CenturyCrow wrote...
Yes, it's hard to pin down. Like it's missing a heart and soul, that extra dimension that keeps it from being flat. It's what gets left out or replaced with glitter, when the creator's try to 'improve' the next version.
I think what Nerdage said on the last page about it having the least interesting characters is a large part of the problem too. I never really seem to feel much connection to anyone or anything I'm doing; strong characters have never been Bethesda's strong suit, but in previous games they've been "good enough", whereas most of Skyrim's characters are instantly forgettable and mostly rather uncharismatic.
I'm inclined to agree with the "improvements" too: it would've been better had they made smaller, incremental improvements and fixed the stuff that people didn't like about previous games. Which they pretty much did in the latter regard by overhauling vanilla Oblivion's scaling and economics, but then it seems they kept on fiddling about with stuff, which is always fatal; I guess they ended up with the equivalent of DA2's "awesome button" instead of concentrating on things like immersion and atmosphere. And by "stuff" I don't just mean the visually-cool-but-awkward skills trees but also stuff like trying to make it feel more gritty and "grown up": I guess they succeeded, but in the process I think they lost more than they gained.
It's a pity because nebulous problems like this are harder to fix than the widely publicised faults of games like Oblivion: sure, that also had some artistic elements that some people didn't like and a few found the "mediaeval Europe" type setting a bit uninspired, but I think that's a more straightforward piece of subjectivity than whatever it is that's wrong with Skyrim; whereas its more widely criticised faults with gameplay mechanics such as the scaling and economics I mentioned were successfully overhauled by a number of different people.
Before it sounds like I'm being overly critical, I guess I feel the same way about Skyrim as I do about DA2: it's not
crap and actually I really rather enjoyed it, I just felt like it could've (should've?) been so much more.