Aller au contenu

Photo

Den of Delusions - The morality discussion topic


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
3618 réponses à ce sujet

#3076
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Sepewrath wrote...

Its a pretty obvious perspective, who would think an army is out of character for Cerberus, they sure seemed to have a lot people yelling they were going to destroy me, with sniper rifles and throw in ME1.


There was barely any Cerberus troops in ME1. There were more mercs fought in Garrus' recruitment mission than there were Cerberus troops in all of ME1.

#3077
Someone With Mass

Someone With Mass
  • Members
  • 38 560 messages
Yeah. Obviously. Building an army with well-equipped soldiers is not something you can do overnight.

#3078
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages

Someone With Mass wrote...

Yeah. Obviously. Building an army with well-equipped soldiers is not something you can do overnight.

That and the whole "secret army" thing...

#3079
Arijharn

Arijharn
  • Members
  • 2 850 messages
On the face of it though; Cerberus as it currently is doesn't need an army. I can understand trying to build alliance super-troopers, but Cerberus isn't a public face.

Additionally, if TIM wanted to be a politician, he would have put himself in the running and not conspire to get his man in the Terra Firma instead. That's the only issue I have with it really.

EDIT: Broke this up so as to not to appear *too* scatter-brained :S

Modifié par Arijharn, 18 août 2011 - 06:06 .


#3080
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages

Arijharn wrote...

On the face of it though; Cerberus as it currently is doesn't need an army. I can understand trying to build alliance super-troopers, but Cerberus isn't a public face. Hell, if TIM wanted to be a politician, he would have put himself in the running and not conspire to get his man in the Terra Firma instead. That's the only issue I have with it really.

TIM thinks a in very longview kind of way, you can't really put anything past him,building a personal army of juggernauts is  easier then trying to control the geth,or krogan,or rachni.


That and it is very low-risk,mind you the numbers of that army could never approach that of those mentioned species under control,but it is more of a supplemental army anyway.

Modifié par Humanoid_Typhoon, 18 août 2011 - 06:07 .


#3081
Arijharn

Arijharn
  • Members
  • 2 850 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...
TIM thinks a in very longview kind of way, you can't really put anything past him,building a personal army of juggernauts is  easier then trying to control the geth,or krogan,or rachni.


That and it is very low-risk,mind you the numbers of that army could never approach that of those mentioned species under control,but it is more of a supplemental army anyway.


I'm not arguing that he can't do it, I just don't see the point of why he's doing it. He doesn't seem to want to directly wield power given the fact he likes to haunt a shadowy boardroom and has a kick ass wardrobe and regularly pulls in the space babes.

#3082
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages
The whole thing reeks of Bioware trying to have an enemy that draws an emotional response from the player as opposed to the Reapers who amount to being nothing more than a natural disaster that can speak. Cerberus just happens to fit the mold best.

We'll see if the alleged reason they're fighting Shepard is as clever as BW thinks it is...

#3083
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages

Seboist wrote...

The whole thing reeks of Bioware trying to have an enemy that draws an emotional response from the player as opposed to the Reapers who amount to being nothing more than a natural disaster that can speak. Cerberus just happens to fit the mold best.

We'll see if the alleged reason they're fighting Shepard is as clever as BW thinks it is...

I just know if you can kill TIM it will be turned into a GIF that will spread like wildfire,faster then bieber getting shot to crap on csi.

#3084
Lotion Soronarr

Lotion Soronarr
  • Members
  • 14 481 messages

GuardianAngel470 wrote...

Also, to the topic, I tend to just post my opinion in these and then leave so here goes. I agree that the best decision is to keep the base for dozens of reasons. I agree that the choice is much too black and white and that the lines stated by Shepard as a rationale for destroying the base are idiotic and naive.

But I always blow it up. Every. Single. Time. About 15 times to be exact. Why? The Illusive Man. Samara, Mordin, and many others voice better for my Shepard than Shepard did my reasons for destroying the base. To paraphrase Samara, "TIM believes he has the wisdom to utilize it. He does not."



Ohhkaaay...and how would Samara know that?

Better yet, who does have the wisdom? Note that "no one" is not an acceptable asnwer.

#3085
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

Seboist wrote...

The whole thing reeks of Bioware trying to have an enemy that draws an emotional response from the player as opposed to the Reapers who amount to being nothing more than a natural disaster that can speak. Cerberus just happens to fit the mold best.

