Aller au contenu

Photo

Origin and Mass Effect 3


5521 réponses à ce sujet

#1201
anzolino

anzolino
  • Members
  • 1 070 messages
Wow. This is growing fast.

Incognito JC wrote...
A couple of things.

For those posters that aren't bothered to read through the thread or use their higher cognitive process before posting, many are against Origin, and NOT Steam, because Steam asks for permission to ransack your PC for data. Origin does it ANYWAY without asking. If you are even bothered to read through the thread, you would learn that people have done tests sometime ago and learnt that Origin goes through your private files on your PC, outside of the Origin program folder, via a process monitoring program.

For the more recent posts that Origin only scans its own folders, who is to say it won't scan others. It has been proven to do so before. And no, don't ask for image links. It has been posted on this thread, and you would have seen it if you bothered reading through.


For those people that said, "what's the big deal with privacy, you use sites such as Facebook, etc etc", here's the thing, YOU control what information you want to release to public on sites such as Facebook. And as a matter of fact, I don't use Facebook myself. I have an account, but it does not have my personal information. Just my name, and it's used just to keep in touch with people I know. I do not have the compulsion to show and tell the public everytime I take a photo of myself in the toilet, or everytime I drink a can of beer.


For those people who says, "you're a pirate so you don't want Origin scanning your files lool". What a load of bull. We care about what it scans because we might have important information on our PC. It is no secret that nowadays no major corporations can prevent their database from being hacked. With your logic, why don't you leave your house doors open, you have nothing to hide right? God forbid that you may have sensitive and/or banking information in your house. Just let strangers wander in anytime to take what they want. Because, hey, you have nothing to hide.


As for those ignorant enough to say we can opt out of sharing data on Origin; no we can't. Mr. Priestly's carefully worded post said that we can only opt out of ME3 data sharing, which, to be honest, I do not have a single issue with. Feel free to take my ME3 statistics, how I play the game and whatnot. Origin on the other hand, mines for data that are, bluntly put, none of their damn business.


For those who said, "what's the big deal, switch to console". Not all PC gamers have console. Most PC gamers choose the PC because they do not like playing on consoles. Switching would mean paying more for the console itself, and paying more for games, because PC games are still cheaper. In ME3's case, I CAN'T switch. I have a PS3, but my ME1/ME2 saves are for the PC.


Again, I've said it countless times, and I'm not the only one; DRM do not prevent piracy, it promotes piracy. Pirates will do what they do best, and excel at it. It's us as the paying consumers that gets harmed. A CD check is more than enough, because ME2 was great with just that.

Many of you do forget that, it's our own money that comes out of the pocket to pay for the game. We should not have to pay for a product and go through all the trouble to make our gaming experience more pleasant. If Origin really does prove itself to not be a spyware like so many
claims it to be, then good, I may be able to play a great game after
all.

Lastly, if you do not have problems with Origin, or if you do not play on the PC, good for you, refrain from posting in here. This news does not concern you whatsoever. All you do is bait arguments.

We should repeat the complete post on every single page here. Thanks for making clear, Incognito.
Edit: I'm the lucky first, so here is the complete post :)

Can we please stop this Steam crying? That would be nice. It's about Origin.

casadechrisso wrote...
If you want EA to listen to us and stop forcing Origin on us, all your sandboxing or pirating+buying or other ways to prevent Origin from actually running on your comp won't help the cause at all. EA will only see "ah, they buy so they accept it". If you want EA to stop forcing stuff on you, the only way is sadly not buying at all (or get the console version if you must).
Also, I simply refuse to go through all the trouble setting up a sandbox for Origin or whatever, I mean, how much of a sick addict am I? No way, no money from me before I start stuff like that.
And even if I won't ever promote or support that, but if EA really doesn't see how many potential customers they turn into pirates this way simply because it's the only way they get a hassle-free gaming experience... how dumb are they? To me this only proves again that piracy can't be the issue and reason they force Origin on us, because it must be clear to them that the result is the opposite.
Who knows, maybe catching pirates has become the better business than legal sales by now, a new business model?

Yes, sometimes it seems they are going into this. However, well said.


