376 réponses à ce sujet

[Sonvega]

Kaidan
Wrex
Liara
Kasumi
Legion
Jack
Thane
Tali
Zaeed
Ashley
Garrus
Grunt
Miranda
Jacob
Samara
Mordin
Morinth

[albafica]

 Garrus
Ash (Rom paragon)
Wrex
Legion
Jack (Rom Renegade,only choosed her paragon answer for relationship)
Mordin
Tali
Miranda
Kasumi
Thane
Jacob
Morinth
Samara (didnt even bother with her once except her loyalty,never or will had her in my squad)
Kaidan (most boring and monotone chara in the ME)
Grunt (Wrex wannabe? no thx,Grunt sucks period)

[Zakatak757]

Corporal Jenkins and Wilson are by far the best squadmates.

STFU, people.

[DeadpoolBub]

 Love:

1. Wrex
2. Tali
3. Garrus
4. Zaeed
5. Grunt
6. Liara
7. Mordin
8. Legion

Like:

8. Thane
9. Jacob
10. Kaidan

Meh
11. Ashley
12. Miranda
13. Samara

Dislike
14. Jack

(Haven't downloaded Kasumi yet)

[dreamextractor]

1. Legion
2. Wrex
3. Garrus
4. Mordin
5. Thane
6. Kasumi
7. Ashley
8. Kaidan
9. Jack
10. Miranda
11. Grunt
12. Zaeed
13. Tali
14. Liara
15. Jacob
16. Samara
17. Morinth

1 being favorite & 17 being the least.

Modifié par dreamextractor, 11 octobre 2011 - 03:27 .

[Sketchy77]

AdmiralCheez wrote...

Screw you, OP, I'll include DLC characters if I want.

01. Wrex
02. Garrus
03. Mordin
04. Legion
05. Kasumi
06. Ashley
07. Thane
08. Samara
09. Jack
10. Tali
11. Liara
12. Miranda
13. Grunt
14. Kaidan
15. Jacob
16. Zaeed

Wrex, Garrus, Mordin, and Legion have always been my top four. I only recently came to really like Thane and Ashley. I actually like all of the characters, just some a lot more than others. It was really hard for me to list them because I like each one for different reasons.

Didn't list Morinth because I haven't recruited her yet.

No need to be a rude ****

Modifié par Sketchy77, 11 octobre 2011 - 05:36 .

[kyonkun]

Tali
Garrus
Ashley
Jacob
Mordin
Kaiden
Miranda
Legion
Liara
Thane
Samara
Grunt
Wrex
Jack

I did like or at least tolerate most of the characters however Jack I did not like in the least

[harktag]

1) Mordin - The very model of a Scientist Salarian! He is hilarious! Love his personality, his quirks, and the way he talks. And when you go through his loyalty mission, you get to see a totally different, more serious/deeper side to him. That was what impressed me the most.

2) Kasumi - She's petite, smart, and Japanese. What more do you need? Plus she has both my favorite companion power "Shadow Strike" and favorite loyalty mission (it was so uniqe compared to all the others).

3) Legion - He's a geth and a gamer! Love this character and I was sad that we got him so late in ME2.

4) James Vega - I know this is jumping the gun here, but I really am intrigued by James Vega's character - even long before people started to like him more since the Conviction comic. Admittedly, a lot of my positivity towards this character is because of the rumors of him finally being a same gender romance option for male Shepard. I hope somewhere inside the bulky and rough exterior is a good heart I can be happy to pair my male Shepard with.

5) Tali - She's just very cute and sweet. And I love her culture's back story.

6) Wrex - Like Tali and the Quarians, I really enjoyed learning about the krogans through Wrex. And considering how Wrex was probably the one squadmate from ME1 who seemed the most genuinely happy to see Shepard again definitely adds major brownie points.

7) Garrus - Garrus to me was just "okay." I mean he's cool and all, but nothing about him really made me excited about him. It was neat discovering that he was Archangel in ME2, though.

8) Liara - Like Garrus, I too found Liara to be for the most part "okay." The asari in general are interesting creatures, but I found other asari in the ME series to be far more interesting than her. It is cool when she becomes the new Shadow Broker though.

9) Thane - I really felt for Thane's back story. Even though I didn't particularly care for any of the romanceable males in ME2, Thane was the one I would have been most interested in pursuing.

