Aller au contenu

Photo

The Official Knight-Captain Cullen Discussion thread 2.0.


89415 réponses à ce sujet

#31551
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

deuce985 wrote...

motomotogirl wrote...

Can you guys think of another NPC that made a similar impact on you? I really can't. I do love Alain. But I am weird in that lol


Morrigan. I like sassy women!


LOL she's a companion, they don't count cos they're supposed to make an impact on you (especially the romanceable ones!) What about npc's that aren't companions? Did any of those make a big impact on you as much as Cullen did (if he made a big impact on you at all, that is).

#31552
VampOrchid

VampOrchid
  • Members
  • 3 537 messages
Maybe Anora...Sir Gylmore...but nowhere in comparison to Cullen

Personally, I really like Dagna and Jowan 'had' potential

#31553
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Can anyone think of an NPC from any other BioWare game that's created as much positive and negative attention as Cullen?

(Companions don't count lol).

... Harbinger maybe? No, wait, that space kid... Although that was mostly negative LOL.

#31554
deuce985

deuce985
  • Members
  • 3 572 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Can anyone think of an NPC from any other BioWare game that's created as much positive and negative attention as Cullen?

(Companions don't count lol).

... Harbinger maybe? No, wait, that space kid... Although that was mostly negative LOL.


Harbinger was annoying in ME2. I got tired of hearing his repetitive lines..."Assuming direct control". Blah blah. Hated him.

To answer your question, no non-companion comes to mind. Cullen is really the only one I can think of currently. I always liked Cullen because he felt like he had great character development for such a minor role in our stories. But then again, I'm half awake, just took two aspirin, and my mind is clouded. Maybe I can revisit this subject tomorrow when I don't feel like a zombie and can actually think.

God child was all negativity. I don't think he generated ANY positivity.

Dang, I can't spell lol

Modifié par deuce985, 12 janvier 2013 - 07:53 .


#31555
CuriousArtemis

CuriousArtemis
  • Members
  • 19 656 messages

cacey lee wrote...

motomotogirl wrote...

Can you guys think of another NPC that made a similar impact on you? I really can't. I do love Alain. But I am weird in that lol

Fenrial...(if thats how you spell it) *Not as much as Cullen but I really liked him.


I think Feynriel :D Yeah that's a good one; I'm not that into him, but I can see how he'd definitely intrigue a player into wanting to know more about him and his story, where he's going, etc.

Anora... I've noticed a few people here and there who seem to think Anora is in love with their Cousland and the pair lived happily ever after as king and queen. Not sure if that's in the players' heads or if Anora really does fall in love with Cousland if he marries her. Have a feeling it's the former though.

Jowan... I think because he has so many different potential fates (he can actually escape, right?) that people find him interesting. Also because it's never clear I think whether or not he's a good guy or a bad guy. 

I have to say Tamlen left an impact on me. I was really depressed when he disappeared. I thought he'd return, too. And then when he DID "return"...!  

:o

Always felt there were unrequited feelings between him and my Dalish Warden. But of course I learned later that he DOES have feelings for the FEMALE Dalish Warden. Bah.

I find it kind of strange that people never went bonkers over Cassandra on the BSN. She's beautiful, she's strong, her voice is awesome, she's in the entire game, in a way, and she gets her own anime. There's enough to love and hate for both sides there.

#31556
Danny Boy 7

Danny Boy 7
  • Members
  • 3 762 messages

motomotogirl wrote...

Can you guys think of another NPC that made a similar impact on you? I really can't. I do love Alain. But I am weird in that lol


I'd say Cassandra, but she had...a good bit more. I mean I'd say she has idk if you all agree :P She actually has a good hate following lol believe it or not, but nowhere near the amount that Cullen does. For her it tends to be an attack on anime's in general and how purist some of the fans are with regard to their games. Others just don't like Chantry characters and as they say can't wait to knife her, Cullen, Leliana and Sebastian. So idk if it's her hate so much as it's those general topics hate. It might also be because instead of being a possible companion, she's basically been confirmed without actual confirmation.

I thought Tamlen was pretty cool though I HATED the Dalish Origin, or should I say found it a tad boring. Start in the woods, go to cave, find mirror, get corrupted, meet Duncan, learn Dalish stuff, go back to cave, profit. It did have a rather nice send off though. I'm actually curious how a Dalish Warden would deal with Marethari's death and his/her clan's (if you killed them all) and what he/she would do to Merrill.

