Aller au contenu

We Can't Save Earth, We Can't Beat the Reapers


2463 réponses à ce sujet

#726
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

100k wrote...

Sisterofshane wrote...

Hey 100, notice how my last post ( on the last page) and your last post have gone completely ignored?

Win.


OP is indoctrinated. Don't take it personally, buddy.
:):):)
My original quote, which also brought up a good point, went completely unnoticed as well. 


No, no no!  See how I said "Win."?
She's ignoring it because she has no argument.  Therefore, we win!
And it looks like you're already celebrating! (nods toward the post above about drinking)

#727
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

RobotWalk wrote...

Sisterofshane wrote...

Hey 100, notice how my last post ( on the last page) and your last post have gone completely ignored?

Win.


Man I'm sorry, I was busy coming up with IRREFUTABLE PLANS for why we actually CAN beat the Reapers.


Ok, was totally misunderstood.  I meant WE WIN.  Against Saphra.
I swear I'm not indoctrinated!

#728
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages
I still like my idea.
Image IPB

#729
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

I still like my idea.
Image IPB

Remember how I said earlier I was ready with my two-step?
Apparently so is Shepard!

#730
100k

100k
  • Members
  • 3 152 messages
@ Sisterofshane, well I guess we should have a toast to a plausible victory, then :-D

Oh, and reposted to effectively end the OPs argument.

"

You can still fight it!

Yes, you bring up some excellent points. But ME1 and ME2 involved two key crippling strikes against the Reapers: preemptive planning is now almost completely out of the question.

In Mass Effect, Shepard managed to destroy two very powerful advantages that the Reapers had: Sovereign, their in-galaxy scout, and the Citadel (which Shepard gained control of), which gave the Reapers the ability to control the relays, along with uploading practically every bit of data on every species, world, and system.

In Mass Effect 2, Shepard managed to take out the Collectors, the Reaper's last eye into the galaxy they were planning to invade.

Their three biggest scout teams are gone! They don't have the Citadel to gather information on world locations, or control relays! They don't have Nazara to help them unite the geth! They don't have the Collectors to give them a run down on what makes a species tick!

If the Reapers are modern soldiers, then the rest of the galaxy are cave men wielding bows, spears, and poison darts. But the Reapers are entering our jungle! Despite the fact that the Old Machines have entered this forest many times, the long years in between have caused the brush and vegetation to overgrow their well known paths.

There is always hope."

#731
BrotherCorvid

BrotherCorvid
  • Members
  • 154 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

I still like my idea.
Image IPB


You know what's pretty good at pushing?

A starfish. 

I think I know what I want Kasumi's animal power to be.

#732
Fata Morgana

Fata Morgana
  • Members
  • 539 messages
Hey Saphra, I just wanted to say that I find your post fascinating, even though I disagree.

Specifically, I think that extinction is better than becoming a reaper. Yeah, that means that everyone I love dies, too, but all I have to do is look at the plight of a husk and say, "Do I want my mother to become something like that?" to know that death is preferable.

#733
Bogsnot1

Bogsnot1
  • Members
  • 7 997 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

I still like my idea.
Image IPB



I thought Shep was just teaching Mordin and Samara how to shake their tail feather? B) 

Modifié par Bogsnot1, 31 juillet 2011 - 05:40 .


#734
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages

Bogsnot1 wrote...


Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

I still like my idea.*snip*



I thought Shep was just teaching Mordin and Samara how to shake their tail feather? B) 

The original said
No no no,put your right foot in THEN shake it all about

#735
pablodurando

pablodurando
  • Members
  • 516 messages

Fata Morgana wrote...

Hey Saphra, I just wanted to say that I find your post fascinating, even though I disagree.

Specifically, I think that extinction is better than becoming a reaper. Yeah, that means that everyone I love dies, too, but all I have to do is look at the plight of a husk and say, "Do I want my mother to become something like that?" to know that death is preferable.


Becoming a reaper is not the same as becoming a husk.  A reaper contains the essence of a species, at least that's what we have gotten from me2.  I would be very interested in seeing humanity become a Reaper just because the race has become immortalized and become just short of a god.  I think it'd be very interesting for a human reaper to exist.  Salvation through destruction and ascension to perfection(near).

#736
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

100k wrote...

@ Sisterofshane, well I guess we should have a toast to a plausible victory, then :-D

Oh, and reposted to effectively end the OPs argument.

"

You can still fight it!

Yes, you bring up some excellent points. But ME1 and ME2 involved two key crippling strikes against the Reapers: preemptive planning is now almost completely out of the question.

In Mass Effect, Shepard managed to destroy two very powerful advantages that the Reapers had: Sovereign, their in-galaxy scout, and the Citadel (which Shepard gained control of), which gave the Reapers the ability to control the relays, along with uploading practically every bit of data on every species, world, and system.

In Mass Effect 2, Shepard managed to take out the Collectors, the Reaper's last eye into the galaxy they were planning to invade.

Their three biggest scout teams are gone! They don't have the Citadel to gather information on world locations, or control relays! They don't have Nazara to help them unite the geth! They don't have the Collectors to give them a run down on what makes a species tick!

