Punished for trusting the Monster?
#1376
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 07:02
#1377
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 07:04
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...

Suite yourself.
#1378
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 07:45
D.Kain wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
Serial killer: I kill people and eat their livers.
D.Kain: YOU ARE BAD!
Serial Killer: My mother didn't want to be my mother anymore, I had no firends, people wanted me to go to a prison because they thought I am going to kill people, even though I didn't, and when I ran away they started to hunt me because they wanted to kill me. When I eat livers I get stronger and can fight back.
D.Kain: OH YOU POOR DEAR! PLEASE GO OUT AND EAT MORE PEOPLE'S LIVERS!!!!!
There, fixed it for you.
Even with that added change, you still sound like a Monster.
It does not matter what has happened in the Monsters past, that doesn't justify her actions. It is sad that certain men in the world, like you, don't have a strong moral code about the importance of human life (exspecially innocent life). Your type make this world a dark place to live in.
How can anyone think that there is nothing wrong with butchering innocent human life, as long as the Monster has had a sad past??????
It doesn't seem real......
Modifié par AnAccountWithNoName, 02 octobre 2011 - 07:51 .
#1379
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:27
D.Kain wrote...
TobyHasEyes wrote...
What in your mind is different between being seperated from society and the isolation imposed on the AY?
Because, as in the above example, if the individuals offenses can be (within reason) guaranteed to occur, you suggest that they should be killed or "completely seperate them from society"
Entertaining the idea that the AY's offenses can be (within reason) guaranteed to occur, then you appear to support them being seperated from society.. presuming (as would seem to be the case) there is no way of society adjusting to guarantee safety from the AY's condition (as rebreathers would suggest)
Granted you might not believe that the AY's offenses are as guaranteed as in the case I described above, however the point I made was that we do not know enough to say either way, so what I am suggesting is that if it is the case that they are determined, then what?
By separation I meant a free society constructed from only AY with their own cities and entartaiment, maybe a whole planet. Like not a place where they are just going to be underground, but a place that is no different than the original society but has individuals that are equal. That is probably impossible. That's why I said scratch seperation afterwards.
So the only option you are left with is killing the AY.. as you would rather do that than have them living in relative solitude and comfort; I do think you are championing the cause of freedom beyond its means if you think that the humane thing to do if something can't be totally free is to just kill it
My overall point, as you chose to echo in the previous page, is that we do not know enough for certain about the AY condition; whereas I assume the Asari response is appropriately matched to the AY' state, you assume it is an overreaction
Which is where the application of this discussion in-game falls apart.. though I must admit I do still find the idea that it is better to kill a sentient being than to compromise its freedom as peculiar enough to be interesting
Modifié par TobyHasEyes, 02 octobre 2011 - 08:32 .
#1380
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 10:44
I thought I know you from the mage discussion. You realize though that they are two different things. I mean innocent mages vs. serial killer. But you know what, you get a +1 for effort. You are basically argueing against the whole BSN community and not giving in an inch, and without really resorting to insults or something. I respect that. Even if you are still wrong. And if you've been trolling all the time, even more kudos.D.Kain wrote...
Not sure how being for mages freedom is bad for the mage-side. lol
Modifié par AlexXIV, 02 octobre 2011 - 10:45 .
#1381
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 12:00
Goes to check to see if im in the Mass Effect forums....
#1382
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 12:50
....That's suppose to be better?D.Kain wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
Serial killer: I kill people and eat their livers.
D.Kain: YOU ARE BAD!
Serial Killer: My mother didn't want to be my mother anymore, I had no firends, people wanted me to go to a prison because they thought I am going to kill people, even though I didn't, and when I ran away they started to hunt me because they wanted to kill me. When I eat livers I get stronger and can fight back.
D.Kain: OH YOU POOR DEAR! PLEASE GO OUT AND EAT MORE PEOPLE'S LIVERS!!!!!
There, fixed it for you.
What if he was trying to eat your liver?
#1383
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 02:36
Modifié par BatmanPWNS, 02 octobre 2011 - 02:36 .
#1384
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 02:49
I understand you point. But it's not the same case.The dlc Arrival is just the case your talikng about. In extemes you may let innocent people die so you can survive and even many other people to servive.... What your really saying you would never let innocent people die for your own pleasure, reguardless if the pleasure is from their deaths or your want for pleasure cases their deathsBatmanPWNS wrote...
I would never let lives (especially innocent ones who have done nothing seriously wrong and don't deserve death for no reason) be killed just for my own survival. I can't believe someone would support Morinth on that part.
