Aller au contenu

Photo

The Official Knight-Captain Cullen Discussion thread 2.0.


89415 réponses à ce sujet

#67101
Kidd

Kidd
  • Members
  • 3 667 messages

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

I do hope we get to see more of him in the next game. (Literally, ideally... ;))

Oh, you'll fit right in! :D

Welcome aboard! We're all one big family here.


Speaking of which, one of us should sit down and write some piece of lyrics for the Cullen thread. Something like

We are family
I have the Cullenites with me
We are family
Get up everybody and post


but better and a full song ^^

#67102
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
We could make a Dwarven style drunken Shanty, lol!

Also, welcome to the thread, Hannah!

#67103
Mahumia

Mahumia
  • Members
  • 1 730 messages
To quote the three musketeers:

“All for one and one for all, united we stand divided we fall.”

I am actually considering Blackmore's Night 'All for one' (original a Dutch song 'Zeven dagen lang' (freely translated: for seven days)) as a good one: happy, silly and friendships. I'll see if I can come up with an adjusted version?

#67104
Tinu

Tinu
  • Members
  • 657 messages

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

Hi guys! ...


Hello Hannah! Don't worry about the reverse order. I did it like that as well and if the games really stick with you, then you can always play them in their 'right' order. ;)

#67105
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

motomotogirl wrote...

Okay guys. So I'm working on a paper that I'll be presenting at a conference this Spring. It's on women and gaming, and how women redirect the male gaze via modding. Example: Creating sexy male armor for male characters, when the base game only has sexy female armor.

Anyone have a picture and a link to that mod that people sometimes post here, of Cullen (or is it Alistair) in the sexy DA:O armor?

Also any other mods you know of, in any other game, that were created by women, and created to please the female gaze/gamer.

Or just anything you can think of, like fanfiction, fanart, etc. Any fan artists and writers here who'd like to give me permission to display (anonymously, if they prefer) their work? NOT publish without their permission. Just briefly display during a presentation.

EDIT: If you also just have a statement you'd like to offer as a female gamer (or even better, as a female modder / fanfic writer / fan artist), that would also be awesome. And if I use it I'll maybe ask for your basic bio info, like age, etc :P

EDIT: Another example would be the wedding mods, like the Alistair wedding mod, or the Brynjolf wedding mod.

You mean this one? I believe it's Rainshock's armor. I haven't searched for it on the DA nexus, tho. The screenshot is by ladyshamen. (and Cullen's from Karma's, of course)

Posted Image

For story-oriented mods, I'd probably suggest cmessaz's Cullen romance mod or Dahlialynn's Sleep Until Dawn mod. Maybe Karma's companions, which in some sense is in-game fanfic for romancing the unromanceable.

For fanfic, if you find a use for it, you're welcome to use any of my Cullen stuff. It doesn't have my real name associated, so anon or not, is no big deal. My stuff's may not be as smutty or female gaze (or as well written! LOL) as your thesis requires. I do find it interesting to write from Cullen's perspective, so in some sense the female gaze into his thoughts and motivations. I think gaming and gaming fanfic particularly encourages "taking the reigns" like that for the existing characters. At least, it does for me, as I've never felt the inclination to write fanfic before.

edit: And, just saw your post about doing this offline. So, send me a PM if you want to chat more. :wizard:

Modifié par R2s Muse, 11 novembre 2013 - 01:43 .


#67106
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

Hi guys! This is my first forum post, although I've been reading for awhile. :)

I'm relatively new to the Dragon Age series, still in my first playthrough. I've finished DA2 and am about halfway through DA:O. (Yes, I did them in reverse order. Not a very good decision on my part.) I found Cullen a very intriguing character with layers yet to be explored, and I was happy to see there's a discussion thread about him.

I do hope we get to see more of him in the next game. (Literally, ideally... ;))

Welcome to the Cullen thread! There are others about that have played the games in that order as well, so you're in good company. I did them in order, so when I became smitten with Cullen in DA2, I realized that I'd kind of missed him in DA:O.

