. Since their unit is being reassigned for some rest and
relaxation, I thought you should take custody of the weapon in the
meantime.
The weapon is called an arc projector. I sent it to the
Normandy's armory so you can examine it for yourself and use it if you
deem it worthy. It's gone through plenty of tests that indicate it
overloads kinetic barriers and synthetic enemies particularly well, but
laboratory demonstrations are a poor substitute for actual field
reports. We know it works. Now we want to see what it can do in the
right hands. If all goes well, we'll use your tactics to train other
operatives.
-- TIM
Cerberus Assault Armor is designed for shock troops, who are expected to
turn the tide of battle against creatures or forces that would decimate
normal soldiers
. The troops demanded three things in its design:
shields, armor thick enough to last against a superior foe, and a
rechargeable pack to extend a heavy weapon power cell. The only drawback
of the armor is its weight, which the troops carry as a point of pride.
They have a saying: "Out of shape going in, in shape coming out."
-- In-game description

The Cerberus Assault armour and eviscerator has been successfully mass produced and appears to be used by many of the Cerberus troops in ME3.

2. If you re-read my original comment, I never gave Cerberus credit for producing the Mattock/GPS/Phalanx- but they did modify them.

3. Collector armor does not contradict the lore. Collectors have been making deals with the Galaxy's races for centuries prior to ME2. Okeer for example made deals with them. Why couldn't Cerberus do the same?

As for that quote regarding the Collector beam- Cerberus are saying that they have been unable to replicate the beam gun itself. This doesn't mean that all Collector tech is too hard to replicate.

Modifié par Bad King, 15 juillet 2011 - 09:48 .


#102
ME-ParaShep

ME-ParaShep
  • Members
  • 368 messages

Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

They did two things right.
Built a new Normandy and brought Shepard back.
Everything else is kind of a wash.


To add two more things to that list; Cerberus:

-allowed Shepard to find his former squadmates and new recruits
-allowed Shepard to annihilate the Collectors

#103
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages
Yeah, they upgraded some armor and came up with a new weapon. Join the club. Humanity has been doing it for a couple of thousand years now.

#104
Bad King

Bad King
  • Members
  • 3 133 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

Yeah, they upgraded some armor and came up with a new weapon. Join the club. Humanity has been doing it for a couple of thousand years now.


Well at least you're admitting that Cerberus have indeed made successful technological innovations (also be sure to read some of the other DLC items' descriptions- I didn't include all of them).

Modifié par Bad King, 15 juillet 2011 - 09:55 .


#105
Mr. Gogeta34

Mr. Gogeta34
  • Members
  • 4 033 messages
All of the big 4 organizations:

The Council

The Alliance

Cerberus

Reapers

Have been making mistakes and screwing things up...

#106
Paulinius

Paulinius
  • Members
  • 589 messages
 I'm glad there's a story with more of a focus on Aria and Omega. I'm a bit bored by Cerberus story lines, but I'll wait until I read the comic before I render judgement. 

But there's one question on my mind: how is Cerberus able to travel through the Omega 4 relay?

The Cerberus research team of the derelict Reaper found the Reaper-IFF and Shepard took it and still has it. Assuming you swore off Cerberus, then I don't see how the IFF could get back to them since I doubt Shepard would hand it over. I've never sided with Cerberus at the end of ME2, so I don't know if there's a possibility of that Shepard handing back the IFF but I doubt BioWare would make a Shepard who sided with Cerberus at the end of ME2 canon.

On the other hand, the scientists on the derelict Reaper may have studied the IFF enough that there's enough information to reproduce the IFF. But if that was the case, why didn't TIM just make and give Shepard an IFF instead of going to the derelict Reaper where he and his crew could have died and thus been unable to stop the Collectors?

Modifié par Paulinius, 15 juillet 2011 - 10:01 .


#107
Bad King

Bad King
  • Members
  • 3 133 messages

Paulinius wrote...

On the other hand, the scientists on the derelict Reaper may have studied the IFF enough that there's enough information to reproduce the IFF. But if that was the case, why didn't TIM just make and give Shepard an IFF instead of going to the derelict Reaper where he and his crew could have died and thus been unable to stop the Collectors?