We'll see if the alleged reason they're fighting Shepard is as clever as BW thinks it is...

I just know if you can kill TIM it will be turned into a GIF that will spread like wildfire,faster then bieber getting shot to crap on csi.


If they butcher his character I'd glady put him out of his misery myself.

#3086
Ahriman

Ahriman
  • Members
  • 2 022 messages

Seboist wrote...
There was barely any Cerberus troops in ME1. There were more mercs fought in Garrus' recruitment mission than there were Cerberus troops in all of ME1.

And didn't have enough forces to even retake his own lab in last novel. Well, he could lie to himself in case someone reads his mind, but that would be strange.

#3087
Lotion Soronarr

Lotion Soronarr
  • Members
  • 14 481 messages

alperez wrote...
Secondly, you claim that being offered a seat on the council in mass effect (try to remember the criteria for getting that seat in game) somehow shows that you don't have as much power and say as the other 3 members of the council, which in fact in game has not been shown, so cannot be proven.


Logic proves it. Power is the product of size, strength and influence. Humans are the new kids on the block.



Again you seem to believe you have any idea of what i believe in which is a misconception on your part.

I never said they wouldn't or that they are pure and benevolent, what i've said is much more simple than that, its that  in game its not been shown to be the case that they behave or would behave as you say they do and until its shown any suggestion that this is indeed how they are, is based on nothing more than a speculation on your part.

If there are examples of them doing so then you can rightly claim that this proves your point, without those examples you instead have to rely on how things have been presented in game and in game if they suggest that all aliens are one way until shown otherwise the simple truth is that's how they are.


I haven't seen the Council do ANYTHING that doesn't benefit them directly, even at the expense of others.





If the game is trying to go for any semblance of realism, then the defautl applies untill proven otherwise. I never see humans going in the bathroom to take a ******. Does that mean I shouldn't consider they do go to the bathroom, untill the game proves me otherwise?
No.

Politics works as it does because that's how it works best. Consider it a law of the universe and survival (of the fittest). For ME to abandon that would be the same as abandoning evolution or gravity - heck, even worse.


In a game set in a fictional universe where aliens exist and we're about to be wiped from existence by a super advanced machine race that's been doing this for countless cycles, then realism has left the building.

This isn't a politics sim, its not a strategy game based on real events, so why the hell do real world politics (an issue that if done in realisticly in a game would provoke controversy and create problems with accuracy) actually apply.


BS. You cannot argue realism and believabiltiy away on the grounds that SOME fantastical elements exist.
Politics and power gaes not working like politics and power games is like hot ice - stupid.

#3088
Kaiser Shepard

Kaiser Shepard
  • Members
  • 7 890 messages

Seboist wrote...

The whole thing reeks of Bioware trying to have an enemy that draws an emotional response from the player as opposed to the Reapers who amount to being nothing more than a natural disaster that can speak. Cerberus just happens to fit the mold best.

We'll see if the alleged reason they're fighting Shepard is as clever as BW thinks it is...

I doubt it. And even if the reason is clever, the decision stays poor from a design perspective: the CB decision should've been the point at which the main routes split, leading the Paragon go Alliance/rogue/whatever and fight Cerbies, while the Renegade would stay with Cerberus and fight mercs and other enemies.

It doesn't seem to difficult from my end to only have just the one big endgame choice have such a 'big' effect, which from a gameplay perspective would come down mostly to having either enemy set P or enemy set R placed in the levels, as well as a couple of 3 to 5 minute scenes with your 'handler' (TIM or Hackett/Anderson).

Also, should I still change the topic title?

Modifié par Kaiser Shepard, 18 août 2011 - 07:06 .


#3089
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Kaiser Shepard wrote...

Seboist wrote...

The whole thing reeks of Bioware trying to have an enemy that draws an emotional response from the player as opposed to the Reapers who amount to being nothing more than a natural disaster that can speak. Cerberus just happens to fit the mold best.

We'll see if the alleged reason they're fighting Shepard is as clever as BW thinks it is...

I doubt it. And even if the reason is clever, the decision stays poor from a design perspective: the CB decision should've been the point at which the main routes split, leading the Paragon go Alliance/rogue/whatever and fight Cerbies, while the Renegade would stay with Cerberus and fight mercs and other enemies.