10) Kaidan - Oh, Kaidan. Although he actually isn't my type physically, I found him to be the most appealing to romance in the Mass Effect series thus far. And admittedly, he now looks super hot in ME3. If he ends up being available for same-gender romance, he may trickle upwards in this list.

11) Grunt - Grunt to me didn't seem to be particularly more interesting than Wrex, but I loved his design. His blue features and eyes are hypnotizing to me. Dare I say, I found Grunt to be the most "attractive" krogan I've seen? (And now that I think of it, his voice is actually pretty sexy too.) Wow, listen to me! Best to move on now....

12) Miranda - I really did like Miranda a lot. I was sympathetic towards her past, and her accent really helped me warm up to her character (much like Leliana's did in DA:O).
 
13) Jacob - I've seen a lot of Jacob hate because they considered him to be a "boring" character. But he's a really nice guy, and for me, I'd much rather prefer a character to be "boring" but nice and relatable as opposed to interesting but a total $%#^& (*cough* Jack *cough*).

14) Ashley - I never understood why people keep playing the "racist" card on Ashley. There is a difference between a person who has not had as much exposure to certain people different from them (and are thus uncomfortable around them), as opposed to someone who downwright "hates" people who are different from them. I always considered Ashley to be the former. And I think many people have experienced the former within themselves too - more so than they may wish to admit. People also like to knock Ashley's religious faith. I think it's great that Mass Effect is mature enough to allow such themes into their games. I understand people's discomfort over it, but I think it makes Ashley's character more believeable and realistic.

15) Samara - She was kind of "meh" for me. It was interesting learning about Justicars and I was genuinely intrigued by her "family issues." But she just didn't interest me as much as those character above her.

16) Zaeed - Just didn't care for his personality at all, though I know he's got a lot of fans. The way he treated his bounty when you first meet him on Omega kind of turned me off from him right away. If it weren't for that as my first impression of him, I probably would have liked him a lot more.

17) Jack - I just can't stand the attitude. She had a cool intro cutscene, but after that, I really didn't like Jack at all mentally or physically. I am sympathetic to what was done to her, but that in of itself didn't allow me to completely overlook her less than redeeming qualities.

18) Morinth - I only had one playthrough where I actually chose her over Samara. She's got a neat "vampire" like quaity about her, but I guess since I didn't paritcularly care for Samara that much, I didn't particularly care much for her daughter either.

Modifié par harktag, 12 octobre 2011 - 04:44 .

[GodzillavsJason]

Awesome

Tali

Garrus (My bro)

Legion (My other bro)

Mordin

Kasumi

Grunt

Wrex

Like

Samara

Liara

Ashely

Neutral

Jacob

Thane

Morinth

Zaeed

Miranda

Hate

Kaidan

Jack

Modifié par GodzillavsJason, 15 octobre 2011 - 03:19 .

[Merlin 47]

Well....I like them all equally, except for one.

Dislike: Kaidan

....That is all.

[Milkies]

Ignoring the OP's "Not including Zaeed or Kasumi." Sorry.

Love:
1. Garrus - Always a part of my squad no matter what. I'm pretty sure that during his recruitment mission, had I not already known the identity of Archangel, I would have squealed like a child upon discovering it was him.
2. Kasumi - Love her character. I am extremely disappointed we didn't get to see more of her.
3. Tali - Tied with Kasumi for second place. Her story is intriguing, she's sweet and I can't get enough of her voice.

Like:
4. Legion
5. Liara - After playing LotSB, Liara got a whole lot more interesting to me.
6. Mordin
7. Samara

Neutral:
8. Miranda
9. Ashley
10. Wrex - I'm not a fan of Krogans in general, but Wrex is pretty great.
11. Kaidan - Nuked on Virmire. Sorry, bro.
12. Thane
13. Jack
14. Zaeed
15. Grunt 

Dislike:
16. Jacob - Not because he's boring, he is just very unlikeable.
17. Morinth - Only recruited her once in order to unlock Dominate. I find it impossible to choose her over Samara.

