Aller au contenu

Photo

Your Favourite Squadmates - From Best to Worst.


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
376 réponses à ce sujet

#251
Guest_liesandpropaganda_*

Guest_liesandpropaganda_*
  • Guests

Osiris 2.0 wrote...

Am i the only one who likes Morinth?


Nope. There's a whole thread out there if you look around.

#252
thatguy212

thatguy212
  • Members
  • 1 747 messages

EternalAmbiguity wrote...

Osiris 2.0 wrote...

Am i the only one who likes Morinth?


ha ha ha, oh no. There was a huge thread with a fellow named D.Kain on here arguing that she wasn't really bad.

Yah he's kinda crazy even by BSN standards, he's basically the morinth version of a talimancer when they were at their worst :lol:

#253
VanguardOfDestruction

VanguardOfDestruction
  • Members
  • 108 messages

thatguy212 wrote...

AdmiralCheez wrote...

Osiris 2.0 wrote...

Am i the only one who likes Morinth?

I'll get to it, but I haven't gotten that far in my Morinth-saving playthrough yet.  I really like what I've seen so far, but my limited exposure isn't enough to make a fair call.  I think most people are in the same boat.

She's actually a pretty fun character to use squadmember wise, dialogue wise she's a let down, but its a lot of fun to use dominate at just the right time and control harbinger, too many people in this thread talk about never recruiting and i think they should at least recruit her one even if its just so they can appreciate samara that much more, recruiting morinth is kinda like going on a rampage in a game like fallout or elder scrolls, you know you shouldn't but it sure is fun


Yea thats what I mean. I like her abilities a little more than Morinth.. and i think the work they put into her character background (Arkdat yakshi's or how you say it :P) I think thats pretty interesting.... and i kinda wanna see what she is like in ME3 ...if you didn't get killed by her Image IPB

#254
Degs29

Degs29
  • Members
  • 1 068 messages
1) Mordin
2) Miranda
3) Liara
4) Garrus
5) Samara
6) Thane
7) Legion
8) Jack

The only 8 I'm really interested in.  The rest have their moments, but most of the time I just go through the motions with them.

9) Morinth
10) Wrex
11) Tali
12) Grunt
13) Ashley
14) Kaidan
15) Jacob

Modifié par Degs29, 26 octobre 2011 - 05:03 .


#255
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

EternalAmbiguity wrote...

Osiris 2.0 wrote...

Am i the only one who likes Morinth?


ha ha ha, oh no. There was a huge thread with a fellow named D.Kain on here arguing that she wasn't really bad.

D.Kain argue? I don't know...:whistle:

#256
TheKillerAngel

TheKillerAngel
  • Members
  • 3 608 messages
I don't actively dislike any squadmate. There are a few I feel lukewarm or indifferent about, such as Tali (she doesn't come off as terribly interesting to me).

I like Zaeed. He's ****ing badass. Miranda, Thane, and Legion too.

#257
avengeASTRID

avengeASTRID
  • Members
  • 32 messages
 I based mine on who interests me the most, not LI or just my general like of the character. Character depth is important to me. I'll give reasoning to some of them but not all, mainly because I'm lazy.

Thane (I love him the moment I he prayed during his intro and my Shepard told him that the asari needed his prayers, and he said it wasn't for her, but for him. Religion often goes hand in hand with guilt, and I'm a sucker for extreme guilt.)
Samara (Living as long as she has only to give up her possessions and life to The Code, having a family and she has to go against her mothering insincts and kill her own daughter, for the good of everyone else. That's deep. She also is seen as an outsider, even by her own people who may respect her, but fear her. Not to mention she gave us a new insight into asari culture previously unknown.)
Jack
Liara
Garrus
Wrex 
Zaeed (Honestly, this is a new one for me. I've been thinking about Zaeeed since I started my new playthrough and came to the decision that I really like him. I love his appearance. I love how he's much older than everyone else, and his facial features. He's also a badass who is out solely for vengence, and I love vengence seeking characters almost as much as I love guilt stricken characters.)
Grunt (Besides that I think Grunt is adorable, the fact that he spent the majority of ME2 lost. He had no purpose, and had to find his purpose. He was rejected by krogan after he sought their acceptance and had to earn his place in the clan, which I find admirable. I love that he had to find himself and come to terms with the fact he was from a tank and so unlike the rest of his people.)
Legion ("We are Legion, for we are many." I should not have to say anymore, really.)
Mordin
Morinth (I studied psychology in college. She's pretty fasinating, in a distrubing way. I have yet to have her on my team though.)
Miranda
Ashley
Tali (I guess I just don't understand the hype. Sorry.)
Kasumi
Jacob 
Kaidan

#258
fainmaca

fainmaca
  • Members
  • 1 617 messages
Hmm. Tough one...
For me though, I would have to divide it into levels of interest/enjoyment rather than a straight out list.Please bear in mind this is all personal opinion, not judgement of those who have different favourites. No offence is intended.