#67107
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
MMG: Do fan videos count? I made a bunch of Cullen ones that you can use, if you want?

#67108
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

KiddDaBeauty wrote...

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

I do hope we get to see more of him in the next game. (Literally, ideally... ;))

Oh, you'll fit right in! :D

Welcome aboard! We're all one big family here.


Speaking of which, one of us should sit down and write some piece of lyrics for the Cullen thread. Something like

We are family
I have the Cullenites with me
We are family
Get up everybody and post


but better and a full song ^^

LOL THEME SONG!!  Love it!  "every good hero should have some"



#67109
meanieweenie

meanieweenie
  • Members
  • 3 503 messages
Our theme music? Hahaha! It'd have to be something like "Crazy Train" or that weird random SpongeBob chase music:


Let's face it kids, normal we ain't.
Exhibit A -
Posted Image

PS - R2, that scene from I'm Gonna Git You Sucka is classic! xoxo

Modifié par meanieweenie, 11 novembre 2013 - 02:27 .


#67110
Mahumia

Mahumia
  • Members
  • 1 730 messages
*cough* been a bit bored at work, so thought I could give it a try Posted Image


All for Cullen, Cullen for all (based on Blackmore’s nights ‘All for one’ and Rapalje’s ‘Wat zullen we drinken’)

And we shall play, for way too long
And we shall play what a joy
And we shall play, for way too long
And we shall play, what a joy
There is enough for everyone, so we play together
Come and grab your game, then we’ll play together, not alone
There is enough for everyone, so we play together
Come and grab your game, then we’ll play together, not alone
 
First we shall post, thousands pages long
First we shall post, for us all
First we shall post, thousands pages long
First we shall post, for us all
In the thread is room for all, so post together
Random Cullen love, yes we post that, for us all.
In the thread is room for all, so post together
Random Cullen love, yes we post that, for us all.
 
Then we shall fight, no one knows how long
Then we shall fight, against the hate
Then we shall fight, no one knows how long
Then we shall fight, against the hate
For everyone’s sake, we fight together
United we are strong, stronger than the hate
For everyone’s sake, we fight together
United we are strong, stronger than the hate
 
 
And we shall dream, many nights long
And we shall dream, Cullen dreams
And we shall dream, many nights long
And we shall dream, Cullen dreams
Those dreams we can share, so dream together
We just share the love, so dream together, not just me
Those dreams we can share, so dream together
We just share the love, so dream together, not just me

#67111
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages
@Mahumia, LOL , that's awesome! Culleny dreams for all!

@meanie, yes, sad, but true. ;)

Modifié par R2s Muse, 11 novembre 2013 - 03:05 .


#67112
TreeHuggerHannah

TreeHuggerHannah
  • Members
  • 2 167 messages

I did it like that as well and if the games really stick with you, then you can always play them in their 'right' order. ;)

Yeah, I'm finding the reverse order alright, although it's not something I'd recommend to anyone else. I feel like I missed some nuance in DA2, but it's also fun to retroactively find out things that relate to Hawke's journey, so it more or less evens out.

I actually did it this way on the advice of a friend, who said DA2 is disappointing after DA:O unless you reverse the order. This seemed... possibly logical? So I took the advice, but I don't think I would have have found that was the case for me if I'd done them in the right order. I think I still would have liked both. Oh well. There are always subsequent playthroughs!

Maybe it's the order I played in, or maybe it would have happened anyway, but Cullen struck me as an intriguing character from the get-go. For one thing, it's relatively unusual to see trauma portrayed at all realistically in popular media, particularly in games. (Although I tend to blame this more on the audiences than on the writers, since audiences often perceive trauma reactions as "whining" and receive it poorly.) It was kind of a pleasant surprise that the writers were willing to go there rather than pulling back out of fear the fans wouldn't respond well.

