1310 réponses à ce sujet

[Kusy]

EA Changes Origin Terms of Services Forbidding class Action Lawsuits

Modifié par Mr.Kusy, 27 septembre 2011 - 03:55 .

[CSunkyst]

You have to waive your right to file a class action lawsuit in order to play ME3???????
What's next, by agreeing to the Origin terms of service you give EA power of attorney??

Arrrrrrr avast ye mateys.

Seriously, it's like they're BEGGING people to wear an eye patch and fly the Jolly Roger.

No sane person should agree to this.  There's NO CHANCE Origin is sinking one of it's greasy talons onto my PC. 

Modifié par CSunkyst, 27 septembre 2011 - 05:31 .

[Embrosil]

Hitchno wrote...

Filurija wrote...

http://www.gameinfor...-agreement.aspx

Ahahah yeah right.  For those that don't want to read the link...

"By accepting these terms, you and EA expressly waive the right to a trial by jury or to participate in a class action.



YOU UNDERSTAND THAT BY THIS PROVISION, YOU AND EA ARE FOREGOING THE RIGHT TO SUE IN COURT AND HAVE A JURY TRIAL.



YOU AND EA AGREE THAT EACH MAY BRING CLAIMS AGAINST THE OTHER ONLY IN
YOUR OR ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY, AND NOT AS A PLAINTIFF OR class MEMBER
IN ANY PURPORTED class OR REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDING."

Yeah good luck selling that in Canada.  It's 100% illegal to strip away a persons right by EULA, ToS or contract here.  Oh just to add, I'm sure the whole thing about this being a new ToS and giving people only "2 days" to opt out is really kosher and all that. 

Do they have it in the Czech language as well? If not, this, as well as any other EULA not written in Czech language is not valid here in the Czech Republic.

Modifié par Embrosil, 27 septembre 2011 - 06:17 .

[Weskerr]

Embrosil wrote...

Hitchno wrote...

Filurija wrote...

http://www.gameinfor...-agreement.aspx

Ahahah yeah right.  For those that don't want to read the link...

"By accepting these terms, you and EA expressly waive the right to a trial by jury or to participate in a class action.



YOU UNDERSTAND THAT BY THIS PROVISION, YOU AND EA ARE FOREGOING THE RIGHT TO SUE IN COURT AND HAVE A JURY TRIAL.



YOU AND EA AGREE THAT EACH MAY BRING CLAIMS AGAINST THE OTHER ONLY IN
YOUR OR ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY, AND NOT AS A PLAINTIFF OR class MEMBER
IN ANY PURPORTED class OR REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDING."

Yeah good luck selling that in Canada.  It's 100% illegal to strip away a persons right by EULA, ToS or contract here.  Oh just to add, I'm sure the whole thing about this being a new ToS and giving people only "2 days" to opt out is really kosher and all that. 

Do they have it in the Czech language as well? If not, this, as well as any other EULA not written in Czech language is not valid here in the Czech Republic.

Even if they do, this only applies to the United States because of a Supreme Court ruling.

Modifié par Weskerr, 27 septembre 2011 - 09:33 .

[DeathDragon185]

one quick thing

DO NOT respond to BBW(you know who I mean).

[Twinklesz]

Awesome, so thats battlefield 3 pre order cancelled, just waiting on any confirmation of me3 connection to origin and that will be cancelled too. Just to clarify though right, didnt bioware state SWTOR will not use origin ? I hope this will be the same with mass effect 3,,,which i doubt as TOR is a multiplayer game, and going to be impossible to pirate.

Just **** off ea and take your dragging privacy through the mud program with you, we dont want it on our pc's and you will not get our money unless you sort this **** out.

Edit : You know the irony of the origin client, there in all likeleyhood trying to combat piracy with this - but there is nothing more they could of done to push people towards said piracy of there games, did EA not learn anything from Spore ?

Modifié par Twinklesz, 27 septembre 2011 - 11:08 .

[Neverwinter_Knight77]

CSunkyst wrote...

