376 réponses à ce sujet

[dublin omega 223]

Liked

1 Garrus
2 Wrex
3 Grunt
4 Tali
5 Kasumi
6 Kaidan
7 Jacob
8 Thane
9 Samara
10 Zaeed
11 Mordin
12 EDI
13 Vega
14 Jack

Disliked/Hated

1 Ashley
2 Legion
3 Liara
4 Javik
5 Morinith
6 Miranda

Modifié par dublin omega 223, 08 juin 2012 - 08:28 .

[Spitfire017]

Well, since this thread has been brought back from the dead, I'll throw my two cents in, though I really don't hate any of the squad mates.

Love:
1. Ashley Williams: My dream women and canon LI. Sort of disappointed with her in ME3, but still love her.
2. Garrus: My bro since ME2 and always at my side. Plus good in a fight.
3. Miranda: It was hard to decide between Ash and her. She has a lot of qualities that I like and admire in Ash. Though, for the most part I like her confidence, her flaws and easy on the eyes.
4. Kaidan: My ME1 Marine buddy.
5. Wrex: Interesting character with a dark past and motivation to lead his people to a better tomorrow.
6. Liara: Like that girl who had a crush on me, and never never got over it. Still like her though and she is the ****ing Shadowbroker!!!
7. Tali: Feels like a kid sister who grew up...and became an Admiral! Like Garrus, always at my side and really cute when flustered.
8. Zaeed: Love that bloody godamn hero. Always good in a fight and love his stories.
9. Grunt: My other Krogan buddy, really funny.

Liked:

10. Legion: The first Geth who never instantly took a shot at me, and has a soul.
11. Javik: Interesting to talk to and feels like a dark mirror to Shepard.
12. James Vega: Good soldier and officer.
13. Mordin: Good scientist, fun to be around and interesting back story. Never really brought him along on missions though.
14. Jacob: A genuinely good guy with good intentions. Never really brought him along on missions though.
15. Kasumi: Always the optimist. Never really brought her along on missions though.
16. Jack: A messed up girl who just needed a purpose in life. And she got it in ME3. Also, very powerful Biotic, and brought her on a lot of missions.
Edit: 17. Thane: OMG, forget about Thane. Always fond of elite assassin types. Interesting character with an interesting past, and I feel sorry for him. Good friend.
18. EDI: I really don't like the "sexbot" in ME3, but still like the character and how she grows during the game.

Dislike:

N/A

Other:

Morinth: I don't consider her a squad mate cause I always kill her off. She is always be a one mission antagonist to me.

Did I forget anyone?

Modifié par Spitfire017, 08 juin 2012 - 10:21 .

[teh DRUMPf!!]

1.) Jack
2.) Mordin
3.) Wrex
4.) Javik
5.) EDI

6.) Garrus
7.) Zaeed
8.) Legion
9.) James

10.) VS (negligible difference)
11.) Grunt
12.) Samara
13.) Tali
14.) Miranda
15.) Thane
16.) Jacob

--- ranks within actual liking end beyond this point ---
17.) Liara

Not Applicable: Morinth - insufficient character-arc.

[FROST4584]

1. Ashley
2. Tali (Mass Effect 1 )
3. EDI
4. Jack
5. Samara
6. Miranda
7. Kasumi
8. James Vega
9. Garrus
10 .Wrex
11. Grunt
12.Zaeed
13. Liara
14. Legion
15. Jacob
16. Mordin


Least favorites:

Thane
Morinth ( Why would anyone like a mass murder?)
Kaidan
Tali (Mass Effect 2 and 3)
Garrus(Mass Effect 3)

Modifié par FROST4584, 09 juin 2012 - 02:02 .

[gearseffect]

1.Samara
2.Thane
3.Jack
4.Wrex
5.Garrus
6.Ashley (ME1 and ME2 look ONLY)
7.Vega
8.Mordin
9.Grunt
10.Zaeed
11.Jacob
12.Miranda
13.Kasumi
14.Legion
15.Tali
16.Liara
17.EDI
18.Anderson
19.Kaidan
20.Wilson


Morinth

[Ranger3bn]

I would have to rate my top 2 as followed:

Vega: Even though I know little of his combat history in the ME universe, I can say that I related to him the most. His actions and demeanor are very consistent with those who I served with in real life. A soldier through and through and seems to have possessed the Alpha type personality to operate at the level of Shepherd.

Garrus: constant professional on the battlefield and surgical with his wit and candor. Again, very consistent someone who has been down range. Garrus also was able to show a side that very few outside of his inner circle would ever see. His understanding of the pressure that Shepherd was under was spot on.

