Aller au contenu

Photo

The Official Knight-Captain Cullen Discussion thread 2.0.


89415 réponses à ce sujet

#11001
Parmida

Parmida
  • Members
  • 1 592 messages
EXACTLY!
Let me pet my Cullen Bioware... pretty please? *sad puppy eyes*

#11002
Dwarva

Dwarva
  • Members
  • 718 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Well... Anders dated a pro-Templar bloodmage and never complained about it LOL!


Yeah and that's one of my major problems with the romance structure in DA2 lol. Everyone loves everyone no matter what sort of person they are. Just like real life eh? Actually...wait...no. ;) I've never romanced Anders with a Templar supporter or Fenris with a bloodmage because it just doesn't compute in my head. :P

#11003
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages
If he were to romance a bloodmage, I just hope that it's written well enough that they address it instead of furthering poor Cullen's obliviousness. It's really a shame that he (and the rest of the templars) never really notice most of the magery going on in Kirkwall.

Posted Image
Champions and Heroes: Endearing by Ddriana

#11004
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages

Staarbux wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Well... Anders dated a pro-Templar bloodmage and never complained about it LOL!


Yeah and that's one of my major problems with the romance structure in DA2 lol. Everyone loves everyone no matter what sort of person they are. Just like real life eh? Actually...wait...no. ;) I've never romanced Anders with a Templar supporter or Fenris with a bloodmage because it just doesn't compute in my head. :P

Yeah, I'm all for player choice... but I think it's a bit better for the choices to make sense. Or, at least acknowledge that they don't make sense... :P

#11005
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

Staarbux wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Well... Anders dated a pro-Templar bloodmage and never complained about it LOL!


Yeah and that's one of my major problems with the romance structure in DA2 lol. Everyone loves everyone no matter what sort of person they are. Just like real life eh? Actually...wait...no. ;) I've never romanced Anders with a Templar supporter or Fenris with a bloodmage because it just doesn't compute in my head. :P


Yeah it was a bit odd. Maybe Kirkwall does strange things to people lol.

#11006
Dwarva

Dwarva
  • Members
  • 718 messages
It's that damned thin Veil around Kirkwall. Haha..

#11007
simplykaotic222

simplykaotic222
  • Members
  • 129 messages
Good morning ladies.
I def think that on the romance part, your LI should give gifts and flirt back. DA2 was missing that. I don't want to be doing everything in the relationship.

#11008
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
I hope they give is some more details soon, aside from survey leaks that may not even be real we've had literally nothing since the concept armor at PAX.

#11009
simplykaotic222

simplykaotic222
  • Members
  • 129 messages

Staarbux wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Well... Anders dated a pro-Templar bloodmage and never complained about it LOL!


Yeah and that's one of my major problems with the romance structure in DA2 lol. Everyone loves everyone no matter what sort of person they are. Just like real life eh? Actually...wait...no. ;) I've never romanced Anders with a Templar supporter or Fenris with a bloodmage because it just doesn't compute in my head. :P


Agreed.  I think if your a bloodmage, certain people who are against it, won't want to be with you.  Same for anti-mage or anti-templar or whatever.  Your choices should have consequences.   

#11010
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages

LolaLei wrote...

I hope they give is some more details soon, aside from survey leaks that may not even be real we've had literally nothing since the concept armor at PAX.

Here's crossing our fingers for some tidbits over the weekend. I wonder if they'll post anything from any of the panels. It seems DG will be on, like, ten or something at DragonCon.

#11011
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Hopefully in DA3 that'll be taken into account. Granted it might kill my plan to romance Cullen as a Mage, but overall it ups the games replayability.

#11012
Dwarva

Dwarva
  • Members
  • 718 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Hopefully in DA3 that'll be taken into account. Granted it might kill my plan to romance Cullen as a Mage, but overall it ups the games replayability.