You have to waive your right to file a class action lawsuit in order to play ME3???????
What's next, by agreeing to the Origin terms of service you give EA power of attorney??

"I hereby sign my home and all of my monetary assets to Electronic Arts, Inc. in the case of my death..."

[suprhomre]

I haven't play, red, followed or had anything to do with Assassins2 do you know why?

[Jonas TM]

I may be reading between the lines on this one, but check out this recent news item on GameSpot: http://www.gamespot....he-next-year-ea

"[EA] ...has four big Origin pushes coming up. First up is the open beta for Battlefield 3, which begins Thursday and requires players to download the Origin program. After that, DeMartini said he expects The Old Republic, The Sims, and next March's launch of Mass Effect 3 to drive new user adoption of the service." - David DeMartini, EA publishing exec.

Bolded for emphasis. Looks like I'm going to be buying the collectors edition and then DLing a cracked version. I'm not letting Origin on my system with that EULA or giving EA impunity to sniff around everything on my PC.

Modifié par Jonas TM, 27 septembre 2011 - 11:49 .

[LadyofRivendell]

Okay, I'm just wondering, why all the uproar? Sure, I don't think they SHOULD do it, but I'm not going to cancel all games that use Origin because of it. What are they going to see on my computer that could be harmful? Why would they sift through it and take anything? It's not like they're watching us through webcams or sending our credit card numbers to hackers.

[Jonas TM]

The uproar is based on this - by agreeing to the Origin EULA you allow EA to not only scan your running programs (which is annoying, but other services do it to so, meh) but sniff around all your installed programs, drivers and files. It is right their in the EULA. Also as of last week if you accept the EULA in the US you forfeit your right to any class action lawsuit (which I understand is 100% illegal in a lot of other countries).

Its not a matter of what EA will find. Its a matter of what hackers will find when they either exploit some vulnerability in Origin or get into EA's database. Not to mention their twitchy DRM conflicting with something already on your system (StarForce anyone?). I remember back about 10 years ago when StarForce and other similar DRMs were just getting started and burning out people's CD drives and causing registry issues.

[Weskerr]

Jonas TM wrote...

I may be reading between the lines on this one, but check out this recent news item on GameSpot: http://www.gamespot....he-next-year-ea

"[EA] ...has four big Origin pushes coming up. First up is the open beta for Battlefield 3, which begins Thursday and requires players to download the Origin program. After that, DeMartini said he expects The Old Republic, The Sims, and next March's launch of Mass Effect 3 to drive new user adoption of the service." - David DeMartini, EA publishing exec.

Bolded for emphasis. Looks like I'm going to be buying the collectors edition and then DLing a cracked version. I'm not letting Origin on my system with that EULA or giving EA impunity to sniff around everything on my PC.

That's too vague to be a confirmation of anything concerning ME3 and Origin. He "expects [them] to drive new user adoption of the service" does not mean that Origin is required. It sounds more like he thinks the expected popularity of Battlefield 3, which does require Origin, will give people incentive to use Origin for other EA games.

[goofyomnivore]

The file scanning bit is annoying but tolerable(To me anways). Blizzard's TOS/EULA is pretty much the same, and I've played their games for years. However I trust Blizzard much more than EA about hacker prevention/protection.

Origin is pretty crummy though right now. It is in "beta", but it really needs to improve by leaps and bounds for when Battlefield 3 and TOR drop. Origin would be a cancer to those games right now in its current state. Due to its very poor interface and lack of any social atmosphere. It hasn't made any noticeable improvements in 6 months-ish.

"By accepting these terms, you and EA expressly waive the right to a trial by jury or to participate in a class action."

That is absurd. I'm pretty tolerable when it comes to my "gaming/pc rights". However that is way past the line of being reasonable.

I think I'm just going to pre-order a hard copy now rather than a digital version.

Modifié par strive, 28 septembre 2011 - 02:48 .

[ilPianiste]

Jonas TM wrote...
Looks like I'm going to be buying the collectors edition and then DLing a cracked version.

Well, anyone should do what he/she considers the right thing to do.