My favorite characters from the Origins however have been (Cullen obviously :P), Fergus and Shianni. Fergus because he's my bro and kind of funny and Shianni because of how she reacts to the potential rape. She's show she's not a victim, but doesn't lose all trust in humans which many people might (not that I blame them) and doesn't lose any of that fiery spirit that got her in trouble in the first place. I don't much care for character developement through rape, but her's wasn't bad.

In the end though it's very hard for me to think of any NPC who's had as much developement as Cullen. I'm sure there are some. Some are dead though (Duncan) and others just have more time to develope their characters. I'd say for a NPC to reach Cullen's status they would have to have a collective screen time of up to 20 minutes and no more, not be a companion, temporary is fine as long as they fufill the initial requirement and aren't a major quest giver throughout the game.

The first to come to mind though is Flemeth, but...idk she sort of fails that first requirement if only by a little bit. So...hmm idk. No one springs to mind, but then again we have so few returning characters to begin with who were NPC's on both occassions.

I liked Kardol...from the Legion of the Dead. Idk this is hard lol.

#31557
Newschmoo

Newschmoo
  • Members
  • 1 176 messages

motomotogirl wrote...

Can you guys think of another NPC that made a similar impact on you? I really can't. I do love Alain. But I am weird in that lol


I liked Dagna, she had so much enthusiasm.  And I really liked Emeric and I did feel a little sad when his body was found.  I kind of felt like he was one of the 'good' templars.  It's also nice to hear a gruff welsh voice!

#31558
Newschmoo

Newschmoo
  • Members
  • 1 176 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Thinking about it, it's kinda bizarre how much of a following Cullen's acquired, especially considering he's only ever been a relatively unimportant npc. Stranger still is that Cullen's popularity began in DA:O, in which he had even less of a presence than DA2 and was (generally) considered less attractive than his DA2 model. If you put together every possible interaction with Cullen from both games it wouldn't even amount to 15 minutes. 

This oblivious, slightly awkward, (seemingly) socially inexperienced Templar and mere npc has generated more attention (both good and bad) than some of the companions themselves! And it goes beyond just this thread, I've found hundreds, maybe even thousands of fanfic, fan-art, photo manipulations, head swaps, poems and video tributes dedicated to this man and contrary to popular belief, it's not JUST because "he fancied the F!Mage Warden and had a face lift in DA2". Sure, he has quite a large following of women and gay men, BUT he also seems to have quite a sizable straight male and lesbian fanbase too.

His personal story arc actually interests people. His (potential) crush on the Fem!Mage Warden in DA:O, his torture at the hands of demons and bloodmages in KinlochHold, the breakdown that led to him being sent to a Greenfell to recover, his eventual transfer to Kirkwall and subsequent promotion through the Templar ranks to Knight Captain status despite his young age, and finally the realisation that his superior had become corrupt leading him to eventually aid Hawke (sometimes a mage, of all things!) In slaying the Knight Commander. On paper it all seems in-depth and incredibly dramatic and if you didn't know any better you'd be forgiven for thinking that I'd just described a full companions story arc... but all these events, everything that we've learnt about him (that we know to be 100% true) has played out in under 15 minutes of screen time (some of which is only shown via codex entries and npc gossip), and we've barely even scratched the surface! We've seen his personal growth in-game first hand, we feel like we know this character intimately, yet we know very little about him. Hell, we don't even know for sure if he has a Surname, let alone a family, or, Maker forbid, a girlfriend/boyfriend!

When you look at it objectively, it's not surprising that DG seems somewhat shocked by his level of popularity. Yet, after reading this back, to an outsider it would be equally surprising if he wasn't made a companion.

Crazy isn't it.


I agree a lot with what you have said.  He made a bit of an impact on me when I first played DAO, particularly the change from his first encounter with Amell/Surana to when he was in Uldred's cage (felt a bit sorry for him).  And he has grown from there.

I think you should post this on Tumblr.  Make a change from the negativity that people spout!

Edit - forgot to say the links to the new Thedas encylopedia and the comments/thoughts were very informative and has made me a bit more excited about DA3.  You do learn a lot on this thread.  I am in the process of reading the DA books, so my knowledge at the moment is still a bit limited!

Modifié par Newschmoo, 12 janvier 2013 - 03:33 .


