163 réponses à ce sujet

[Z-Dragon]

So it's supposed to be focused on a more intimate team from what Casey Hudson says, so maybe about 7 or 8 (before DLC characters)?  Just curious if anyone had come across any information on this yet.

Also, if Tali and/or Garrus died in ME2, does that mean their spots are just going to be vacant, or will there be others to replace them?  I only ask because if someone plays it with both of them dead, they're kinda getting the short end of the stick with fewer team members and a less in-depth party experience, which is what Mr. Hudson seems to want to focus on.

Oh, and guys, if it is only 7 or 8 guys, that means we only have about 3 reveals to go (depending on whether or not Tali is a temp member, as a certain DEV suggested to torture all of us)

[LGTX]

The leak suggests that's it's indeed around 7-8. I'm not sure.

And Tali and Garrus won't be replaced, sorry. You get the short end of the stick when you get someone killed, it's how it works

Modifié par LGTX, 23 décembre 2011 - 08:20 .

[shepskisaac]

LGTX wrote...
And Tali and Garrus won't be replaced, sorry. You get the short end of the stick when you get someone killed, it's how it works

And it just happens to be Tali & Garrus, and only them. Out of 13 possible ME2 squadmates. It's basically "you may kill everyone else, but if you dare to kill Tali & Garrus, you will have smaller squad as the punishement haha!". Yeahhh.

Modifié par IsaacShep, 23 décembre 2011 - 08:23 .

[LGTX]

IsaacShep wrote...

LGTX wrote...
And Tali and Garrus won't be replaced, sorry. You get the short end of the stick when you get someone killed, it's how it works

And it just happens to be Tali & Garrus, and only them. Out of 13 possible ME2 squadmates. It's basically "you may kill everyone else, but if you dare to kill Tali & Garrus, you will have smaller squad as the punishement". Yeahhh.

You seem upset. What are you suggesting as an alternative? Another ME2 clutter?

[crimzontearz]

I am glad they are punishing people who got people killed....because it really is no punishment at all

[DarthCaine]

There's 7

[shepskisaac]

LGTX wrote...
You seem upset. What are you suggesting as an alternative? Another ME2 clutter?

I would suggest selecting characters for ME3 squad that were in ME2 squad based on their importance, not popularity. Miranda, Legion, Mordin all make much more sense to be in the squad again instead of Garrus & Tali.

[LGTX]

IsaacShep wrote...

LGTX wrote...
You seem upset. What are you suggesting as an alternative? Another ME2 clutter?

I would suggest selecting characters for ME3 squad that were in ME2 squad based on their importance, not popularity. Miranda, Legion, Mordin all make much more sense to be in the squad again instead of Garrus & Tali.

"Making sense" in being a part of a squad during a complicated time of war is an evaluation we are in no position to deduce as of yet. I think you're about as equally correct here as the Garrus/Tali fans, no offence.

Modifié par LGTX, 23 décembre 2011 - 08:34 .

[Wulfram]

I do hope there's someone who can serve as a backup engineer, since Tali is fairly killable

[vvDRUCILLAvv]

IsaacShep wrote...

LGTX wrote...
And Tali and Garrus won't be replaced, sorry. You get the short end of the stick when you get someone killed, it's how it works

And it just happens to be Tali & Garrus, and only them. Out of 13 possible ME2 squadmates. It's basically "you may kill everyone else, but if you dare to kill Tali & Garrus, you will have smaller squad as the punishement haha!". Yeahhh.

Thats a bunch of crap! I resent having someone I can't stand (Tali) forced into my smaller limited squad base especially when there are other characters I would rather have instead. I never use her, never talk to her, she might as well be a paper weight or better yet a hull ornament. ''Suck on FTL speed you beotch!''. 

[Z-Dragon]

DarthCaine wrote...

There's 7

How do you know?

And if it's because of the demo, just say so and don't get to specific, please.

[shepskisaac]

Sofia Lamb wrote...

