Neither set is very good, but Legacy is clearly better. Defense is a junk stat - 5% chance to dodge a melee swing is not better than 9% dmg resistance and 140 more armor (armor = dmg resistance). The set bonus gives 10% damage too which at least is useful. Only downside is two less rune slots. The point is moot if you have Black Emporium, since Robes of Unblemished Cleanliness are better by itself than either chestpiece+bonus. Also, Apostate's Mask is still the best helm in the game if you have the Mage Item Pack DLC.
For Staff attacks, it will always depend on the enemy you're facing - double damage from a lesser +40 staff will trump either staff, especially if that staff (eg. The Final Thought, Torch of Falondin) has a Primeval Lyrium Rune.
However, Hawke's Key is by far the best in the game for casting spells. Base damage is the most important stat. Malcolm's has 16% crit, 3% crit damage versus Hawke's Key with only 9% crit damage, but that's the only thing in its favor. In that sense, having it on hand to swap for a barrage of spells could be considered useful all the time (PC players at least can download a weapon swap mod).
Modifié par thendcomes, 27 juillet 2011 - 07:15 .