[vvDRUCILLAvv]

 :wub::wub:
1. Javik

:O:O:O
1. Grunt
2. Legion

:):)
1. Wrex
2. Mordin
3. Garrus

:sick::sick:
1. Vega
2. Tali
3. Traynor
4. Allers

and the rest I couldn't care less about.

[Bellendaine]

Kaidan (take him everywhere every chance I get ...)
Garrus (same as above)
Kasumi (I really like her for some reason, wish there was more of her)
James (in ME3 ... lots hate him, I find him moderately amusing)
Mordin (don't take him many places, but I find conversations with him fun)
Tali (out of longevity loyalty, mostly)
Liara (I actually like her, I just wish that she wasn't so ... everywhere in the game)
Miranda (she grew on me)
Jacob (a little milquetoast for me ... I usually have him die on the Collector Base just so he has a heroic end rather than be a douche in ME3)
Grunt (I like him better in ME3 than 2)
Thane (same as above)
Wrex (I like him better in ME2/3 than 1)
Samara (I never use her as I'm a biotic Shep and I have Kaidan when I can, but her story is interesting)
Javik (he's fun to talk with, but I don't take him places)
Jack (I've tried to like her, really I have ... just. can't. do. it)
Zaeed (I take every renegade option I can when I use him ... most times I ignore the mission to get him)
Ashley (yah ... just ... not so much)
EDI (I like her better as a ship than a sexy robot ...)

[KingWrex]

Wrex(isn't it obvious) 
Garrus he's my bro
Ash=LI
Grunt= tankborn adopted son
Mordin
Javik
Thane
Legion
Miranda
Zaeed
Jack
Vega
Liara
Kasumi
Tali
Samara
Kaiden
EDI
Jacob

[o Ventus]

1. Miranda
2. Legion
3. Thane
4. Garrus
5. Grunt
6. Wrex
7. Mordin
8. Kasumi
9. Samara
10. Zaeed
11. Jack
12. Liara
13. Ashley
14. Kaidan

[BadExamp1e]

Anderson
Ashley (romance)
Garrus (bro)
Liara
Grunt
Wrex
Kaidan
Tali (sis)
Traynor
Mordin
Legion
Kasumi
Vega
Jack
Miranda
Jacob
Thane
Samara
Cortez
Kelly.

I don't hate any character funny enough. I'm definitely fond of some characters more than others, though.

[Beep Il]

1. Kaidan "Mom was right, I should've brought a sweater."
2. Miranda "Perfect!"
3. Mordin "Close combat, problematic."
4. Kasumi "Gift for you!"
5. Jack "Hello, dead people."
6. James "I'm not a tech expert."
7. Tali "Go for the optics, Chiktikka! Go for the optics!"
8. Garrus "One less to worry about!"
9. Grunt "I AM KROGAN!"
10. Legion "Does this unit have a soul?"
11. Wrex "I'd like you to try."
12. Morinth "Your mind is mine!"
13. Samara "Embrace eternity!"
14. Thane "..."
15. Zaeed "That's a goddamn suicide!"
16. Javik "Throw the machine out the airlock."
17. EDI "That was a joke."
18. Liara "I'm talking with a hallucination."
19. Jacob "Good stuff."
20. Ashley "You know it's the right decision, lieutenant."

[Rikketik]

I can't make a top 20, so I'll instead use the tiers from Pokémon multiplayer and rank each squadmate on how much I use them.

Overused:
- EDI
- Garrus
- Kaidan (ME3)
- Grunt

Borderline:
- Wrex
- Samara
- Miranda

Underused:
- Liara
- Legion
- Thane
- Vega

Rarely used:
- Kasumi
- Zaeed

Never used:
- Tali
- Mordin
- Kaidan (ME1)
- Ashley
- Jack
- Jacob
- Javik

Banned:
- Morinth (Technically she's a copy of Samara in terms of abilities -- aside from Reave, that is -- and therefore belongs in the Borderline group, but I only saved her to unlock Dominate and then quickly reloaded an earlier save. I will never save her again, so I consider her 'banned from the game'.)

[ReptileSmile]

!:
1. Legion
2. Legion in alternate armor
3. Kasumi (She is totally my Shep's BFF)
4. EDI (I think I prefer synthetic beings to organic beings. . .)