Has anyone ever thought about this:
The EULA was changed (multiple times now), the client software was changed - from "oh, it's always Windows function fault and not our fault" (I always wonder how they get MS changed Windows that fast and deliver it to me altough my Windows wasn't updated) to "nothing happened out of Origin folder" (despite the IE folder and the Setup.exe).
Fine. But now there are differences between the German EULA and the English EULA. The second one still contains these software/software usage crap. Right? The German one doesn't, a result of some official commissions work. So, now we have the EA statement:
"EA knows that you care how information about you is collected, used and shared, and we appreciate your trust that we will do so carefully and sensibly... blafasel"
Uhm, what? In Germany it means: no software, no software usage. In the rest of the world it means: software, software usage.
Two regions, two behaviours. And exactly this makes me angry. They don't care! If they would they would change all EULAs and not only a country specific one! EA only cares if EA get threatened by the officials (i.e. court)! This isn't honest to the customer. This is "We do what we want until someone forced us to stop it".

It means you cannot use Origin anonymous? Because in this case EA cannot seperate the two regions. They have to know where you come from for the seperation. IPs can be anonymized, so even if you are in Germany you can have an IP from France or Spain whatever. And then? Software and software usage? Great deal.

Modifié par anzolino, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:30 .


#1202
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 427 messages

MassStorm wrote...

IsaacShep wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

If Origin takes off I wonder how long it'll take the other big name companies to start their own Steam/Origins.

How fun it will be to have a different DD service necessary for each big name gaming company. Yay.

Precisely. We'll end up with DD client from every publisher. AND, they will all sell their games only on their platforms. If people don't realize what it means when a publisher is the only source to buy a product, they should just look at BioWare points. You can only buy them digitally from EA which surprise surprise, is the reason why they never bar once (and only in US and most likely due to an error) went on sale. Welcome to the future of overpriced & overcomplicated gaming. Go Origin lovers!


So then let's defend Steam the monopolist....i want more competition not less


I'm not defending Steam. **** I think it was pretty horrible when they started as well.

No BOXED copy bought in a store should require a DD service to be downloaded. None.

It's ridculous.

I *tolerated* it when it was one company. But more than that hell no.

And if you think that'll lead to more competition? :lol: It'll just lead to all the big names forcing their DD services down their customers throat and not allowing their games to be bought on any other one.

...though this might be a good thing because it will lead to a crash because people will get tired of it. 1 or 2 additional (and bloatware) might be excusable. 10+ though? Nah.

Modifié par Ryzaki, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:30 .


#1203
Fraevar

Fraevar
  • Members
  • 1 439 messages
The infamous word 'piracy' will appear in this post, so I will make a disclaimer up front that this post in no way endorses any such activity by anyone, but merely seeks to illustrate a rather negative side effects for a large part of legitimate ME1, ME2 and it would seem ME3 PC owners.

BioWare games have always had a loyal modding community on PC even as the games themselves have become more and more walled off with BioWare's move to consoles. In fact I think it's fair to say that a large amount of the exceptional fan works we have could not have occurred if not for people modding and tinkering with the files in both games. Videos from sagequeen and Aislinn Trista - excellent works of art, simply could not have come into being without flycam, slowmo and all the other commands edited back in by the PC modding community.

Another aspect to consider is that the majority of modding on ME and ME2 centers around textures. Upscaling the low-res textures of ME2, ELE08's excellent femShep textures etc. All of which requires TexMod - a tiny (legal) program - that you have launch the MassEffect.exe or MassEffect2.exe file instead of doing so directly or through the launcher.

Here is what this mandatory Origin inclusion does. It turns all the people who does these things into criminals. Literally. As of this moment, no breach of any copy protection has been needed to get any of these mods to work. With Origin, it very well would be necessary in order to get any mods working. I am stunned that this has apparently not factored into the BioWare decision process at all here, as people who are very attached to their Commander Shepards, now won't be able to play them because they used mods, which will now require them to bypass the DRM of Origin to get their ME3 experience. These are also not irrelevant mods, they're projects which enhance the presentation of the games they are designed for, like eliminating the terrible texture discrepancies on characters from the neck down in ME2, to fixing a long-standing bug that BioWare never bothered to fix (Garrus' low-res face) in ME1. These are not irrelevant projects, they are things which enrich and enhance the game and actually mean a great deal to people.

