3434 Antworten in diesem Thema

[AnAccountWithNoName]

Do you think there should be negative affects in ME3, for those who chose Morinth over Samara?

After all, Bioware made the option actually seem evil, so should those who went the evil route be punished?

Or should there be no repercussions for murdering a squad mate over a monster?

What do you think?


I would be interesting imo, that the judges in the trial over the events in "Arrival", somehow find out what Shepard (if you picked the option of saving Morinth) did.

Or should this "sin" of Shepard have no relevence in ME3?

EDIT:  How should the Monster be handled in ME3? Im sure she isn't going to be
squad member, so if she survived the events of ME2, how should she
affect the events of ME3?

Please share your opinions.

Bearbeitet von AnAccountWithNoName, 04 Oktober 2011 - 02:33 .

[firefireblow]

she isnt a monster she is the genetic destiny of the asari. and she could seduce some of your jury board to voting on innocent.

[Sepewrath]

Well putting that in the trail would be pointless and a really heavy handed attempt. It probably wont matter as she's just one person. But if they wanted to bring it back, I would say that she could do something like enthrall another squad member or something. Yes its convenient for dramatics, but its what she does, so its not really much a stretch.

[Arkitekt]

The possibilities are endless. Samara inviting you with her waving nipples; Samara twisting your neck due to what you made her do in the previous episode of mass effect; Morinth killing every single lover of her again; they are all sexy!

[bobdooly]

A renegade action automatically being the bad choice? Just like (seeming) ALL of the others? Great idea!

[thatguy212]

Why would there be a negative effect? she's my plan B for destroying the reapers, get her to mind meld with as many people as possible and become a biotic goddess, then have her and niftu cal fly out into space and destroy the reapers

edit: also why would the judges care about shepard siding with morinth, "oh no he added yet another serial killer to his team, whats that make it like 5 now?"

Bearbeitet von thatguy212, 26 September 2011 - 12:55 .

[Kaiser Shepard]

What, this topic isn't about the rachni queen?

[Kalcean]

could be used for character assassination in the trial, to how a pattern of "evil" behavior.

[AdmiralCheez]

I hope we see more of Morinth, since I plan on sparing her in a couple playthroughs. She has a lot of potential as a character, and, even though she is incredibly selfish, could be a powerful ally. After all, if the Reapers wipe out all civilization, that takes away all her fun.

[BTG_01]

Kaiser Shepard wrote...

What, this topic isn't about the rachni queen?

My reaction as well.

I don't think siding Morinth should backfire per se (There's plenty of other terrible stuff Shep can do), but there should be some consequences. She doesn't exactly seem like the type to stick around on a ship which (theoretically) has rules and a command structure. Maybe she could wander off and cause some mess which Shepard has the privilege of cleaning up.

Bearbeitet von BTG_01, 26 September 2011 - 01:12 .

[Kalcean]

show i mean

[Xeranx]

I like the thread title and OP. Neither attempt to steer the thread in a particular direction.

[Destroy Raiden_]

For the pure fact she's a mind serial killer yes I think she should do something maybe team up with Billy or something that girl is just T.R.O.U.B.L.E.

[AnAccountWithNoName]

iOnlySignIn wrote...

Pfffffft. Since when does letting someone live equal trusting that someone?

Perhaps Shep just wants to kill both Morinth AND Samara. Perhaps Shep is simply curious to see what Morinth is capable of. Why does every deed of the protagonist has to be a moral stand?

Not every deed of the protagonist should have to do with their morality, however it so happens that in the Morinth case, it does.

[jbblue05]

iOnlySignIn wrote...

Pfffffft. Since when does letting someone live equal trusting that someone?

Perhaps Shep just wants to kill both Morinth AND Samara. Perhaps Shep is simply curious to see what Morinth is capable of. Why does every deed of the protagonist has to be a moral stand?

political correctness:D

[Izhalezan]

I've always killed her, sometimes for mercy, sometimes for fun.

[D.Kain]

I don't have enough imagination to think of how that decision can bite me in the ass.

How would anybody find out? How would anybody be able to prove it? Who are they going to involve in the investigation? Why would they even care in the first place?

It's so out of sight and out of mind that only my squad members could know it, and I would even uncover Morinth for them and not keep her secret, they are all loyal to me anyway, they wouldn't do anything, some would just dislike her, and there are plenty deslikes going on on the crew anyway, and reapers are a more pressing matter. 

Bearbeitet von D.Kain, 26 September 2011 - 02:46 .

[thatguy212]

D.Kain wrote...

I don't have enough imagination to think of how that decision can bite me in the ass.

How would anybody find out? How would anybody be able to prove it? Who are they going to involve in the investigation? Why would they even care in the first place?

It's so out of sight and out of mind that only my squad members could know it, and I would even uncover Morinth for them and not keep her secret, they are all loyal to me anyway, they wouldn't do anything, some would just dislike her, and there are plenty deslikes going on on the crew anyway.

Mordin would probably even be happy at the chance to study an Ardat-Yakshi

[D.Kain]

thatguy212 wrote...

D.Kain wrote...

I don't have enough imagination to think of how that decision can bite me in the ass.

How would anybody find out? How would anybody be able to prove it? Who are they going to involve in the investigation? Why would they even care in the first place?

It's so out of sight and out of mind that only my squad members could know it, and I would even uncover Morinth for them and not keep her secret, they are all loyal to me anyway, they wouldn't do anything, some would just dislike her, and there are plenty deslikes going on on the crew anyway.

Mordin would probably even be happy at the chance to study an Ardat-Yakshi

Would have to be very careful. 
But I think if I asked Morinth nicely she would let Mordin to see if he can maybe even correct her sex/killing problems.

[Xilizhra]

(unlike other renegade options)

Hah.

I would be interesting imo, that the judges in the trial over the events in "Arrival", somehow find out what Shepard (if you picked the option of saving Morinth) did.

How would they know? The only people in the galaxy who even suspected were Kasumi, Kelly and the Shadow Broker.

Not every deed of the protagonist should have to do with their morality, however it so happens that in the Morinth case, it does.

Perhaps, but it has more to do with priorities, not necessarily pure morality.

[who would know]

It was painted so black-and-white, as such a non-choice, that I actually want to see it reversed. It all depends on the direction Morinth's character takes in ME3. She is no more beyond restitution or positive development than Samara's moral character is beyond obfuscation.

[D.Kain]

who would know wrote...

It was painted so black-and-white, as such a non-choice, that I actually want to see it reversed. It all depends on the direction Morinth's character takes in ME3. She is no more beyond restitution or positive development than Samara's moral character is beyond obfuscation.

It wasn't painted black&white. It was a total free imagination flight.