Cullen also seemed like one of the few characters in Kirkwall who was actually trying to do the right thing instead of just being out for himself; even if my Hawke didn't always agree with his perception of what the right thing was, she respected the attempt. He clearly had boundaries he wasn't willing to cross in spite of what happened to him, and that takes a lot of courage.

Then seeing what happened to him in DA:O increased both my sympathy and my respect for him. My Warden didn't do as he asked her to, but she tried to be as gentle as possible saying no, because his reaction to being tortured and mentally abused was quite understandable. It was so obviously the result of pain instead of malice that is was impossible to blame him for it.

I really hope Cullen has a role in the next game, not just because he's easy on the eyes (although that is true!) but also because he as so much potential as a character. He's been through extreme betrayals on both ends of the spectrum after Meredith, and it would be interesting to see and ultimately maybe influence where he goes from here. I think Cullen is a basically decent person who desperately needs someone he can trust - and by that I don't necessarily mean just romance, although I'd like to have that option, but even a friend or party leader who isn't screwing with his head or willing to throw him to the wolves.

I didn't plan to rant that much, but oh well! :blink:

Modifié par TreeHuggerHannah, 11 novembre 2013 - 07:21 .


#67113
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

I didn't plan to rant that much, but oh well! :blink:

LOL No worries, and here is the place to do it!

Agree that his continuing evolution will be interesting to see. I also agree that trust is likely a central issue for him. I like to think that by the end of DA2, he started to actually trust himself and his own moral compass instead of being pushed and pulled by others' expectations and requirements. I'm curious to see how relatively 'independent' he might be in the next game. Could  be more accustomed now to trusting his own instincts? Or could something happen that makes him backslide and become a (perhaps reluctant) follower again? 

#67114
BevH

BevH
  • Members
  • 3 165 messages

R2s Muse wrote...

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

I didn't plan to rant that much, but oh well! :blink:

LOL No worries, and here is the place to do it!

Agree that his continuing evolution will be interesting to see. I also agree that trust is likely a central issue for him. I like to think that by the end of DA2, he started to actually trust himself and his own moral compass instead of being pushed and pulled by others' expectations and requirements. I'm curious to see how relatively 'independent' he might be in the next game. Could  be more accustomed now to trusting his own instincts? Or could something happen that makes him backslide and become a (perhaps reluctant) follower again? 

I have to agree with you here. I think that by the end of DA2, he could see what Gregoire was trying to steer him away from after the Broken Circle. That was rather Cullen's way of thinking after that, and now he could see it in Meredith's "All mage are blood mage/abominations and should be put down!"

#67115
TreeHuggerHannah

TreeHuggerHannah
  • Members
  • 2 167 messages

Agree that his continuing evolution will be interesting to see. I also agree that trust is likely a central issue for him. I like to think that by the end of DA2, he started to actually trust himself and his own moral compass instead of being pushed and pulled by others' expectations and requirements. I'm curious to see how relatively 'independent' he might be in the next game. Could  be more accustomed now to trusting his own instincts? Or could something happen that makes him backslide and become a (perhaps reluctant) follower again? 

I definitely think he'd be more independent - I can't see him blindly trusting an authority figure again after Meredith. That said, he was (maybe still is?) a soldier, and likely still has the soldier's mindset, so I do think he would be willing to follow a party leader pragmatically, since a group of fighters all going off on their own tangents instead of working with a cohesive strategy won't be very successful. I guess what I'm trying to say is I think he would follow the leader on practical matters because it just works better that way, but would want to make up his own mind on moral matters, if that makes sense?

At this point I would see Cullen trusting another person more as a touchstone for his own decision-making than relying on that person to make the decisions for him. I do think he's probably gained confidence in his own ability to make choices after standing up to Meredith, but I could also see him looking to a friend/party leader/love interest for things like "In your opinion am I still doing the right thing?" "Am I going off the rails here?" etc. Basically someone who can show him his own reflection through eyes he can trust to help instead of taking advantage. I think that's something we all need, but especially Cullen since he's been jerked around so much,

All pure speculation on my part, obviously. ;)

#67116
Mahumia

Mahumia
  • Members
  • 1 730 messages
I also think that he will be more independant and has gained more confidence in his own moral compass. I think there might actually be a two-ways cooperation between him and the inquisitor in finding support in eachother and asking eachothers opinions. A strong cooperation and bonding based on mutual trust and understanding.

