376 réponses à ce sujet

[D.Kain]

hotdogbsg wrote...

1. Zaeed

2. Everyone Else

I kinda see the logic, but why is Kasumi worse?

[wildannie]

Favourites

1- Thane
2- Mordin

Likes

3- Wrex
4- Garrus
5- Kaidan
6- Legion
7- Kasumi
8- Jack

Okays
9- Tali
10- Zaeed
11 - Samara

Dislikes
12- Grunt
13 - Ashley
14- Jacob
15 - Miranda
16 - Liara
17 - Morinth - never recruited - she's a cold blooded murderer.

[Jeanne22]

Liara/Wrex/Legion
Ashley
Mordin
Miranda
Grunt
Kasumi
Samara
Jack

I don't care about the others.

[FFinfinity1]

Garrus
Wrex
Ashley
Kaiden
Liara
Tali
Mordin
Legion
Grunt
Thane
Zaeed
Jacob
Samara
Kasumi
Miranda
Jack
Morinth

Basically l like the Original ME1 squad because their were so few and you felt closer to them. Opposed to the ME2 army you had going on I love all the squad mates in their own respect but that my list imo.

[FFinfinity1]

If Morinth had more to so and you could hear her stories and background, she might be higher on my list but eh.

[Dunmer of Redoran]

...any agreements/disagreements on some of the choices I posted last page?

[ZenJestr]

Tali
Garrus
Wrex
Legion
Mordin
Liara
Kasumi
Jack
Kaidan
Thane
Zaeed
Ashley
Grunt
Samara
Miranda
Jacob
Morinth

please note that I don't hate any of the characters...it's just in order...in terms of my disposition towards them, they are pretty close together, with the #'s 2-4 competing for a slot to share with #1...

[AdmiralCheez]

Arcian wrote...

>Not recruiting Morinth to get Dominate
>2011
What.

Hey, I've only completed three runs so far.  I'm gettin' to it.

[Ryzaki]

Favs:
Garrus
Legion
Miranda
Mordin
Wrex
Thane
Samara

Okay:
Jacob
Zaeed
Kasumi
Tali

Loathe:
Jack
Kaidan
Ashley

Bleh on:
Morinth

Please go die in a fire: 
Liara

Modifié par Ryzaki, 10 octobre 2011 - 04:25 .

[Kaiser_Wilhelm]

Liara (Romance)
Tali
Ashley
Mordin
Jack
Wrex
Miranda
Samara
Legion
Garrus
Grunt
Jacob
Thane
Kaidan
Morinth

[mineralica]

Sketchy, may you please get out of docks properly next time?

Anyway:
Kaidan
Miranda
Wrex
Kasumi
Mordin
Zaeed
Legion (not at all fair, he appears to late to shine properly)
Jack
Samara
Tali
Ashley
Thane
Grunt
Garrus
Jacob
Morinth
Liara

Edit: now it looks really strange. Never expected Ashley be so low, so more familiar to me tiers list:

Favs: Kaidan, Miranda
Likes: Wrex, Kasumi, Mordin, Zaeed, Legion. Jack, Samara, Tali, Ashley
Dislikes: Thane, Grunt, Garrus, Jacob
Would like never see again: Morinth, Liara

Modifié par mineralica, 10 octobre 2011 - 12:46 .

[ilovemesometurian]

ARUGH I absolutely adore them all. But if I had to pick favorites it would be this.


Garrus- He's who I'd want to be/would most likely go gay for. He's independent, smart, tactical, a great sniper and leader. He's HILARIOUS in that dry, witty and slightly awkward charming sort of way. He's smooth on the battlefield and most of all a loyal friend. He's my ace in the whole.

Kasumi- You may not have been able to talk to her, but man she stole my heart. Her loyalty mission was top notch and it was nice to see such a beautiful garden world. Her lines were golden. Everything that came out of her mouth was pure delight no matter serious, funny, good or bad. She's such a bad ass infiltrator and has amazing stealth technique and I like having a tech oriented human around. I also like how she's friendly and normal despite having a thrilling occupation. Whenever she formed an opinion I found a hard time finding any kind of argument against it.

