R2s Muse wrote...
I could also see, depending on how 'hardened' he is by the time we see him, him sort of shutting that part of his life away and not wanting to even mention it. Doing the stiff upper lip thing.
But, overall, I see the cage conversation as being a much more awkward point than a simple crush. At his age, that would be like telling the prom queen you had a crush on her when you run into her at the high school reunion. A point of interest (maybe), but in the past.
In all events, *if* he's going to be an LI ... I don't want to see him still carrying a torch. Not the kind of angst that interests me.
I too see the cage conversation as having more of an effect on somebody than a youthful crush. I don't know about the rest of you, but I still cringe about awkward things I said years ago. Bumping into that crush at a high school reunion isn't terribly uncomfortable, even if it involves saying something like "You look fantastic, but you always did. I had such a crush on you sophomore year!" It's a lot harder to make graceful smalltalk after stalkerish photos were found during a locker search.
I wouldn't expect him to be carrying a torch for her, certainly, but I might expect him to be a little self-conscious about making a donkey of himself.
Lola, you raised an interesting point at the bottom of the last page, but I have to get back to work! The conversation will probably have moved on by the time I get back, but I hope the thread doesn't mind a little Cullen-related rambling.