Aller au contenu

Photo

Origin and Mass Effect 3


5521 réponses à ce sujet

#1951
anzolino

anzolino
  • Members
  • 1 070 messages

crimzontearz
Chris asked someone to prove them that origin is basically spyware and scansall sort of things it should not, Anzolino. That was done on page 2 by several users. Also he was asked if origin could be removed after the first validation for offline play

Has he answered?

If it's true that Chris read all in this and earlier threads then he has already noticed the proof weeks ago. I always reported the results here (in the locked threads), he didn't have to ask, if he read this.
He didn't notice the corrected German documents URL too (on Friday), so I think he is too busy or what else, weekend. Doesn't matter.


StarcloudSWG wrote...
This is evasion. Why does Origin demonstrably create, pack up, encrypt, and send over a megabyte worth of information to EA? What's in that packet? What's it sending?

Sorry Starcloud, but I have a lot of questions here:
To which IP the data were send? To the IPs in Seattle over this nsesrvr Port 9988? Were the data stored on the HDD before they were send? How big is the data stream? Which folders Origin access while the creating/packing process?
I know there is a second traffic over port 443 for the login. Did you see another traffic over this port?

Modifié par anzolino, 14 janvier 2012 - 10:15 .


#1952
photographerleia

photographerleia
  • Members
  • 102 messages

Mass Effect Player wrote...

Brockololly wrote...

Mass Effect Player wrote...

I'm really surprised that the whole internet isn't in rage. Meaning this isn't on other websites. Probably safe, the internet would EXPLODE.


Give it time. There's likely a reason they only announced this on a Friday evening/afternoon, hoping it wouldn't get big exposure  due to the weekend.


I even expected facebook and twitter to have a response. We all know how those unregulated people are.

I've already read it on gamebanshee.  I passed the news on, as soon as I found out, through facebook and many of those friends have passed it on since.  Just give it time.

#1953
GirlPower23

GirlPower23
  • Members
  • 112 messages

OmegaBlue0231 wrote...


In the US the PC preorder sales are 72k and the 360 sales are 450k. Even the PS3 has better preorder numbers.

Source: http://www.vgchartz.com/preorders//


Unfortunately I wish this were true. However, vgChartz can only track Physical Purchases. They do not and cannot list Digital Purchases so the numbers are going to be skewed when it comes to charts like this. However it's unlikely that PC Sales are outselling the Xbox just because ME is primarily a console game.

#1954
aridor1570

aridor1570
  • Members
  • 1 063 messages

photographerleia wrote...

Mass Effect Player wrote...

Brockololly wrote...

Mass Effect Player wrote...

I'm really surprised that the whole internet isn't in rage. Meaning this isn't on other websites. Probably safe, the internet would EXPLODE.


Give it time. There's likely a reason they only announced this on a Friday evening/afternoon, hoping it wouldn't get big exposure  due to the weekend.


I even expected facebook and twitter to have a response. We all know how those unregulated people are.

I've already read it on gamebanshee.  I passed the news on, as soon as I found out, through facebook and many of those friends have passed it on since.  Just give it time.


The news hit Kotaku, just so you know.

#1955
Metallisika

Metallisika
  • Members
  • 186 messages

During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a
number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this
time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which
limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and
other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to
players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase
or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service
that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our
consumers.


Am I the only one who sees how ****ing ironic this is?

#1956
Mike Shepard

Mike Shepard
  • Members
  • 1 667 messages

Metallisika wrote...

During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a
number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this
time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which
limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and
other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to
players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase
or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service
that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our
consumers.


Am I the only one who sees how ****ing ironic this is?


Posted Image

#1957
mcneil_1

mcneil_1
  • Members
  • 678 messages

Metallisika wrote...

During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a
number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this
time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which
limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and
other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to
players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase
or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service
that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our
consumers.


Am I the only one who sees how ****ing ironic this is?

Nope, quite a few folks have noticed and commented on it as well.

#1958
Pixieking

Pixieking
  • Members
  • 447 messages

Sgt Stryker wrote...

Relix28 wrote...

pc.ign.com/articles/121/1216562p1.html

This was rather fast. IGN just published the article on the subject. However, I think the first sentance in the last paragraph is slightly misleading.

