28 réponses à ce sujet

[magic space chicken]

im trying to pick who to romance, yes i know i can eomace liara in me1 and tali in me 2 but thats not im my sheppards way of life, and i know i can have two saves but i do not whant to do that

[Wtiger96]

Well if you really can't decide just flip a coin I did that for every choice in one of my playthroughs

[magic space chicken]

hmm.... any one have any thing to say to make it more easy to take a side?

[Donnstar]

Liara.

Once you become a talimancer you don't come back. I mean like ever. I'm pretty sure some genetic mutation happens the moment you begin to romance her. I don't know how else to explain their behaviour.

[Eclipse_9990]

Liara: She's mature, smart, cute, very loyal, and you know what you're getting into.

Tali: She's cute, smart, more innocent, very loyal, and if you like surprises she's perfect for you.

So in the long run it just comes down to preference.

Personally I prefer Liara, I used to like Tali the most, but after 2 years of growing up Tali just seems to... Little sistery for my tastes, not interested in romancing her anymore.

Donnstar wrote...

Liara.

Once you become a talimancer you don't come back. I mean like ever. I'm pretty sure some genetic mutation happens the moment you begin to romance her. I don't know how else to explain their behaviour.

I'm evidence to the contrary. I was a very dedicated Talimancer like a year or two ago, now I'm 21, and things are different... Very different. 

Modifié par Eclipse_9990, 07 janvier 2012 - 08:21 .

[JeffZero]

Of the two options I would say Tali'Zorah. I like her character arc more and I've always enjoyed Liara more as a close friend type.

[Donnstar]

Eclipse_9990 wrote...

Liara: She's mature, smart, cute, very loyal, and you know what you're getting into.

Tali: She's cute, smart, more innocent, very loyal, and if you like surprises she's perfect for you.

So in the long run it just comes down to preference.

Personally I prefer Liara, I used to like Tali the most, but after 2 years of growing up Tali just seems to... Little sistery for my tastes, not interested in romancing her anymore.

Donnstar wrote...

Liara.

Once you become a talimancer you don't come back. I mean like ever. I'm pretty sure some genetic mutation happens the moment you begin to romance her. I don't know how else to explain their behaviour.

I'm evidence to the contrary. I was a very dedicated Talimancer like a year or two ago, now I'm 21, and things are different... Very different. 

Right right right. 

I think not being a teenager is the natural cure for Taliucus.

Thats just speculation though. 

Modifié par Donnstar, 07 janvier 2012 - 08:36 .

[Dariustwinblade]

When I was 18 I didnt like Tali, I am 21 I still dont like her romance.

[Donnstar]

Dariustwinblade wrote...

When I was 18 I didnt like Tali, I am 21 I still dont like her romance.

Good. You must have a strong immune system. The weaker ones are always the most susceptible.


That's why there is a link between nutrients deficiency and Talimancers. According to the studies, atleast.

[Soviet Rei]

Neither.

Jack.

[CroGamer002]

Easy, Tali.

Though please make it more challenging to decide, next time.



Jacob or Liara, now that's very hard to decide.

[arne1234]

If you had to compare them I would say they are like lois lane and superman (At the start of ME2 you have to save her at freedom's progress from the mec, you them have to continue saving her at haelstrom and in her loyalty mission you have to defend her in her process, also at ME1 you have to save her from the shadow broker).
Liara on the other hand while still being very young basicly succeeds in everything she does she's a brilliant scientist, some sort of lawyer information broker she literary cannot die and as the shadow broker she has the ominpotence to know legions high score in online games and wether or not Tali has yet again upgraded her nerve stim programe.

So when your dating Tali you can be her superman, if you date Liara you're constantly reminded how unrealisticly great she really is.

[mineralica]

Wtiger96 wrote...

Well if you really can't decide just flip a coin I did that for every choice in one of my playthroughs

For every choice? Hm. Sounds like a plan. Thanks for idea

[Eclipse_9990]

arne1234 wrote...

