Kaiser_Wilhelm wrote...
2. This prologue immediately makes Shepard a technical war criminal. As I said, I'm not sure what happened in Arrival, but if it's gotten Shepard on trial, then in all technicalities, they're a war criminal. This is a more minor complaint but it still annoys me. In my playthrough over ME1, ME2, and ME3, I've been trying to get a high paragon character. I realize war's not always black and white, difficult decisions have to be made. However, I hate immediately starting as a war criminal on trial, especially considering that for me and others who've not played Arrival have no say in what's going on. We didn't make any difficult decisions, we didn't do any major actions, we're just thrown into some trial that has no real bearing or purpose to our characters, and whether we like that war criminal image or not, it's given to us without choice. This basically throws away the entire high paragon image I was going for, and I'm sure others went for as well. And as I said, I don't know what happened in Arrival, whether Shepard did some huge crime or not, but even if he didn't, being on military trial makes him a war criminal, in a technical sense, and this is an image I personally don't like. However, this wouldn't be a real complaint, since by now it's irreversible, if it didn't fit in with my third point.
I take some issue with this. From a story perspective I really like the idea of the despised hero, who does the right thing and gets no praise, but rather scorn. Especially with regards to Mass Effect, where paragon decisions have been largely praised by other in game characters. A despised paragon makes for a refreshing and welcome change.
Plus, you kinda ruffled my civil libertarian feathers with this paragraph. Specifically your use of the words "technical" and "technically" with regards to Shepard being a "war criminal." Any person being on trial, military or civilian, only makes someone an accused or alleged criminal of any sort. So
technically Shepard isn't a war criminal until and unless a guilty verdict is returned. Just puttin' it out there.