With this decision BioWare is essentially slapping their entire modding community in the face as well as telling them to abandon all their work or be confined to the "piracy/criminal" label forever. It shows incredibly poor judgment, and I am sorry to say, will drive people to seek ways bypassing the Origin DRM, people who had no intention or need of doing so in the past.

Origin was stripped from Battlefield 3 by one of the major scene release groups, the same thing will happen with ME3. The ball is in BioWare's court now as to how many of its loyal PC customers they send into the arms of those release groups just to be able to keep playing their TexModded Shepard.

#1204
MassStorm

MassStorm
  • Members
  • 955 messages
sorry wrong thread

Modifié par MassStorm, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:29 .


#1205
_Infiltrator

_Infiltrator
  • Members
  • 145 messages
GG Bioware.

I own ME1, ME2, Dragon Age, Baldur's Gate 1&2, IWD 1&2, NWN 1&2, most of the expansions for every one of them, but I am NOT going to buy ME3. Not with this pathetic origin and your disgusting accusations on steam. Restrictive rules? I guess that's why EVERYONE but EA just LOOOOVES steam.

No buy for me. It's gonna be AAAAAAAAAAAARGHHHHHHHHHHHH MATEYS!!!!

Modifié par Infiltrator, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:29 .


#1206
Weiser_Cain

Weiser_Cain
  • Members
  • 1 945 messages

jamskinner wrote...

Just run the dang thing on another installed partition if you are so worried about EA looking at all your pirated games.

If I was a pirate I wouldn't care, they'll get around this while we're screwed.

#1207
Lux

Lux
  • Members
  • 765 messages

wolfsite wrote...

ETermin wrote...

Aeowyn wrote...

TerminatorT1994 wrote...

Did I miss something? Why is Orgin the Satan of gaming? It's exactly like Steam with a different layout and skin. It also has faster downloads speeds from what I've experienced. If you resort to pirating because of a digital download service, you should probably dismantle your entire computer and sell your parts to people who are more intelligent than you. Then you should probably use that money you made to buy a console that uses more than 7 year old tech as Origin is apparently the Satan of gaming. It's pretty funny actually, if EA made Origin before Steam, you would be all be saying Steam is too intrusive or you hate it because it's required for Valve games. So many hypocrites in gaming communities these days.

I've been using Origin for ages and even long before it was even renamed to Origin. Haven't had any distinct problems with it at all. I think it's just blind hate for EA as a company, anything they do is followed up by idiots with grudges against them.


I suggest you search for the old Origin thread....


there is one of them in my sig. dating about 5 months ago


A lot has changed in 5 months making that thread a poor place to go for information.


Here's an interesting read: be careful with what you say.

#1208
Pupuppu

Pupuppu
  • Members
  • 140 messages

MassStorm wrote...

So then let's defend Steam the monopolist....i want more competition not less


So why defend Origin the monopolist for ME3?

#1209
Killjoy Cutter

Killjoy Cutter
  • Members
  • 6 005 messages
What the hell was wrong with buying a disk, taking the disk home, installing the game, and using a CD Key, and a one-time, in-game validation of that Key?  

What the hell was wrong with buying DLC, manually downloading an installation file directly from the website, installing it,  and then having a one-time, in-game validation of that DLC? 

Why the hell does everything have to be automatic, hand-delivered, monitored, faux-"convenient", etc, and so on? 

I don't want your "helpful" Origin software, EA.  I don't need it.  It does nothing for me. 


At this point, I don't care how they change Origin, I'll never install it, and I'll never use it, and EA is never going to see a dime from me for a game that requires it.

Modifié par Killjoy Cutter, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:33 .


#1210
El Neebre

El Neebre
  • Members
  • 25 messages
http://img703.images...uninstalled.jpg

Thanks EA, thanks.

#1211
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 427 messages

Killjoy Cutter wrote...