Liara on the other hand while still being very young basicly succeeds in everything she does she's a brilliant scientist, some sort of lawyer information broker she literary cannot die and as the shadow broker she has the ominpotence to know legions high score in online games and wether or not Tali has yet again upgraded her nerve stim programe.

So when your dating Tali you can be her superman, if you date Liara you're constantly reminded how unrealisticly great she really is.

I've always had a thing for strong, smart, independent, and impressive women.

Modifié par Eclipse_9990, 07 janvier 2012 - 09:12 .

[Gallimatia]

If you are indifferent or close to indifferent when it comes to their personalities you should go for Liara because her biology is superior and more compatible with Shepard's. Only with Liara will you be able to share your meals, air and DNA.

[Dariustwinblade]

Don't forget about memories and mindsex.

[Yuqi]

Eclipse_9990 wrote...

Liara: She's mature, smart, cute, very loyal, and you know what you're getting into.

Tali: She's cute, smart, more innocent, very loyal, and if you like surprises she's perfect for you.

So in the long run it just comes down to preference.

Personally I prefer Liara, I used to like Tali the most, but after 2 years of growing up Tali just seems to... Little sistery for my tastes, not interested in romancing her anymore.

Donnstar wrote...

Liara.

Once you become a talimancer you don't come back. I mean like ever. I'm pretty sure some genetic mutation happens the moment you begin to romance her. I don't know how else to explain their behaviour.

I'm evidence to the contrary. I was a very dedicated Talimancer like a year or two ago, now I'm 21, and things are different... Very different. 

This^ When I was younger I would have gone for the Tali type. Thankfully when I found out about mass-effect I was older and wiser..

[arne1234]

Eclipse_9990 wrote...

arne1234 wrote...

Liara on the other hand while still being very young basicly succeeds in everything she does she's a brilliant scientist, some sort of lawyer information broker she literary cannot die and as the shadow broker she has the ominpotence to know legions high score in online games and wether or not Tali has yet again upgraded her nerve stim programe.

So when your dating Tali you can be her superman, if you date Liara you're constantly reminded how unrealisticly great she really is.

I've always had a thing for strong, smart, independent, and impressive women.

Offcourse but there are limits to what someone realisticly could achieve if you add up everything their is no reason to care for Liara I'm sure if you didn't bother recruiting Tali She died in haelstrom whill if you didn't play the shadowbroker Liara will have done so nicly alone by the time of ME3.

Then there are the more emotional scenes Both Tali and Liaravecome orphans and frankly Tali's reactions seem more genuin. Tali  VS Liara 
Personally I believe you're allowed to go snotty for 5 minutes when you discovered the remains of one of your parents, Liara's "mother" doesn't cut it for me altough to be fair Liara actually shot hers.
The point being Liara doesn't really need emotions because everything generally goes perfectly and is that is your thing...

[gearseffect]

Umm this is a no brianer for me Liara.
I've never liked Tali, and I've been on board since the first game. I was 17 when it came out and I back then I thought Tali was annoying, and Tali only seems to get more annoying. And Tali's Cult of annoying Tali Teli-Whackeros only make me hate her more. Tali acts like a cry baby spoiled daddies girl, and she just don't shut up. If I could kill a member of my crew in the game just for no reason on board the Normandy in front of every one I'd strangle Tali every time.

Now Liara on the other hand is intelligent, successful and powerful she can have an intelligent conversion, and from various sources (the novels, and game) Asari are great in the bedroom.

Not to mention Liara you can touch and see Liara with out worry about getting her sick. And her eyes they say it all.