"Priestly confirmed that players will be able to opt out of data collection, and refuted a question about Origin being spyware."

Why wouldn't it be misleading? IGN is a gaming journalism site, is it not?


Not very good journalism. Though, if you want my opnion, there's very little "good" gaming journalism out there, full stop.

#1959
crimzontearz

crimzontearz
  • Members
  • 16 789 messages
Again....this comes from someone who has TWO digital countdowns to ME3, one on my PC and one on my tablet. Tablet PC and phone ME bacgrounds, bought ME1, 2 and ME3 N7 edition paid in full, all possible DLC, all the comibooks and even avatar armor and the Mako prop......Mass effect is by FAR the series I have loved and played the most EVER....overall the series that all other series have ro measure up to for me

but come the **** on Bioware.

And then people go around saying EA did not corupt Bioware....yeah right

Modifié par crimzontearz, 14 janvier 2012 - 10:24 .


#1960
Zannana

Zannana
  • Members
  • 168 messages
I think that we should react actively(those of us that do not want Origin) to this decision and massively cancel our preorders. I am doing that either way but it would be nice to get the point across by demonstrating some solidarity.

#1961
Metallisika

Metallisika
  • Members
  • 186 messages

mcneil_1 wrote...
]Nope, quite a few folks have noticed and commented on it as well.



Figured.

I admit I didn't bother with reading the whole thread.

#1962
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

Incognito JC wrote...

For those posters that aren't bothered to read through the thread or use their higher cognitive process before posting, many are against Origin, and NOT Steam, because Steam asks for permission to ransack your PC for data. Origin does it ANYWAY without asking. If you are even bothered to read through the thread, you would learn that people have done tests sometime ago and learnt that Origin goes through your private files on your PC, outside of the Origin program folder, via a process monitoring program.


Used to, months ago it does not now. I gave evidence of this which is contrary to that many months old beta version of Origin tested. The newer version does not. You also do give persmission via the accepting terms when installing both game and client which then also as stated on first page has an opt out option. how far that opt out goes is open to interpretation right now because the first page did not word it the best way could to explain it.


For the more recent posts that Origin only scans its own folders, who is to say it won't scan others. It has been proven to do so before. And no, don't ask for image links. It has been posted on this thread, and you would have seen it if you bothered reading through.


I have already answered that when someone made the comparrison between Valves rules on privacy and EAs version of privacy terms. The difference is same between "what you think they might do" and "what they actually do". This line of thought borders fear mongering.

For those people who says, "you're a pirate so you don't want Origin scanning your files lool". What a load of bull. We care about what it scans because we might have important information on our PC. It is no secret that nowadays no major corporations can prevent their database from being hacked. With your logic, why don't you leave your house doors open, you have nothing to hide right? God forbid that you may have sensitive and/or banking information in your house. Just let strangers wander in anytime to take what they want. Because, hey, you have nothing to hide.


A hacker can target you just like those corporations. The difference is minimal unless you have two machines one online one no internet at all which someone already suggested else your never going to be secure and your privacy will always without fail be at risk if your computer is connected to the internet at all even with a million firewalls. Most of this is going again by the assumption that they might start trying to look at such things as bank statements which as already said is not what they are doing and not what they are going to do and also on their EULA right now says only scans the game and client folders and maybe system specifications is listed there as might look at. Most of the people raging are going on out of date EUALs and out of date client and out of date PR phrases where all have since pretty much been changed and contradict the earliest aspects people originally were upset about the most.

As for those ignorant enough to say we can opt out of sharing data on Origin; no we can't. Mr. Priestly's carefully worded post said that we can only opt out of ME3 data sharing, which, to be honest, I do not have a single issue with. Feel free to take my ME3 statistics, how I play the game and whatnot. Origin on the other hand, mines for data that are, bluntly put, none of their damn business.


On this you may be semi-right dependent on if he said what he mean't or if he did not explain it well. But in the end I have shown what it looks at and that is relating to the game not your bank statements and personal information. Could the EULA be worded better, maybe but the latest EULA I read actually stated they only look at game folders and files and system specs and they did not say will be looking at your bank statements or your personal information. The EULA which did have that bad wording was old and has been changed long ago. Just like the evidence of the early version of the client is not what the client does now and new evidence showed this.