If the Reapers are modern soldiers, then the rest of the galaxy are cave men wielding bows, spears, and poison darts. But the Reapers are entering our jungle! Despite the fact that the Old Machines have entered this forest many times, the long years in between have caused the brush and vegetation to overgrow their well known paths.

There is always hope."


I remember reading this.  I totally agree.

I'm not going to sit here argue battle tactics, but I will say one thing about war - the biggest problem that any army can face is the unknown. In that aspect, humanity (and galactic civilization, I'm not a xenophobe!) has the advantage.
We know the Reapers are coming, we've seen examples of their power in battle.  We've had access to their technology.  And, for the first time in how many millions of years, we've managed to at least delay their cycle of extinction!
Thanks to the Protheans, the Reapers have no access to information regarding our population and locations.  They are not capable of "sneaking up" on us.  They haven't managed to cripple our transportation system.
And what they do know, is that all of their back-up plans thus far have failed.  Pretty intimidating for an invading armada.

Don't give up hope!  There is still a chance!

#737
BrotherCorvid

BrotherCorvid
  • Members
  • 154 messages

Sisterofshane wrote...

Don't give up hope!  There is still a chance!


This is the truth.

Anything else is the talk of the weak and feeble.

Jargon of the quitters and the riders of bandwagons.

Anyone that tells me to go along with the Reapers is going to get a lobster claw in the face.

Modifié par RobotWalk, 31 juillet 2011 - 05:51 .


#738
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages
"My brothers! I see in your eyes the same fear that would take the heart
of me! A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our
friends and break all bonds of fellowship. But it is not this day. An
hour of woes and shattered shields when the age of Men comes crashing
down! But it is not this day! This day we fight! By all that you hold
dear on this good Earth, I bid you stand!"

Modifié par Humanoid_Typhoon, 31 juillet 2011 - 05:54 .


#739
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

100k wrote...


Its drive core is HEAVILY protected by armor in ME2, and god knows what other protections they have when fully active.


...and when a Reaper is violently blown apart?

Considering we were able to disable that core on foot I'm not putting a lot of faith into that armor. It has a very large hole in it that opens up periodically. If the Reaper is being destroyed anything can happen. Power surges and the like which could force it open. A strike could even penetrate the hull and hit the core itself.

Another thing to remember (that I've pointed out dozens of times) is that it won't just be Reapers getting destroyed. Lots and lots of friendly ships are going to bite the dust as well. Their cores, as you pointed out, aren't as well shielded.

#740
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

pablodurando wrote...

Fata Morgana wrote...

Hey Saphra, I just wanted to say that I find your post fascinating, even though I disagree.

Specifically, I think that extinction is better than becoming a reaper. Yeah, that means that everyone I love dies, too, but all I have to do is look at the plight of a husk and say, "Do I want my mother to become something like that?" to know that death is preferable.


Becoming a reaper is not the same as becoming a husk.  A reaper contains the essence of a species, at least that's what we have gotten from me2.  I would be very interested in seeing humanity become a Reaper just because the race has become immortalized and become just short of a god.  I think it'd be very interesting for a human reaper to exist.  Salvation through destruction and ascension to perfection(near).


Nope. Totally disagree.  We would be reaching an impasse upon our evolutionary curve.

Legion even says it in game -- allowing someone else to determine your path for you only limits your opportunities.  And he was an AI, closer to being a Reaper then you or I could ever dare (or dread) to imagine.
Who's to say that we couldn't achieve something greater as a species?  Or that become a Reaper might ultimately lead us down the path to our complete destruction? ( Individual Reapers have been destroyed before).

So, becoming a Reaper means Game Over.  Where's the fun in that?

#741
Bogsnot1

Bogsnot1
  • Members
  • 7 997 messages
@robotwalk: So which team member will get worm powers, so they can infect the Reapers and be a constant distraction by giving them an itchy bum?

#742
BrotherCorvid

BrotherCorvid
  • Members
  • 154 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

"My brothers! I see in your eyes the same fear that would take the heart
of me! A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our
friends and break all bonds of fellowship. But it is not this day. An
hour of woes and shattered shields when the age of Men comes crashing
down! But it is not this day! This day we fight! By all that you hold
dear on this good Earth, I bid you stand!"


Man all this bravery and courage is getting me so pumped I could punch a Reaper to pieces.

#743
100k

100k
  • Members
  • 3 152 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

100k wrote...


Its drive core is HEAVILY protected by armor in ME2, and god knows what other protections they have when fully active.


...and when a Reaper is violently blown apart?

Considering we were able to disable that core on foot I'm not putting a lot of faith into that armor. It has a very large hole in it that opens up periodically. If the Reaper is being destroyed anything can happen. Power surges and the like which could force it open. A strike could even penetrate the hull and hit the core itself.


Considering that a CAIN isn't able to shoot through the covered Reaper core (which was maintaining minimal functions at the time), I think an explosion destroying the drive core might be out of the question. And this isn't any small "might" either. This is a 70% I'm confident in my argument right. Not to be cocky or anything.