Modifié par dreman9999, 02 octobre 2011 - 02:50 .
#1385
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 03:43
D.Kain wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
Serial killer: I kill people and eat their livers.
D.Kain: YOU ARE BAD!
Serial Killer: My mother didn't want to be my mother anymore, I had no firends, people wanted me to go to a prison because they thought I am going to kill people, even though I didn't, and when I ran away they started to hunt me because they wanted to kill me. When I eat livers I get stronger and can fight back.
D.Kain: OH YOU POOR DEAR! PLEASE GO OUT AND EAT MORE PEOPLE'S LIVERS!!!!!
There, fixed it for you.
First, that "fixed it" thing is the height of rude. Don't edit people's quotes.
Second, you didn't actually change anything, you just added more words to say the same thing.
#1386
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 03:47
D.Kain wrote...
BlueMagitek wrote...
D.Kain wrote...
BlueMagitek wrote...
It wasn't a gamble, it was a definite outcome. So melding with him would kill him. And she knew this and did so anyway.
So she grasped for her life for 400 years to make a suicide when she doen't need to run from Samara anymore. Briliant writing!
That is what she does. Because she has no reason to believe that mind melding would not kill Shepard.
Well doesn't it seem silly to you? She has reason to believe that, she named them.
Oh yes, because Morinth has never lied to anyone to get them to meld with her, ever ever.
If Morinth is certain to be killed soon after killing Shep, then that just shows how little control she has over her additiction.
#1387
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 04:35
Killjoy Cutter wrote...
D.Kain wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
Serial killer: I kill people and eat their livers.
D.Kain: YOU ARE BAD!
Serial Killer: My mother didn't want to be my mother anymore, I had no firends, people wanted me to go to a prison because they thought I am going to kill people, even though I didn't, and when I ran away they started to hunt me because they wanted to kill me. When I eat livers I get stronger and can fight back.
D.Kain: OH YOU POOR DEAR! PLEASE GO OUT AND EAT MORE PEOPLE'S LIVERS!!!!!
There, fixed it for you.
First, that "fixed it" thing is the height of rude. Don't edit people's quotes.
Second, you didn't actually change anything, you just added more words to say the same thing.
Exactly.. D. Kain is suggesting that the only reason Morinth starting 'melding' is because she needed the additional strength in order to not be returned to isolation
As though that makes it in any way morally acceptable
If that were the case, then yes it would mean that her actions aren't proof that AY are 'guaranteed' to kill when in a population. As her initial actions would not be the result of an addictive condition, but of her choices. But that neither proves that the AY-isolation-program is wrong (just because her first actions don't prove the AY condition is determined, at the same time they don't prove they aren't determined) nor does it morally absolve Morinth
So what is the point being made?
#1388
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 06:47
dreman9999 wrote...
I understand you point. But it's not the same case.The dlc Arrival is just the case your talikng about. In extemes you may let innocent people die so you can survive and even many other people to servive.... What your really saying you would never let innocent people die for your own pleasure, reguardless if the pleasure is from their deaths or your want for pleasure cases their deathsBatmanPWNS wrote...
I would never let lives (especially innocent ones who have done nothing seriously wrong and don't deserve death for no reason) be killed just for my own survival. I can't believe someone would support Morinth on that part.
Morinth is different. Shepard kills for the greater good. Morinth is the exact opposite. Everything she has done is for selfish reasons. I will not doubt Shepard has a bigger kill count but has Shep kept the galaxy safer? Yes. The actions in Arrival was sacrificing mostly innocents for the rest of the Galaxy to have some time to prepare. Morinth however kills for her pleasure. The pleasure can be from the meld but it still kills people there is no sugar coating it.
#1389
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 07:03
1136342t54 wrote...
dreman9999 wrote...
I understand you point. But it's not the same case.The dlc Arrival is just the case your talikng about. In extemes you may let innocent people die so you can survive and even many other people to servive.... What your really saying you would never let innocent people die for your own pleasure, reguardless if the pleasure is from their deaths or your want for pleasure cases their deathsBatmanPWNS wrote...
I would never let lives (especially innocent ones who have done nothing seriously wrong and don't deserve death for no reason) be killed just for my own survival. I can't believe someone would support Morinth on that part.