It appears that they have replicated the IFF- if Shepard dies in the suicide mission and gives the base to Cerberus, you see TIM watching a hologram of Cerberus ships heading towards the Collector Base. I have no idea how they did this. Maybe it was done between Shepard retrieving the IFF and the suicide mission.

Modifié par Bad King, 15 juillet 2011 - 10:05 .


#108
Paulinius

Paulinius
  • Members
  • 589 messages

Bad King wrote...

Paulinius wrote...

On the other hand, the scientists on the derelict Reaper may have studied the IFF enough that there's enough information to reproduce the IFF. But if that was the case, why didn't TIM just make and give Shepard an IFF instead of going to the derelict Reaper where he and his crew could have died and thus been unable to stop the Collectors?


It appears that they have replicated the IFF- if Shepard dies in the suicide mission and gives the base to Cerberus, you see TIM watching a hologram of Cerberus ships heading towards the Collector Base. I have no idea how they did this. Maybe it was done between Shepard retrieving the IFF and the suicide mission.


I guess they could also throw in that some obscure member of the Normandy stole it, if need be. It's not a major issue, but I hope the comic and whatever future media details Cerberus' excursions into Collector space.

#109
alperez

alperez
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Xanfyrst wrote...

I think you misunderstand something here... some people cheer for heels in wrestling because they're the most interesting characters and most know (I certainly hope) that it's scripted. Take for example CM Punk, he's a heel, but also the best on the microphone of all the wrestlers. He makes the show, not Cena or any of the other boring faces.


At the risk of turning this into a wrestling discussion, CM punk isn't a proper heel, he's more of a tweener or anti hero the same as Stone cold was.

What i meant by the comparison was that when you wish to create a heel in wrestling you get that person to do bad acts but sometimes if the writing isn't good enough or the audience doesn't get it or if the wrestler themselves shouldn't have been turned heel in the first place, in order to get the point across, writers have the heel do more and more outlandishly bad things until people accept them as heels.

With pro cerberus fans this seems to be an apt analogy, they either like cerberus and what it stands for to the point of forgiving every single action, they don't agree that the actions cerberus take are really that bad or they blame the quality of the writing as the reason why Cerberus being bad guys doesn't ring true in thier opinion

Hope that cleared it up.

#110
Adanu

Adanu
  • Members
  • 1 400 messages
Wow..... the intelligence level in this thread is mind boggling.

And not in a good way. Without Cerberus, the Reapers would have gotten to the galaxy already and pretty much killed us all.

#111
alperez

alperez
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Ieldra2 wrote...

Apart from the annoying repetition:

That's exactly it. I don't like that's all there might be to Cerberus: an organization of cardboard villainy with no redeeming, even less interesting features whatsoever.

It's been said that Cerberus is both the best and the worst of humanity. So far we've seen only the worst. I'd like to see some of the best. I *HATE* black and white scenarios, and I'm very much tempted to take their side regardless just because of the one-sided presentation.

To say nothing of the rampant technophobia of the whole setup with Reaper tech as evil mojo and the blatant Paragon favoritism in all this. The more it seems that ME3 will really be that one-sided, a standard good vs evil story with no moral grey and complexity in the main plot, just mind-numbingly simplistic at the core, the more I fear I'll come regret that I was ever drawn in by the first game.

Perhaps this complaint is premature. But with every "hammering home" of Cerberus' cardboard villainy, any love I still have for the games and their story is slowly hammered out of me.


While it may not seem like it i actually agree with you on your core points, how Cerberus could have been handled or what potential there might have been if they were handled differently would have made a much more interesting and morally ambigious game and forced us to properly examine which path we should take.

We still don't know if there will be an example of that moral ambiguity and if we will find ourselves more in the grey area which we won't know until me3 (i doubt it will happen but it could).

The problem is though that just like movies, games have to appeal to the highest possible percentage and must answer not always in terms of quality but in terms of bottom line.

In essence a certain dumbing down and black and whiteness is much more prevelant than examining those issues you would like to see, which was basically the point i was trying to make.

