153 réponses à ce sujet

[Flashflame58]

Jack.

[Homebound]

When given a choice between Tali and option B, most BSN users will choose Tali 71.913% of the time even when the option to choose her doesnt make sense.

[PrinceLionheart]

Liara's is the lesser of two evils.

Dean_the_Young wrote...

Get a real woman (or man), not a girl tailor-made for geek-appeal.

Someone who isn't based around needing to be protected or 'fixed' in order to live a happy life.

The only MaleShep romance like that is Ashley's.

Modifié par PrinceLionheart, 18 novembre 2011 - 05:45 .

[Dariustwinblade]

@Hellbound555 there are a larger population of Mirandamancer,Liaramancer and Kaidanmancer than there are Talimancer.

Its just that those mancer are less loud.

[Tasha vas Nar Rayya]

You know what? Just bromance with Garrus.

[Ravensword]

Both.

[Comsky159]

PrinceLionheart wrote...

Liara's is the lesser of two evils.

Dean_the_Young wrote...

Get a real woman (or man), not a girl tailor-made for geek-appeal.

Someone who isn't based around needing to be protected or 'fixed' in order to live a happy life.

The only MaleShep romance like that is Ashley's.

There isn't a character not explicitly manufactured for geek appeal. You're kidding yourselves if you believe otherwise.

Dariustwinblade wrote...

@Hellbound555 there are a larger population of Mirandamancer,Liaramancer and Kaidanmancer than there are Talimancer.

Its just that those mancer are less loud.

Since I've been on the BSN those former three bases have seemed a lot more prominent actually.

Modifié par Comsky159, 18 novembre 2011 - 03:04 .

[Air36723]

I say, think about it for a bit, make a list if it helps. Why you like each of them, things you dont like about them, then compare and contrast them. No one answer is right for everyone, ask 5 people the question and get 5 different answers. Since your playing the shep, listen to your "heart and mind" pick who you like the best, take everything said here with a grain of salt, as we all have our personal favorites and will therefor be biased against those we see as "diminishing" our own personal choice, whether that be tali, liara, miranda, jack or ash in a MShep's case. Or do what a bunch of us do and do multiple play throughs with all LIs so you dont have to worry about choosing so much.

[PrinceLionheart]

Comsky159 wrote...
There isn't a character not explicitly manufactured for geek appeal. You're kidding yourselves if you believe otherwise.

Obviously there some sort of "geek appeal" in every romance, but no where in Ashley's romance did she ever come across as co-dependent on Shep or act like she was about to jump Shepard's bones. At least, no where in ME1.

[darthnick427]

Hey! I made this thread myself awhile back haha. I say 2 different playthroughs one romancing each. For my first import to ME3 tho I'm going with Liara. Tali will be second. And the love triangle between the two will be third

[DoNotIngest]

PrinceLionheart wrote...

Comsky159 wrote...
There isn't a character not explicitly manufactured for geek appeal. You're kidding yourselves if you believe otherwise.

Obviously there some sort of "geek appeal" in every romance, but no where in Ashley's romance did she ever come across as co-dependent on Shep or act like she was about to jump Shepard's bones. At least, no where in ME1.

She's also the first damsel in distress that Shepard in Shining Armour rescues in ME1.

[jlb524]

PrinceLionheart wrote...
Obviously there some sort of "geek appeal" in every romance, but no where in Ashley's romance did she ever come across as co-dependent on Shep or act like she was about to jump Shepard's bones. At least, no where in ME1.

I thought Ash was flirtier with Shepard than Liara was?

I don't really know...I don't play ManShep.  But that's what I've heard.

[Nightwriter]

Don't really understand how you can say Liara is co-dependent after playing LotSB. She has her own multi-billion dollar galaxy-spanning intelligence network, y'know.

And Tali is a strong spitfire who doesn't really need you either.

[Ariadnee]

Tasha vas Nar Rayya wrote...

You know what? Just bromance with Garrus.

I like this human. She understands! 

[Dariustwinblade]

PrinceLionheart wrote...

Comsky159 wrote...
There isn't a character not explicitly manufactured for geek appeal. You're kidding yourselves if you believe otherwise.

Obviously there some sort of "geek appeal" in every romance, but no where in Ashley's romance did she ever come across as co-dependent on Shep or act like she was about to jump Shepard's bones. At least, no where in ME1.

Shepard has to save Ashley's sorry ass THREE TIMES. That more than Liara.

She was a damsel in distress for three times in the game.


Liara's also saves Shepard twice! That more than anyone can say about themselves.

[vvDRUCILLAvv]

I agree with said comment above.

Modifié par vvDRUCILLAvv, 19 novembre 2011 - 07:43 .

[Someone With Mass]

Saphra Deden wrote...

Go with Liara. Tali is a hypocrite and a liar, and a little bit self-absorbed.

I personally find the person who's willing to sacrifice everything for the good of her people to be anything but self-absorbed.

Feel free to point out when and how she's a hypocrite too.

[Someone With Mass]

Because a character's views can never change or be altered because of emotional moments.

[Abrams216]

I say Liara. She can stop someone flat out in their tracks. Tali has a drone that gets destroyed in 2 seconds, then suffers a 30 second cooldown. The choice is obvious to me.

[Someone With Mass]

Saphra Deden wrote...

Someone With Mass wrote...

Because a character's views can never change or be altered because of emotional moments.

How did her view change? Her antagonism to Daro'Xen remains consistent even after she covers for her father.

Xen is crazy, that's why Tali is hostile towards her. Because Xen is jeopardizing a potential alliance between the quarians and the geth because she sees the geth as nothing but machines.

Tali simply got a moment to think over some things after the trial and then decided that she couldn't let the action of her father bring her down too. At the time, she wasn't really sure what was the right action.

When a character can shrug off anything without showing any sort of affection at the time or makes a jarring change (like how Liara went from a unsocial and somewhat insecure researcher to a top leveled information broker in less than two years) and then marks that as some form of character development, that's bad writing.