185 réponses à ce sujet

[CptData]

Trinity66 wrote...

Sorry for a bit off-topic maybe, but I just came to a conclusion.

Most people that loves Miranda hates or don't like Garrus, Liara and Tali. And vice versa.

And I bet a lot of them have never played ME1 or really don't like it either.

Uhh, not me. Miri, Tali, Garrus ... pretty much on the love/like level. Liara is a "like", not a "love", but that's because of taste and story telling reasons.

Just for the record. I just think liking Team Dextro and two awesome human ladies like Ashley and Miranda at the same time is possible

[Trinity66]

CptData wrote...

Trinity66 wrote...

Sorry for a bit off-topic maybe, but I just came to a conclusion.

Most people that loves Miranda hates or don't like Garrus, Liara and Tali. And vice versa.

And I bet a lot of them have never played ME1 or really don't like it either.

Uhh, not me. Miri, Tali, Garrus ... pretty much on the love/like level. Liara is a "like", not a "love", but that's because of taste and story telling reasons.

Just for the record. I just think liking Team Dextro and two awesome human ladies like Ashley and Miranda at the same time is possible

Well, of course it is possible, but not that common it seems.

[S.A.K]

Trinity66 wrote...

CptData wrote...

Trinity66 wrote...

Sorry for a bit off-topic maybe, but I just came to a conclusion.

Most people that loves Miranda hates or don't like Garrus, Liara and Tali. And vice versa.

And I bet a lot of them have never played ME1 or really don't like it either.

Uhh, not me. Miri, Tali, Garrus ... pretty much on the love/like level. Liara is a "like", not a "love", but that's because of taste and story telling reasons.

Just for the record. I just think liking Team Dextro and two awesome human ladies like Ashley and Miranda at the same time is possible

Well, of course it is possible, but not that common it seems.

I think Miri fans are just sad/mad about team dextro getting big roles and not Miranda. Dunno why team dextro fans hate Miri though. I love team dextro(points to my sig). I also like Miranda(not love). I think it depends on perspective.

[AresXX7]

Trinity66 wrote...

CptData wrote...

Trinity66 wrote...

Sorry for a bit off-topic maybe, but I just came to a conclusion.

Most people that loves Miranda hates or don't like Garrus, Liara and Tali. And vice versa.

And I bet a lot of them have never played ME1 or really don't like it either.

Uhh, not me. Miri, Tali, Garrus ... pretty much on the love/like level. Liara is a "like", not a "love", but that's because of taste and story telling reasons.

Just for the record. I just think liking Team Dextro and two awesome human ladies like Ashley and Miranda at the same time is possible

Well, of course it is possible, but not that common it seems.

I don't see why not, I like them all. Sure, there are some I like a little more, but I've never actually hated any of the squadmates.

Sometimes I think it stems from the squad interaction, in-game, that affects some fan's perception of certain characters. If a character has any animosity towards their favorite(s), they tend to react negatively towards that character, as if it were some personal attack against them as well.
Of course this isn't always the case, it might have more to do with that they don't care for the character's personality.

[Mathias]

1. Ashley
:wub:
2. Garrus
3. Wrex
4. Zaeed
B)
5. Liara
6. Miranda
7. Mordin
8. Grunt
:happy::happy:
9. Thane
10. Kaiden
^_^
11. Kasumi
12. Legion
13. Tali
:mellow:
14. Samara
15. Morinth
16. Jack
:sick:

Ash you're mai girl.
Garrus you're my bro.
Liara you're my favorite asari.
Tali you used to be cool, sorry fans ruined you.
Jack you too weird for me.

Modifié par Mdoggy1214, 08 décembre 2011 - 02:42 .

[JosephDucreux]

S.A.K wrote...

Trinity66 wrote...

CptData wrote...

Trinity66 wrote...

Sorry for a bit off-topic maybe, but I just came to a conclusion.

Most people that loves Miranda hates or don't like Garrus, Liara and Tali. And vice versa.

And I bet a lot of them have never played ME1 or really don't like it either.