[yfullman]

Wrex
Kasumi
Legion
Mordin
Tali
Ashley
Jacob
Samara
Kaidan
Garrus
Grunt
Zaeed
Thane
Miranda
Morinth
Liara
Jack

[Esqudo]

1. Garrus...Was my bro in ME1 (dissapointed in the lack of interaction in ME2)
2. Liara...Real brainy and grounded, always enjoyable to have a Lisa Simpson around when traversing the traverse.
3. Grunt...Saved my ass countless times on Insanity, and has decent lines. Needs to read more Hemingway.
4. Jack... Ton of moments where you wish Shepard had a "STFU," interrupt, Still  found her the most interesting
5. Mordin...Best dialogue in the game.
6. Wrex...Like Sten from Origins, always refreshing to see a party member second guess the protagonist,or die trying.
7. Samara...What Thane was going for, but with fewer jarring cheese lines.
8.Legion...Because he's a pro
9. Jacob...Thought he was pretty flat at first, but the bro sessions after loyalty had me wanting to spill some drinks
10. Tali...Too rainbows and butterfly's, felt like I was being pushed into a pity date by everybody on the Normandy
11. Thane...Found the deadbeat monk dad to be too much, thought he could have been written more subtley.
12. Miranda...Boring as hell, felt like she was grasping at stigma straws
13. Kaidan/Ash...Kaidan is too archetypical of a good guy to be interesting, and Ashley is irritating as hell.
14. Morinth...Cheeseball Grand Champion, couldn't help but cringe everytime she spoke.

[Lotto]

Garrus
Wrex
Liara
Tali
Mordin
Legion
Ashley
Samara
Grunt
Miranda
Jacob
Thane
Jack
Kaidan
Morinth

[Darkfoxz87]

Like:
1.Garrus
2.Kasumi
3.Jacob
4.Legion
5.Grunt

Neutral:
The rest

[jake112296]

On the battle field best are
Legion
thane
garrus
Generally my favorite are
garrus
liara
mordin

[NeroSparda]

Wrex
Legion
Tali
Garrus
Kasumi
Zaeed
Thane
Grunt
Jack
Jacob
Samara
Miranda
Mordin
Liara
Morinth.
Kaidan
Ashley.

[frozn89]

ME1

Ashley
Tali
Wrex
Garrus
Liara
Kaidan

ME2

Miranda
Samara/Morinth
Garrus
Jacob
Grunt
Tali
Legion
Thane

Seeing how my canon Shep is an adept, my top two favorites are teammates that I find most useful. Ash and Tali in ME1 for combat and tech, Miranda and Samara in ME2 for well, pretty much the same.

Tbf you don't really need anyone else than Miranda as an Adept imo, you're pretty much unstoppable if you pick Enery Drain as your bonus power as well

[Geriond]

Legion
Kasumi
Zaeed

-
The others
-







Thane

[Xeranx]

Like:
    ME:
                 Ashley
                 Garrus
                 Tali

    ME2:
                 All of the above though they really screwed with Tali combat-wise and in terms of maturity. <_<
                 Morinth

Okay:
    ME (not exactly neutral, I could take them or leave them):
                 Wrex
                 Kaidan
                 
    ME2 (in order of most useful to me):
                 Zaeed
                 Legion
                 Kasumi
                 Grunt
                 Jack
                 Thane
                 Mordin
                 Jacob

Dislike:
     ME:
                 Liara

     ME2:
                 Liara (had no relevancy after Ilos)
                 Miranda (forgot to add this one)
                 Samara

Modifié par Xeranx, 17 octobre 2011 - 01:38 .

[Illeuad]

Kasumi Goto
Tali'Zorah vas Nomandy
Kaidan Alenko
Dr. Liara T'Soni
Garrus Vakarian
Morinth
Legion
Thane Krios
Ashley Williams
Jack
Mordin
Urdnot Wrex
Samara
Grunt
Zaeed Massani
Jacob Taylor

That was /really/ hard!! The only character I actually dislike for his personality, choices, etc. is Zaeed. He's a bastard. Jacob is actually quite likable, but... 

[Terraforming]

Too hard to leave Zaeed and Kasumi out - I just really like them both.
1. Mordin
2. Miranda
3. Samara
4. Zaeed
5. Liara
6. Wrex
7. Kasumi
8. Kaidan
9. Ashley
10. Tali
11. Garrus
12. Jack
13. Thane
14. Grunt
15. Legion
16. Morinth

Modifié par Terraforming, 17 octobre 2011 - 02:02 .

[sambshep]

I haven't played ME1, so my experience with certain characters may be somewhat lacking. I'm going to give my take on squadmates and non-squadmates alike based on their voice acting and storylines. 

