Dionkey wrote...
No, but the Geth cannot tell the difference between the innocent and the ones at fault.
Rogue Unit wrote...
Read my post above.
And if that's true, why the hell would they try to go to war with the Geth again? Their numbers are fewer than what they were during the Morning War and the Geth are more advanced and have so many advantages it's hard to list them all.
Seems like they're detremined to lose that last 1%.
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Technologically, they are the most advanced race in the galaxy. Philosophically, they are the most primitave. Examing data cannot help you gain a sense of morality or emotion, it can do just about everything else, though.didymos1120 wrote...
Dionkey wrote...
No, but the Geth cannot tell the difference between the innocent and the ones at fault.
Please. They were just plain incapable of determining that, say, an infant wasn't a threat? If they were truly so stupid, they shouldn't have been able to win that war, much less read the sacred scrolls (which demonstrates they had access to all sorts of knowledge that would have helped them make such determinations) and comprehend them well enough to ask troubling questions about souls.
jreezy wrote...
The more logical choice would probably be the quarians.
Modifié par Ryanratto, 13 août 2011 - 10:08 .
Mr_DeMille wrote...
"But they're are sentient"
Screw their sentience. They feel no pain or fear. They don't suffer. That's the difference.
If you try to kill a geth, it won't "like" it, it wont "dislike" it. It will only do what it thinks it's logical, fight for continued existence. They're were an accident.
Unless you really need them to fight the Reapers there is no point in choosing fancy robots over living, breathing beings.
Plus they want to build some megastructure and isolate themselves anyway, all the galactic civilizations will get is a creepy neighbor.
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Yeah that makes sense. From a combat perspective the Geth would most likely be the better choice. Personally I want the Quarians and the Geth on my side.xXljoshlXx wrote...
jreezy wrote...
The more logical choice would probably be the quarians.
I can see where your coming from but i think the more logical choice for me would be the Geth. One of the biggest reason is they already beat the quarians. I can see alot more advantages and less disadvantages than the Qaurians.
But hey that's just my take on it.
Ad hominem much?AnAccountWithNoName wrote...
xXljoshlXx wrote...
AnAccountWithNoName wrote...
You want Proof? How about using something called common sense? We know the Quarian species numbered in the billions, and we know not every quarian in existence was apart of their military. Put 2+2 together.
Sounds like assuming and you know what say about assumingWhat sin? Winning the war?AnAccountWithNoName wrote...
So your blaming the father for the sins of the son now? Yes the quarians did wrong, however once the geth gained free will they are responsible for there OWN ACTIONS, they became "there own man" so to speak.
Men like you makes this world a scary place.
SandTrout wrote...
While the Geth might be more immediately useful, the Quarians are more likely to be a loyal client species to the rising Human Empire.
legion999 wrote...
Mr_DeMille wrote...
"But they're are sentient"
Screw their sentience. They feel no pain or fear. They don't suffer. That's the difference.
If you try to kill a geth, it won't "like" it, it wont "dislike" it. It will only do what it thinks it's logical, fight for continued existence. They're were an accident.
Unless you really need them to fight the Reapers there is no point in choosing fancy robots over living, breathing beings.
Plus they want to build some megastructure and isolate themselves anyway, all the galactic civilizations will get is a creepy neighbor.
Some humans don't feel pain or fear. Should we just kill them because they don't like or dislike it?
xXljoshlXx wrote...
SandTrout wrote...
While the Geth might be more immediately useful, the Quarians are more likely to be a loyal client species to the rising Human Empire.
I don't really support any client race not because I don't like but i don't want become reliant on another species like the council races. Maybe the Vorcha I would accept.legion999 wrote...
Mr_DeMille wrote...
"But they're are sentient"
Screw their sentience. They feel no pain or fear. They don't suffer. That's the difference.
If you try to kill a geth, it won't "like" it, it wont "dislike" it. It will only do what it thinks it's logical, fight for continued existence. They're were an accident.
Unless you really need them to fight the Reapers there is no point in choosing fancy robots over living, breathing beings.
Plus they want to build some megastructure and isolate themselves anyway, all the galactic civilizations will get is a creepy neighbor.
Some humans don't feel pain or fear. Should we just kill them because they don't like or dislike it?
Of course that is the logical course of action
Besides i prefer people who don't bother me.
Does it matter if they breathe or don't ?
SovietCyborg wrote...
I chose to enslave both races as a servants of the Grand Shepard's Empire.
Glory_Man wrote...
I think the council races might dislike that you side with the geth, so there might be other consequences...
Rockworm503 wrote...
Slayer299 wrote...
I keep seeing this type of comment and I can only shake my head sadly. How can you accuse the Quarians of enslaving VI's that were programmed to handle dangerous jobs for them? Are you saying that your toaster or your PC is being enslaved by you?
Unfair how many toasters do you know can talk and have consious thought?
Did anyone actually dismiss everything Legion says just because he's made of metal?
Rockworm503 wrote...
Heres the thing about the "their just machines" argument. If my toaster tried to kill me for making toast then I'd think I'm crazy lol. You can't really compare this to real life application. The Geth are machines yes. But machines capable of fighting back if pushed. What if the way to avoid the rise of the machines in Terminator was to talk to them and try to reach an understanding? Maybe the fact their just machines mean they should have no rights. Their actions and what their capable of tells me otherwise.
Han Shot First wrote...
Someone With Mass wrote...
Slayer299 wrote...
Yes, its just terrible that they have different views on how to deal with the Geth instead of just falling on their knees apologizing.
Plus, the Geth committed Genocide against the Quarins in the MW, how do you commit genocide against a piece of software?
That.
Legion even says that they're immortal.
They have privileges the quarians don't.
The Geth aren't really immortal. They don't die naturally of course, but they can be killed. Geth 'death' occurs when a Geth platform is destroyed before the software can upload itself safely to a server.
Modifié par Wereparrot, 13 août 2011 - 01:26 .
Modifié par Ryzaki, 13 août 2011 - 01:23 .
Someone With Mass wrote...
Can't they simply work together?
Modifié par Rogue Unit, 13 août 2011 - 01:27 .
Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut