Aller au contenu

Photo

Origin and Mass Effect 3


3659 réponses à ce sujet

#1551
Rudy Lis

Rudy Lis
  • Members
  • 2 097 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...

I'm sorry to hear that, mine doesn't seem to have that problem and works even if I uplug my internet cable though.


Mine worked too. Until you exit game or you got CtD and you try to run game again. No link - no work. Also, it doesn't start in offline. Ever.

tishyw wrote...

You see, now that's why I'd like dev confirmation for these questions rather than other forumites opinions on what the devs are saying.


Agree. Only they turn "ignore mode" on it seems.

Modifié par Rudy Lis, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:21 .


#1552
Sgt Stryker

Sgt Stryker
  • Members
  • 2 590 messages
It seems my question has been buried by pages of new posts, so I will ask once again. With a couple more, of course.

Mr. Priestly, what is the nature of the data gathered by Origin? Are the allegations that it scans the entire contents of peoples' hard drives true? If so, what use could having this information possibly serve for EA?

#1553
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

Pupuppu wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...

Rudy Lis wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...

2. You can play offline after activation. This was answered too, do not need to be connected to play but do need to activate one time online. 


You can. Only you cannot. First, Origin, unlike Steam, don't know "and stay offline" command. Or know, but do not obey. And, if it will crash (happens every 30-60 minutes in DA2 with me) - it will need to take a lea... To catch some breath online. Otherwise it refuse to rerun DA2. Maybe it's just me and my Origin, I don't know.


I'm sorry to hear that, mine doesn't seem to have that problem and works even if I uplug my internet cable though.


So your Origin client stays offline until you tell him to go online? The one i took a look at does not really wants to remember what it's been told to do.


In my example I unplugged my internet cable and could play fine. The epitome of "offline". I used ME2 and Origin to test and started the game offline rather than unplugged after loaded.

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:24 .


#1554
Zkyire

Zkyire
  • Members
  • 3 449 messages

tishyw wrote...

Rudy Lis wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...

2. You can play offline after activation. This was answered too, do not need to be connected to play but do need to activate one time online. 


You can. Only you cannot. First, Origin, unlike Steam, don't know "and stay offline" command. Or know, but do not obey. And, if it will crash (happens every 30-60 minutes in DA2 with me) - it will need to take a lea... To catch some breath online. Otherwise it refuse to rerun DA2. Maybe it's just me and my Origin, I don't know.


You see, now that's why I'd like dev confirmation for these questions rather than other forumites opinions on what the devs are saying.


This, while I appreciate the answers given by the forum members here, I'd still prefer to hear what BW have to say on the matter.

#1555
CenturyCrow

CenturyCrow
  • Members
  • 675 messages

theycallmeryan wrote...

How are more people not pissed about this? We HAVE to boycott BioWare/EA until Mass Effect 3 is on Steam and Origin is NOT required.

Lots of people don't like Origin for a wide variety of reasons. Search out the hundreds of pages on other Origin threads. Origin as a DD is a major business decision that you'll not influence by boycotting.

You could always try a variation of Occupy Wall Street and go to Edmonton, Alberta. Dress warmly but bring an ice pick. :lol:

#1556
Pupuppu

Pupuppu
  • Members
  • 140 messages

Rudy Lis wrote...

Mine worked too. Until you exit game or you got CtD and you try to run game again. No link - no work. Also, it doesn't start in offline. Ever.

There is no opt-out. They want to "directly communicate" with you.

Modifié par Pupuppu, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:36 .


#1557
Pupuppu

Pupuppu
  • Members
  • 140 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...

In my example I unplugged my internet cable and could play fine. The epitome of "offline". I used ME2 and Origin to test and started the game offline rather than unplugged after loaded.


Thank you for confirming that the offline option in the client is putting you online after a restart.

#1558
Rudy Lis

Rudy Lis
  • Members
  • 2 097 messages

Pupuppu wrote...

The is no opt-out. They want to "directly communicate" with you.


I think I can live with that.:)

Pupuppu wrote...

Thank you for confirming that the offline option in the client is putting you online after a restart.


Well, while I played BF3 single and was "online", my ISP once had some unscheduled maintance, so I was cut-off from web, literally. BF3 continued to play nicely. But, when I finished my playing and exit game, Origin went into "eternal slumbers" state and required using three-finger spell to awoke it.
When similar situation happened few days after first one, while I was playing multiplayer, BF3 CtD almost instantly. Origin went sleeping, as usual.

#1559
Sundance31us

Sundance31us
  • Members
  • 2 647 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...
In my example I unplugged my internet cable and could play fine. The epitome of "offline". I used ME2 and Origin to test and started the game offline rather than unplugged after loaded.

The only catch is that ME2 doesn't have an MP/co-op element; we don't know if that aspect of ME3 might mean it requires Origin to be active while it is active.

#1560
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

Pupuppu wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...

In my example I unplugged my internet cable and could play fine. The epitome of "offline". I used ME2 and Origin to test and started the game offline rather than unplugged after loaded.


Thank you for confirming that the offline option in the client is putting you online after a restart.


What actually happens is two situations.

1. If you are connected to the internet with an always on connection (broadband lets say) and start Origin or in case of ME3 I assume Start ME3 which starts Origin. What happens is it logs into Origin in online mode then you can go to option and turn on offline mode (whether it continues to send data or not at thats stage I do not know, haven't tested)

2. If you do not have an interent connection or you are "offline" as in not connected to the internet and (not) offline as in client already loaded but set ot offline mode. What happens is Origin loads and signs in to the client and you can play your game in true offline mode and the client tells you that you are logged into the client but in offline mode, with ME3 the same will probably apply if load the game or Origin in this version of "offline" you can continue to play the game fine.

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:50 .


#1561
tishyw

tishyw
  • Members
  • 581 messages
This is a deal breaker for me - if off-line mode doesn't work then I'm not installing Origin on my PC.

I can live with it being active on-line for a few minutes when the game is activated, and then never again because I'm not interested in MP, DLC or even patches (unless they fix game breaking bugs), but if Origin needs to keep connecting to the internet for no readily apparent reason, and stops me from playing the game until it does, well that I can't live with.

So it will be a no sale for me until I can be confident that off-line mode works.

#1562
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

Sundance31us wrote...

Dragoonlordz wrote...
In my example I unplugged my internet cable and could play fine. The epitome of "offline". I used ME2 and Origin to test and started the game offline rather than unplugged after loaded.

The only catch is that ME2 doesn't have an MP/co-op element; we don't know if that aspect of ME3 might mean it requires Origin to be active while it is active.


Yes you are right at this stage that element (MP) effects is unknown. But what makes the most sense (to me) given the examples I just gave above is that same happens in that logs in to Origin same as each example given above and MP just is not playable until either connect internet cable again or switch back to online mode in the client. That is what I believe is the most logical outcome.

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:48 .


#1563
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

tishyw wrote...

Stops me from playing the game until it does.


Doesn't right now unless MP in ME3 has complete and drastic affect which changes how works, it currently doesn't.

If do not wish it to connect unplug your cable or turn off your router and as it stand right now it doesnt connect to the internet because it cant but you can still play the game. Origin still loads but in offline mode and the game can still be played with test ran on current version.

If that is not good enough for you then sorry but not much more can say on the subject.

However I also haven't had same issue Rudy has so maybe I'm just lucky with regards to my client regarding the issue of exiting game on his/hers crashing.

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:46 .


#1564
Rudy Lis

Rudy Lis
  • Members
  • 2 097 messages
Just tested the issue. Unplugged cable. Started Origin. Origin is no go (although WDM showed it amongs processes). Login window popped up as soon as connection was reestablished. Just like before the latest update.

Edit: added answer below.

Dragoonlordz wrote...

However I also haven't had same issue Rudy has so maybe I'm just lucky with regards to my client regarding the issue of exiting game on his/hers crashing.


It not about issue, really. If I understood you correctly (hard to say with that medicine), Origin can stay off-line as long as it works Ok. No matter is there any connection, or not. But as soon as something bad happens (CtD, for example), Origin "hangs". Even restoring connection doesn't help (so Ctrl+Alt+Del>kill process>start again).
If you have no connection whatsoever PRIOR running Origin - it simply refuse to start. That is my biggest issue with it. Also, I'm a bit annoyed with ME2, when it tries to connect to Cerberus network EVERY damn time I start it. Up to 2 munites of delay. DA2 have similar behaviour, without Cerberus network, of course. Maybe Dead Space will have it too, haven't tested it yet.
Yes, if Steam was online, but connection was disabled, you may have issues with it. But if you opt your Steam to stay off-line, it'll never went online until you say so. Or something terrible happens (game cache verifying or something).

Modifié par Rudy Lis, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:58 .


#1565
Harbinger1985

Harbinger1985
  • Members
  • 19 messages
I am a fan never on these forums before. I created an account to let BioWare / EA know that I'm cancelling my preorder. Origin is unacceptable.

#1566
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

Rudy Lis wrote...

Just tested the issue. Unplugged cable. Started Origin. Origin is no go (although WDM showed it amongs processes). Login window popped up as soon as connection was reestablished. Just like before the latest update.


I think yours is not working. Mine with no cable plugged in loaded Origin (latest version downloaded week ago) and it logged into the service then brought up message and here is screenshot proving it. My computer was completley disconnected from the router prior to launching Origin.