Once you've gone down that route and you find that instead of accepting things the way you intended them to be accepted, people are putting their own spin and own morally ambiguity to situations that were supposed to be black and white, your forced to keep hammering home the same points until there can be no doubt.

In saying this i could be completely wrong and Bioware could have something up their sleeves to show that ambiguity in me3, its just it hasn't been prevelant in me1 or me2 and i don't think they'll bring it into me3 at the risk of confusing or alienating the majority.

#112
Praetor Knight

Praetor Knight
  • Members
  • 5 772 messages

Adanu wrote...

Wow..... the intelligence level in this thread is mind boggling.

And not in a good way. Without Cerberus, the Reapers would have gotten to the galaxy already and pretty much killed us all.

:blink:

Posts like these are of the mind boggling variety, IMHO=]

:D


And as long as we have crazy scientists, Cerberus can never run out of bad ideas, even if they get lucky from time to time.

Tis the price of being on the cutting edge I suppose, some times you get cut.

#113
ME-ParaShep

ME-ParaShep
  • Members
  • 368 messages

Adanu wrote...

Wow..... the intelligence level in this thread is mind boggling.

And not in a good way. Without Cerberus, the Reapers would have gotten to the galaxy already and pretty much killed us all.


Actually, you're partially correct. It was also due to the intervention of deep cover agent of the Alliance: Dr. Amanda Kenson that the Reapers wouldn't have gotten here sooner

#114
alperez

alperez
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Adanu wrote...

Wow..... the intelligence level in this thread is mind boggling.

And not in a good way. Without Cerberus, the Reapers would have gotten to the galaxy already and pretty much killed us all.


Without Tali we would never have gotten that info on Saren which would have left Shepard stuck on the citadel and the reapers would have arrived much earlier.

Or without the alliance requistion officer Shepard wouldn't have got a really big gun and would have died while trying to stop Saren.

See we can pretty much claim anyone as being the reason why the reapers haven't gotten here already and it's as valid as you saying Cerberus are the reason.

#115
Bluko

Bluko
  • Members
  • 1 737 messages

TMA LIVE wrote...

Here's the text burb in the comic:

"When Cerberus’s experiments with Reaper technologies goes wrong, a new threat emerges from the Relay, ready to wreak destruction on an unsuspecting galaxy. The first stop on the path to utter destruction: Omega, which stands, as always, alone…"


Image IPB


Surely someone other then Cerberus could potentially be at fault for releasing some bad Reaper stuff? To be fair though I guess Cerberus is really the only organization that could have a mishap with Reaper tech. It's just getting a little cliche how every Cerberus project fails. In retrospect I am especially glad my default Shepard destroys the base, cause trusting Cerberus to not screw up is about as wise as letting someone drive drunk at this point who's gotten half a dozen DWIs. Seriously I'll bet at the end of ME3 Shepard will defeat the Reapers, but then their life battery fails. (Cerberus bought some cheap generic batteries when they should have bought those Energizers...)

I mean okay... I sort of get it. Some people may not have encountered Cerberus in ME1 and thus know nothing about them. Some people haven't played ME1. So some folks may not be aware what Cerberus is going into ME2. But the numerous and largely dangerous/unethical projects Cerberus takes part in that we know of from both ME2 and the novels should have made it pretty clear by now.

Eh I dunno I suppose something had to go wrong for Cerberus to work with the Reapers. I mean I've always been pretty sure Cerberus would become "bad guys" in ME3. I was just sort of hoping they'd have their own reasons for doing so and not because they spilled some "Chemical X".

#116
Warkupo

Warkupo
  • Members
  • 317 messages
Cerberus likes to play with fire. When they win, they win very well. When they lose, they lose hard. There's no middle ground for a corporation who does the kind of **** they do.

#117
Praetor Knight

Praetor Knight
  • Members
  • 5 772 messages

Bluko wrote...

Eh I dunno I suppose something had to go wrong for Cerberus to work with the Reapers. I mean I've always been pretty sure Cerberus would become "bad guys" in ME3. I was just sort of hoping they'd have their own reasons for doing so and not because they spilled some "Chemical X".


I think it's so that Shepard can "cut ties with Cerberus" to fight the Reapers.