If ya want your Shep to ride off and have the happy ever after ending
with Tali it'd be like this
Tali is covered from head to toe all the time, when ya wanna do her she gots to shoot up with god knows what and maybe you have to as well, she hasn't had much of an intelligent conversation imo. And she'd probally die after making love to her or sneezing on her or maybe eating your food (cause Quarians have to eat different food than everyone else or they die). oh also you'll probally end up financially supporting Tali and any other quiarions she wants ya to bale out

Now with Liara
You'll die before her, oh well, you can have kids with her and bonk her without having to worry about her getting sick, ya can eat the same food. and you'll both be capable of being supporting yourself financially, but if ya cheat on Liara she could kill ya rather easy.

Also with Liara your less likely to become a member of the Cult of Tali Teli-Whackeros I rest my case and hope this helps you make up your mind

[Eclipse_9990]

gearseffect wrote...

Umm this is a no brianer for me Liara.
I've never liked Tali, and I've been on board since the first game. I was 17 when it came out and I back then I thought Tali was annoying, and Tali only seems to get more annoying. And Tali's Cult of annoying Tali Teli-Whackeros only make me hate her more. Tali acts like a cry baby spoiled daddies girl, and she just don't shut up. If I could kill a member of my crew in the game just for no reason on board the Normandy in front of every one I'd strangle Tali every time.

Now Liara on the other hand is intelligent, successful and powerful she can have an intelligent conversion, and from various sources (the novels, and game) Asari are great in the bedroom.

Not to mention Liara you can touch and see Liara with out worry about getting her sick. And her eyes they say it all.

If ya want your Shep to ride off and have the happy ever after ending
with Tali it'd be like this
Tali is covered from head to toe all the time, when ya wanna do her she gots to shoot up with god knows what and maybe you have to as well, she hasn't had much of an intelligent conversation imo. And she'd probally die after making love to her or sneezing on her or maybe eating your food (cause Quarians have to eat different food than everyone else or they die). oh also you'll probally end up financially supporting Tali and any other quiarions she wants ya to bale out

Now with Liara
You'll die before her, oh well, you can have kids with her and bonk her without having to worry about her getting sick, ya can eat the same food. and you'll both be capable of being supporting yourself financially, but if ya cheat on Liara she could kill ya rather easy.

Also with Liara your less likely to become a member of the Cult of Tali Teli-Whackeros I rest my case and hope this helps you make up your mind

I agree with this. Except for the Tali thing; I actually find her personality endearing. Like a little sister. 

[darthnick427]

I have this problem myself. I'm just doing multiple playthroughs instead of choosing. However I am importing my Liara playthrough first since I stayed loyal on my first playthrough of ME2 (which was conveniently right when LotSB came out). My Tali playthrough will be second.

[Vilio1]

I prefer Liara's romance. The ME1 romance isn't great, but LOTSB Liara is leagues ahead of the rest, in my opinion. The way that Shepard and Liara can interact in ME2 is amazing.

[ThePuppetWithNoStrings]

While I do like Liara and Tali as characters, romance-wise I think you should choose Miranda or Jack. IMO, they're better written and have more depth to them and the romances are more believable. They feel like Shepard's "equals" - Miranda possibly moreso than Jack, but still. As I said, just my opinion and people are free to disagree, but I don't really want to get into a p1ssing contest about it. 

Between Liara or Tali, however, if Miranda and Jack really aren't your thing, then Liara. She went through hell to retrieve Shepard's body and that shows a lot of loyalty on her part. Tali's the "little sister" as others have said.

Modifié par ThePuppetWithNoStrings, 07 janvier 2012 - 09:59 .

[Eclipse_9990]

Arcian wrote...

This, of course, being the main gripe I have with her romance - it feels like taking advantage of someone immature who is in a position of dependency. Feelsbadman.jpg.

This is exactly how I see it as well.

When I started getting into the Mass Effect series again, and loaded up my old character I was like.. "What? She's like a little kid. Why the hell did I romance her again?" Then I started playing ME1 again and I was like.. "Damn.. I was crazy to romance anyone but Liara. I do not know what I was thinking."

Modifié par Eclipse_9990, 07 janvier 2012 - 10:03 .