:happy::happy::happy:

Another thing to remember (that I've pointed out dozens of times) is that it won't just be Reapers getting destroyed. Lots and lots of friendly ships are going to bite the dust as well. Their cores, as you pointed out, aren't as well shielded.


Yes, but we are in control THESE ships. Alliance vessels, quarian ships, geth and turian dreadnoughts, they should all be fighting for us at the end. If they can lure the Reapers into space, then eezo might not spill over our planet.

Modifié par 100k, 31 juillet 2011 - 05:58 .


#744
BrotherCorvid

BrotherCorvid
  • Members
  • 154 messages

Bogsnot1 wrote...

@robotwalk: So which team member will get worm powers, so they can infect the Reapers and be a constant distraction by giving them an itchy bum?


That one's only gonna be available if you killed Samara and kept Morinth around, actually.  It's insidious as all get out.

Modifié par RobotWalk, 31 juillet 2011 - 06:00 .


#745
pablodurando

pablodurando
  • Members
  • 516 messages

Sisterofshane wrote...

pablodurando wrote...

Fata Morgana wrote...

Hey Saphra, I just wanted to say that I find your post fascinating, even though I disagree.

Specifically, I think that extinction is better than becoming a reaper. Yeah, that means that everyone I love dies, too, but all I have to do is look at the plight of a husk and say, "Do I want my mother to become something like that?" to know that death is preferable.


Becoming a reaper is not the same as becoming a husk.  A reaper contains the essence of a species, at least that's what we have gotten from me2.  I would be very interested in seeing humanity become a Reaper just because the race has become immortalized and become just short of a god.  I think it'd be very interesting for a human reaper to exist.  Salvation through destruction and ascension to perfection(near).


Nope. Totally disagree.  We would be reaching an impasse upon our evolutionary curve.

Legion even says it in game -- allowing someone else to determine your path for you only limits your opportunities.  And he was an AI, closer to being a Reaper then you or I could ever dare (or dread) to imagine.
Who's to say that we couldn't achieve something greater as a species?  Or that become a Reaper might ultimately lead us down the path to our complete destruction? ( Individual Reapers have been destroyed before).

So, becoming a Reaper means Game Over.  Where's the fun in that?


You're right and I think your point will ring true after the series.  I just thought it'd be an interesting experience for humanity to be captured in a Reaper.^_^

#746
Praetor Knight

Praetor Knight
  • Members
  • 5 772 messages
Hmm... sometimes I just wonder if we are just playing devils' advocates, just a little too well?! :wizard:

=]

#747
Bogsnot1

Bogsnot1
  • Members
  • 7 997 messages

pablodurando wrote...
You're right and I think your point will ring true after the series.  I just thought it'd be an interesting experience for humanity to be captured in a Reaper.^_^


Go and get a frog. Put it in a blender. Drink it. Now ask the frog what it thinks of the experience. :devil:

#748
Sisterofshane

Sisterofshane
  • Members
  • 1 756 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

100k wrote...


Its drive core is HEAVILY protected by armor in ME2, and god knows what other protections they have when fully active.


...and when a Reaper is violently blown apart?

Considering we were able to disable that core on foot I'm not putting a lot of faith into that armor. It has a very large hole in it that opens up periodically. If the Reaper is being destroyed anything can happen. Power surges and the like which could force it open. A strike could even penetrate the hull and hit the core itself.

Another thing to remember (that I've pointed out dozens of times) is that it won't just be Reapers getting destroyed. Lots and lots of friendly ships are going to bite the dust as well. Their cores, as you pointed out, aren't as well shielded.


Only you can't disable it once the armor is in place.  You have to wait for it to open again.  And I believe that the armor possibly responds to damage, so in battle it is safe to assume that, on a working Reaper, and damage sustained to the core would result in the armor shutting, sealing off further damage.

Kind of like in the end battle with the human goo-vats feeding into the human reaper.  A s soon as one is destroyed, the rest close up.

Doesn't mean that there would be no damage to any Reaper core, but it does help.

#749
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

100k wrote...

Considering that a CAIN isn't able to shoot through the covered Reaper core


You know what else it can't shoot through? Any wall you encounter in the game.

Gameplay/story segregation.

A mass accelerator shot from a star ship or thanix cannon blast would be a hell of a lot more powerful. The CAIN isn't going to take out the Collector ship.

100k wrote...

Yes, but we are in control THESE ships. Alliance vessels, quarian ships, geth and turian dreadnoughts, they should all be fighting for us at the end. If they can lure the Reapers into space, then eezo might not spill over our planet.


Oh but it will. Too many will be destroyed for you to ever be able to hope to salvage them all before they come crashing down onto the planet.

Bulldozer. Sand. Hand-shovel.

#750
BrotherCorvid

BrotherCorvid
  • Members
  • 154 messages

Bogsnot1 wrote...

pablodurando wrote...
You're right and I think your point will ring true after the series.  I just thought it'd be an interesting experience for humanity to be captured in a Reaper.^_^


Go and get a frog. Put it in a blender. Drink it. Now ask the frog what it thinks of the experience. :devil:


Incidentally, Zaeed is going to have frog powers that'll help him swim in a lake and snipe Reapers with a newly-awakened Jessie.