Now if you don't like debating with people or do not like to debate with people of opposing views then your not doing anything more than raging and raging on its own is not that constructive. The alternative is maybe you only wish to talk to those who hold the very same view as you in which case stop replying to me when I post something you do not agree with. 

The not on steam aspect I can understand frustration for those.People have a preference for where they buy their games this is fully reasonable and slight surprise it is not on there but I believe it will in time be added to steam after initial release on origin so that initial increase in sales go direct without dilution of profit but then opening up to other sources to then maximise that profit. They don't have to share profit if host themselves on own client hence initial hosting then opening out to others will build on it. They do not lose money by not hosting it on steam (if) at some point it is released on steam as well. They do lose money if they never let steam host it but thats unlikely. 

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 14 janvier 2012 - 10:30 .


#1963
Pixieking

Pixieking
  • Members
  • 447 messages

Metallisika wrote...

During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a
number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this
time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which
limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and
other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to
players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase
or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service
that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our
consumers.


Am I the only one who sees how ****ing ironic this is?


Definitely not the only one. And quoting For Truth. :lol:

#1964
RoseLegion

RoseLegion
  • Members
  • 72 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

Below are answers to the most commonly asked questions about Origin and Mass Effect 3. Thank you for your patience as we have worked to answer them.

1) Will Origin be a requirement to play all versions of Mass Effect 3? (Digital and/or from a retail brick and mortar store)
Yes, Origin is required for all PC editions of Mass Effect 3, physical or digital.

2) Is constant Origin connection required or is it a single one off authentication when the game is first installed. Is there also a limit to the number of installations available?
Mass Effect 3 will require a one time, single authorization for the single player game. There is no limit to the number of installs. Playing Mass Effect 3 Multiplayer will require a constant connection.

3) Is Origin required for the retail versions of the game?
Origin is required for the PC versions of Mass Effect 3, both physical and digital.

4) Will ME3 be available on Steam?
During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our consumers.

5) Is there an opt in or opt out clause for data collection? 
Users will be allowed to opt-out of Mass Effect 3 data collection from inside the game.

6) I’ve seen reports that Origin is spyware.  Is this true?
Origin is not spyware, and does not use or install spyware on user’s machines.  In order to allow Origin to install games and their patches for everyone to use, Origin implements a permission change that results in Windows, not Origin, reviewing the filenames in the ProgramData/Origin folder.   This is an ordinary Windows function, not an information-gathering process. 

7) Has the Origin EULA been updated following recent questions in Germany?
The German Origin EULA has been updated.  For more information, please review the Origin EULA here: http://www.ea.com/1/product-eulas.

8) Is there a double-opt in for Mass Effect 3 marketing emails for German residents?
Yes, we always adhere to the German requirement of a double opt-in standard for marketing emails.  Mass Effect 3 users must opt-in twice to receive these emails.


I appreciate everyone's patience on this topic. Please continue to ask questions about Mass Effect 3 and Origin and I will continue to try to get the answers for you.




:devil:


Thank you for the update, as always information is greatly appruciated.  Also in this case it is also apprciated that the information has been provided in time for me to cancle my ME3 pre-order.  As, having tried Origin for other products I find that it does not meet my needs as a consumer.  I find that it, just like steam, cuases preformance and other technical issues related to the smooth and stable running of games and appliations on my system. 
While I appruciate EA developing their own digital distribution method, and offering products via digital distribution the move to require this client for all versions is one that I do not support.  A service provider should not be in the business of limiting purchase options.  It is a pity that this forced move will mark the end of my enjoyment of the Mass Effect seires, perhaps in time a version will be released without this burdensom requirement until that time (if it ever comes) I will simply have to forgo my purches in this arena. :(

~Legion

Addendum: This is a universal stance, I will not purchase any product that requires use of a digital client for a physical game to function.  I have purchased two copies of almost everything bioware has ever released and all the DLC to go with it.  I usually purchase the collectors editions and almost always pre-order.  I even follow the series enough to the point of making sure I get all the tiny promo items like those from Dr. Pepper et al.  I own 2 PCs 2 laptops 2 PS3s and an xBox 360 all of which I've been buying bioware products for.  I will not be purchasing any title, on any platform, that contains forced requirements for Origin.  (i.e. yes I could buy them for PS3 or xBox 360 and not have to use the client but I simply will not support a forced requirement business modle).
I support gamers having the option for digital distribution however I will contribute no purchases to any titles/series that force a digital client on gamers.