The thing though is that I don't think Cullen shouldn't be able to romance a mage. I know that seems to go against what I said above but seriously, I'm not about pigeonholing people. I think having options is great, when they make sense either from a lore or common sense perspective. Cullen has already established he has previously had feelings for a mage (or, at the very least, the potential to have feelings for one). I think it's only very severe choices that should have restrictions. ie Fenris/Anders with a blood mage

The end choice where you make Anders fight against the mages in line with the Templars absolutely broke my heart. It was ridiculous, completely unrealistic and basically showed the ONE THING that was in his character could be changed completely at the whim of another. I refuse to believe Hawke has that kind of power. Hell, no one should have that kind of power.





Aaaaaaaand breathe.... :innocent:

#11013
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

R2s Muse wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

I hope they give is some more details soon, aside from survey leaks that may not even be real we've had literally nothing since the concept armor at PAX.

Here's crossing our fingers for some tidbits over the weekend. I wonder if they'll post anything from any of the panels. It seems DG will be on, like, ten or something at DragonCon.


Maybe they'll have another little show 'n' tell? Mind you, if those survey leaks are real then I doubt we'll be seeing any concept art for a long time lol.

#11014
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Staarbuxx: Don't get me wrong, I really hope Cullen will romance a mage, I'm just not sure how they'll go about the mental process of having him go from feeling intense guilt for once being in-love with a Mage mixed with his untrust of them due to his torture etc, to finally being willing to get into a relationship with one. I'm sure it's do-able, I just wonder what the catalyst will be that leads him to take such a big life defining step.

I have this feeling that maybe he'd kiss her or something but when it comes to the relationship he won't be able to do it due to his beliefs. Or they'll get together but he'll have to leave her permanently.

#11015
Parmida

Parmida
  • Members
  • 1 592 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Staarbuxx: Don't get me wrong, I really hope Cullen will romance a mage, I'm just not sure how they'll go about the mental process of having him go from feeling intense guilt for once being in-love with a Mage mixed with his untrust of them due to his torture etc, to finally being willing to get into a relationship with one. I'm sure it's do-able, I just wonder what the catalyst will be that leads him to take such a big life defining step.

I have this feeling that maybe he'd kiss her or something but when it comes to the relationship he won't be able to do it due to his beliefs. Or they'll get together but he'll have to leave her permanently.


NOOOOOOOOOO!:crying: that's horrible!

#11016
simplykaotic222

simplykaotic222
  • Members
  • 129 messages

Staarbux wrote...

LolaLei wrote...

Hopefully in DA3 that'll be taken into account. Granted it might kill my plan to romance Cullen as a Mage, but overall it ups the games replayability.


The thing though is that I don't think Cullen shouldn't be able to romance a mage. I know that seems to go against what I said above but seriously, I'm not about pigeonholing people. I think having options is great, when they make sense either from a lore or common sense perspective. Cullen has already established he has previously had feelings for a mage (or, at the very least, the potential to have feelings for one). I think it's only very severe choices that should have restrictions. ie Fenris/Anders with a blood mage

The end choice where you make Anders fight against the mages in line with the Templars absolutely broke my heart. It was ridiculous, completely unrealistic and basically showed the ONE THING that was in his character could be changed completely at the whim of another. I refuse to believe Hawke has that kind of power. Hell, no one should have that kind of power.

Aaaaaaaand breathe.... :innocent:


Agreed.  Except i do think he should be romancable to a mage *maybe it would take a little longer for him to trust you*, but i just don't see him falling in love with a bloodmage, ever. 

#11017
Parmida

Parmida
  • Members
  • 1 592 messages
What if inquisitors are allowed to use Bloodmagic legally ? that opens up interesting options, no?

Modifié par Parmida, 29 août 2012 - 02:49 .


#11018
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages

LolaLei wrote...

Staarbuxx: Don't get me wrong, I really hope Cullen will romance a mage, I'm just not sure how they'll go about the mental process of having him go from feeling intense guilt for once being in-love with a Mage mixed with his untrust of them due to his torture etc, to finally being willing to get into a relationship with one. I'm sure it's do-able, I just wonder what the catalyst will be that leads him to take such a big life defining step.