Band one: Most liked.

Jack (My LI on all playthroughs so far. A very deep character, and I'm always thrilled to see the layers getting stripped away to reveal the soft core to her.)

Legion (A geth on the squad by itself is interesting. Add to that the skillful way he can add a synthetic slant to organic topics such as religion, reverence for the dead and so on, and you have a powerful tool. Anything that challenges my normal way of thinking is brilliant.)

Mordin (His guilt is very well written, as is his dedication to what must be done. Also, his comic moments are great. The 'advice' chat he gives had me blushing a little, but it felt like a concerned friend speaking out for me.)

Wrex (Two words: Bad. Ass. His scene with C-sec, where he says 'I want you to try' just made me punch the air and go 'Yes! i must have him in my squad!' Then meeting him on Tuchanka was so heartwarming.)

Garrus (Another badass. His friendship with Shepard feels so genuine, and so strong, I wish I knew someone like him in Real Life who i could go drinking with.)

Band Two: Quite enjoyed.

Thane (His spirituality was inspiring, as was his struggle with his past. Also his statement that shep was the first real friend he'd had in over a decade made me really appreciate the depth of the character. Again, a character I could visualise as a good drinking buddy.)

Samara (Tragic past, strength of character, ageless beauty, she has it all. Very well written. Shame she wasn't an LI. Might have been tempted away from Jack...)

Grunt (he feels very much like a student of Shepard's, so i feel a sort of responsibility for how he turns out. You have a good emotional investment in him, which leads to a strong empathy for him.)

Kasumi (So much fun! Her banter, her shipboard commets, all done so well.)

Zaeed (I like having a more experienced, if embittered soldier around. Very well done, considering he's optional.

Kaidan (Kaidan has always been a liked character for me. he's not complicated, but he doesn't need to be. Sometimes you need a straightforward, honest guy on the team. plus his being there in the first scene of the game hints at him being a part of Shepard's crew for a while like joker. Again, someone I feel would be a close enough friend to share a few drinks with.)

Jacob (I don't get all the hate for him. While not a powerful personality like some others, he's always clear, straight-up and doesn't meekly keep quiet. A level head in a crew of potentially unstable beings. Once more- drinking buddy.)

Band Three: Liked, but mostly neutral.

Miranda (I despised her after her 'clearly you were a mistake' comment to Jack, but she redeemed herself in my third playthough by telling TIM to shove it. Now, I have an improved appreciation for the character. While not a favourite, she's alright.)

Tali (I can understand the fascination with what's behind the helmet, but I don't share it. She's sweet, quirky, and feels a little like a little sister to Shepard after he helped her complete her Pilgrimage, but she wasn't given enough non-romance content to really score well with me.)

Liara (Do not get the fascination with her. I romanced her on my very first ME playthrough, pre ME2 release, but that was just for the 'hehehe, blue boobies' moment. I think what most irritates me is her plot invulnerability. While I wouldn't deliberately kill her off, I hope it is possible to have her die in ME3, just to keep her realistic.)

Band Four: Disliked/Did not recruit.

Morinth (What kind of Shepard honestly thinks recruiting this psychotic serial killer at the expense of her older, more experienced mother who is unquestioningly loyal to you is actually a good idea? She dies every time in my games. Every. Time. I didn't even spare her just to get Dominate.)

Ashley (Sorry, Ashaholics, but she's the one character I've had on my squad I wished I could get rid off at the first stop. her comments comparing aliens to animals, and particularly the downer comment in the presidium 'that's a big lake, wonder if anyone's been drowned in it' really switch me off. I understand her family history and so on explains a lot of her attitude, but I still feel like its overcompensating. A different person's mileage may vary, but I just can't like the character, even though I try to. I go to her every playthrough and have the conversations, but they just don't do anything to improve her in my eyes.)

Anyway, that's my list.

#259
avengeASTRID

avengeASTRID
  • Members
  • 32 messages

Mordin (His guilt is very well written, as is his dedication to what must be done. Also, his comic moments are great. The 'advice' chat he gives had me blushing a little, but it felt like a concerned friend speaking out for me.)


Oooh. You are right about that. I forgot about his loyalty mission where he had to confront his past and try to convince himself and Shepard that what he did was the right thing. Okay, I would bump him up in my list now : ]

#260
avengeASTRID

avengeASTRID
  • Members
  • 32 messages
[quote]fainmaca wrote...

[quote]

Mordin (His guilt is very well written, as is his dedication to what must be done. Also, his comic moments are great. The 'advice' chat he gives had me blushing a little, but it felt like a concerned friend speaking out for me.)

