Aller au contenu

Photo

Thank the Enkindlers that Mass Effect movie is based on ME1


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
440 réponses à ce sujet

#276
Squidbreath

Squidbreath
  • Members
  • 215 messages

didymos1120 wrote...

No, you're missing the point: people are going to try and use the movie to win arguments about what the "real" canon is.  And the type of people who do that kind of thing tend to be annoying, largely due to not shutting up about whatever it is they're intent on proving.


Wel, if it absolutely has to be a first game recap, they can always pretend it's CITADEL: THE MOVIE. < It's advertised ingame :)


...I expect to have my expectations blown! ...considering how low they are at the moment, why thankyou lovely statistics - http://www.rottentom..._adaptations/6/

Modifié par Squidbreath, 26 juillet 2011 - 07:11 .


#277
ThePwener

ThePwener
  • Members
  • 2 652 messages
ME1 huh? I'll reserve judgement and remain skeptical of it's possible success.

Excuse to have a different Shepard then you're own - ALTERNATE UNIVESES

#278
Fredvdp

Fredvdp
  • Members
  • 6 186 messages

Squidbreath wrote...

...I expect to have my expectations blown! ...considering how low they are at the moment, why thankyou lovely statistics - http://www.rottentom..._adaptations/6/

I love how the number one on that list isn't even a game adaptation.

#279
LordAnguis

LordAnguis
  • Members
  • 184 messages
Something we should probably think about is that they're not going to do every little side-mission in the movie. They might do the Kahoku/Cerberus side-mission to set up the possibility of a film for ME2, but I'm guessing that they'll stick with the main storyline: Eden Prime-Citadel-Therum-Noveria-Feros-Virmire-Ilos-Finale.
Personally, the only thing that would make me unwilling to go see a film based on the game is if it's an hour and a half. That would be TOO rushed for all those events. Two and a half hours, at minimum.
I think if they weave the backstory into the film rather than trying to shove all the information down people's throats in the first 30 minutes, they can pull it off.
With BioWare's involvement, I have a bit more faith than other game-based films.

#280
Guest_PureMethodActor_*

Guest_PureMethodActor_*
  • Guests
So the Mass Effect movie is being based off of the first game? With a canon Liara romance and removal of Feros? and canon Renegade story paths?

Yep, this is gonna fail worse than "The Last Airbender"...

#281
Gweedotk

Gweedotk
  • Members
  • 151 messages
Yeah my expectations are extremely low. I thought the way the game portrayed aliens is what made it unique, instead of making it all about Humans and blah blah. if PureMethodActor is right and the renegade path is the canon, I honestly hope this film doesn't make it past the conceptual stage.

All I see is EA milking the series, which will simply end up damaging the fan base and hurting the game experience (it will for me at least). If they had made up a story from scratch, I would be more optimistic, but porting a game into a movie has never been successful. There is little originality to begin with, we've got enough "AHHH Aliens!" movies already out. If it were taking the paragon path, it would at least have some originality there but nah, once more the aliens suck, humans rule, gun and run, blah blah.

Nothing good can come out of this. Except for short term profits of course, but of course that will damage the long term profitability. Every other media did not establish a canon that related to the actual games and made sure to leave room for the players decision. I really don't see why they have to change development goals for the movie.

But this is just me.

#282
sbvera13

sbvera13
  • Members
  • 432 messages
Bottom line is if it's a good production or not. Canon this or My Shepard that doesn't matter; you play your game, they make their movie. We're already familiar enough with how the system works, we know we are stepping into our own personal version of Shepard every time we play. It's not even a half step away to let the moviemakers do the same thing.

I just hope they do a good job. If it gets the Prequels treatment, I will die inside. Oh, and I hope they base the music on the original score. Nothing else is acceptable.

#283
Guest_PureMethodActor_*

Guest_PureMethodActor_*
  • Guests

Gweedotk wrote...

