376 réponses à ce sujet

[Sketchy77]

Basically I'd like to know what people would order their squadmates in from ME1 and 2 in order from best to worst.
Not including Zaeed or Kasumi.

Mine are;

Mordin
Liara (Romance)
Legion
Jack
Miranda
Garrus
Tali
Wrex
Ashley
Thane
Morinth
Samara
Grunt
Kaidan
Jacob

[JRCHOharry]

Why not Zaeed and Kasumi?

[Chewin]

Sketchy77 wrote...

Basically I'd like to know what people would order their squadmates in from ME1 and 2 in order from best to worst.
Not including Zaeed or Kasumi.

DLC characters do have souls too!

[The Elder King]

Wrex
Legion
Miranda (romance
Mordin
Jack
Garrus
Kaidan
Thane
Ashley
Grunt
Samara
Tali
Morinth
Jacob

Though I have to say that I don't hate or dislike no squadmate.

[diamondedge]

Liara
Garrus
Miranda
Samara
Legion
Mordin
Tali

Indifferent about the rest (haven't used them as squadmates, but there's no one I'd really dislike).

[Prince Zeel]

Ashley
Morinth
Kaidan
Liara
Wrex
Grunt
Jack
Miranda
Mordin
Legion
Samara













































































Thane










Garrus
Tali

Modifié par Prince Zeel, 09 octobre 2011 - 12:30 .

[The Elder King]

Prince Zeel, is Thane's position related to the recent news about him?

[Prince Zeel]

hhh89 wrote...

Prince Zeel, is Thane's position related to the recent news about him?

Yes. Though to be fair, I always found that religious assassin f*cktard to be a female fanservice character, with just as much depth.

[Asari_Party]

1. Mordin
2. Wrex
3. Liara
4. Legion
5. Kasumi
6. Miranda

neutral: Ashley, Samara, Grunt, Jacob, Jack, Tali, Zaeed
dislike: Garrus, Thane, Kaidan

[WalkingBartie]

Tali
Thane
Jack
Mordin
Legion
Garrus
Liara
Wrex
Morinth
Ashley
Samara
Miranda
Grunt
Kaidan
Jacob

[alex90c]

Liara
<other people I'm too lazy to list>
Jacob (second worst)
Thane (worst)

[Giant ambush beetle]

Like:
1. The biotic bi....errrm Jack.  
2. Zaeed Massani
3. Samara

Neutral:
4. Jacob
5. Thane
6. Legion
7. Garrus
8. Liara
Ashley - haven't played ME1
Kaiden - haven't played ME1
Kasumi - haven't played the DLC

Don't like:
9. Mordin
10. Grunt
11. Miranda (Dead)
12. Tali (Dead)

Modifié par The Woldan , 09 octobre 2011 - 01:27 .

[TCBC_Freak]

Ash (LI and my girl till the end)
Garrus (My brother till the end)
Wrex (Great friend and overall awesome dude)
Tali (Who doesn't like Tali... a few people, but they're all crazy, lol)
Grunt (The perfect Krogan and power house on the field)
Miranda (Takes down all defenses, why wouldn't she be up here)
Thane (Just a cool guy)
Kaidan/Jacob (They tie, I like them both but they are a lot alike as a person)
Zaeed (Mad props. and tough hombre)
Jack (The only reason she isn't high is because she's pointless in combat with the way I play, but I like her as a character)
Mordin (He doesn't fit my play style and so he drops a bit, but he's a good guy and funny too)
Legion (You get him too late in game for me to see him a beifical squad mate in game, but he's a cool character)
Kasumi (Not being able to really talk to her on the ships makes me not really be able to like her as much as I might otherwise)
Liara (Sorry folks, the shy little girl act put me off in ME1 and then she's a vindictive information broker in ME2, not much better)
Samara (Not a fan, sorry, don't really like her)





Morinth (She's a murdering sociopath, I dislike her so much as a character and can't think of any reason I'd keep her; though I did side with her once for dominate which is invaluable on an Insanity play but I loaded the save before picking her right after to take Samara... though dislike Samara almost as much....)

[Golden Owl]

Love:

1.) Legion....Fascinating dialog, kicks *ss on the battle field.
2.) Garrus....Hot head with a heart of gold...funny lines....want him as my Sargeant at Arms.
3.) Thane....Can't beat Thane on the Insanity Battle field....Fascinationg dialog.
4.) Kaidan....Nice dude, can't help but like him....hoping his my XO.
5.) Samara....Interesting dialog, would love to explore her dialog further.