Cerberus shouldn't be this major opponent in the first place regardless of the CB. The whole implication of Arrival was that the Batarians would be the big Reaper proxy whether through indoctrination or willingly due to wanting revernge against Shepard/humans.

We should have been fighting Batarian SIU in Sar'kesh and wherever else not some large Cerberus army that shouldn't even exist.

#3090
Homebound

Homebound
  • Members
  • 11 891 messages
you humans are all flipflops!

#3091
Kaiser Shepard

Kaiser Shepard
  • Members
  • 7 890 messages

Seboist wrote...

We should have been fighting Batarian SIU in Sar'kesh and wherever else not some large Cerberus army that shouldn't even exist.

Meh, Chessmaster/Magnificent Bastard. Hell, we probably even led hid to the stuff he needed for his army throughout ME2, most notably the cloning and memory imprinting tech on Korlus.

#3092
Arijharn

Arijharn
  • Members
  • 2 850 messages
I think it would be awesome to know in some ways that actions you took in ME2 does benefit Cerb in 3, and they were innocuous as well (i.e., not the CB elephant in the room). Stuff like; getting the Pulp Fiction-esque 'suitcase' from the freighter or something inane like that.

#3093
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Arijharn wrote...

I think it would be awesome to know in some ways that actions you took in ME2 does benefit Cerb in 3, and they were innocuous as well (i.e., not the CB elephant in the room). Stuff like; getting the Pulp Fiction-esque 'suitcase' from the freighter or something inane like that.


The data collected from the Firewalker missions would fit the bill but they're dlc unfortunately.

#3094
Arijharn

Arijharn
  • Members
  • 2 850 messages
Meh, they can 'assume' people have it, it was free after all. They assume that Shadow Broker and Arrival happened too.

#3095
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Arijharn wrote...

Meh, they can 'assume' people have it, it was free after all. They assume that Shadow Broker and Arrival happened too.


Hopefully.

Was that freighter mission you were refering to that one from the blue suns beacon campaign?

#3096
Humanoid_Typhoon

Humanoid_Typhoon
  • Members
  • 4 735 messages
After I unlocked the achieevo I never went after those files again on firewalker.

Would be interesting if the little side mission and crap that didn't seem to matter helped Cerberus against you...or so appease the "zomg no good deed unpunished is bs" crowd,not doing them has the same effect.

Modifié par Humanoid_Typhoon, 18 août 2011 - 07:43 .


#3097
Arijharn

Arijharn
  • Members
  • 2 850 messages

Seboist wrote...

Arijharn wrote...

Meh, they can 'assume' people have it, it was free after all. They assume that Shadow Broker and Arrival happened too.


Hopefully.

Was that freighter mission you were refering to that one from the blue suns beacon campaign?


I do believe so, the one with Sergeant Bortis (Boris?) trying to duff over his commanding officer and get the loot.

#3098
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages
That's definitely the one.

I must say that I'm almost as curious as to the outcomes of the Rawlings data and Overlord missions in ME3 as I am with the CB. Those data packets from Overlord would also fit the bill of being innocuous..... if they have purpose beyond being for achievement grinding that is.

#3099
sH0tgUn jUliA

sH0tgUn jUliA
  • Members
  • 16 812 messages

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

Arijharn wrote...

Humanoid_Typhoon wrote...

Well,they said TIM isn't after you *per se* but there isn't too much besides from "40%",maybe that little factoid shouldn't have been thrown out there so willy-nilly


Could mean that we start to involve ourselves in whatever shenanigans Cerberus are performing imo, and not the other way around like so many (myself included) have come to believe.

Eh who knows,maybe TIM is tired of alien women and he has moved onto varren and horses.


So THAT's how the scale itch got on board the Normandy.:blink:

#3100
SalsaDMA

SalsaDMA
  • Members
  • 2 512 messages

Wizz wrote...

Seboist wrote...
There was barely any Cerberus troops in ME1. There were more mercs fought in Garrus' recruitment mission than there were Cerberus troops in all of ME1.

And didn't have enough forces to even retake his own lab in last novel. Well, he could lie to himself in case someone reads his mind, but that would be strange.


That's actually one of the things that bother me the most.

After the novel, TIM and Cerberus was basicly crippled and was in need of time to be able to get back on its feet as a big player. Yet here we are and they are a primary force to deal with. It's almost as if they disregarded the novels implications.