Yeah my expectations are extremely low. I thought the way the game portrayed aliens is what made it unique, instead of making it all about Humans and blah blah. if PureMethodActor is right and the renegade path is the canon, I honestly hope this film doesn't make it past the conceptual stage.

All I see is EA milking the series, which will simply end up damaging the fan base and hurting the game experience (it will for me at least). If they had made up a story from scratch, I would be more optimistic, but porting a game into a movie has never been successful. There is little originality to begin with, we've got enough "AHHH Aliens!" movies already out. If it were taking the paragon path, it would at least have some originality there but nah, once more the aliens suck, humans rule, gun and run, blah blah.

But this is just me.


I agree with you completely, especially the bolded parts. I mean, are we really SO closed off to having aliens play huge roles in franchises, or "OMG! What if..." alien protagonists? I'm so tired of seeing human-centric storylines play out. I have to say this is precisely one reason I stay more of a Star Wars geek than a Trekkie, because the focus in Star Wars isn't completely human-centric. I actually think (please don't shoot me, fellow Star Wars lovers) that the new Clone Wars series helps in that, especially with Ahsoka Tano as a main protagonist. We see someone who's not human take a major role. Star Trek: TOS was like this, too, with Spock taking a major, and sometimes main, role in the episodes.

My point is that relegating everything to "humans are the only major players in the conflicts" is just utterly boring to me. Its a reason I don't like Dragon Age 2, and its a reason I've been worried about Mass Effect's direction since ME2. While the "collectors capturing humans" thing wasn't bad, but the revelation that we'd be seeing Earth in the series annoyed me, and the whole "must take earth back from evil bad guys" thing is almost too much. I wanted something original, something else to bring the Reaper conflict to a head, but instead of a galactic-proportions epic, we're reduced to collecting everyone in the galaxy....

to save Earth <_<

Because I'm pulling my last bit of available finances and focusing solely on getting Elder Scrolls Skyrim, I probably won't be getting ME3 for a while unless I find a job very soon. I don't mind at all, and will be waiting for reviews to come in.

Now, as it goes for the movie... there's no way I'm seeing it if those involved in the movie actually go forward with their plan to base it off the first movie rather than create a tie-in. I'd rather not see Renegade Sheploo getting Udina on the council.

In fact, I don't want to see ANY Renegade at all in Shepard. I want this Shepard to be a goody-two-shoes boy/girl-scout, Hulk Hogan-like noble hero. I think the anti-hero has been overdone now :D

Modifié par PureMethodActor, 29 juillet 2011 - 07:22 .


#284
Sgt Stryker

Sgt Stryker
  • Members
  • 2 590 messages

Eshaye wrote...

Fredvdp wrote...

I saw the Mass Effect movie panel on YouTube and they literally said they're focusing on the first game for the first movie.

At 06:40


Awwww nuts! 


To clarify, Protosevich's exact quote was "We're solely concentrating on the first game right now, but we are following and honoring that story." That's still very unclear on whether or not this movie will be a simple rehash of Shepard's story in ME1, or something a little more original.

Insufficient data available. Concensus cannot be reached at this time.

#285
PSBlasius

PSBlasius
  • Members
  • 86 messages
I would love to see the first game... made into a musical... played entirely by elcor actors! Runtime: 280 mins. Rated: L for lethargy.

#286
Uzrbital

Uzrbital
  • Members
  • 173 messages
No. Just no. This is MY SHEPARD. Go away.

#287
masseffectfan00

masseffectfan00
  • Members
  • 503 messages

Uzrbital wrote...

No. Just no. This is MY SHEPARD. Go away.



Just deal with it

#288
SandTrout

SandTrout
  • Members
  • 4 171 messages

PSBlasius wrote...

I would love to see the first game... made into a musical... played entirely by elcor actors! Runtime: 280 mins. Rated: L for lethargy.

This has a greater chance of being sucessful, methinks.

#289
Gabey5

Gabey5
  • Members
  • 3 434 messages

Valentia X wrote...