What the hell was wrong with buying a disk, taking the disk home, installing the game, and using a CD Key, and a one-time, in-game validation of that Key?  

What the hell was wrong with buying DLC, manually downloading an installation file directly from the website, installing it,  and then having a one-time, in-game validation of that DLC? 

Why the hell does everything have to be automatic, hand-delivered, monitored, faux-"convenient", etc, and so on? 

I don't want your "helpful" Origin software, EA.  I don't need it.  It does nothing for me. 



And yet again. Agreed. :wizard:

I buy my damn games from the store.

A DD service does NOTHING for me but take up resources on my comp that I can be using playing the damn game.

#1212
GirlPower23

GirlPower23
  • Members
  • 112 messages

MassStorm wrote...

So then let's defend Steam the monopolist....i want more competition not less


First off you have no idea what a Monopoly is if you are calling Steam a monopoly. Secondly, when EA restricts games from other Services there is no competition. So your hope for more competition is moot. EA Games has a long way to go before they are competition. They need to be less restrictive, make a service on par with Steam, need to be more community oriented. Need a helluva  a lot bigger catalogue.. unfortunately EA Games has yet to do any of this so people are not going to accept Origin. EA Games has been failing with this service since 2005 with EA Downloader. 

EA Games has also created a very negative Stigma over the years with gamers. A stigma that won't ever go away until they show they do care about their customers and stop pulling bull**** out of their asses.

Modifié par GirlPower23, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:34 .


#1213
Hathur

Hathur
  • Members
  • 2 841 messages
EDIT Sigh, nevermind, I've no desire to get mixed up / contribute to this mess.

Modifié par Hathur, 14 janvier 2012 - 03:36 .


#1214
Mister Mida

Mister Mida
  • Members
  • 3 239 messages

Infiltrator wrote...

GG Bioware.

I own ME1, ME2, Dragon Age, Baldur's Gate 1&2, IWD 1&2, NWN 1&2, most of the expansions for every one of them, but I am NOT going to buy ME3. Not with this pathetic origin and your disgusting accusations on steam. Restrictive rules? I guess that's why EVERYONE but EA just LOOOOVES steam.

No buy for me. It's gonna be AAAAAAAAAAAARGHHHHHHHHHHHH MATEYS!!!!

Not everyone loves Steam, and if that 'argh' means what I think it means, thanks for showing that by the corporations' logic, these kind of actions are needed.

#1215
MassStorm

MassStorm
  • Members
  • 955 messages

Ryzaki wrote...

I'm not defending Steam. **** I think it was pretty horrible when they started as well.

No BOXED copy bought in a store should require a DD service to be downloaded. None.


If this was the rule then i would agree with you but it appears it is not. Valve is doing money from DD services and you cannot blame EA for starting competition in a profitable market.

#1216
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

MassStorm wrote...

So then let's defend Steam the monopolist....i want more competition not less

There are many other independent DD services, all growing their market share.

#1217
wolfsite

wolfsite
  • Members
  • 5 780 messages

Infiltrator wrote...

GG Bioware.

I own ME1, ME2, Dragon Age, Baldur's Gate 1&2, IWD 1&2, NWN 1&2, most of the expansions for every one of them, but I am NOT going to buy ME3. Not with this pathetic origin and your disgusting accusations on steam. Restrictive rules? I guess that's why EVERYONE but EA just LOOOOVES steam.

No buy for me. It's gonna be AAAAAAAAAAAARGHHHHHHHHHHHH MATEYS!!!!


I just love how people have the EA/Steam things completely wrong in every respect despite all information available stating that EA would like to put games on Steam it is just Valve's stance on DLC preventing it

www.giantbomb.com/news/crysis-2-was-removed-from-steam-over-dlc-distribution-deal/3399/


Even Notch has some problems with it notch.tumblr.com/post/9550850116/why-no-steam-notch

#1218
Killjoy Cutter

Killjoy Cutter
  • Members
  • 6 005 messages
EA is the same company that wrangled an exclusive years-long deal from the NFL, meaning that only EA can use anything related to the NFL in a game, quashing all other NFL-based games for the foreseeable future.