Modifié par RoseLegion, 14 janvier 2012 - 10:41 .


#1965
Incognito JC

Incognito JC
  • Members
  • 693 messages
Dragoonlordz wrote...

Used to, months ago it does not now. I gave evidence of this which is contrary to that many months old beta version of Origin tested. The newer version does not. You also do give persmission via the accepting terms when installing both game and client which then also as stated on first page has an opt out option.


No, it's an opt out option for ME3's data, not the general data mining Origin does.


I have already answered that when someone made the comparrison between Valves rules on privacy and EAs version of privacy terms. The difference is same between "what you think they might do" and "what they actually do". This line of thought borders fear mongering.

Being cautious is not fear mongering. Better safe than sorry.


A hacker can target you just like those corporations. The difference is minimal unless you have two machines one online one no internet at all which someone already suggested else your never going to be secure and your privacy will always without fail be at risk if your computer is connected to the internet at all even with a million firewalls. Most of this is going again by the assumption that they might start trying to look at such things as bank statements which as already said is not what they are doing and not what they are going to do and also on their EULA right now says only scans the game and client folders and maybe system specifications is listed there as might look at. Most of the people raging are going on out of date EUALs and out of date client and out of date PR phrases where all have since pretty much been changed and contradict the earliest aspects people originally were upset about the most.


No, chances of a hacker to target a random individual is significantly lower than hackers targetting a big corporation, as proven in the past year or so.


On this you may be semi-right dependent on if he said what he mean't or if he did not explain it well. But in the end I have shown what it looks at and that is relating to the game not your bank statements and personal information. Could the EULA be worded better, maybe but the latest EULA I read actually stated they only look at game folders and files and system specs and they did not say will be looking at your bank statements or your personal information. The EULA which did have that bad wording was old and has been changed long ago. Just like the evidence of the early version of the client is not what the client does now and new evidence showed this.


Again, better save than sorry. He purposely worded it that way to evade the data mining in question. Or perhaps he genuinely mistaken what people are saying. Then again, it's pretty hard to have mistaken which data we're talking about.


Now if you don't like debating with people or do not like to debate with people of opposing views then your not doing anything more than raging and raging on its own is not that constructive. The alternative is maybe you only wish to talk to those who hold the very same view as you in which case stop replying to me when I post something you do not agree with. 

Debating is not my hobby. Apparently it's yours. You just argue for the sake of argument. I tell you a point or two in a civil manner, and you go all out and going off topic at that.

#1966
Relix28

Relix28
  • Members
  • 2 679 messages

Metallisika wrote...

During initial release Mass Effect 3 will be available on Origin and a
number of other 3rd party digital retailers, but not on Steam at this
time. Steam has adopted a set of restrictive terms of service which
limit how developers interact with customers to deliver patches and
other downloadable content.  We are intent on providing Mass Effect to
players with the best possible experience no matter where they purchase
or play their game, and are happy to partner with any download service
that does not restrict our ability to connect directly with our
consumers.


Am I the only one who sees how ****ing ironic this is?


I understand what they were trying to say with this, but yeah, it's irony at it's finest. :lol:

#1967
FlotsamX

FlotsamX
  • Members
  • 1 messages
I'm out. Might as well delete my ME2 save now.

#1968
hangmans tree

hangmans tree
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages
The thing with DRM and customers is like a sunday's mass. The people who attend get scolded by the preacher for not going to church... oh the irony...

BTW
Talking about piracy and pirating the game only gives giants like EA more ammo and they shut their ears to arguments. Please refrain from this approach.

#1969
anzolino

anzolino
  • Members
  • 1 070 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...
...
A hacker can target you just like those corporations.

