First of all thank you very much for the opensource client.Secondly I have two questions you may can answer.
IP addresses and also the NICs mac are personally identifiable data, at least where I live.
1. Question: In what ways are the IP and MAC addresses are associated with i.e. the aggregated data or what are they used for at all, except for the access logs of the Websites in the client.2. Question: As the people in Germany got a different EULA, how does the Origin client determine which EULA applies to whom?
Your IP and MAC address by itself contain no personal information, They don't contain your name, address, DOB or any other personal data.
1. They are aggregated in server access logs along with the millions of other requests.
2. I'm not aware of a different EULA or seperate Origin client
for German users. If you can
http://pastebin.com the EULA found in the Origin install directory I'll take a look.
CenturyCrow wrote...Sorry that doesn't work for me. First, I just want to play the game and finish the series, not become a programmer.
However, I do appreciate you taking the time to examine forum member's concerns and answer them. Thank you. It benefits both the user and EA/BioWare.
For some, seeing and being able to work with the source code will undoubtly prove of interest and valuable. What they really want though, is to be able to mod the game.
You're welcome, A thread 65 pages long needs some official attention and I hope to be able to alleviate any concerns or questions you might have.
You won't need to be a programmer to make changes, I could remove all the friends code and rebuild the client within a few minutes if users desired.
Game Modding will entirely be upto the Bioware developers, It's outside my scope of work

Gatt9 wrote...I would like to view this evidence so I may make a judgement. I believe you are a Dev and I am interested to assess the evidence.
As far as the revoking goes, I'm afraid there's alot of noise on the 'net about this, and as a Developer I would expect you to be isolated from community relations and likely not reasonably privy to the actions taken in that department. I know I couldn't tell you what my community relations department is doing, and they're right downstairs from me.
The specific screenshot I showed of Origin from Start to Finish, not scanning your files is available in this post along with the software I used:
http://forum.ea.com/...5.page#19555964I also posed information about my expeience as a staff memeber being banned, also information about how it does not affect your games as we've made changes to prevent this from occurring

Forbidden wrote...Will the open source version authenticate the games' DRM? i.e. Can I play ME3 without ever installing the closed source version of Origin?
Origin won't be required, as for the DRM it's handled seperate from Origin by the games themself and is what has allowed me to create OpenOrigin.
Forbidden wrote...
I've seen many reports of banning people from single player games with EA representatives explaining it specifically as you can't play single player when your account is banned.
Thats not entirely true, You can still play your games.
Forbidden wrote...
That very thread you pointed to mentioned that you were actually banned at one point, and the only way you could play your games again was because you worked for EA and got your manager involved! Consider how insane that sounds from someone sitting on our side of the fence. If you didn't work for EA and couldn't get your own management involved, you'd still be banned. Is it so hard to understand why we have trouble trusting EA?
Yes, Support staff where unable to verify my identify and where right to not unban my account (else anyone can say their an EA developer and get unbanned), contacting the internal management teams was the correct action for staff in that situation.
Forbidden wrote...
What I got from the thread was "See, it wasn't Origin scanning the whole hard drive, it's just a bug in windows", which sounds a bit far-fetched, but I don't know windows internals enough to evaluate it. If it was Unix/Linux, I could easily do so, I try to use windows as little as possible.
FindFirstFile/FindFirstFileEx use wildcard string matching, If you throw an ANSI string into a function expecting Unicode you can expect bugs like that one causing your entire drive to be enumerated.
I also mentioned how no major news source or industry experts even bothered to mention it and how the few media stories completely relied upon Process Monitor as their proof with explanations coming from random users with no real programming experience. PM doesn't show the API calls, if it did you could clearly see the wildcard string was incorrect.
You can search the major news sites for Origin and find nothing and if you look back on the news sources, PM was the only evidence provided to backup those claims, they also provided no logs or internet traffic to backup the 'transmitting your data to EA' statements which is bad reporting and clear FUD.
Forbidden wrote...
2) How is your IP address a licence to rifle though your data?The bit about "operating system", "software" and "software usage". That could cover everything on your disk.
It is a little unclear, I'm waiting for offical clarification.
I do know that also covers Support techs asking what OS you have and what software you have installed to help troubbleshoot problems with your games. "Software Usage" should be only about Origin telemety such as it's start-up time, what windows use the most and performance counters such as it's memory usage.
I'll wait to hear back about that before saying that section only applies to Origin.
dmex