Miranda- She's smart, charismatic, confident and yet you can get her to warm up to you in a way that you feel like you're getting a ticket into disney world once you have her trust. I love the accent, the backstory, the smooth flawless attitude. Ms. Lawson will have her way, efficiently and humanely. She's a woman I want at my side (and depending on my playthrough my bed) who I know will command both my heart and my head to victory.

Mordin- He's a genius. And he's funny. What more can you ask? He has a heart of gold and only wants to do the right thing. He's wise in the fact that a doctor can not only help by healing, but by dispatching those who cause harm as well. I like how he's struggling to make amends, and his likable personality just makes me want to help him resolve his problems in peace. It's nice to see someone want to do good with all the brain they're given. Not to mention he's a fabulous singer.

Ashley- She's a little harsh and her views can be a bit radical, but Lieutenant Williams offers the swag of Miranda mixed with the sturdy battle-hardness of a true soldier. She's beautiful even with her hair up, and she has noble goals and a feisty will to achieve them. She's a woman who can make me both stare in awe and tremble in fear with the same gaze.

Legion- He's so different from the typical robot to me. His obsession with Shepard and his views on religion and so many other topics gives him a depth that I couldn't find with synthetic companions in other stories. His lack of humor is amazing and he takes the geth image up a notch with expressive face plates and sniper skills. I enjoy his dialogue as well. He makes me regret killing any geth that attack me.

Grunt- Grunt says little and speaks a lot. He's so totally different from Wrex. He's actually the opposite. He's young and naive while Wrex is hardened through experience. However it is the raw power and the quest to find himself through age and maturity that makes me like Grunt more. His look is unique, from his eye color to the fact that his juvenile plates seem a bit softer compared to other krogan. His fist bumps are indeed amusing and his respect for Shepard and views on his duty make sense for even one so young.

Samara- She's stoic, wise and her abilities are incredible. She is a master at both words and biotics and I find it amazing when she speaks due to the fact that she has been alive literally for almost a thousand years. Her Justicar code gives her such a unique depth, as I often wonder how someone can give away all their possessions (and from the Shadow Broker dossiers, I see she had quite a lot) and travel alone throughout the galaxy to fight crime. She is disciplined and skilled, a true showing of asari morals and determination.

Tali- She's sweet and adorably awkward. I think Kasumi could take a little more flushing out and Tali could stand to lose a bit, but regardless I see her as a young woman just trying to make her place in the world and help her people. She's intelligent but has her limitations, which makes her believable. She's young and much is new to her, but her obvious growth has been easily noticed from the first game to the second. I like how she learns what she is both good and bad at, and is determined to solve her problems one way or the other. Her romance is sweet and hits home to many, and under that unique suit I think beats the heart of a living and believable girl next planet.

Wrex- He's blunt, intelligent and oh so cocky and he knows it. But despite coming from a brutish race, Wrex is the symbol of what a good krogan can learn to be. He is wise and knows what is best for his people, capable of uniting an entire nation. His skills are formidable and he is an impressive fighter. Sure there may not be much on the surface, but there's a lot of substance. When he speaks, it may not be much, but you're going to want to hear it. Shepard.

Liara- Her character has taken a real 180 and it shows very well. Her position as Shadow Broker is interesting and she is learning to hold her own. Her biotic abilities have grown and become increasingly impressive, and her knowledge on the protheans is nothing to kick under the rug. She hurts like anyone else, and it is nice to see a bit of vulnerability with such a strong asari when it comes to romance. I still think she would have been better in ME3 as your replacement T.I.M and stayed at the Broker base in Hagalaz and fed us intel, freeing up the spot for another squad permie (if such a thing even exists) but regardless I'm excited to see where she leads us next.