Morinth is different. Shepard kills for the greater good. Morinth is the exact opposite. Everything she has done is for selfish reasons. I will not doubt Shepard has a bigger kill count but has Shep kept the galaxy safer? Yes. The actions in Arrival was sacrificing mostly innocents for the rest of the Galaxy to have some time to prepare. Morinth however kills for her pleasure. The pleasure can be from the meld but it still kills people there is no sugar coating it.
Well the difference to MY Shep (can't speak for all) is that my Shep doesn't kill when there is a choice. However, Arrival doesn't give you a choice which is a small wink from Bioware to tell us, there wasn't a choice. Mass exodus of 300.000 Batarians or of the whole galaxy. Not much of a choice really, because the Batarians would have died anyway.
#1390
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 07:15
I was not comparing Shepard to Mornith... I was just commenting on the extemes of the comment above. He say He would never let people die so he can live, which in mostcasesis fall. If you were hinding forma group that wants to kill you and you see someone in the open in danger to be killed who is a stranger who is about to be notice by the group that is killing people and you could save that person by destracting that group who is kill but you can save yourself by letting that group kill that person...What would you do?1136342t54 wrote...
dreman9999 wrote...
I understand you point. But it's not the same case.The dlc Arrival is just the case your talikng about. In extemes you may let innocent people die so you can survive and even many other people to servive.... What your really saying you would never let innocent people die for your own pleasure, reguardless if the pleasure is from their deaths or your want for pleasure cases their deathsBatmanPWNS wrote...
I would never let lives (especially innocent ones who have done nothing seriously wrong and don't deserve death for no reason) be killed just for my own survival. I can't believe someone would support Morinth on that part.
Morinth is different. Shepard kills for the greater good. Morinth is the exact opposite. Everything she has done is for selfish reasons. I will not doubt Shepard has a bigger kill count but has Shep kept the galaxy safer? Yes. The actions in Arrival was sacrificing mostly innocents for the rest of the Galaxy to have some time to prepare. Morinth however kills for her pleasure. The pleasure can be from the meld but it still kills people there is no sugar coating it.
Morniths' case is just killing so she can get pleasure. That is much different from sacrificing lives to save your own.
#1391
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:03
#1392
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:07
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
I think it's kind of sad that D.Kain thinks it's okay to kill people for your own pleasure.
No D.Kain thinks its okay to kill because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough.
#1393
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:09
Oh! That makes it okay then!1136342t54 wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
I think it's kind of sad that D.Kain thinks it's okay to kill people for your own pleasure.
No D.Kain thinks its okay to kill because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough.
http://t3.gstatic.co...9fa_dFs3JmwGjmQ
#1394
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:23
I would offer to refute his "arguments" but I imagine anything I would have said was already covered in the 30+ pages I skipped and that he simply ignored or misunderstood those refutations.
#1395
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:24
Pretty much.PantheraOnca wrote...
I am saddened that I skipped from page 19 or so to page 56 and D. Kain seems to still be arguing the same points.
I would offer to refute his "arguments" but I imagine anything I would have said was already covered in the 30+ pages I skipped and that he simply ignored or misunderstood those refutations.
#1396
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:27
thatguy212 wrote...
Why would there be a negative effect? she's my plan B for destroying the reapers, get her to mind meld with as many people as possible and become a biotic goddess, then have her and niftu cal fly out into space and destroy the reapers
edit: also why would the judges care about shepard siding with morinth, "oh no he added yet another serial killer to his team, whats that make it like 5 now?"
i was just thinking that a few days ago.
#1397
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:47
1136342t54 wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
I think it's kind of sad that D.Kain thinks it's okay to kill people for your own pleasure.
No D.Kain thinks its okay to kill because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough.
I thought he claimed it was okay to kill for pleasure because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough...
#1398
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 08:56
Killjoy Cutter wrote...
1136342t54 wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
I think it's kind of sad that D.Kain thinks it's okay to kill people for your own pleasure.
No D.Kain thinks its okay to kill because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough.
I thought he claimed it was okay to kill for pleasure because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough...
Details baby Details.
#1399
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 09:02
Kaiser Shepard wrote...
What, this topic isn't about the rachni queen?
I thought this immediately after seeing the thread title.
#1400
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Posté 02 octobre 2011 - 09:13
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
I guess that means I could go out and kill somebody then since I never knew my dad.1136342t54 wrote...
Grand Admiral Cheesecake wrote...
I think it's kind of sad that D.Kain thinks it's okay to kill people for your own pleasure.
No D.Kain thinks its okay to kill because Mommy and Daddy didn't love you enough.




Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut




