355 réponses à ce sujet

[Xilizhra]

Saphra thinks Prazza was an idiot, like everyone else who doesn't trust Cerberus. He's simply framing it in a manner that presents Prazza heroically, as a disguised attack on Paragon Shepard.

[Pride Demon]

jreezy wrote...
This:

Saphra Deden wrote...
Prazza was brave and had good reason to mistrust Tali and Shepard/Cerberus. It was mostly bad luck and fate that did him in. Sure, with Shepard's help he might have got passed the heavy mech, but then trusting Shepard and Cerberus might have just delayed the inevitable.

Either way it was a risk but Prazza at least took the path that he thought would get his people out of the dangerous situation faster.

Xilizhra wrote...
Saphra thinks Prazza was an idiot, like everyone else who doesn't trust
Cerberus. He's simply framing it in a manner that presents Prazza
heroically, as a disguised attack on Paragon Shepard.

And here's the problem...
And this is what I mean whan I say I never saw his/her clear opinion...

I can agree with one's action and still think him a fool, I can disagree and still think him a hero...

Saphra speaks generals but didn't spell out his/her actual opinion of Prazza...
So if one tries a contradictory he/she can simply say "I wasn't talking about ..." of "what I mean was..."
It's easy to win a debate if no one knows whose side you are on: simply put, no one will know how to counter you, for you put forward no point to counter to begin with...
A nice use of modern sophism, well played to Saphra but this is not how a proper debate is made...
Debating on clearly defined ground is something very dear to me, I don't like being taken for a fool without reason, so I'll just leave and take my uninteresting opinions with me...

Hoping not to have offended anyone, see you BSN...

Modifié par Pride Demon, 25 janvier 2012 - 02:32 .

[GodWood]

Xilizhra wrote...
Saphra thinks Prazza was an idiot, like everyone else who doesn't trust Cerberus. He's simply framing it in a manner that presents Prazza heroically, as a disguised attack on Paragon Shepard.

It's quite clever.

[Xilizhra]

GodWood wrote...

Xilizhra wrote...
Saphra thinks Prazza was an idiot, like everyone else who doesn't trust Cerberus. He's simply framing it in a manner that presents Prazza heroically, as a disguised attack on Paragon Shepard.

It's quite clever.

Well, more people fell for it than is good for my faith in the forum.

[GodWood]

Now you're wiser.

[Nizzemancer]

D3MON-SOVER3IGN wrote...

They're idiots because as I recall, 6-8 quarians including Prazza was killed. 3-4 were injured. You mean to tell me an entire platoon of Quarian marines couldn't handle 1 HEAVY MECH!!

Obviously they couldn't...

Prazza really was an idiot.

When your commanding officer says to wait for backup you don't charge in guns blazing, even if your allies are questionable according to your own views, especially if your commander isn't an experienced leader, in wich case excessive caution is always better and more responsibility to get your men home safe relies on your abilities.