Never mistake EA for a company that wants anything other than complete and exclusive control over all the content it can get its hands on.

#1219
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 427 messages

MassStorm wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

I'm not defending Steam. **** I think it was pretty horrible when they started as well.

No BOXED copy bought in a store should require a DD service to be downloaded. None.


If this was the rule then i would agree with you but it appears it is not. Valve is doing money from DD services and you cannot blame EA for starting competition in a profitable market.


When did I say I was blaming EA for *starting* competition?

I'm blaming them for wasting more resources on my damn comp on another damn service I don't need or want.

Just like I blamed Steam. Didn't work and this might not work either but hey. I tried.

That said if this does become the norm and every big publisher makes their own exclusive DD service I at least won't have to worry about Steam for much longer. They'll more than likely cause each other to crash.

#1220
wolfsite

wolfsite
  • Members
  • 5 780 messages

Killjoy Cutter wrote...

EA is the same company that wrangled an exclusive years-long deal from the NFL, meaning that only EA can use anything related to the NFL in a game, quashing all other NFL-based games for the foreseeable future.

Never mistake EA for a company that wants anything other than complete and exclusive control over all the content it can get its hands on.


................. ya It's safe to say this thread has run it's course, the Soapboxes are starting to get pulled out.

#1221
MassStorm

MassStorm
  • Members
  • 955 messages

GirlPower23 wrote...

MassStorm wrote...

So then let's defend Steam the monopolist....i want more competition not less


First off you have no idea what a Monopoly is if you are calling Steam a monopoly. Secondly, when EA restricts games from other Services there is no competition. So your hope for more competition is moot. EA Games has a long way to go before they are competition. They need to be less restrictive, make a service on par with Steam, need to be more community oriented. Need a helluva  a lot bigger catalogue.. unfortunately EA Games has yet to do any of this before anyone will blink in their direction. EA Games has been failing with this service since 2005 with EA Downloader. 

EA Games has also created a very negative Stigma over the years with gamers. A stigma that won't ever go away until they show they do care about their customers and stop pulling bull**** out of their asses.


Well i know perfectly what a monopoly is and you are biased. Valve restricts his games from other services if i HAVE to install Steam to play Skyrim. Restrictive EA? And what about the freaking REGIONAL LOCKS Steam games have??? Please stop being a Valve sucker......

#1222
Gamerpru

Gamerpru
  • Members
  • 65 messages

Remus Artega wrote...

IsaacShep wrote...

Gamerpru wrote...

I can garantee you, that you will need to boot ME3 via Origin every time, just like they did with BF3. Even if you were to double click on the ME3.exe in you folder it will still first boot up origin, even for the SP part of the game. MARK MY WORDS

Appreciate your take on this, but I want direct official answers.

You know you can run BF3 SP in offline mode do you? So there is no reason for ME3 SP to work otherwise


funny. When I go to battlelog and press SP, origin starts. If I double click the extension, origin also starts.

#1223
Ahglock

Ahglock
  • Members
  • 3 660 messages
Ah well no ME3 for me. They probably lost me as a customer, though maybe they will come to their senses at some point.

#1224
Killjoy Cutter

Killjoy Cutter
  • Members
  • 6 005 messages

Fredvdp wrote...

I've also monitored its datamining recently. I was one of the people shouting spyware, but it scans almost nothing now. Mainly files in the EA folder.


The EULA / ToS make it clear that they reserve the "right" to change Origin's behavior at any moment, with no notice.

Facebook's long history of behavior in this regard is a good example of how things will go. 

#1225
Killjoy Cutter

Killjoy Cutter
  • Members
  • 6 005 messages

wolfsite wrote...

Killjoy Cutter wrote...

EA is the same company that wrangled an exclusive years-long deal from the NFL, meaning that only EA can use anything related to the NFL in a game, quashing all other NFL-based games for the foreseeable future.

Never mistake EA for a company that wants anything other than complete and exclusive control over all the content it can get its hands on.


................. ya It's safe to say this thread has run it's course, the Soapboxes are starting to get pulled out.


What in the post you quoted is not true?