I'm sure it will make money, but if I wanted to play a paragon soldier Sheploo, I'd make one, and that's what it's mostly likely going to be.


people read harry potter and see all the films
same with lord of the rings
or game of thrones


:whistle:

Modifié par Gabey5, 29 juillet 2011 - 10:37 .


#290
SandTrout

SandTrout
  • Members
  • 4 171 messages
Books are somewhat easier to adapt to the silver screen, and the movies provide things that the books don't: primarily visual and audio that is not imaginary. The movie cuts out a large portion of content from the book as well as altering some scenes in exchange for this visual and audio stimulus.

Comparatively, the movie format is a downgrade from a video game. A video game has visual and audio, but the movie lacks the game's interactive nature. The result is that the movie must cut a significant amount of content as well as removing a key part of the experience of the game, and returns nothing unique to the medium.

Ever read a book that was based off of a movie and followed the main plot of the movie? The ones that I have seen have been pretty damn terrible.

Alternately, things that were originally movies or books and adapted 'up' to video games have had only a slightly lower success rate of video game originals.

#291
nicksmi56

nicksmi56
  • Members
  • 410 messages
I have no problem with the movie coming out as long as it isn't a flop and I agree the public has the right to see Mass Effect in all it's glory. However I won't be going to see it since movies like that stick with me and I would rather only have my Shepard's story in my mind.

#292
nicksmi56

nicksmi56
  • Members
  • 410 messages
Oh, who am I kidding? There's no way they can make an ME1 movie and keep me satisfied. It can happen but I'll pretend it didn't.

#293
jamesp81

jamesp81
  • Members
  • 4 051 messages
If I gave some of you people a gold bar, you'd complain that it was too heavy.

#294
darthnick427

darthnick427
  • Members
  • 3 785 messages
As long as they make the story work in movie form and choose actors that suit the roles i'm fine with it.

#295
azerSheppard

azerSheppard
  • Members
  • 1 279 messages
too bad tho, rachni wars, followed by krogan rebellions, and finally the first contact war would have made a AAA trilogy.

#296
The Everchosen of Chaos

The Everchosen of Chaos
  • Members
  • 140 messages
Well I don't really care as I have never played ME 1, so really if anything the movie would be a new experience. Say what you will about ME 2 but for it's one of the best games I've ever played. If this movie works, then I will be interested in how they adapt ME 2.

Jeez, you guys are worse than the nerds at Bungie who can't deal with the Master Chief having a face. Honestly people it's just a game and now it will be a movie good or bad, deal with it or not.

Just don't whine if it fails your expectations. thats all I have to say.

#297
jamesp81

jamesp81
  • Members
  • 4 051 messages

azerSheppard wrote...

too bad tho, rachni wars, followed by krogan rebellions, and finally the first contact war would have made a AAA trilogy.


Very few people are going to watch an epic sci fi that doesn't include humans.

#298
jamesp81

jamesp81
  • Members
  • 4 051 messages

The Everchosen of Chaos wrote...

Well I don't really care as I have never played ME 1, so really if anything the movie would be a new experience. Say what you will about ME 2 but for it's one of the best games I've ever played. If this movie works, then I will be interested in how they adapt ME 2.

Jeez, you guys are worse than the nerds at Bungie who can't deal with the Master Chief having a face. Honestly people it's just a game and now it will be a movie good or bad, deal with it or not.

Just don't whine if it fails your expectations. thats all I have to say.


You're telling the BSN to not whine.  You might as well tell the birds to quit singing, or tell the dogs to quit barking and peeing on fire hydrants.

#299
The Everchosen of Chaos

The Everchosen of Chaos
  • Members
  • 140 messages
I know It's an impossible achievement, the day pigs fly will nerds not whine. 'sigh'.

#300
A-K-M

A-K-M
  • Members
  • 161 messages
There's a 99% probability that this movie will stink still gonna watch it though, can't stem the curiosity.