motomotogirl wrote...
Can you guys think of another NPC that made a similar impact on you? I really can't. I do love Alain. But I am weird in that lol
I'd say Cassandra, but she had...a good bit more. I mean I'd say she has idk if you all agree

She actually has a good hate following lol believe it or not, but nowhere near the amount that Cullen does. For her it tends to be an attack on anime's in general and how purist some of the fans are with regard to their games. Others just don't like Chantry characters and as they say can't wait to knife her, Cullen, Leliana and Sebastian. So idk if it's her hate so much as it's those general topics hate. It might also be because instead of being a possible companion, she's basically been confirmed without actual confirmation.
I thought Tamlen was pretty cool though I HATED the Dalish Origin, or should I say found it a tad boring. Start in the woods, go to cave, find mirror, get corrupted, meet Duncan, learn Dalish stuff, go back to cave, profit. It did have a rather nice send off though. I'm actually curious how a Dalish Warden would deal with Marethari's death and his/her clan's (if you killed them all) and what he/she would do to Merrill.
My favorite characters from the Origins however have been (Cullen obviously

), Fergus and Shianni. Fergus because he's my bro and kind of funny and Shianni because of how she reacts to the potential rape. She's show she's not a victim, but doesn't lose all trust in humans which many people might (not that I blame them) and doesn't lose any of that fiery spirit that got her in trouble in the first place. I don't much care for character developement through rape, but her's wasn't bad.
In the end though it's very hard for me to think of any NPC who's had as much developement as Cullen. I'm sure there are some. Some are dead though (Duncan) and others just have more time to develope their characters. I'd say for a NPC to reach Cullen's status they would have to have a collective screen time of up to 20 minutes and no more, not be a companion, temporary is fine as long as they fufill the initial requirement and aren't a major quest giver throughout the game.
The first to come to mind though is Flemeth, but...idk she sort of fails that first requirement if only by a little bit. So...hmm idk. No one springs to mind, but then again we have so few returning characters to begin with who were NPC's on both occassions.
I liked Kardol...from the Legion of the Dead. Idk this is hard lol.