234 réponses à ce sujet

[Storm Farron]

 there's one for JRPG's so why not for WRPG's

Favorite: Deus Ex: Human Revolution:
This game revied a dead franshise with he prefect mix of "action" gameplay and what most humans like to call "RPG elements" (aka weapon customization, dialog choices etc)

Hated: The Witcher 2:

The only game I consider worse than FFVII. everything about it was just bad. bad graphics, gameplay, characters, story. I sold that piece of **** after i finished it.

[Clover Rider]

 

[naughty99]

Favorite: Skyrim
I was initially expecting essentially Oblivion with more snow and some dragons, but the game far exceeded my wildest expectations. Most fun I've had in 20 - 30 years of gaming.

Hated: Gothic 4
It's a game with almost complete lack of freedom of choice for the player. There are lots of linear games like this, where you can't ignore the main quest to go off and do your own thing, in other words corridor, cut scene, fight, cut scene, etc. However, the cut scenes in this game are really bad, which makes it worse. Also, the enemy A.I. pathing is designed in a way where if you take two steps backward, the enemies stop attacking and wait for you to heal. Horribly written dialog and a story that makes absolutely no sense, combined with a railroading, anti-choice structure make for a perfect storm of "do not buy this game."

[I Ryukage I]

Don't have much experience with WRPGs,

Favorite: Fallout: New Vegas - just had much more story/side quest choices than I've ever played in a game before. All the characters felt like they had depth, and DLCs were pretty damn good and worth the money.

Skyrim I love for the exploration and Graphics... wish they would have taken notes from Obsidian from NV in terms of story and depth though. And then toss in both Dragon Age and Mass Effect Series, with the exception of DA2.

Worst/Hated - Two Worlds 2, Gothic 4. Two World's dialogue was pretty laughable, Gothic was cringeworthy (especially that damn witch) DA2, was just an average game, expected much more, pre-ordered signature edition and all

Modifié par I Ryukage I, 05 janvier 2012 - 05:22 .

[Eski.Moe]

Favourite - A toss up between Skyrim and the original Mass Effect.
Least Favourite - DA2. You see, I don't make a habit of buying terrible games or at least games that don't interest me. DA2 just falls down to the bottom of the pile when compared to all the other WRPGs that I've played extensively. I'd nominate Awakenings if I could instead but that hardly constitutes a full game.

[In Exile]

Favourite KoTOR

My first RPG. Brillaint game. Can't say enough about it.

Worst Icewind Dale

Nothing that I enjoy. The combination of a battle system based on D&D (ugh, I hate that ruleset, may it die a thousand deaths in fire), a party of automatons (this was the game that taught me I a create-your-own party game is even less enjoyable than a solo game for me). Just nothing redeeamble about it.

[DreamwareStudio]

Favorite: BG 2, the Witcher EE, or DA:O, too close to call (if not for those damn QTEs -- handled but hated them -- the Witcher 2 would be on this list)

Least: Gothic 4 or Dragon Age 2, take your pick.

[Rockworm503]

Dragon Age Origins. Skyrim is getting there and Fallout New Vegas is almost perfect IMO

I don't think I've played enough to have a hated but DA2 came close. Disappointed more than hated.

[Zanallen]

I am forced to agree with In Exile.

Favorite: KotOR

Worst: Icewind Dale

[DreamwareStudio]

Storm Farron wrote...

 there's one for JRPG's so why not for WRPG's

Favorite: Deus Ex: Human Revolution:
This game revied a dead franshise with he prefect mix of "action" gameplay and what most humans like to call "RPG elements" (aka weapon customization, dialog choices etc)

Hated: The Witcher 2:

The only game I consider worse than FFVII. everything about it was just bad. bad graphics, gameplay, characters, story. I sold that piece of **** after i finished it.

To each his own, but bad graphics w/ the Witcher 2?  I never thought I would see anyone type that.  I can understand the gameplay, however.  I was not a fan of the QTEs.

[Storm Farron]

google_calasade wrote...

Storm Farron wrote...

 there's one for JRPG's so why not for WRPG's

Favorite: Deus Ex: Human Revolution:
This game revied a dead franshise with he prefect mix of "action" gameplay and what most humans like to call "RPG elements" (aka weapon customization, dialog choices etc)

Hated: The Witcher 2:

The only game I consider worse than FFVII. everything about it was just bad. bad graphics, gameplay, characters, story. I sold that piece of **** after i finished it.

To each his own, but bad graphics w/ the Witcher 2?  I never thought I would see anyone type that.  I can understand the gameplay, however.  I was not a fan of the QTEs.

wasn't a big fan of the graphic style. 