Nuetral:

]6.) Jacob....A cynic and wet blanket.
7.) Tali....Meh....she's alright.
8.) Mordin...Salarians bug me, they may have the knowledge but they don't have the wisdom to utlize it.
9.) Ashley...A cynic and can be jeaolous and b*tchy.
10.) Jack...Seriously messed up but I can understand why...I do consider her a danger to the Normandy though.

Dislike:

11.) Liara....Goes from innocent school girlish...yuck...to ruthless killer....very yuck.
12.) Morinth....Psychopathic killer.
13.) Wrex....Blood thristy, war mongering Krogan....no thanks.
14.) Grunt....Blood thirsty, war mongering Krogan...no thanks.
15.) Miranda...Ruthless Cerberus cheer leading b*tch...big pass.

Why no Kasumi and Zaeed? They would fit as Kasumi in the top three, Zaeed somewhere in the middle.

Modifié par Golden Owl, 09 octobre 2011 - 02:47 .

[Erani]

Liara
Legion
Garrus
Kaidan
Mordin
Wrex
Tali

Don't care about the others.

[jlb524]

Liara
Liara
Liara
Liara
Miranda
Miranda
I don't remember the rest.

[Prince Zeel]

jlb524 wrote...

Liara
Liara
Liara
Liara
Miranda
Miranda
I don't remember the rest.

No surprise.

[shepskisaac]

Love/like:
1. Kaidan
2. Legion
3. Jacob
4. Miranda
5. Thane
6. Wrex
7. Morinth
8. Mordin
9. Jack
10. Zaeed
11. Ashley
12. Garrus

Don't care:
12. Samara
13. Grunt

Dislike:
15. Liara

Hate:
16. Tali

[Fiery Phoenix]

Ashley + Thane
Wrex
Legion
Miranda
Mordin
Liara
Kasumi
Tali
Kaidan
Garrus
Jacob
Jack
Samara
Zaeed
Grunt
Morinth

Modifié par Fiery Phoenix, 09 octobre 2011 - 01:59 .

[jlb524]

Prince Zeel wrote...

jlb524 wrote...

Liara
Liara
Liara
Liara
Miranda
Miranda
I don't remember the rest.

No surprise.

I like smart/hot chicks...I'm predictable.

[BatmanPWNS]

Garrus
Wrex (dead on Virmire)
Zaeed (Dead)
Grunt
Tali (ME2 Romance)
Samara
Legion
Mordin
Ashley ((ME1 Romance)
Thane (Dead as much as I didn't want to)
Jack
Kasumi (Dead)
Kaidan (Dead on Virmire)
Liara
Jacob (Dead)
Miranda
Morinth (Dead- no real explanation needed)

Just my 2 pennies. (No cent from me)

Modifié par BatmanPWNS, 09 octobre 2011 - 02:07 .

[Mr.House]

Legion
Liara
Miri
Wrex
Mordin
Kaidan
Ash
Thane
Samara

Sod the rest.

[Moondoggie]

it's probably easiest to give my top and bottom three. I'm quite indifferent about most characters they don't thrill me but i don't hate them either.

Top 3

Garrus - Consistently well written and interesting since the first game

Mordin - Had a pretty deep character and even though he's only been in one game so far i felt like i knew him and cared about him

Kasumi - kind of shallow since she was DLC and for some reason they decided that means you can't converse with her. But i thought her original lines in certain situations were really funny and i also thought her personal quest was pretty well written.


Bottom 3

Ashley - **** hypocrite b*tch, Did the writers forget all her alien hating antics in the first game when they did the second game? They made her really annoying when she starts pointing fingers because you are with cerberus when she shared many of their ideals in the first game.

Kaidan - Just so boring. If he's going to have to be in ME3 for the whole game i hope they make him more manageable to listen to. I hated talking to him in the first game "So yeah....this horrible thing happened to me wanna hear about it?" and then you go back again another time "Hey...Wanna hear something WORSE than the last thing i told you about?" He's like the worlds biggest downer.

Jacob - OH MY GOD. What were they thinking!? Didn't anyone tell them how black stereotypes went out with the 80's? everytime he spoke it was just so cringey and felt like a bad movie from the 70's combined with Mr.T quotes. I can't believe any writer could create a character that annoying.

Modifié par Moondoggie, 09 octobre 2011 - 02:27 .

[Phoenix92254]

hhh89 wrote...

Prince Zeel, is Thane's position related to the recent news about him?

What is the recent news about Thane?