In my opinion, however, buying and then *****ing is inconstent and will result in EA thinking this consumer is okay with their business practises. I won't elaborate on what in my opinion is a lot more consistent...

[MartinDN]

ilPianiste wrote...

Jonas TM wrote...
Looks like I'm going to be buying the collectors edition and then DLing a cracked version.

Well, anyone should do what he/she considers the right thing to do.

In my opinion, however, buying and then *****ing is inconstent and will result in EA thinking this consumer is okay with their business practises. I won't elaborate on what in my opinion is a lot more consistent...

It looks like im going to do the same thing, however, im not sure what you wrote i assume it was "crack"ing and i think it only sends a clear signal to EA, we want your games, we do not want origin, so we are prepared to crack our purchased games to play it.

But if everyone was to crack it without purchasing it, that gives then the justification they need to continue with their business practices in the first place, you must not go to there level and download it.

I have one question for anyone please, what happens if we were to purchase mass effect 3 like normal and it required origin to install, and we had to crack it after the install ? it would defeat the whole point of this as origin will still be installed right ?

[ilPianiste]

I'm sure certain words and too clear implications have to be avoided in order for this thread to remain open.  

MartinDN wrote...
It looks like im going to do the same thing, however, im not sure what you wrote i assume it was "*****"ing and i think it only sends a clear signal to EA, we want your games, we do not want origin, so we are prepared to ***** our purchased games to play it.

Let's be realistic: The most clear signal that can be sent is explicitly worded protest. But does it matter to EA just because it's "clear"?

Obviously their only real concern is a) negative publicity (too much of it anyway), loss of sales. I doubt anyone at EA/BioWare will be seriously concerned if sales are "very good" or even "exceedingly good" but a small portion of buyers didn't bind their game to an Origin-account. The management just will hope that in the future they can further refine their DRM so that it becomes more difficult or even impossible to circumvent.

But if everyone was to crack it without purchasing it, that gives then the justification they need to continue with their business practices in the first place, you must not go to there level and download it.

True, that might be their line of thought. But as said above, I think buying and then *****ing the game fails on an even more fundamental level to have any impact...

On another note: Origin is inacceptable not just because it is "spyware" but also for it's intent to make the purchase one of a "service" and thus any used-sales impossible. This in my eyes massively degrades the worth of a boxed copy, and I'm simply not willing to pay as much for such a game as I did "in the past" when after purchase I could consider the game "mine". (Though I never wanted to sell my copy of ME2 and presumably wouldn't want to do so with ME3 - if I ever purchased it. )

Modifié par ilPianiste, 28 septembre 2011 - 10:15 .

[DCopeland]

No steam?
No retail?
Forced Origin?
No buy.

[MagicGis]

The problem with buying the orginal and than cracking will be that you have to install ori to install it. We all know ...**** like this is opretty hard to get off your system after that... like the dirty virus it is it will crowl his way deep into your system and hide behind some acceptable programms.

On the other hand ...I have no other chance, than install my original and than crack, since I want my dlc and they will be linked to... ah damn.

But the right way for sure is... buy...than crack. Oh and pray that the people making that decision at EA and Bioware, will get their 1000 years of extra torture in hell for it.

Another thing, reading the EULA i see at least 3 points completly illegal in germany ... nice one EA.

Also still no post form an offical here I think we can this count as a confirmed on forced origin.

[elitecom]

Jonas TM wrote...

I may be reading between the lines on this one, but check out this recent news item on GameSpot: http://www.gamespot....he-next-year-ea

"[EA] ...has four big Origin pushes coming up. First up is the open beta for Battlefield 3, which begins Thursday and requires players to download the Origin program. After that, DeMartini said he expects The Old Republic, The Sims, and next March's launch of Mass Effect 3 to drive new user adoption of the service." - David DeMartini, EA publishing exec.

Bolded for emphasis. Looks like I'm going to be buying the collectors edition and then DLing a cracked version. I'm not letting Origin on my system with that EULA or giving EA impunity to sniff around everything on my PC.