Thane- His philosophies are unique and I enjoy his outlook on life. His mystic is matched by his charm and inner and outer manners, but his attitude is far from cold. I can actually see myself justifying some of his viewpoints and I believe that he is only trying to do good the best way he knows. And he suffers because of that. He is very useful as a crew member, I believe that he would pair up well with Kasumi for a stealth mission. Although he is the only one I can see during the suicide mission not having a clearly specific role...

Zaeed- Let's just say it. Zaeed is a badass. He's a knee-skinned, hard hitting sonofa**** and we all know it. You know it, I know it. What lacks in depth due to DLC status (which is not a character flaw, rather an unfortunate design decision) is made up for the fact that Zaeed is just freaking awesome. Shoot first, have a drink later, Zaeed is definitely a handy albeit less stable member of the group. But what craziness he brings seems to be slightly nullified by Jacob or Kaidan.

Jacob- He's a good man. I see him as just, stable and reliable more than boring. He has good morals, good virtues and a unique tie in to the game via Mass Effect Galaxy. I think his romance is sincere, loving and with a perfect hint of cheesy. He's a biotic brother who I need at my side and I am glad that I have a determined soldier in my squad for the upcoming battles. He does not get to have Kasumi or Miranda though. Okay... maybe on some playthroughs. SOME!

Jack- I believe Kasumi sums up Jack the best. "I know why Jack is the way she is. I don't like it, but i get it." Jack at first I love to hate. Then when I break her down she's someone I love to love. She's tortured, a badass, we get it. But it's that little girl vulnerability that scars her that really makes me go "wow... there are probably so many girls like her." But, you know... with less biotics and murderous intent.

Kaidan- Kaidan's a nice guy. I dig him, he's well-oiled and knowledgeable. He knows what a good person is and he's trying to bend his own definition to it. He's sturdy and a solid rock despite some childhood hardships. I don't dislike Kaidan at all, I adore the guy, but he is one of the last in the ME world. I am very excited to have him back in ME3 though. A game cannot go long without Mr. Alenko.

Morinth- I think she's awesome. She's interesting both due to her defect and personlity. She's alluring, psychotic, but sophisticated and carries herself with a strange form of dark grace. I love to hate the biatch, but she just has such a lack of content, even less than DLC's, which is a shame because she is such an interesting character. But unlike Jack, she is pure evil despite her ramblings. We just have to see what ME3 brings from Samara's mind twisting daughter.

Modifié par ilovemesometurian, 10 octobre 2011 - 05:26 .

[Sketchy77]

mineralica wrote...
Sketchy, may you please get out of docks properly next time?

erm....what?!?

[Eyerock]

I love'em all, but for the sake of posting something:
Tali
Mordin
Garrus
Zaeed
Grunt
Wrex
Ashley
Thane
Legion
Samara
Jacob
Jack
Kasumi
Miranda
Liara
Kaidan

[ReallyRue]

Legion
Wrex
Jack
Samara

Garrus
Ashley
Mordin
Kasumi
Zaeed

Liara
Tali
Thane
Kaidan
Jacob
Grunt
Morinth

Miranda

I don't actually dislike any of the characters other than Miranda. Although Morinth is a horrible person, I think she's an interesting character, whereas I don't find Miranda remotely interesting.
Edit: Forgot Grunt.

Modifié par ReallyRue, 10 octobre 2011 - 05:35 .

[Meldwyn301]

And this is why the ME series has so many fans. Enough characters and different personalities/story lines to make it both interesting and unique to every player. My list:

Favorites:
1. Ash (love her personality - tough and sassy - LI too - can't wait to rekindle the romance in ME3)
2. Garrus (can't ask for a better comrade)
3. Liara
4. Tali
5. Wrex/Grunt
....
Least favorite
1. Jack
2. Zaeed
3. Jacob

Enjoy but am ambivalent toward:
1. Miranda
2. Legion
3. Mordin
4. Samara
5. Thane

Wish he had more lines and dialogue: Joker!! (always makes me laugh)

[Darkstar Aurora]

Jack
Liara
Legion
Miranda
Wrex
Mordin
Samara
Thane
Tali
Kasumi
Garrus
James
Kaidan
Ashley
Grunt
Jacob
Zaeed
Morinth