Posted Image

Now I am not fibbing, I am not kidding or messing about on this either. It a few times has brought up a prompt at the login screen saying could not connect and when put in my password again it did actually connect no problems. You get the screen I just took and linked above and if click "OK" it goes straight into Origin client and then lists all your games as normal which can play. I could stop that pop up telling my I am not connected to the internet ever again (something I already knew when started application lol) obviously with the little check box but I wanted screenshot of it to show so kept it on.

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 01:58 .


#1567
_Guy_Fawkes_

_Guy_Fawkes_
  • Members
  • 73 messages
@Dragoonlordz

Howdy,

as I have followed the ME3 + Origin debates on this forum and It's numerous threads to a very very large extent and have noticed  that you also seem to be quite interested in this topic, just contrary to me seem to be perfectly fine with it and it appears to me that you very often speak in it's defense, may I ask what your personal benefit from this additional piece of software is? Or even the other way round: wouldn't you prefer ME3 without Origin (i.e. also any other download client) as well? If not, then why?  Are you possibly employed in a similar field of work? Weren't the options of obtaining patches/updates/DLC's good or easy enough? 

Thanks in advance.

#1568
Rudy Lis

Rudy Lis
  • Members
  • 2 097 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...

I think yours is not working.


Maybe. Maybe not. I have no idea and EA support seems to be ignoring me (as long as they do not drive their vehicles near me I'm fine with it), so I can't check issue further. I'm still trying to run Origins on totally offline PC, BTW (not this one, of course:)).

#1569
Sundance31us

Sundance31us
  • Members
  • 2 647 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...
Mine with no cable plugged in loaded Origin (latest version downloaded week ago) and it logged into the service then brought up message and here is screenshot proving it. My computer was completley disconnected from the router prior to launching Origin.

I disconnected without unplugging anything and got the same message when I logged into Origin; it went into off-line mode.

#1570
Ravenknight

Ravenknight
  • Members
  • 21 messages
n/t

Modifié par Ravenknight, 18 janvier 2012 - 02:54 .


#1571
Lux

Lux
  • Members
  • 765 messages

Dragoonlordz wrote...

Rudy Lis wrote...

Just tested the issue. Unplugged cable. Started Origin. Origin is no go (although WDM showed it amongs processes). Login window popped up as soon as connection was reestablished. Just like before the latest update.


I think yours is not working. Mine with no cable plugged in loaded Origin (latest version downloaded week ago) and it logged into the service then brought up message and here is screenshot proving it. My computer was completley disconnected from the router prior to launching Origin.

Posted Image


Turning on a VPN will get you the same result. I need to use a VPN all the time and this was something quite annoying that kept happening, before I uninstalled Origin.

#1572
Dragoonlordz

Dragoonlordz
  • Members
  • 9 920 messages

_Guy_Fawkes_ wrote...

@Dragoonlordz

Howdy,

as I have followed the ME3 + Origin debates on this forum and It's numerous threads to a very very large extent and have noticed  that you also seem to be quite interested in this topic, just contrary to me seem to be perfectly fine with it and it appears to me that you very often speak in it's defense, may I ask what your personal benefit from this additional piece of software is? Or even the other way round: wouldn't you prefer ME3 without Origin (i.e. also any other download client) as well? If not, then why?  Are you possibly employed in a similar field of work? Weren't the options of obtaining patches/updates/DLC's good or easy enough? 

Thanks in advance.

 

Wall of text incoming...

The benefits is firstly talking to my friends who have the same client, some have Origin because bought retail copy from store of EA game and registered to Origin because their CD broke and Origin allows access to download free copy if register retail game. Steam has better chat features/functions but over time I think Origin will catch up.

Patches and updates I did not like having to search the web just 'incase' there may have been a new patch randomly. Clients inform you of updates available so I am not randomly guessing, but this also depends on the game as some tell you in game however some do not (timing). Then there is ease of updates and patches too in that it is much easier to download the latest one if you missed any rather than looking around and trying to find which is the latest (location). In that regard they were better or easier then having to search and figure out when and if patches and updates are ready compared to using a client which makes things easier to keep track of, locate and install.

I use Steam and Origin for those purposes. I have never bought a game on Steam because no I am not willing to wait half a year to buy games when I can buy them now at only slightly above the price Steam will have them at when sales come around (ones I want not random junk Steam decides is worth biggest discount but specific games I have on my list to get for year). Origin is very expensive most of the time so I don't tend to buy much on there either. I think again this will change over time as Origin gets bigger and see more discounts (more than currently see).

Would I prefer without clients, maybe. but pissing against a wall won't bring the wall down. Even if I did not wish to use a client for ME3 I still have Steam being dropped on me with my retail copies anyways. I do not favor Steam anymore than I favor Origin they are doing the same job (for me) as someone who doesn't buy many game on the respective clients. I would also like going back to the days of cartridges but some stuff is not going to happen. DD business is BIG business this won't change are part of that is Steams fault for proving just how huge the amount of money can be made, I do not blame EA for wanting a piece of the pie.