Blast! Well one can always continue to hope, anyway I shouldn't be forced to use Origin to play ME3 a singleplayer game, which shouldn't require any connection to an online service whatsoever.  

MartinDN wrote...
we want your games, we do not want origin

Exactly, why force Origin upon us? Next to no people like things being forced upon them.

Modifié par elitecom, 28 septembre 2011 - 04:37 .

[anzolino]

MagicGis wrote...
Another thing, reading the EULA i see at least 3 points completly illegal in germany ... nice one EA.

Not only 3 points - there are 12 dubios points despite the data protection law.
The problem with buying and than cracking is that the sales numbers won't drop down and EA will never learn that the customers do not want this EULA.

[shepskisaac]

anzolino wrote...

The problem with buying and than cracking is that the sales numbers won't drop down and EA will never learn that the customers do not want this EULA.

Actually, they will. If EA technicians see Origin usage stops in (let's say) 40%+ of ME3 copies right after initial installation, they will know it ain't just those few people who forgot about the game/gave it away like it happens with every game, but that the consumers mass crack their legitimate copies with the obvious goal - making Origin go away.

Frankly, I don't get EA's uber-basic mistake with Origin. They KNEW they're huge corporation which automatically puts them at disadvantage and consumer untrust when it comes to stuff like this, especially when compared with Steam that comes from small & beloved Valve. I don't mind at all they want to create their own platform, their right and all and I wouldn't mind at all installing Origin for ME3 if it didn't have these spyware functions, most likely like the majority of the gamers. But instead of proving everyone wrong and making everything they could to earn & ensure consumers' trust for Origin before TOR, BF3 & ME3 debut, they did exactly what everyone feared & suspected, the exact 'big corporate evil thing' and right at the beginning at that. I'm just... Why?! All the work they've done in the past few years, investing into new IPs, putting AAA quality in priority, gets wasted with such banal mistakes like this and DA2 and pretty much reverts EA's image back to its pre-Riccitiello state.

[Weskerr]

IsaacShep wrote...

anzolino wrote...

The problem with buying and than cracking is that the sales numbers won't drop down and EA will never learn that the customers do not want this EULA.

Actually, they will. If EA technicians see Origin usage stops in (let's say) 40%+ of ME3 copies right after initial installation, they will know it ain't just those few people who forgot about the game/gave it away like it happens with every game, but that the consumers mass crack their legitimate copies with the obvious goal - making Origin go away.

Frankly, I don't get EA's uber-basic mistake with Origin. They KNEW they're huge corporation which automatically puts them at disadvantage and consumer untrust when it comes to stuff like this, especially when compared with Steam that comes from small & beloved Valve. I don't mind at all they want to create their own platform, their right and all and I wouldn't mind at all installing Origin for ME3 if it didn't have these spyware functions, most likely like the majority of the gamers. But instead of proving everyone wrong and making everything they could to earn & ensure consumers' trust for Origin before TOR, BF3 & ME3 debut, they did exactly what everyone feared & suspected, the exact 'big corporate evil thing' and right at the beginning at that. I'm just... Why?! All the work they've done in the past few years, investing into new IPs, putting AAA quality in priority, gets wasted with such banal mistakes like this and DA2 and pretty much reverts EA's image back to its pre-Riccitiello state.

Apparently they disagree with your point of view. They think this risk will pay off - literally. It's up to the consumers to decide whether or not they succeed or fail. All I can say for certain is that they won't be getting my money if they don't either 1. Satisfactorily change their EULA OR 2. Allow ME3 to be played without Origin.

[shepskisaac]

Weskerr wrote...

Apparently they disagree with your point of view. They think this risk will pay off - literally. It's up to the consumers to decide whether or not they succeed or fail. All I can say for certain is that they won't be getting my money if they don't either 1. Satisfactorily change their EULA OR 2. Allow ME3 to be played without Origin.

But what in the world is worth risking so much? Origin would've been exactly as succesful (and more likely even more) if it didn't have these spyware characeristics og gathering all information about console/computer/user.