311 réponses à ce sujet

[Quole]

ADLegend21 wrote...

Quole wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...

Quole wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...

That's because Tali's father died! if he's alive that's two of 5 with one having the potential to be swayed and my bets go to Shala siding with her life long friends. Plus, as Legion said the Quarians have attacked the Geth when they thought victory was certain. That means they've attacked the Geth before this whole ordeal with creating new geth to test weapons on. Still a war crime, nothing can change that.

Doesnt everyone do that in in war? Again, they dont know about the true geth. Perhaps if the geth actually tried communicating with them (or anyone else fr that matter), instead of letting the heretics be their only means of representation. You didnt read my what I said, did you?

That's why they sent Legion, The geth have cleaned and restored rannoch and the quarians havne't returned so theys ent him to investigate organics and find Shepard once She defeats a reaper.  Also theyw ere at war with the true geth and they drove the quarians from Rannoch they also attacked the True geth on several occaisions which is how Legion knew tha statistic ass the heretics are not part of his network so they have been attacking true geth and Heretics.

No... legion was sent to find shepard. He never attempted to contat the quarians. Quarians and everyone else have mostly faught heretics.

... do you even know what you are talking about?

I do, "We have watched you" "Me or organics" "both"

do YOU know what you're talking about?

<
Ok. So how does this help your argument? They still have never tried to communicate with anyone.

Modifié par Quole, 17 octobre 2011 - 04:43 .

[ADLegend21]

The fact that LEgion has studied organic life, relayed it's findings to the true geth the same way it would have relayed the data of the henious war crimes the quarians did after Tali's LM that she asks Shepard to hide which is why alot of Non Talimancers who are vs fans dislike her because the VS would never ask you do do such a thing but then there are people like the OP of this thread who say "oh Tali and Garrus are your real friends" which is the entire point of this crappy ass thread that needs to be closed! That's what Quole the troll. That's what it has to do with it,

[Quole]

ADLegend21 wrote...

The fact that LEgion has studied organic life, relayed it's findings to the true geth the same way it would have relayed the data of the henious war crimes the quarians did after Tali's LM that she asks Shepard to hide which is why alot of Non Talimancers who are vs fans dislike her because the VS would never ask you do do such a thing but then there are people like the OP of this thread who say "oh Tali and Garrus are your real friends" which is the entire point of this crappy ass thread that needs to be closed! That's what Quole the troll. That's what it has to do with it,

... and I explained why Tali`s request for you to hide the evidence is completely justified, especially if it will start a war with the geth which would kill millions of innoncents and geth alike, not to mention it would occupy two potential allies against the reapers. Legion even SAYS this in game. He also understands why the data shouldnt be sent back. If HE can, then why cant you?

I am not saying anything against the VS. I am just pointing out the flaws in your logic. Why did you call me a troll again?

Modifié par Quole, 17 octobre 2011 - 04:56 .

[Made Nightwing]

Xilizhra wrote...

I'll say it again. The canon story is the one relayed to us by the ME1 Codex, not that of a four panel cameo in a comic written by guys who seemed to have been barely familiar with the plot of the first game.

The codex also called Sovereign a geth ship. It's not omniscient. That which is revealed within it can be overridden later.

I simply believe that all of it has to be brought out and examined before there can be a lasting peace between quarians and the geth. The Geth will eventually find out about it. Better that the quarians acknowledge what they did wrong, and condemn it for the war crime that it was.

I'm actually not sure about this, for the same reason that Tali wasn't told about the Alarei attack for a while. If the geth saw that the quarians were genuinely shocked at the affair upon finding out about it, it might convince them that most quarians didn't, in fact, back the experiments.

Yes, but Sovereign being a Reaper is not common knowledge. If General Williams had thrown a hissy fit and quit because he wasn't allowed to keep fighting the turians, then that would have gone down in the history books and codex as what had happened. Instead, he is regarded as a coward and a traitor because he surrendered. The turians have it down that he surrendered. Everyone knows that he surrendered, except for the guys that were writing the comic.

And that's why I believe it should be revealed sooner rather than later.

[ADLegend21]

Quole wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...