Because a hacker also doesn't offer opt-out options? What logic is that?
I can protect me against hackers, but I cannot protect me against a software I have to open the firewall for and I have to let it sends data. It's completely different!

Modifié par anzolino, 14 janvier 2012 - 10:38 .


#1970
_aD

_aD
  • Members
  • 1 messages
I'm now forced to abandon my principles or be allowed to finish the fantastic and engrossing story of Mass Effect.

I will not be abandoning my principles so will not be purchasing this game.

#1971
Severyx

Severyx
  • Members
  • 1 609 messages
The funny thing is that 80% of the people complaining about Origin are going to buy ME3 anyways, whether they want to let the public know or not.

Origin hasn't really bothered me much. I installed it for Battlefield 3, and while it does get in the way and provide a nearly useless platform, it hasn't directly interfered with my BF3 experience. I just shut it off when I'm done playing. The biggest problem I have with Origin is the fact that it is extremely inconvenient to the player. Now I have to juggle Steam and Origin when playing my favorite games, which is just irritating more than disabling.

Personally, I have a hard time believing the PR-speak of rules and restrictions that Steam has. It is certainly (and probably likely) possible that Steam did enact new rules, but EA is the only major company having issues with it enough to say "Nevar!", and the timing was just a bit too convenient. I mean, come on - only after Origin's launch did all this become a serious problem. Call me a conspiracy theorist if you want, but I'm aware of EA's past.

I don't blame BioWare for any of this (which a lot of misdirected anger seems to be aimed at), it wasn't their call. Regardless, things like this whole Origin deal is only furthering the public's perception of EA's draconian hold over developers. Whether or not this is true is no longer relevant. . . Players now believe this to be the case and EA should be (and more than likely is) thinking about how to react.

In the end, I just want to see Origin games back on Steam for the purposes of player convenience. I'll be research this 'Rules and restrictions' issue more in depth to better understand what's really going on and continue to watch all this. Regardless, ME3 collector's edition is still going to be MINE. ALL MINE. :D

#1972
Epic Legion

Epic Legion
  • Members
  • 485 messages
EA still lies about Steam "restrictions". Good enough reason for me to cancel my pre-order.

#1973
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages
[quote]Incognito JC wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...

I have already answered that when someone made the comparrison between Valves rules on privacy and EAs version of privacy terms. The difference is same between "what you think they might do" and "what they actually do". This line of thought borders fear mongering.
[/quote]

Being cautious is not fear mongering. Better safe than sorry.
[/quote]

Which isn't completley wrong however there is the difference between people who say "it might do x or y" and those who say it "will do x or y". But in the end the new EULA states what it will look at and that is game files and folders and system specs, that is what it might do unless they change the EULA again. The old EULA you were right in that is did not specify with enough clarity and opened up can of worms of just how much would look at being dubious. The "will do x or y" is fear mongering. The "might do x or y" is cautious imho.

[quote]
No, chances of a hacker to target a random individual is significantly lower than hackers targetting a big corporation, as proven in the past year or so.
[/quote]

You said you have a PS3, how much information did you put into that and your PSN account including purchses of products. Facebook, Bioware/BSN site sign up information, Kotaku? Steam? Local government? Any other forums or gaming sites or blogs? Who do you use for email.. Hotmail? All these places already have your information and all at some point or another has been hacked by someone. In the end the ultimate version of privacy will be to not connect to the internet at all. 

#1974
ShaneP

ShaneP
  • Members
  • 213 messages
Just a question to those of you claiming that Origin and Steam cause performance issues... Seriously? are you running PC's from 2002 or something? BF3 plays smooth as butter on my (admittedly pretty powerful) rig at 1080p on Ultra, so do all of the games that I own on steam (as they did on my previous hardware). You'd have to have a pretty pants PC to have it impacted in a serious way by Origin and Steam :/

#1975
Metallisika

Metallisika
  • Members
  • 186 messages

Severyx wrote...

The funny thing is that 80% of the people complaining about Origin are going to buy ME3 anyways, whether they want to let the public know or not.


Hahaha, no. They'll just pirate it.