#31559
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Newschmoo: Asunder is one of the best to read for the DA3 set up. It fills in a few things, definitely useful!

#31560
Newschmoo

Newschmoo
  • Members
  • 1 176 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Newschmoo: Asunder is one of the best to read for the DA3 set up. It fills in a few things, definitely useful!


Thanks, I shall download it!

#31561
Danny Boy 7

Danny Boy 7
  • Members
  • 3 762 messages
So while trying to write dialogue for the thread. (Cullen talking to our Inquisitor directly about well anything) I found this weird kink (mind out of the gutter Lola) that unlike Hawke or the Warden...saying Inquisitor in everyday conversation is just weird. It needs something in front of it, a Mr/Mrs, the or whatever.

Soooo how important do you think our surnames will be this time around? Also does this preclude any chance of different surnames.

#31562
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

Danny Boy 7 wrote...

So while trying to write dialogue for the thread. (Cullen talking to our Inquisitor directly about well anything) I found this weird kink (mind out of the gutter Lola) that unlike Hawke or the Warden...saying Inquisitor in everyday conversation is just weird. It needs something in front of it, a Mr/Mrs, the or whatever.

Soooo how important do you think our surnames will be this time around? Also does this preclude any chance of different surnames.


LOL! You've got me pegged! :lol:

I'm hoping that they'll tell us the new protagonist's Surname in Spring so that we can actually address him/her correctly. It feels weird refering to him/her as just "Inquisitor" or "protagonist", even the choice of Warden(s) in DA:O had their individual Surnames that we could use to address each of them. I think the character will feel more "real" once we know the name.

I bet once we have more details about DA3's protagonist then the fanfics and fan-art will start rolling in. It's gonna be awesome!

#31563
Danny Boy 7

Danny Boy 7
  • Members
  • 3 762 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Danny Boy 7 wrote...

So while trying to write dialogue for the thread. (Cullen talking to our Inquisitor directly about well anything) I found this weird kink (mind out of the gutter Lola) that unlike Hawke or the Warden...saying Inquisitor in everyday conversation is just weird. It needs something in front of it, a Mr/Mrs, the or whatever.

Soooo how important do you think our surnames will be this time around? Also does this preclude any chance of different surnames.


LOL! You've got me pegged! :lol:

I'm hoping that they'll tell us the new protagonist's Surname in Spring so that we can actually address him/her correctly. It feels weird refering to him/her as just "Inquisitor" or "protagonist", even the choice of Warden(s) in DA:O had their individual Surnames that we could use to address each of them. I think the character will feel more "real" once we know the name.

I bet once we have more details about DA3's protagonist then the fanfics and fan-art will start rolling in. It's gonna be awesome!


I'm hoping to get the Warden, Hawke and whoever the new protagonist is drawn up by iTrixia, she does some beautiful Dragon Age work. But maybe, just maybe the Inquisitor is related to the Couslands in some way, black sheep of the family like Hawke's mother was.

Because come on....Cousland's are just as awesome as stinky ol' Amell :P

#31564
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

Danny Boy 7 wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Danny Boy 7 wrote...

So while trying to write dialogue for the thread. (Cullen talking to our Inquisitor directly about well anything) I found this weird kink (mind out of the gutter Lola) that unlike Hawke or the Warden...saying Inquisitor in everyday conversation is just weird. It needs something in front of it, a Mr/Mrs, the or whatever.

Soooo how important do you think our surnames will be this time around? Also does this preclude any chance of different surnames.


LOL! You've got me pegged! :lol:

I'm hoping that they'll tell us the new protagonist's Surname in Spring so that we can actually address him/her correctly. It feels weird refering to him/her as just "Inquisitor" or "protagonist", even the choice of Warden(s) in DA:O had their individual Surnames that we could use to address each of them. I think the character will feel more "real" once we know the name.

I bet once we have more details about DA3's protagonist then the fanfics and fan-art will start rolling in. It's gonna be awesome!


I'm hoping to get the Warden, Hawke and whoever the new protagonist is drawn up by iTrixia, she does some beautiful Dragon Age work. But maybe, just maybe the Inquisitor is related to the Couslands in some way, black sheep of the family like Hawke's mother was.

