193 réponses à ce sujet

[Zakatak757]

Hypothetical but impossible scenario. You can make up your own story as to how this happened, but that isn't really important. The point is that the Asari, Humans, and Turians have somehow gotten into a full-scale three-sided with one another. No outside influences, no alliances, no diplomacy, no rules but these rules.

Who would fair best? Consider everything. Turians have military strength and experience, and conscription is part of their culture. The Asari have top-of-the-line technology and impressive biotic powers. Humanity fights in unpredictable and very tactical ways.

The Alliance only have 3% of the population in the military, but I imagine when Earth is at risk, plenty are likely to join. Yes, we DID defeat the Turians in the FSW, but mainly because we were prepared for full-scale war. Use your judgment, consider all variables.

Modifié par Zakatak757, 30 octobre 2011 - 08:52 .

[onelifecrisis]

Zakatak757 wrote...

No outside influences, no alliances, no diplomacy, no rules.

Am I the only one that's a little confused by this?

[CptBomBom00]

Hell its easy enough, i say Volus.
nah joke I think humans as Liara said that we crush anyone in our way to get what we want.

[General User]

Conscription is part of human culture too. In Britain until the 1950s. The US didn't switch to an all-volunteer military until after Vietnam. Many nations still have some form of (mostly military) national service.

Modifié par General User, 30 octobre 2011 - 08:56 .

[Liec]

Humans win, because the other sides don't have a Commander Shepard.

[billy the squid]

Sheep, they look harmless, but that's what they want you to think.

[King Minos]

I don't know but if I was a world leader I won't hesitate to use chemical, biological or nuclear. No alien is going to kill my people and get away with it.

[Zakatak757]

King Minos wrote...

I don't know but if I was a world leader I won't hesitate to use chemical, biological or nuclear. No alien is going to kill my people and get away with it.

We should get the UNSC over here to help us out.

NOVA Bomb = man-made neutron star. That'll glass half of Palaven into a firey wasteland.

[atheelogos]

Turian would win hands down.

[Sajuro]

The Salarians would win, when all the sides wore each other down the Salarians would still be there strong as ever and ready to strike.

[Someone With Mass]

The Alliance and the turian military are out, because they both get their homeworlds overrun by the Reapers and I doubt the asari can do much on their own.

[billy the squid]

Turians. Their entire culture is based upon the military and everyone enlists, so no suprise that the have the largest fleet and military.
Considering their economy is far larger than the Alliance and they control client races like the Volus they can afford to fight it as well.

Their entire military doctrine is based on the concept of total war, paticularly as they deployed the genophage against an entire species after the Turians fought the Krogan to a stand still, and still didn't remove themselves from the conflict even after the Krogan dropped asteroids on 3 of their colonies.

As to the relay incident the Turians hadn't mobilized for a full scale war before the Council interviened. Although they were also leveling parts of the city from orbit, to eliminate Alliance soldiers on the ground, not subtle, but effective.

Whilst their not exactly stupid as they developed the Thanix Cannon, not Cerberus.

[mango smoothie]

         Humans would win hands down. Asari and Turians don't really think outside the box, and tend to stick to a certain type of position in battle. Because of this the council rely on each other, example Turians are front lines heavy type troops, Asari are Special Forces, and Salarians are intelligence.
         Humans are good at all those, and have divisions in all those aspects giving them more options. so the only way for the Turians or Asari to win would be if they joined together. Heck even if they did that Humanity would bring in their great diplomacy skills and get other races to join them.

Modifié par mango smoothie, 30 octobre 2011 - 09:47 .

[Zakatak757]

mango smoothie wrote...

         Humans would win hands down. Asari and Turians don't really think outside the box, and tend to stick to a certain type of position in battle. Because of this the council rely on each other, example Turians are front lines heavy type troops, Asari are Special Forces, and Salarians are intelligence.
         Humans are good at all those, and have divisions in all those aspects giving them more options. so the only way for the Turians or Asari to win would be if they joined together. Heck even if they did that Humanity would bring in their great diplomacy skills and get other races to join them.

Humans? Diplomacy? Lawl. Not our forte.

And I specifically said no outside interference. No other races. Even if I allowed it, the other races would join the Turians/Asari any other day of the week. The Volus are jealous of our rise to power because we did what they couldn't in 1/100th of the time, and are trade partners with the other 2. Nobody else gives a damn enough to help us.

[suprhomre]

Turians. Their culture is basicaly made for war kinna reminds of the old Sparta.

[alex90c]

suprhomre wrote...

Turians. Their culture is basicaly made for war kinna reminds of the old Sparta.

Actually if you read the codex, their culture is more akin to the Roman Empire.

[GMagnum]

asari cuz all dey gotta do is camp for 500 yrs and all da other races would die gg come again plz

[SandTrout]

Turians based pretty much of raw fleet size. After them, the Humans in ME seem the most military-inclined, with the Asari taking a distant 3rd. Their culture simply isn't set up to respond cohesively to a military threat.

[Jog0907]

turians but with some trouble, then humans because of what humanity can do with a war geared economy and last the asari in war all they have done is be cannon fodder until something like krogans or turians come and win the war

[Yezdigerd]

I'd say the Salarians. They won the Rachni war by drafting the Krogans, and defeated the Krogan rebellion with the genophage and despite this no one believes they are dangerous.

[Barquiel]

The turians would win a short war (fleet size), the asari would win a long war (economy and population numbers).