[/quote]

Oooh. You are right about that. I forgot about his loyalty mission where he had to confront his past and try to convince himself and Shepard that what he did was the right thing. Okay, I would bump him up in my list now : ]

Modifié par avengeASTRID, 26 octobre 2011 - 04:17 .


#261
Tomoya Nagase

Tomoya Nagase
  • Members
  • 1 messages
Love:

Tali ME2 LI and Liara ME1 & ME2 LI
I just can't realy decide between these two well I will just make two playthrough. I have one Tali save and one Liara save both played since ME1.

Like
Garru: God he is an awesome teammate and has hilarius metaphors (You know me, always like to savor that last shot before popping the heatsink.)
Wrex: He survived ME 1 and I met him again in ME2
Legion: He is kinda cool and i love Snipers!
Kasumi: Well i have a fetish asian woman...
Miranda: Well i just say "ASSUMING CONTROL OF DAT ASS!"
Moradin: I like the way he speaks lol
Grunt: He was ok but he will never be as awesome as Wrex!

Neutral up to dislike
Thane: Well I always had a fishy feeling about him. *laughts about his own bad joke*
Kaidan: No special reason.
Jacob: No special reason.
Zaeed: I saved him but I dislike people that go against me.
Samara: She was kinda lame and you couldn't interact with her that much.
Jack: Well I just didn't like her and that IM SO TOUGH number...
Morinth: You die when you try to romance any more reasons? Well she also killed her own mother!
Ash: I didn't like her because she disliked alians (damn racist) and I hated her after ME2 damn ****! (my opinion sorry at all the ash fans)

Modifié par Tomoya Nagase, 27 octobre 2011 - 12:41 .


#262
Han Shot First

Han Shot First
  • Members
  • 21 148 messages
1. Garrus

2. Mordin

3. Legion

4. Wrex

5. Liara (LotSB, romance)

6. Samara

7. Miranda (romanced in ME2)

8.  Ashley

9. Grunt

10. Thane

11. Jack

12. Tali

13. Kaidan

14. Jacob

15. Morinth


For the most part that list is just in the order of who I like most, with Morinth the only one I truly dislike. She always end up getting killed in every one of my playthroughs.
 
Kaidan and Jacob also round out the bottom of my list but I wouldn't say that I dislike either character, it's just that I find the others more interesting. Jacob also has moments where he can be a bit standoffish. Tali is near the bottom of my list because while she was a well fleshed out and interesting character in ME2, in ME1 she was the most boring person on the squad.

Modifié par Han Shot First, 27 octobre 2011 - 12:39 .


#263
lost.long.ago

lost.long.ago
  • Members
  • 37 messages
Like them all! Well, except Jacob... I don't mind him, but he's just not super amazingly interesting. And I never recruited Morinth, but I like the idea behind her/ what I know of her. The other two Asari are probably at the top of my list; me gusta intellectuals/wisdom.

#264
Feena.c

Feena.c
  • Members
  • 63 messages
What? No Zaeed or Kasumi? Fine. But let it be known I love them both(Kasumi right after VS, and Zaeed right after Tali).
* means I have romanced them in a playthrough(All my Sheps are faithful)
Let's see then.....

*Garrus(BFF, not actually fave romance though)
**VS(I love them both so they can share 2nd)
*Jack (Surprisingly given my first impression, but I love her now)
Miranda (Again, surprisingly, I just like having her around)
Mordin (Hilarious, and great story connection to Genophage)
Wrex (Shepard)
Tali (By virtue of being important, not much emotion on my part though)
*Thane (Nice)
Legion (Fine)
Samara (Eh, like her hate her loyalty quest)
Grunt (Boring)
Jacob (*Snort*)
Liara (~HATE~, and not in a good way)

Modifié par Feena.c, 28 octobre 2011 - 12:53 .


#265
iloveTali81

iloveTali81
  • Members
  • 20 messages
1.Image IPBTali'Zorah  Image IPB                                                                                                                                      2.Wrex                                                                                                                                                          3.Legion                                                                                                                                             4.Mordin                                                                                                                                                        5.Liara                                                                                                                                                          6.Samara                                                                                                                                                           7.Garrus                                                                                                                                                          8.Morinth                                                                                                                                                       9.jacob                                                                                                                                                                               10.thane                                                                                                                                                11.grunt                                                                                                                                                   12.jack                                                                                                                                                         13.Kaidan                                                                                                                                                                                           14.I hate you MirandaImage IPB

#266
Hawkeye121

Hawkeye121
  • Members
  • 308 messages
1 - Ashley
2 - Garrus
3 - Liara
4 - Wrex
5 - Miranda
6 - Zaeed
7 - Kaidan
8 - Tali
9 - Mordin
10 - Jack
11 - Thane
12 - Kasumi
13 - Samara
14 - Legion
15 - Grunt
16 - Jacob
17 - Morinth

Just my two cents

-Hawk

#267
Td1984

Td1984
  • Members
  • 1 328 messages
Miranda
Ashley
Wrex
Garrus
Jacob
Mordin
Grunt
Legion
Tali
Samara
Jack
Thane
Kaidan

NOTE: I left out Morinth because I never chose her over Samara

Modifié par Td1984, 07 janvier 2012 - 04:15 .