Because come on....Cousland's are just as awesome as stinky ol' Amell :P


So long as I don't have to play as a stinky noble! I like my protagonists in the gutter or locked in a glorified cage for most of their life! :lol:

#31565
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages
You know I like the Amell connections for how they add more information to the lore and back story of Hawke... primarily helping us identify his/her age along with Solona Amell's... but otherwise, I sorta hope the new protagonist is totally new. I'm not as keen on the whole "special snowflake" status that would connote to either family to have so many heroes in it. I'm more interested in the regular joe/jane who rises to the challenge as the reluctant hero than some kind of hero pedigree. I think that's more important to me than whether they happen to be noble or common.

Of course, that being said... I'll love whoever our protagonist happens to be! I also agree that it will be nice to have a name, although Inquisitor doesn't sound to bad to me as a formal title ... yet. (Of course, I haven't written that much dialogue with it yet, either! LOL ).

#31566
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

Newschmoo wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Newschmoo: Asunder is one of the best to read for the DA3 set up. It fills in a few things, definitely useful!


Thanks, I shall download it!

Second this about Asunder. Although I think they're all useful in filling in parts of the lore, Asunder so far is the most integral to the world state, tho.

Finally getting back to trying Stolen Throne... I just got the meet cute of the Maric-Loghain bromance.

#31567
Shades_Of_Pale

Shades_Of_Pale
  • Members
  • 2 319 messages
Hehe I am reading Stolen Throne again too, I have been having Dragon Age withdrawls, so I am either playing the games or re-reading the books ^.^

#31568
Danny Boy 7

Danny Boy 7
  • Members
  • 3 762 messages

R2s Muse wrote...

You know I like the Amell connections for how they add more information to the lore and back story of Hawke... primarily helping us identify his/her age along with Solona Amell's... but otherwise, I sorta hope the new protagonist is totally new. I'm not as keen on the whole "special snowflake" status that would connote to either family to have so many heroes in it. I'm more interested in the regular joe/jane who rises to the challenge as the reluctant hero than some kind of hero pedigree. I think that's more important to me than whether they happen to be noble or common.

Of course, that being said... I'll love whoever our protagonist happens to be! I also agree that it will be nice to have a name, although Inquisitor doesn't sound to bad to me as a formal title ... yet. (Of course, I haven't written that much dialogue with it yet, either! LOL ).


Wasn't your protagonist an Amell though R2? Easy to dismiss it when it's not yours :P jk. I agree having all the heroes related to one of the Wardens may cause small world or Skywalker syndrome, but it's not necessarily a bad thing if we as players get a little nod. Like maybe the Cousland cousin is a member of traveling circus...or just nowhere in line for the nobility or an embassador to Orlais or something.

#31569
CuriousArtemis

CuriousArtemis
  • Members
  • 19 656 messages
I will be annoyed if the PC is an Amell or a Cousland. Those are already the "popular" Wardens; Cousland is basically the BW canon Warden, and Amell is related to Hawke. How about some love for dwarves and elves here?! Yeah, let me say who the inquisitor is NOT going to be related to: Tabris and Mahariel. So my own personal canons may as well have not even existed in BW's universe (that's how it feels sometimes... and then I can't even play an elf anymore. It SUCKS!)

#31570
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

Danny Boy 7 wrote...

R2s Muse wrote...

You know I like the Amell connections for how they add more information to the lore and back story of Hawke... primarily helping us identify his/her age along with Solona Amell's... but otherwise, I sorta hope the new protagonist is totally new. I'm not as keen on the whole "special snowflake" status that would connote to either family to have so many heroes in it. I'm more interested in the regular joe/jane who rises to the challenge as the reluctant hero than some kind of hero pedigree. I think that's more important to me than whether they happen to be noble or common.

Of course, that being said... I'll love whoever our protagonist happens to be! I also agree that it will be nice to have a name, although Inquisitor doesn't sound to bad to me as a formal title ... yet. (Of course, I haven't written that much dialogue with it yet, either! LOL ).


Wasn't your protagonist an Amell though R2? Easy to dismiss it when it's not yours :P jk. I agree having all the heroes related to one of the Wardens may cause small world or Skywalker syndrome, but it's not necessarily a bad thing if we as players get a little nod. Like maybe the Cousland cousin is a member of traveling circus...or just nowhere in line for the nobility or an embassador to Orlais or something.

Do you mean in DA:O?  Actually no. I've never finished an Amell playthrough. I hated playing a mage in Origins. My canon playthrough for that was my Queen Cousland. 