Perhaps he will grab back to his childhood dream of being a knight and keep that ideal in his mind when making decisions?

#67117
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

TreeHuggerHannah wrote...

Agree that his continuing evolution will be interesting to see. I also agree that trust is likely a central issue for him. I like to think that by the end of DA2, he started to actually trust himself and his own moral compass instead of being pushed and pulled by others' expectations and requirements. I'm curious to see how relatively 'independent' he might be in the next game. Could  be more accustomed now to trusting his own instincts? Or could something happen that makes him backslide and become a (perhaps reluctant) follower again? 

I definitely think he'd be more independent - I can't see him blindly trusting an authority figure again after Meredith. That said, he was (maybe still is?) a soldier, and likely still has the soldier's mindset, so I do think he would be willing to follow a party leader pragmatically, since a group of fighters all going off on their own tangents instead of working with a cohesive strategy won't be very successful. I guess what I'm trying to say is I think he would follow the leader on practical matters because it just works better that way, but would want to make up his own mind on moral matters, if that makes sense?

At this point I would see Cullen trusting another person more as a touchstone for his own decision-making than relying on that person to make the decisions for him. I do think he's probably gained confidence in his own ability to make choices after standing up to Meredith, but I could also see him looking to a friend/party leader/love interest for things like "In your opinion am I still doing the right thing?" "Am I going off the rails here?" etc. Basically someone who can show him his own reflection through eyes he can trust to help instead of taking advantage. I think that's something we all need, but especially Cullen since he's been jerked around so much,

All pure speculation on my part, obviously. ;)

I agree that he's still a soldier, so I always imagine a scene where he disagrees with our Inquisitor, but necessarily in private since, in his world, you don't question your superior's orders in front of others. I think it could be a kinda cute call back to his training, particularly if your Inquisitor's style is a bit more lax.  And, even more so if you're sleeping with him. :P

Of course... that's all if he's actually a follower and following the Inquisitor's orders. If he's just an "important NPC" ala Morrigan, then who knows how simpatico he is with the Inquisitor's aims.

Sadly, I can still conceive of a situation where his most recent insubordination is somehow beaten out of him, metaphorically or physically, and he's stuck following Lambert et al.'s orders without the gumption to fight back any longer. But, that would take some extra steps in his story to explain how he got there.

Modifié par R2s Muse, 12 novembre 2013 - 12:21 .


#67118
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 877 messages

Mahumia wrote...

I also think that he will be more independant and has gained more confidence in his own moral compass. I think there might actually be a two-ways cooperation between him and the inquisitor in finding support in eachother and asking eachothers opinions. A strong cooperation and bonding based on mutual trust and understanding.

Perhaps he will grab back to his childhood dream of being a knight and keep that ideal in his mind when making decisions?

LOL I always wonder if they'll ever touch upon that again in the future. Sadly, I could also imagine him scoffing at such a simplistic ideal after everythinig he's seen/been through.  Would be an interesting conversation, nonetheless.

#67119
HurricaneGinger

HurricaneGinger
  • Members
  • 2 197 messages

R2s Muse wrote...

Mahumia wrote...

I also think that he will be more independant and has gained more confidence in his own moral compass. I think there might actually be a two-ways cooperation between him and the inquisitor in finding support in eachother and asking eachothers opinions. A strong cooperation and bonding based on mutual trust and understanding.

Perhaps he will grab back to his childhood dream of being a knight and keep that ideal in his mind when making decisions?

LOL I always wonder if they'll ever touch upon that again in the future. Sadly, I could also imagine him scoffing at such a simplistic ideal after everythinig he's seen/been through.  Would be an interesting conversation, nonetheless.