Anderson: N/A

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline N/A
Comments: His role in ME2 isn't prominent enough for me to comfortably make a judgement about the character's storyline, but his voicework was very well done.

Ashley Williams/Kaidan Alenko: N/A

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline N/A

Liara T'Soni: 2.0

Voice Acting 2/5
Storyline 2/5
Comments: Her voice was too monotone, which made believing the serious and dramatic scenes far too difficult, and therefore ruined her storylines for me as well.

Joker: 3.0

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 2/5
Comments: While Joker does have more scenes than say Anderson, I feel that their approach to bring about said scenes was too unbelievable. Every squadmate leaves the Normandy...yeah, too farfetched for my taste.

Morinth/Samara: 3.0

Voice Acting 3/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: I rate these two together because of how intertwined their characters are with regards to the plot. Their voicework isn't all that special, and while their story is definitely interesting, at times it's a bit too obvious (chatting with Morinth in the club). The concept and history of Justicars are quite fascinating however.

Grunt: 3.0

Voice Acting 3/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: The voicework and storyline wasn't terrible, but nor was it spectacular. It definitely provided some additional insight into Krogan culture, but that's about it.  I wasn't all that surprised by the loyalty mission, it was quite stereotypical through and through.

Thane: 3.0

Voice Acting 3/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: The spiritual assassin concept isn't all that interesting, nor do I find the liklihood of there being a "spiritual" assassin all that surprising. My views on this character are a lot like my views on Grunt.

Jacob: 3.5

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: I didn't find all that much wrong with the voicework or storyline with regards to the character.  The loyalty mission didn't seem all that relevant given Jacob's dismissed attitude regarding his father (before, during, and after the loyalty mission) which took a lot of the importance out of it.

Miranda: 3.5

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: I haven't explored a romantic relationship with her yet, so I may be missing out on some context with regards to her story, but as it stands I feel that while it wasn't terribly written, it just doesn't seem to resonate very much with me.

Tali'Zorah nar Rayya: 3.5

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 3/5
Comments: Based on how her story progressed in ME2, I got the impression that she doesn't really matter. Firstly she is on missions that are said to be a waste of time, if not proven by her eagerness to join Shepard, add to the fact that when she was charged with treason that not even at her own trial is she the primary focus leads me to believe that her relevancy is diminished.  Her loyalty mission did have an interesting plot: choosing between what is fair for Tali, or what Tali wants (of course there is a third choice).

Kasumi: 4.0

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 4/5
Comments: The voicework for this character was very suiting, and I found her story to be quite interesting.

Urdnot Wrex: 4.0

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 4/5
Comments: The majority of my assessment stems primarily from my experience with the character in ME2. I find that while most Krogan are alike and share many similarities, Wrex is noticeably different and provides a unique outlet for the race of stereotypical warriors.

Legion: 4.0

Voice Acting 3/5
Storyline 5/5
Comments: The voicework wasn't too special, but it shouldn't be all things considered. The storyline on the otherhand was well written and despite the emotionless voice behind the character, the seriousness and complexities of the plot didn't suffer in the slightest.

Garrus Vakarian: 4.0

Voice Acting 4/5
Storyline 4/5
Comments: I think if there was more dialogue with Garrus in ME2 then the redundancies in a lot of what he says wouldn't stand out so much.  Based on videos I've seen of ME1 content, his character has developed quite a bit, but he is still just as impulsive and out for revenge as he seemed to be in ME1 (I'm hoping that changes with ME3). However, they do highlight this character flaw with his stories: his loyalty mission shows what could or couldn't happen if you don't think things through.

Zaeed: 4.5

Voice Acting 5/5
Storyline 4/5
Comments: The story for Zaeed was more than likely one of my favorites given the choices to be made and depth in which it gives to the character; the voicework was exceptional.

Jack: 5.0

Voice Acting 5/5
Storyline 5/5
Comments: The voicework covered everything from anger to emotional vulnerability, which I feel only further complimented the complex storyline.

Mordin: 5.0

Voice Acting 5/5
Storyline 5/5
Comments: By far the best story of all the characters, bar none. There is a depth to this character's story that very few of the other characters have, which says quite a lot given the fact that Mordin was introduced in ME2 and not ME1.  The voicework covers a wide range of emotions, none of which seem unbelievable, and all in all the quality of this character appears to be most evident than the rest.

Modifié par sambshep, 17 octobre 2011 - 05:25 .