2940 réponses à ce sujet

[Sialater]

We don't have to be separate. Just don't criticize another's Shepard when it's not asked for.

[CrazyRah]

rynluna wrote...

Cypher0020 wrote...

ok can't we all just get along? Or... please... keep the fighting down? I'd hate to see this thread get locked...

All of us are united for our love for Shepard! H/She's awesome!

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

Quoted for truth.
I <3 You

[Hyper_gateway]

*sighs* Sorry, I got to say this off topic comment...

This IS exactly what could went wrong through internet, people feels and think they can make any comments as they see fit in.

In real world, before you say anything towards a person, you WILL consider and respect that person in some way. Do you dare to make fun of your boss right in front of him? What someone did here is just slam their comment/action right into that person's face. How can you ask someone easily to forgive you on that? Especially a character that person has a feeling to connect with.

Sure you will make joke with each other, but that only limit to those you really know and understand.

Be considerate and respect other comments, pictures and so on....

Don't forget people can ONLY judge your motivation by your words, please keep that in mind.

[MizzNaaa]

rynluna wrote...

Cypher0020 wrote...

ok can't we all just get along? Or... please... keep the fighting down? I'd hate to see this thread get locked...

All of us are united for our love for Shepard! H/She's awesome!

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

Well said Ryn! Well said. 

[Rinji the Bearded]

rynluna wrote...

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

I'm not sure if separating the genders will fix it, either.   You just form two cliques that way.

Shepard threads in general are just begging to be flamed.

Modifié par RinjiRenee, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:16 .

[JamieCOTC]

RinjiRenee wrote...

rynluna wrote...

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

I'm not sure if separating the genders will fix it, either.   You just form two cliques that way.

Shepard threads in general are just begging to be flamed.

Actually, to be as active as it is, the ME2 femshep thread is one of the most civil on BSN

Modifié par JamieCOTC, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:19 .

[Ottemis]

rynluna wrote...

Cypher0020 wrote...

ok can't we all just get along? Or... please... keep the fighting down? I'd hate to see this thread get locked...

All of us are united for our love for Shepard! H/She's awesome!

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

Ryn, I wub you.To clarify, I would be thrilled if a combined thread would be possible, but if people can't be civil to eachother, which they obviously can't, what's the point.

JamieCOTC wrote...
Actually, to be as active as it is, the femshep thread is one of the most civil on BSN

*nods*

Modifié par Ottemis, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:18 .

[Sialater]

Ottemis wrote...

rynluna wrote...

Cypher0020 wrote...

ok can't we all just get along? Or... please... keep the fighting down? I'd hate to see this thread get locked...

All of us are united for our love for Shepard! H/She's awesome!

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

Ryn, I wub you.To clarify, I would be thrilled if a combined thread would be possible, but if people can't be civil to eachother, which they obviously can't, what's the point.

As I said, We don't have to be separate. Just don't criticize another's Shepard when it's not asked for.

[Mystranna Kelteel]

RinjiRenee wrote...
I'm not sure if separating the genders will fix it, either.   You just form two cliques that way.

Those cliques already exist.  This happens every time Shepard is mentioned in a specific gender form.  It devolves into praising how awesomely high-res Sheploo is, how all femSheps look the same and are plasticy, how Meer is deadpan, and/or how Hale sounds like a butch lesbian.

And it's been that way for years.  At least with separate threads you have a better chance at peace and quiet, being left with people who generally agree as opposed to those who are very opinionated and love to take anecdotal potshots at the other side and try to disguise it as honest criticism.

[syllogi]

JamieCOTC wrote...

RinjiRenee wrote...

rynluna wrote...

Hate to be a downer but this thread was doomed to fail.  Having separate threads for the different genders just works better. There are plenty of fans of both Shepards but they have always provided their support in both threads. I'm surprised this flamewar didn't start by who is better...it just took one clown to be rude about how someone's Shepard looked.

I'm not sure if separating the genders will fix it, either.   You just form two cliques that way.

Shepard threads in general are just begging to be flamed.

Actually, to be as active as it is, the femshep thread is one of the most civil on BSN

Apparently, there are people who are REALLY bothered by that.

I can't think of any other reason for coming out of nowhere to attack specific characters made by well known posters in that thread.

It must REALLY hurt them, that FemShep fans are enthusiastic and enjoy themselves.

[SilentNukee]

*Kills thread with fire* KILLING IT.

[ipgd]

ALL RIGHT THIS THREAD HAS A TOPIC RIGHT



HOW ABOUT SOME DANCING SHEPLOO EVERYONE LIKES DANCING SHEPLOO.

[Sylvianus]

No, no, no .... Please. STOP ! No chauvinism !

I personally find it ridiculous to think that a topic shepard ( femshep/manshep can not work. )

Chauvinism has no place here. Do not participate, if you think it will not work.

I just think that a group of people can not appreciate another group that's all. but the majority does not need to follow you in your disagreement.

Rather than spoil this topic, why not go back to your respective topics that please you so much with your gender, alone ?

It's about shepard.

Modifié par Sylvianus, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:24 .

[Quorrah]

So, are we concluding that a good chunk of us are sexists? o_O

[Arxduke]

Oh wow, are we suddenly deciding to close this thread as fans because we can't get along?

A Sheploo thread was started, but a mod merged it into this one. But then again this was made already with intentions to please both M/F Shepards. But to no luck.

Mash Mashington wrote...
All your Shepards suck

If there ever was a comment on a forum that could make me facepalm.....

Modifié par Arxduke, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:27 .

[ipgd]

Fiddles_stix wrote...

Mash Mashington wrote...

All your Shepards suck

Say it ain't so

With lips like that, I'd say.

[Rinji the Bearded]

JamieCOTC wrote...

Actually, to be as active as it is, the femshep thread is one of the most civil on BSN

After browsing the femshep thread a few times, are you so sure that if someone were to post a constructive criticism about a certain Female Shepard's face, or to make a comment about how "photomanips" are a form of artistic plagiarism, do you think that would be taken well at all in the femshep thread?

But hey, I don't post there.  Disregard this post, it's derailing.

Modifié par RinjiRenee, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:28 .

[co_oki]

RinjiRenee wrote...

JamieCOTC wrote...

Actually, to be as active as it is, the femshep thread is one of the most civil on BSN

After browsing the femshep thread a few times, are you so sure that if someone were to post a constructive criticism about a certain Female Shepard's face, or to make a comment about how "photomanips" are a form of artistic plagiarism, do you think that would be taken well at all in the femshep thread?

But hey, I don't post there.

No... hate to say.. but it would quickly turn into a catfight.

[upsettingshorts]

TeenZombie wrote...

It must REALLY hurt them, that FemShep fans are enthusiastic and enjoy themselves.

What?

I have a couple Femsheps.  Even posted some screenshots in the thread for a while, here's a post.  In fact, here's a (on topic!) couple screenshots of one I just made, and she's just as confused as I am:




I've posted a few times about how I prefer Mark Meer's work in ME2 to Jennifer Hale's, but I felt the opposite in ME1.  I'm not sure how that would make me part of some anti-Femshep bogeyman cult.

Modifié par Upsettingshorts, 21 juillet 2011 - 01:32 .

[Sialater]

How hard is it to understand that you don't give "criticism" unless asked?

[SilentNukee]

Btw, I love your sig TZ
So,




Pretty colours while the fire burns to kill the thread.

[Aggie Punbot]

Gotta agree with the Rinji here.