Yep, I can imagine it too. It would be a very sad, yet enlightening conversation. True knights don't have shiny armor.

#67120
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

Cullen also seemed like one of the few characters in Kirkwall who was actually trying to do the right thing instead of just being out for himself; even if my Hawke didn't always agree with his perception of what the right thing was, she respected the attempt. He clearly had boundaries he wasn't willing to cross in spite of what happened to him, and that takes a lot of courage.

Apparently boundaries that didn't include genocide.

Of course, it's likely that he's reformed somewhat. As another note, I seriously doubt you have to worry about Lambert; I'd give it a 99% chance that he's dead.

#67121
TreeHuggerHannah

TreeHuggerHannah
  • Members
  • 2 167 messages

Xilizhra wrote...

Cullen also seemed like one of the few characters in Kirkwall who was actually trying to do the right thing instead of just being out for himself; even if my Hawke didn't always agree with his perception of what the right thing was, she respected the attempt. He clearly had boundaries he wasn't willing to cross in spite of what happened to him, and that takes a lot of courage.

Apparently boundaries that didn't include genocide.

From a canon standpoint, I have to say I disagree with this - that is in fact exactly where his boundary seems to be on the subject. If you side with the templars (which I didn't, my Hawke sided reluctantly with mages, but I've watched various alternate versions) Cullen will defy Meredith about sparing the mages who surrendered when she wants them dead. His argument for doing so is that things were even worse during the Ferelden situation, and even then some mage lives were saved.

Which suggests to me that 1.) after having some time to recover from the trauma of his experience with Uldred, he has realized that what he had advocated at the time was not, in fact, correct, and 2.) he went into the Kirkwall crisis planning to save any mages he could, and was going along with the Right of Annulment only on the assumption that no one was going to be salvageable. When he saw that wasn't the case, he doesn't hesitate to advocate for keeping alive the mages who weren't a direct threat.

#67122
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

From a canon standpoint, I have to say I disagree with this - that is in fact exactly where his boundary seems to be on the subject. If you side with the templars (which I didn't, my Hawke sided reluctantly with mages, but I've watched various alternate versions) Cullen will defy Meredith about sparing the mages who surrendered when she wants them dead. His argument for doing so is that things were even worse during the Ferelden situation, and even then some mage lives were saved.

The mages in question are rendered Tranquil after the battle, so it doesn't mean much. He also has no qualms about slaughtering those who only want to defend themselves, or even if he does, will still do so. As does Hawke if siding with the templars.

#67123
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages
As a sidenote, I apologize if I came on too strong; I'm used to debating with people who are equally intractable. I'm not trying to bullrush you out or anything.

#67124
TreeHuggerHannah

TreeHuggerHannah
  • Members
  • 2 167 messages

Xilizhra wrote...

The mages in question are rendered Tranquil after the battle, so it doesn't mean much. He also has no qualms about slaughtering those who only want to defend themselves, or even if he does, will still do so. As does Hawke if siding with the templars.

My Hawke did too, siding with mages, even though she was actively trying to avoid causing any unnecessary deaths. Personally, I think that's more the nature of the story - that there isn't a way to stay on the middle ground, and people who are primarily trying to defend themselves will still become a danger to others - than any personal failing of Cullen's.

Xilizhra wrote...

As a sidenote, I apologize if I came on too strong; I'm used to debating with people who are equally intractable. I'm not trying to bullrush you out or anything.


Nah, I'm good, no need to apologize. (I work with teenagers; my skin is not that thin. ;)) But thanks for the thought, that was kind. :)

#67125
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

My Hawke did too, siding with mages, even though she was actively trying to avoid causing any unnecessary deaths. Personally, I think that's more the nature of the story - that there isn't a way to stay on the middle ground, and people who are primarily trying to defend themselves will still become a danger to others - than any personal failing of Cullen's.

The templars are the aggressors; their lives are forfeit without moral issue unless they surrender.