LolaLei wrote...
What I wonder is, what are the Templars actually rebelling for? Are they fighting against Mages or have they sided with the Mages against the Chantry in some weird twist of fate? Alternatively have they gone rogue and formed their own hierarchy, ruling with an iron fist and killing every Mage on sight?
If it's the latter then I can't imagine Cullen would want to be a part of that, perhaps he would have in the beginning of DA2, but by the end he's realised that killing Mages nonsensically is wrong. In which case he would be an ex Templar... maybe even a seeker? Hell, he might even be working with the Mages!
If the mage/templar conflict is going to be a good-sized chunk of DA3, I can see Cullen continuing down that voice of reason thread again. Perhaps he could initially join the PC's crew in hopes of gaining assitance so he could minimize casulaties on both sides. I agree with you that I don't believe he would support outright slaughter of mages because we left him in DA2 with this peace that he had realized his true purpose as a templar. I think his integrity is too strong now to revert his ways.
I don't know if he could fully turn his back on the rebel Order to the point of outright working with mages, nor do I suspect he'd even be able to justify being a "spy" of sorts for them. If he does in fact become a companion choice, I think he'll have some sort of goal in mind, but with an unclear path of how to achieve it. One thing I'm sure of, the man is going to have some delicious inner conflict.
The thought of Cullen as a Seeker has definitely crossed my mind and makes the most sense to me. He stood up to his looney toon commander to do what he believed was right, effectively curbing further rebel enthusiasm. After Varric's retelling to Cassandra of the role Cullen played, I do find it believable that he could be recruited by her because I think he would share her opinion that "not everyone desires war".
I'm really enjoying your questions, lol. You should make a daily post, "Dragon Age Food for Thought" by LolaLei.