Uhh, not me. Miri, Tali, Garrus ... pretty much on the love/like level. Liara is a "like", not a "love", but that's because of taste and story telling reasons.

Just for the record. I just think liking Team Dextro and two awesome human ladies like Ashley and Miranda at the same time is possible

Well, of course it is possible, but not that common it seems.

I think Miri fans are just sad/mad about team dextro getting big roles and not Miranda. Dunno why team dextro fans hate Miri though. I love team dextro(points to my sig). I also like Miranda(not love). I think it depends on perspective.

It is possible, but when jackasses like Quole come along...

I like Garrus, and used to like Tali. Until Bioware decided to ruin her in ME2. And I like just about everyone TBH.

@ SAK

We're not sad or mad, we're just doing this:

Modifié par JosephDucreux, 08 décembre 2011 - 02:47 .

[Trinity66]

S.A.K wrote...

I think Miri fans are just sad/mad about team dextro getting big roles and not Miranda. Dunno why team dextro fans hate Miri though. I love team dextro(points to my sig). I also like Miranda(not love). I think it depends on perspective.

This exactly. As for the other thing, I could list some points why I don't like her, but this is not the thread for it, nor I would like to start a fight. 

Modifié par Trinity66, 08 décembre 2011 - 03:29 .

[who would know]

ME2 did nothing but add character to Tali where there previously was none. But, I can understand not liking the way she was developed.

My favorites (as of ME2) are Mordin, Ashley, Zaeed, Kasumi, Miranda, and Morinth. I visit everybody, but I always look forward to visiting these characters.

I'm not particularly fond of the rest, but I don't hate them. It's more that I feel like their characters are any combination of flat, wildly inconsistent, or underwhelming. So they don't appeal as much.

[CptData]

who would know wrote...

ME2 did nothing but add character to Tali where there previously was none. But, I can understand not liking the way she was developed.

My favorites (as of ME2) are Mordin, Ashley, Zaeed, Kasumi, Miranda, and Morinth. I visit everybody, but I always look forward to visiting these characters.

I'm not particularly fond of the rest, but I don't hate them. It's more that I feel like their characters are any combination of flat, wildly inconsistent, or underwhelming. So they don't appeal as much.

Excactly. Tali got a better developed character in ME2. I liked her in ME1, but sometimes I had the feeling she was there to complete the set - and to act as an codex extension. In ME2 she matured a lot and actually acted on her own. She has interests and a past and seems to be a known specialist in a people full of engineers.
Also she seems to be a quite confident soldier.

Whatever - I like her in ME1 and I'm glad she got some development in ME2. I wonder how things turn out for her in ME3.

[Random citizen]

A list (most liked/loved) Liara, Tali Garrus.(Joker even though he is not in my squad)

B list (which I like much) Kaidan, Wrex, Mordin, Kasumi, Zaeed (strangely enough) Legion. (and EDI even though she is not in my squad) Jack (mostly because her character makes me feel sorry for her)

C list (which I like fine) Thane, Ash, Grunt, Samara, Miranda (after she warms up a bit otherwhise she is in the category below) Jacob.

D list (don't like) Morinth (interesting and tragic character, but creepy as hell)

Modifié par Random citizen, 08 décembre 2011 - 04:18 .

[vvDRUCILLAvv]

CptData wrote...

who would know wrote...

ME2 did nothing but add character to Tali where there previously was none. But, I can understand not liking the way she was developed.

My favorites (as of ME2) are Mordin, Ashley, Zaeed, Kasumi, Miranda, and Morinth. I visit everybody, but I always look forward to visiting these characters.

I'm not particularly fond of the rest, but I don't hate them. It's more that I feel like their characters are any combination of flat, wildly inconsistent, or underwhelming. So they don't appeal as much.

 In ME2 she matured a lot and actually acted on her own. She has interests and a past and seems to be a known specialist in a people full of engineers.
Also she seems to be a quite confident soldier.

She also acted as if she was PMSing the entire game. I've never seen such a snippity character.....well other than Miranda.