Yum!:
5. Samara (She is like my Shep's surrogate mother)
6. Mordin
7. Zaeed

Yay!:
8. Garrus
9. Tali
10. Jack
11. Thane
12. Vega
13. Wrex

Meh:
14. Grunt
15. Liara
16. Miranda (Although she grew on me after watching Legion & Friends)
17. Ashley

Yuck:
18. Kaiden (whiny and disloyal)
19. Jacob (snooooore)
20. Javik
21. Morinth

[Barquiel]

ME1
Liara
Wrex
Garrus
Ashley
Kaiden
Tali

ME2
Miranda
Mordin
Samara
Kasumi
Morinth
Legion
Jack
Grunt
Zaeed
Tali
Thane
Jacob
Garrus

ME3 (I don't have Javik/Kaiden was dead)
Liara
EDI
Garrus
Vega
Tali
Ashley

[Vlk3]

Loved:
1. Thane (LI and he was very helpful for my vanguard, took him to every mission)

Liked very much :
2. Garrus (second most frequent squadmate, Garrus is a bro, I can't even think of him as a LI, best friend to Shepard- definitely)

Liked (I liked most of characters, but they were rarely on my missions, because there was no place for them;):
3. Javik (he and Garrus were my squaddies on most of the missions in ME3; I really like him for being a troll, but he wasn't very good at fight)
5. Samara (I just like her character, my Shep really respects her and considers a friend )
6. Liara ( She saved Shepard and is a very good friend for her. Also has useful skills.)
7. Jack (She grew on me and is very useful in combat)
8. Mordin (Great skills and he is so funny, I also like his concern for Shepard's health due to the hallucinations :>  )
9. Kasumi ( I like to imagine that she and Shepard became close friends, loved the backstab)
10. Tali ( Tali is like a little sister to Shepard)
11. Wrex ( because he's Wrex.)
12. Kaidan (A LI in one of my playthroughs, good skills and he is sometimes sweet; my canon Shepard virmired him though)
13. Legion (He's adorable: "No data available"; too bad he's at the end of the game if you want everyone alive)
14.  Ashley (At first I didn't like her, but she and my Shep have a connection (spacers))
15. Miranda ( She is competent and rebuilt Shepard. Later they became friends, despite difficulties at the beginning. Also quite useful)

Neutral:
16.Jacob ( I really liked him, but then he said something unpleasant to Thane and since then i never took him on my mission again)
17. James Vega (he's just dumb... funny sometimes but still I didn't really care about him)
18.Grunt (He's okay but not really a great friend for Shep)
19. EDI ( I loved her as a ship, but I simply didn't like the idea of her as a squadmate)
20. Zaeed ( I simply didn't care but some of his stories are good; also useful, but i prefered to take other squadmates)

Never used:
21. Morinth (Because she's a ruthless murderer and I like Samara)

Modifié par Vlk3, 19 juin 2012 - 09:05 .

[Mr.House]

ME
1:Wrex
2:Liara
3:Ash
4:kaidan
5:Tali
6:Garrus

ME2:
1 Legion
2:Miranda
3:Mordin
4:Thane
5:Samara
6:Jack
7: Grunt
8:Kasumi
9:Zaeed
10:Garrus
11:Jacob
12:Tali
13:Morinth

ME3
1:Liara
2:Javik
3:Kaidan
4:Garrus
5:EDI
6:Vega
7:Tali
8:Ash

[ObserverStatus]

Morinth
Mordin
Wrex
Garrus
Legion
Zaeed
Tali
Liara
Kasumi
Jack
EDI
Grunt
Vega
Miranda
Thane
Javik
Kaidan
Jacob
Ashley
Samara

[wright1978]

Miranda. Amazing character. How she didn't get a role in ME3 Cerberus arc is beyond me.
Kasumi. Love her in ME2.
Wrex. Clearly the best of ME1 characters and yet i'm forced to stomach the rest of the ME1 characters come ME3.
Mordin. He rocks, pity about the actor change
Javik. Finally got to meet a prothean and he was a surprise and not a letdown.
Legion. Another very interesting character that didn't get enough time on squad.
Jack. Initiallyhated her but in later playthroughs began to appreciate her.
Grunt: The perfect Krogan even if he wasn't wrex.
Garrus: Didn't like how forced Garrus was but still have some fondness for him.
Thane: Pity his character wasn't given more thought in ME3 despite his cool fight scene.
Samara: Reasonably Interesting character
Kaidan/Ashley: Well characterised even if i didn't have much attachment to them.
EDI: Preferred her as ship's AI.
Zaeed: Had potential, could have done with better exposition.

Liara: Really grew to dislike her character more and more as theseries progressed. Plot armor crazy.
Jacob: Weak
Vega: Even weaker
Morinth: No development time put into her.