EA will not back down just because you do not wish to use it, prove it is still doing something illegal specifically the client else you won't stop them and even if you did prove something like that in court and this does not include the EULA which they have already changed they could quite easily change it again the client this time and get through. There is not even close to the amount of people needed to even be considered a bother to EA right now about the client, the EULA was different because you had a legal case, as far as I know you do not as of yet have one against the software in the courts.

The prices is the downside to the clients (both of them) whether generally high price on Origin through out year with some exceptions or Steams faff about sales where the ones on sale during those two major periods are not the ones on my list of titles to get specifically and the discount on the ones I have wanted is never worth the wait for that reason.

Neither go around scanning or sending information about me that I consider offensive and too personal (you may not feel the same but thats your opinion and this is mine). Origin is less inconvenient than Steam on mine simply because I have never had the problems some people seem to have had and Steam takes longer to load and close down on my system, always has. 

This part you will not like but is how I see it, privacy is a selfish (if not the most) selfish of principles (based on the simple principle of "me" and "my") I give it far less value when compared to what I consider more important principles which are not based on "me me me". Such as standing up against deforestation or for end to poverty in third world countries or finding cure for cancer even standing up against child abuse plus more (ones that do not revolve around just me and only me). I said you probably would not like this paragraph and that really makes no difference to me if like or don't. But this does not mean I devalue those who have different regard to this and haven't attacked anyone on it (though have given information if there is a very specific sentence in something they said which was not about privacy within the paragraph or post).

However I have never said people shouldn't fight for their privacy if that is their major principle they feel is currently on trial and have no objection if wish to try to get Opt In or Opt Out and generally havent responded directly to those [much] in fact even wished them luck as would do me no harm if they won. For this reason instead of telling people what they should or should not be doing (other than put blame where it should be instead and instead of picking the closest and easiest target), I have been trying to supply information. Information from my experience with all the major DD clients, information regarding watching all the answers could or have seen come up on the last thread and this one incase someone missed something already said. It is not really defence regarding what I have said above in this paragraph, it is forwarding information. The only defence really is when people place blame where I consider it doesn't belong and I have that right to say as such as much as they have the right to target someone.

The only client I do not actually like right now is the Ubisofts one because of bad experiences, I have had none with either Steam or Origin. There are pros to using Steam and there are some slight ones to Origin for same reason even if prices is not one of those. There are also downsides to both minor but nothing more than inconvenience. What you have to remember is EA is first and foremost a business however and in order to be greatly offended by something it has to do something that I find greatly offensive, currently that is not that case. I think those who wish for change prior to ME3 release date know they cannot get this at this stage, but they do stand chance dependant on sales which will be after released. Not a very high chance by any stretch of the imagination, but a chance is a chance.

I also look at long term which is to say whatever the slight inconvenience may be for clicking an extra button before playing a game, my lower regard for my own privacy which is not to say i have no regard. If Origin does indeed and this goes on nothing more than assumption make no mistake get to be a big player that rivals Steams it will yes create a two services war of prices and the ones who will benefit is the customer. I think Bioware should only be blamed for the quality of game they make and any disgruntled people even if valid reason if they feel their privacy needs to be defended in this situation should be really be blaming EA the distributer for sticking an additional peice of software alongside the game Bioware created aka "distributing" if offended.

Bet you wished you never asked now eh? :lol:

Modifié par Dragoonlordz, 18 janvier 2012 - 03:14 .


#1573
StElmo

StElmo
  • Members
  • 4 997 messages
Does origin spy on your PC? Any way to stop it sharing our information about non-origin games?

I only just found out it did this, like a scummy bit of spyware... grrr....

#1574
Lux

Lux
  • Members
  • 765 messages

StElmo wrote...

Does origin spy on your PC? Any way to stop it sharing our information about non-origin games?

I only just found out it did this, like a scummy bit of spyware... grrr....


They're... working on improving the system. I'm hoping for better transparency (as an opt-out/opt-in mechanism similar to Steam's) before the release of ME3.

Modifié par Merkar, 18 janvier 2012 - 03:09 .


#1575
mcneil_1

mcneil_1
  • Members
  • 678 messages

Merkar wrote...

StElmo wrote...

Does origin spy on your PC? Any way to stop it sharing our information about non-origin games?

I only just found out it did this, like a scummy bit of spyware... grrr....


They're... working on improving the system. I'm hoping for better transparency (as an opt-out mechanism similar to Steam's) before the release of ME3.

I hope so as well, because looking at that picture that DL posted, Origin is still a Beta program :blink: (why curious to know why BW are using a beta program in what could be a hit game for 2012 :?)

Modifié par mcneil_1, 18 janvier 2012 - 03:17 .