[Jessihatt]

Love:
Garrus
Legion
Kaidan (LI)
Wrex
Mordin

Like:
Thane
Grunt
Jack
Miranda

Indifferent:
Kasumi
Ashley
Samara

Dislike:
Zaeed
Jacob
Morinth
Tali

Hate:
Liara

[StonedVolus]

Mordin
Tali
Garrus
Legion
Liara
Kasumi
Wrex
Thane
Zaeed
Samara
Jack
Jacob
Kaidan
Miranda
Ashley

[CptData]

I don't like to write down an entire list of "loved", "liked", "meh" and "disliked" characters with reasons why I have these feelings. Instead of, I'll write down my top 5.

Top 5.

#5 Anderson. Huh ... a non-squaddie or permanent Normandy crewmember here?
Right. I like Anderson. He's one of my fav characters, mostly because he comes with his own interesting past. Somehow I can imagine him as "the old Shepard" - not more, not less. Since he was the first candidate for a human Spectre (things got horrible wrong, so Shepard MADE it into the ranks of the Spectres), he must have been extraordinary soldier and/or tactician in the battlefield - an hero with the same reputition like Shepard when he became a candidate.
There's still fighting spirit in Anderson, and he seems to be more "badass" than you can see on first sight. Punching Udina or taking out C-Sec to allow Shepard to steal the Normandy is a glimpse - and we're going to see more of Anderson in ME3.

#4 Tali? Garrus? Miranda? Actually, I don't know. I have some candidates for #4. I think they all are interesting characters with more or less believeable flaws. Okay - Miranda doesn't fit the bill here - she's awesome, comes with great (maybe TOO great) looks, but also has some major flaws that kinda distract me from her. One flaw is her tendency to have "one night stands" - something I don't really like (actually, I dislike such tendency in general for men and women). I don't like the idea a "romantic relationship" with Miranda could end in another one night stand for her - so I hope ME3 will clear things up: Shepard should be the "big deal" for Miranda.
Tali comes without major flaws - except you don't like her inexperience when it comes to serious romantic stuff. She's one of my fav squaddies in combat and is usually paired up with either Ashley or Wrex (ME) or Garrus or Miranda (ME2). I see her as a very good friend I would go through hell just to save her.
Garrus is the third one that's on #4. He saw a lot of action in both ME, but a bit less in ME2 since I tend to play Infiltrator-Shepards. His biggest flaws is his tendency to go on vendettas and to repeat the same mistakes. It seems as if Garrus still needs someone to point the right direction for him - not a good trait for a leader. His combat skills are great, however.

#3 Joker. The best pilot of the Alliance - and a true friend.
There's not much to say about Joker. Everyone knows him and he got his fans. If everything goes wrong, you can count on Joker. If time is running out, he'll be there with the Normandy and pick you up. He did it often enough in both ME.
Besides that, I like Joker's sense of humor - it's pretty close to my own.

#2 Wrex. If I have to name any true brother in arms in ME, then I would call Wrex.
Wise, stoic, a true beacon in the battlefield. When not picking my fav #1 character for combat, I usually pick Wrex. It's kinda sad he's not part of your squad in ME2, I missed him much.
The Wrex doesn't come with much flaws or bad surprises. He wants to save his people, he's still hoping for a cure.
He also appears to be like an "old Krogan" with deep understanding of honor and esprit de corps - he's no stupid bully that wants to kill because his instincts demand it.

#1 Ashley. Every single m!Shepard ended with Ashley. It's not that I couldn't avoid her - I don't want.
Xenophobic? Not a bit. She's a realist. She doesn't trust anyone easily, and even less aliens she don't know well enough. At the end of ME she seems to trust Garrus and Tali, doesn't hold much grudge against her competitor for Shepard (Liara) and is also fine with Wrex - if he survived the incident on Virmire.
Religious Zealot? Negative. I know a lot of guys in R/L who fit the "religious zealot" type. Ash isn't like that. Actually, she never asked for Shepards religion, so I asume she doesn't care. Since I am an atheist, all my Shepards are atheists or agnostics as well.
I love her character since she comes with flaws - normal flaws - you don't have to save her from stuff of her past, you don't need to fix her in any way.