With the events in Arrival, Shep can't look too good to the average person (another Saren wannabe). So if Cerberus assumes the blame and pursues Shepard, that could exonerate Shep to keep fighting the Reapers and get official support from the militaries to support Shepard.

I figure TIM can make that kind of sacrifice without a second thought and that's what makes TIM such a badass and a perfect nemesis for any moral alignment.

#118
TMA LIVE

TMA LIVE
  • Members
  • 7 015 messages
The summery is in the actual comic. So yeah, a Cerberus experiment with Reaper technology has gone wrong.

Modifié par TMA LIVE, 15 juillet 2011 - 11:49 .


#119
REgentleman

REgentleman
  • Members
  • 81 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

Yeah, they upgraded some armor and came up with a new weapon. Join the club. Humanity has been doing it for a couple of thousand years now.

I've had enough of your disingenuous assertions >:

Seriously, throw them a bone. To add to the list, didn't they partially co-opt geth shield technology? Everybody had been banging their heads trying to get somewhere with that for so many years even before humans came along.

I'm not even a big humanist or Cerberus fan, and they're very far from invincible when looking at things realistically or even in terms of plot armor, but a Team Rocket kind of comparison is just too harsh. I've wondered about Cerberus' bottom line myself, but for a totally rogue organization to experiment in goddam near everything and keep its investors happy enough to maintain their crap in the face of relatively catastrophic failures has to count for something.

I wonder if we'll see all the bungled experiments catch up to them or something. It would be nice to get some resolution that addresses openly just how much they've done for better or worse, rather than a game's worth of posturing over them being the dudes with no rules who get things done no matter how much they act like jerkoffs!

Modifié par REgentleman, 16 juillet 2011 - 12:03 .


#120
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests
Comic book mentality. Cerberus is the Joker and if the Joker didn't escape from jail then there'd be no story. In this case "escape from jail" is "screw up with their experiments".

#121
ItsFreakinJesus

ItsFreakinJesus
  • Members
  • 2 313 messages
They're using Reaper tech. Not the best stuff to be messing around with long term.

#122
Bad King

Bad King
  • Members
  • 3 133 messages

REgentleman wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

Yeah, they upgraded some armor and came up with a new weapon. Join the club. Humanity has been doing it for a couple of thousand years now.

I've had enough of your disingenuous assertions >:

Seriously, throw them a bone. To add to the list, didn't they partially co-opt geth shield technology? Everybody had been banging their heads trying to get somewhere with that for so many years even before humans came along.


I completely forgot about Cerberus's involvement in producing some of the upgrades. Silly me! Info:

masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Research#Shield_Upgrades

It seems Cerberus were responsible for certain upgrades and are actively doing further research in certain fields in order to produce better upgrades in future.

List:
- Sniper Headshot Damage
-The Avalanche
-The Cain
-Medi Gel capacity upgrades
-Hard Shields
-Redundant Field Generator

These upgrades are confirmed in their descriptions to be Cerberus experimental technology.

Modifié par Bad King, 16 juillet 2011 - 12:42 .


#123
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

Comic book mentality. Cerberus is the Joker and if the Joker didn't escape from jail then there'd be no story. In this case "escape from jail" is "screw up with their experiments".


Yeah but this is just laziness. There's no reason why they couldn't create a Cerberus story that didn't involve a screwed up experiment.

#124
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

Seboist wrote...

Yeah but this is just laziness. There's no reason why they couldn't create a Cerberus story that didn't involve a screwed up experiment.


Because then they'd have to actually show unethical methods being somewhat successful, something they've been trying to avoid since the start of the Mass Effect series. 

#125
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages

Bad King wrote...

I completely forgot about Cerberus's involvement in producing some of the upgrades. Silly me! Info:

masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Research#Shield_Upgrades

It seems Cerberus were responsible for certain upgrades and are actively doing further research in certain fields in order to produce better upgrades in future.


Oh yeah?

http://masseffect.wi...onic_Array).PNG
Image IPB

Quarians manged to do the same and with their limited resources.

No matter what Cerberus does with weapons, armor or shields, it won't impress me.