#268
xxprokillazxx

xxprokillazxx
  • Members
  • 423 messages
1.Liara(Romance)
2.Samara
3.Legion
4.Ashley
5.Zaeed
6.Jack
Don't Really care about the rest.

#269
Volc19

Volc19
  • Members
  • 1 470 messages
Mordin
Legion
[Male spoiler character from the leak]
Zaeed (I had to)
Garrus
Wrex
Thane
Kasumi
(a bunch of generic blahh)
Miranda
Ashely
Vega
Jacob

If only there was a place lower than "last" for Jacob. He has never once made a good suggestion. "I don't trust Thane", "Send me to hack", "Throw Legion out of an airlock".

Modifié par Volc19, 07 janvier 2012 - 04:43 .


#270
Wrathra

Wrathra
  • Members
  • 627 messages
Don't dislike any of them, but my top five (in no particular order)

Mordin
Wrex
Kaidan
Garrus
Miranda

#271
double02

double02
  • Members
  • 1 025 messages
Garrus
Ashley
Liara
Wrex
Tali

I like them all, to some extent.

#272
Shepard_Vas_Normandy

Shepard_Vas_Normandy
  • Members
  • 47 messages
Like the best:


Tali
Liara
Kasumi
Thane
Jack

Like (Just to talk and wouldn't mind havin around)

Samara/Morinth
Miranda
Garrus
Mordin
Ashley

Indifferent about: (Don't mind um, but they would not be missed)

Zaeed
Grunt
Wrex
Legion
Jacob

Can't Stand:

Kaiden

#273
Lil-Vinny29

Lil-Vinny29
  • Members
  • 190 messages
My list of favorites

ME: Tali, Wrex, Garrus and Liara

ME2: Tali, Garrus, Samara, Grunt

Played alot of times, each time Kaiden stayed on Virmire...Oups

#274
barrier power

barrier power
  • Members
  • 3 messages
1.Miranda
2.Legion
3.Ashley
4.Wrex
5.Samara
6.Liara
7.Mordin
8.Kasumi
9.Grunt
10.Jack
11.Zaeed
12.Kaidan
13.Garrus
14.Tali
15.Jacob
16.Morinth

#275
gearseffect

gearseffect
  • Members
  • 1 592 messages
My order of them
1.Wrex: He's such a bad@ss, and has so much depth to his character and Species

2.Liara: My first romance and I'll always be found of her

3.Jack: Such a tormented and broken individual. Her self-destructive behavior and some of her other personalitly traits reminded me a bit of myself when I was in High School

4.Garrus: his style of justice he's like my main Shepards Brother

5.Samara: I want One of my main Shepard's and her to "have happiness together" at the very lest do her. Her personality is really cool.

6.Kelly Chambers: Her personality is great for many reason, first to greet ya after a mission, Warm and Kind, and to me she had rather calming aura about her that put ya at ease and felt everything would be ok

7.Mordin:liked his moral crisis with the work he did with the Genophage (also liked Captain Kirrahe from ME1)

8.Ashley: Blunt and sharp with her opinions. Not to good with words yep that's a big plus!!!

9.Thane: his spiritual beliefs,and Zen attitude were really cool

10.Joker: what's not to like about him

11.Tie Legion and Morinth: Both were interesting characters that added lots to the ME universe and intrigued me

12.Miranda : Ice cold, perfect, superior, arrogant, great eye candy, and the type that's good for a hit and run, I'd also I'd happily let her die over several characters due to the fact to me she seemed like she only cared about herself

13.Kasumi: I feel she had so much more to offer and really wanted to talk with her like the other squad members

14.Jacob: In ME1 when ya found the brain dead dude named Jacob it freaked me out, I gave my Shepard that same first name and named him after myself, and Jacob T. seemed like a decent dude and we had a first name in common. I wish he could have been better written,

15.Kaidan: he gets headaches and reminds me of Tom Brady (I hate Tom Perfect Pretty Boy Brady) I usually let Kaidan die.

16.Zaeed: Yawn... he was boring to me

17.Grunt: made me miss Wrex

18.Doc Chakwas, EDI and the other Normandy crew in ME2

19.Tali: Annoying if I could strangle and kill any of my crew members for no reason or any reason it would be Tali, she never shut up and was annoying

Modifié par gearseffect, 07 janvier 2012 - 07:18 .