[SykoShadow]

In ME1 I liked them all alot, I would say Garrus and Wrex were my favorites and Ashley was my least favorite, but I enjoyed the interactions Shepard had with all of them.

In ME2, it goes a lil something like this:

Like:
-Garrus
-Tali
-Jacob
-Mordin
-Legion
-Grunt
-Kasumi

Neutral:
-Samara
-Miranda
-Jack

Dislike:
-Zaeed
-Thane

What can I say, I liked the majority of the cast. Garrus and Tali were old friends who got more interesting between games. Jacob is by far the only non-ME1 squadmate I could fully trust and just chill with, he's my natural choice to lead the second teams during the Suicide Mission, and I always felt like he had my back 100% while at the same time being unafraid to put me in my place if I stepped over the line, he was basically the Nightwing (NOT Robin) to my Shepard's Batman. Mordin is a genius, has great dialogue (especially his loyalty mission), and despite his past seemed like a good person. Legion brought whole new depth to the story of the geth, was an intriguing character, and my biggest complaint about ME2 overall is how late in the game he's introduced. Grunt is just awesome, I always wanted a pubescent krogan that just wants to kill stuff with you, no family drama or anything like that. Kasumi's loyalty mission is one of the most interesting ones (WHAT'S IN THE BOX?!), and her character was very likable.

Samara, Miranda and Jack are all ok, but that's about it. They're ok. I actually wish Jack was MORE over-the-top, she was kinda mellow to me. I was hoping for a true psychopathic madwoman.

Zaeed irritates me just because he's such an unpleasant jerk. Several BioWare characters have been jerks before, and it worked, but I just didn't think Zaeed worked for me, and my favorite moments with him are when Shepard knocks him down a peg or two in the loyalty mission. He's not extremely bad though, so to be more specific Zaeed would probably be inbetween Neutral and Dislike.

Thane is my least favorite squadmate for a few reasons, most notably his pseudo-spiritual "body and soul are separate" crap. I just didn't buy into the whole "I am the weapon, not the wielder" mentality he has, just felt like some cheap justification for his profession. It worked with HK-47 in KotOR because he's a droid with programming (plus HK admits to enjoying his job), not a living person with free will who doesn't enjoy his profession in the same sense as other assassins, organic or otherwise.

Other than that, he strikes me as a brooding badboy which I am not fond of at all, his loyalty quest and backstory all remind me too heavily of Carth Onasi (dead wife, sought revenge against people who killed wife, son falls into very bad crowd and becomes very thing father fears the most), his romance path is that bad kind of soap opera, the love scene especially, and the "be alive with me tonight" line with Shepard and Thane kissing while the camera spins around them felt like it came right out of a REALLY bad adult romance novel, it has my vote for "most cringe-worthy dialogue in a videogame romance."

[leggywillow]

Wheeee, just did this the other day.

Not including Zaeed or Kasumi (as per the OP's request), or Morinth because I never get her and thus don't know anything about her:

Love - These guys are my go-team for any given mission
1. Kaidan
2. Garrus
3. Miranda

Like -
4. Wrex
5. Mordin
6. Ashley
7. Legion

Okay -
8. Grunt
9. Jacob
10. Jack

Dislike -
11. Liara
12. Samara
13. Thane
14. Tali

[GMagnum]

GOD TIER:
-Garrus
-Miranda
-Tali

DEMIGOD TIER
-Wrex
-Grunt
-Jack
-Kasumi (woulda been god if u could romance her)
-Legion

THEY AIGHT TIER
-Liara
-Samara/Morinth

GO TO HELL TIER
-Ashley/Kaidan
-Thane
-Jacob
-Mordin
-Zaeed

if i forgot someone they're automatically sht tier cuz i woulda thought of them

Modifié par GMagnum, 10 octobre 2011 - 06:55 .