I have this feeling that maybe he'd kiss her or something but when it comes to the relationship he won't be able to do it due to his beliefs. Or they'll get together but he'll have to leave her permanently.


You know, Lola, I don't see him feeling that intense guilt anymore, tho. He seems to have rather fond remembrances of Amell, so I always feel that he has come to terms with his past feelings come Act 2. The codex talks about the rumors about his crush on a mage and that Meredith likes to quell those rumors... but that's also from Act 1.

Anyway, I think part and parcel of the big steps he's already taken with respect to mages would allow him to view someone, like even mage!Hawke, as a potential LI so long as he/she is not a part of his own Circle. Post-Act 3, I think he'd be even more likely. Now, I think he'd be against fraternization with a mage he oversees indefinitely, no no romances with a mage from his own Circle. But in DA3 there will be no Circles anymore.

#11019
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
I don't think he'll have any guilty feelings left for the Mage Warden, just that he feels guilty because it was a sin in the eyes of his beliefs, so he might be apprehensive of it happening again. Of course,bi guess it's a slightly different situation if he's not actually ordered to watch over the new protagonist (although having him full in love with a Mage he's keeping watch over would be incredibly sweet.)

I don't doubt that he'll develop feelings for a Mage protagonist, I just wonder if DG will allow us to fully romance him lol.

#11020
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages
So I just learned something that has blown me away. Dawn of the Seeker takes place just after Meredith became Knight Commander of Kirkwall. The "events in Kirkwall" they mention was the failed rebellion of Perrin Threnhold in 9:21, DG says. So... her interrogation of Varric takes place almost twenty years later... Girl ages well. :) So, DotS basically has no bearing on anything for the future. LOL

#11021
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages

R2s Muse wrote...

So I just learned something that has blown me away. Dawn of the Seeker takes place just after Meredith became Knight Commander of Kirkwall. The "events in Kirkwall" they mention was the failed rebellion of Perrin Threnhold in 9:21, DG says. So... her interrogation of Varric takes place almost twenty years later... Girl ages well. :) So, DotS basically has no bearing on anything for the future. LOL


Woah! I thought the Kirkwall events were the ones surrounding Hawke lol.

#11022
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages

LolaLei wrote...

I don't think he'll have any guilty feelings left for the Mage Warden, just that he feels guilty because it was a sin in the eyes of his beliefs, so he might be apprehensive of it happening again. Of course,bi guess it's a slightly different situation if he's not actually ordered to watch over the new protagonist (although having him full in love with a Mage he's keeping watch over would be incredibly sweet.)

I don't doubt that he'll develop feelings for a Mage protagonist, I just wonder if DG will allow us to fully romance him lol.

You know, I always headcanon Cullen as incredibly protective, and I would bet that would be an instinct that wouldn't go away. So, whether he's still a templar or not, or even in the case where he's not charged with overseeing mage!PC, I imagine him not being able to help himself and trying to protect her all the time. So I agree, that would be incredibly sweet!

*sigh* "Cullen, you know, I can take care of myself..."

#11023
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
Wait... How old was Cassandra supposed to be in DotS? Old enough to be a Seeker... She must be in her 40's surely?

#11024
R2s Muse

R2s Muse
  • Members
  • 19 865 messages

LolaLei wrote...

R2s Muse wrote...

So I just learned something that has blown me away. Dawn of the Seeker takes place just after Meredith became Knight Commander of Kirkwall. The "events in Kirkwall" they mention was the failed rebellion of Perrin Threnhold in 9:21, DG says. So... her interrogation of Varric takes place almost twenty years later... Girl ages well. :) So, DotS basically has no bearing on anything for the future. LOL


Woah! I thought the Kirkwall events were the ones surrounding Hawke lol.

I know! I'm... shocked. So everything we saw about Val Royeaux was from ages ago. But, presumably, the last scene where she's given the book is still co-eval with DA2. :blink:

Still collating... :huh:

#11025
LolaLei

LolaLei
  • Members
  • 33 006 messages
I'm still having doubts that he'll be a companion/LI at all.