The fact that LEgion has studied organic life, relayed it's findings to the true geth the same way it would have relayed the data of the henious war crimes the quarians did after Tali's LM that she asks Shepard to hide which is why alot of Non Talimancers who are vs fans dislike her because the VS would never ask you do do such a thing but then there are people like the OP of this thread who say "oh Tali and Garrus are your real friends" which is the entire point of this crappy ass thread that needs to be closed! That's what Quole the troll. That's what it has to do with it,

... and I explained why Tali`s request for you to hide the evidence is completely justified, especially if it will start a war with the geth which would kill millions of innoncents and geth alike, not to mention it would occupy two potential allies against the reapers. Legion even SAYS this in game. He also understands why the data shouldnt be sent back. If HE can, then why cant you?

I am not saying anything against the VS. I am just pointing out the flaws in your logic. Why did you call me a troll again?

It's not justified. Covering up war crimes is never justified what aren't you getting? Tali's father broke laws that PREDATE the mourning war. He's ba M'kay. and she covers it up. that's even worse M'kay. Tey wouldn't be doing weapons tests if they weren't prepping for war with the Geth, again. Also the VS tie in was for staying with the original topic of this thread which is, oh idk...the VS. thsi thread has turned into Tali & garrus vs Ashley and Kaidan and through two games two of the four are Spectre's and have lives outside of serving under Shepard and Cerberus which some peolpe hated and some people liked.

[ADLegend21]

jreezy wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...
Am I really? Tehn why is qwib qwib the only quarian that wants to make peeace with the Geth? everyone other quarian wants to blow Legion's head off or thinks Tali's guilty by his presence on the ship. teh admiralty is all in favor of war except qwib qwib and what the admiralty says goes for all quarians.

You did it once again and...wrong, what the admiralty board says does not go for all Quarians.

If the Admiralty board declares war on the Geth (Again) then yes they do speak for all quarians because all quarians will be dedicated to the ffort of that war with the Geth whether they agree or not, that's how it works,

[Quole]

ADLegend21 wrote...

Quole wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...

The fact that LEgion has studied organic life, relayed it's findings to the true geth the same way it would have relayed the data of the henious war crimes the quarians did after Tali's LM that she asks Shepard to hide which is why alot of Non Talimancers who are vs fans dislike her because the VS would never ask you do do such a thing but then there are people like the OP of this thread who say "oh Tali and Garrus are your real friends" which is the entire point of this crappy ass thread that needs to be closed! That's what Quole the troll. That's what it has to do with it,

... and I explained why Tali`s request for you to hide the evidence is completely justified, especially if it will start a war with the geth which would kill millions of innoncents and geth alike, not to mention it would occupy two potential allies against the reapers. Legion even SAYS this in game. He also understands why the data shouldnt be sent back. If HE can, then why cant you?

I am not saying anything against the VS. I am just pointing out the flaws in your logic. Why did you call me a troll again?

It's not justified. Covering up war crimes is never justified what aren't you getting? Tali's father broke laws that PREDATE the mourning war. He's ba M'kay. and she covers it up. that's even worse M'kay. Tey wouldn't be doing weapons tests if they weren't prepping for war with the Geth, again. Also the VS tie in was for staying with the original topic of this thread which is, oh idk...the VS. thsi thread has turned into Tali & garrus vs Ashley and Kaidan and through two games two of the four are Spectre's and have lives outside of serving under Shepard and Cerberus which some peolpe hated and some people liked.

........... Im going to assume you are trolling.

[Quole]

ADLegend21 wrote...

jreezy wrote...

ADLegend21 wrote...
Am I really? Tehn why is qwib qwib the only quarian that wants to make peeace with the Geth? everyone other quarian wants to blow Legion's head off or thinks Tali's guilty by his presence on the ship. teh admiralty is all in favor of war except qwib qwib and what the admiralty says goes for all quarians.

You did it once again and...wrong, what the admiralty board says does not go for all Quarians.

If the Admiralty board declares war on the Geth (Again) then yes they do speak for all quarians because all quarians will be dedicated to the ffort of that war with the Geth whether they agree or not, that's how it works,

So... you blame all of Germany for WW2? Again, troll moar plox.

[Stanley Woo]

Hey folks, we've already got threads for each VS and I'm pretty sure we've got a thread just on VS in general. Please take your thread to one of them. Thank you.

End of line.