Anyway, I'm not being dismissive! I see the attraction to have mentions of your past character, I just don't know that I want the mention to be because they're related.

#31571
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
I'm ready to play a new protagonist with no ties to the previous two games.

That's why I like the idea of having the option of a traveller/gypsy background, someone that has no emotional attachments to any particular part of Thedas or factions within it. A background like that would leave things open to interpretation and allow us to head canon, roleplay and shape the protagonist to suit our own individual tastes.

#31572
CuriousArtemis

CuriousArtemis
  • Members
  • 19 656 messages

LolaLei wrote...

That's why I like the idea of having the option of a traveller/gypsy background, someone that has no emotional attachments to any particular part of Thedas or factions within it. A background like that would leave things open to interpretation and allow us to head canon, roleplay and shape the protagonist to suit our own individual tastes.


Me, too, I like that idea! Maybe you have the option to pick country of origin, too, and that will effect your CC. Say you can pick Rivain, Anderfels, Fereldan, etc. But as a traveler, you've spent much of your time in, say, Fereldan, and hence have a Fereldan accent.

#31573
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

motomotogirl wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

That's why I like the idea of having the option of a traveller/gypsy background, someone that has no emotional attachments to any particular part of Thedas or factions within it. A background like that would leave things open to interpretation and allow us to head canon, roleplay and shape the protagonist to suit our own individual tastes.


Me, too, I like that idea! Maybe you have the option to pick country of origin, too, and that will effect your CC. Say you can pick Rivain, Anderfels, Fereldan, etc. But as a traveler, you've spent much of your time in, say, Fereldan, and hence have a Fereldan accent.


That would be awesome! Then part of the customization of the game is that people you meet could respond to you through the lens of your country of origin...

#31574
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

motomotogirl wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

That's why I like the idea of having the option of a traveller/gypsy background, someone that has no emotional attachments to any particular part of Thedas or factions within it. A background like that would leave things open to interpretation and allow us to head canon, roleplay and shape the protagonist to suit our own individual tastes.


Me, too, I like that idea! Maybe you have the option to pick country of origin, too, and that will effect your CC. Say you can pick Rivain, Anderfels, Fereldan, etc. But as a traveler, you've spent much of your time in, say, Fereldan, and hence have a Fereldan accent.


Yeah! Or maybe, for example, you were born into a wealthy Orlesian family. Your childhood was spent with the best education and luxuries money could buy, however, you always felt disenchanted by the lifestyle, loathing the ridiculous parties and social politics. When you came of age your parents introduced you to your future wife/husband in an arranged marriage to the son/daughter of one of the more influential noble families. You plead with your parents but you have no choice. On the day of your wedding you plan your escape (either running from the ceremony mid-swing or escaping from your families mansion the night before) and hitch a ride on the back of the first merchants cart you see. Since then you've lived your life on the road, never revealing your true heritage to anyone.

So it would be kinda like a toss up between Alistair and Evangeline's background but turned on it's head. Man, could you imagine how awkward it would be running into the pompous, arrogant fiance you ditched upon your return to Orlais! :lol:

Modifié par LolaLei, 12 janvier 2013 - 08:22 .


#31575
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Inflitrating an Orlesian masquerade ball:



Protagonist: *Thinking out loud* "Oh! Merde!"

Cullen: "... Something wrong *insert Surname*?"

Protagonist: "Wha? Uh, it's... it's nothing" *Protagonist looks uncomfortable and re-adjusts his/her mask*

Pompous noble man/woman: "Well, what do we 'ave ere!"

Protagonist: *Lowers head, trying to avoid eye contact*

Pompous noble man/woman: "*Insert surname*! My-my, look what ze chat coughed up. Time 'az indeed been kind to you. I'd recognise that heaving bosom/pert derriere anywhere"

Protagonist: "What?! I-I don't know what you're talking about! You must be mistaken"

Cullen: *Steps forward* "Now look here, you..."

Pompous noble man/woman: "Pah Fereldan Turnip! Who are you to talk to me zis way, you dog lord! Zis woman/man iz ma fiance and legally bound to me!"

Cullen: " Preposterous!"

Protagonist: *Removes mask* "... I'm afraid it's true. I was ONCE engaged to this pig"



*The crowd gasp in amusement and shock as the party falls silent*

Modifié par LolaLei, 12 janvier 2013 - 09:54 .