[coldwetn0se]

I can't remember if I did this list so what the hell:

ME: (liked them all, but here is how I rank them in terms of character arcs and combat use)
1)Wrex
2) Kaidan/Ashley (enjoyed Ashley's character, but admittedly rarely used her in combat)
3) Garrus
4) Liara
5) Tali

ME2:
1)Thane (LI choice for all my Fem!Sheps, brother-in-arms for all Male!Sheps, plus my go-to character for combat. Sniper+Throw/Warp=win
2) Jack/Garrus/Samara (Great characters, and combat buddies.)
3) Mordin/Legion (actually LOVE them as characters, but I get Legion so late, and Mordin is not my first choice for combat, though I do love Incinerate......I often play Infiltrators or Engineers though, so......)
4) Kasumi/Miranda (Good characters, but combat wise they were hit or miss.)
5)Grunt/Zaeed/Tali/Jacob (I do like them well enough, but liked others a bit more, and didn't use them that often in combat........however, I have started playing a couple new Sheps in ME2, and I am going out of my way to play with them more; it has been fun.)

me3: (didn't finish the game, but here is the list that I at least played a bit with)
1) Javik (can't help but find him funny)
2) Garrus (he's a bro)
3) VS/Liara (I guess.......)
4) Vega (I didn't hate him)
5) EDI/Tali (actually in all fairness to them, I never got a chance to really play with them...well, a little with EDI, but.........)

Modifié par coldwetn0se, 19 juin 2012 - 11:21 .

[mnomaha]

ME1
1) Garrus
2) Wrex
3) Tali


ME2

1) Thane...the soulmate of most of my FemSheps
2) Garrus/Grunt...Garrus being the only other LI for one FemShep
3) Samara....She'd be higher but my ManShep is still heartbroken over the not-kiss
4) Jack/Legion/Mordin
5) Jacob
6) Miranda
7) Kasumi/Zaeed...couldn't stand the auto dialogue but loved the characters

ME3

Miss Effect 3 does not exist for me.

[Shaleist]

In order top to bottom

Jack
Mordin

Wrex
Kaidan  *Stole the 'Reliable, normal, relatable mantle*
EDI *as the Normandy/Crewmember*
Zaeed  *was higher, just amazing how little he was in ME3*
Legion
Kasumi *dropped , see Zaeed notes*
Garrus *this low because he bored the Hell out of me in ME1*

Liara *yay for the EC. 5% LESS creepy Liara stalking my Shepard, it' s a start*
Ashley *dropped, 2nd playthrough she turned annoying Ash again*
Vega
Javik
Thane      *moved up 100% due to Marauder Shields comic*
Jacob 


Samara
Miranda
Tali
Grunt
<_<
Edi *in the Fembot suit at least*
Morinth

Oh I'm assuming this is a Like to dislike list. Not ranking the story quality above.
And I can't believe I felt the need to update this 3 weeks after posting, and I replayed it and did another full ME1 to ME3 playthrough...for no good raisin...

Modifié par Shaleist, 11 juillet 2012 - 06:11 .

[CrimsonN7]

I like everyone else for different reasons, each with their pros and cons however the only two I would love to roll up into a carpet and toss off a bridge would be Jacob and Vega. Ugh we don't get a Krogan squaddie in ME3 but we do get a George Lopez wannabe... lame<_<

Modifié par CrimsonN7, 20 juin 2012 - 12:20 .

[warlock22]

ME1
Liara My main LI
Garrus Best friend and a badass
Tali she is just to cute, and loveable
Rex nuff said
Kaiden

ME2
Samara My other main LI (seriously I'm torn between Liara and Samara, love them both
Garrus Best friend, and a badass
Tali once again cute and loveable
Thane Good and wise friend, and a badass naturally
Grunt nuff said
Morinth very interesting character, she deserved way better than what she got in ME3
Kasumi awesome attitude, a cool character and just a nice person
Legion is awesome
Jack bit of a temper but a cool character.
Miranda
Zaeed

ME3... they need for fix a lot of stuff first before I say anything.

Modifié par warlock22, 20 juin 2012 - 12:25 .

[CrazyManimalR]

1. Garrus
2. Legion
3. Tali
4. EDI
5. Samara
6. Kasumi
7. Liara
8. Wrex
9. Mordin
10. Miranda
11. Zaeed
12. Thane
13. Grunt
14. Jack
15. Ashley
16. Javik
17. Jacob
18. Kaidan
19. Vega

Modifié par CrazyManimalR, 20 juin 2012 - 01:42 .