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Most Favorite:


Least Favorite:



lol

[Savber100]

Storm Farron wrote...

The only game I consider worse than FFVII. everything about it was just bad. bad graphics, gameplay, characters, story. I sold that piece of **** after i finished it.

You lost me with "bad graphics"  

Everything else might be true in your tastes but graphics? The graphical fidelity in the Witcher 2 is top-notch unless you're talking aesthetic-wise. 

Anyways, 

Favorite: Knights of the Old Republic

Worst: Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion 

Skyrim was strangely enough really good (much to my surprise). :happy:

Modifié par Savber100, 05 janvier 2012 - 05:43 .

[Andarthiel_Demigod]

 Favourite
Really hard to choose but in the end I think Neverwinter Nights takes the cake. It was so amazing back in the day, the builds, the customization, the modules and custom content. So awesome.



Least Favourite:
Two Worlds- Just so bad. Everything was bad about this game: the voice acting, the plot, the characters,the combat.

[chrisuuuu]

Favorite: Planescape Torment or Ultima VI

Hated: Divinity 2: Ego Draconis

[Freddo]

Favorite:
VtM: Bloodlines - buggy unpolished game, but that doesn't matter cause the atmosphere, characters and story are all excellent. The gameplay is fun too despite it's quirks. I'm certain it's the WRPG I've played thru the most times, even if I spent more hours with TES2: Daggerfall. The Witcher and Jade Empire are excellent as well

Worst/Most Disliked:
Might and Magic IX - anyone who played it knows why, it was pretty much universally slammed. Lots of poor WRPGs were made in the 90s too, but meh.

[Ghost Lightning]

Favorite: KoTOR, ME2, or Skyrim. I can't choose.

Least: Fable 3

[slimgrin]

Favorite: BF3. Liked it for the original story.

Least favorite: Any Nintendo game.

Modifié par slimgrin, 05 janvier 2012 - 06:10 .

[Andarthiel_Demigod]

Kazutoyo wrote...

Favorite:
VtM: Bloodlines - buggy unpolished game, but that doesn't matter cause the atmosphere, characters and story are all excellent. The gameplay is fun too despite it's quirks. I'm certain it's the WRPG I've played thru the most times, even if I spent more hours with TES2: Daggerfall. The Witcher and Jade Empire are excellent as well

Damn, I forgot Bloodlines, this one def shares first place with NWN for me.

[Fidget6]

Favorite: Dragon Age: Origins

Least Favorite: Darkstone. So horrible. @_@

Modifié par Fidget6, 05 janvier 2012 - 06:27 .

[PsychoWARD23]

Wait, praising Deus Ex:HR for dialog choices, and bashing witcher 2's graphics? Ummm

[Dominus]

My favorite would be the original Mass Effect, with Neverwinter Nights as the Runner-up. Though keep in mind my experience with WRPGs is relatively limited compared to JRPGs.

A WRPG that needs to burn in the fires of mordor? Dragon Age 2. It wasn't a game without merit, but the lack of quality content among other issues left a bad taste in my mouth.

[milena87]

Favourite:
probably Mass Effect 1, with KotOR2 pretty close.
There are a lot of others I really liked (notably KotOR, Planescape: Torment, Bloodlines, NWN2, Ultima IX, DA:O/DA2), but the 2 I mentioned above have that special something that I can't really express

Hated:
nothing in particular, really. There were a lot of OKish games though (Fable 2, Oblivion, NWN single player and Gothic 3 with all the game-breaking bugs come to mind)

[horacethegrey]

Favorite: I like many of the RPG's I've played. But my faves can be boiled down to two:



Mass Effect 2 - It's the ultimate Space Opera RPG. A vast galaxy to explore with a rich history and populated by a diverse and interesting cast of characters. It also improves on many of the flaws of the first game in regards to gameplay and exploration. My favorite from Bioware.




The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Just so you know, I began playing this title as a fresh faced young noob. I'd never played any of the previous Elder Scrolls games, so I had no idea what I was getting myself into. But... WOW. This is the most expansive and dense RPG world I've ever had the pleasure to get myself lost in. Apologies to Bioware, but this is the real successor to Baldur's Gate and not Dragon Age. 

Hated: I can't honestly say I've played and RPG that I depised. I tend to avoid those. Maybe Icewind Dale 2 which frustrated the hell out of me? But I never finishing that one so maybe it doesn't count. I'd like to say Alpha Protocol but I quite liked the story and characters in that one, despite the crappy gameplay.