But those three characters are also hugely popular. Making your complaint boil down to "I do not like Tali and Garrus"

But they also happen to be very important, much more than Tali & Garrus. Legion knows & understands the Reapers more than anyone else. Miranda is a key figure in the organization that during ME2 was doing the most to stop the Reapers AND she's personally responsible for bringing Shep back to life, she knows the best Shep's current condition. Mordin is one of the central figures of the Turian/Salarian/Krogan conflict and he's a science expert which already proved extremly useful in uncovering Collector secrets and thus protecting Shep & the squad from Reaper forces. Not a coincidence you're strongly advised to recruit him first in ME2.

Modifié par IsaacShep, 23 décembre 2011 - 08:46 .

[MACharlie1]

IsaacShep wrote...

Sofia Lamb wrote...

But those three characters are also hugely popular. Making your complaint boil down to "I do not like Tali and Garrus"

But they also happen to be very important, much more than Tali & Garrus. Legion knows & understands the Reapers more than anyone else. Miranda is a key figure in the organization that during ME2 was doing the most to stop the Reapers AND she's personally responsible for bringing Shep back to life, she knows the best Shep's current condition. Mordin is one of the central figures of the Turian/Salarian/Krogan conflict and he's a science expert which already proved extremly useful in uncovering Collector secrets and thus protecting Shep & the squad from Reaper forces. Not a coincidence you're strongly advised to recruit him first in ME2.

...aren't these also the reasons why they shouldn't be squadmates? :innocent:

Tali and Garrus...aren't that important in terms of the Quarians and the Turians. Admiral Xen said that Tali was only connected because they wanted to use her to finally decide on the Geth problem. 

[LGTX]

IsaacShep wrote...

Sofia Lamb wrote...

But those three characters are also hugely popular. Making your complaint boil down to "I do not like Tali and Garrus"

But they also happen to be very important, much more than Tali & Garrus. Legion knows & understands the Reapers more than anyone else. Miranda is a key figure in the organization that during ME2 was doing the most to stop the Reapers AND she's personally responsible for bringing Shep back to life, she knows the best Shep's current condition. Mordin is one of the central figures of the Turian/Salarian/Krogan conflict and he's a science expert which already proved extremly useful in uncovering Collector secrets and thus protecting Shep & the squad from Reaper forces. Not a coincidence you're strongly advised to recruit him first in ME2.

I simply can't fathom how you can just... scoop up character priorities from ME2 and jam them into ME3 ignoring the little nuance which is the Galaxy waging an all-out war.

We do not know what the hell is going on. Legion might be needed for the geth because it knows so much. Miranda may be off to save her sister or sabotage Cerberus or enlist in an Alliance spy network or whatever in order to better aid the war effort, the way she sees it fit. And the arguments you provide on Mordin are basically begging to lock him away somewhere safe and not bring him on the frontlines at all. 

It's never that simple. ME3 is not ME2 where everyone is good at something and the story aligns prettily to accomodate them. It's a war, and hell knows what's going on, and who actually has the time and dedication to join Shepard, even as whole homeworlds burn and star systems are harvested.

Modifié par LGTX, 23 décembre 2011 - 08:53 .

[DonutsDealer]

IsaacShep wrote...

Sofia Lamb wrote...

But those three characters are also hugely popular. Making your complaint boil down to "I do not like Tali and Garrus"

But they also happen to be very important, much more than Tali & Garrus. Legion knows & understands the Reapers more than anyone else. Miranda is a key figure in the organization that during ME2 was doing the most to stop the Reapers AND she's personally responsible for bringing Shep back to life, she knows the best Shep's current condition. Mordin is one of the central figures of the Turian/Salarian/Krogan conflict and he's a science expert which already proved extremly useful in uncovering Collector secrets and thus protecting Shep & the squad from Reaper forces. Not a coincidence you're strongly advised to recruit him first in ME2.

Then let's replace Kaidan for one of those. Would you like that? 

[Aimi]

Wulfram wrote...

I do hope there's someone who can serve as a backup engineer, since Tali is fairly killable

There is.

[shepskisaac]

DonutsDealer wrote...

Then let's replace Kaidan for one of those. Would you like that?

A Spectre and an Alliance Major? I don't think so

LGTX wrote...

and who actually has the time and dedication to join Shepard, even as whole homeworlds burn and star systems are harvested.

Tali and Garrus as always