88264 réponses à ce sujet

[Mr.House]

Fate route did that, that's my point Chewin. Turning UBW route into something it's not is a crappy move. If they wanted to do a continuation of Saber they should have picked the Fate route first, not UBW.  UBW only follows Sabers story near the end, that's all there is too it. If they are adding new scenes, the chance of those scenes taking priority is high and thus will ruin the anime for us that expected UBW in anime form.

 

Now if they can add this new content without harming UBW, then sure, that's amazing. But I do fear that they might harm what made UBW good  just because they decided to skip the Fate route.

[Mr.House]

Oh Akane, sometimes you need to take more from Seryu than just her voice. Stupid pacifist justice.

Please no.

[Chewin]

Sure, I can understand the concern, but as I said I don't see the need for UBW to be centered on Saber to portray her as an established character. As long as the show manages to take up her motivation for fighting, reflect upon her ideological views that was taken up in Zero and how it develops and / or changes, her external / internal conflicts she faces now and faced in the previous war, what her relationship was with Kiritsugu and how it differs from Shirou, among other things.

I don't know how UBW develops narratively, but I don't see that there exists a necessity for the show to change drastically in favor for putting characterization on Saber's path forward. Even Deen's version didn't spend the entirety of the show covering these aspects (and instead had nonsensical factors which contributed little to nothing).

If the show decides to completely ignore these, then Saber as a character on the show as its own will be terrible and it is not justifiable to say that it gets resolved in another medium.

[Saber Wolf]

Sure, I can understand the concern, but as I said I don't see the need for UBW to be centered on Saber to portray her as an established character.

Aye, I see this being the case as well. Sure I like more Saber, but I am more concerned that she won't be much of a character and whatever she did and felt in Fate Zero will be ignored.

I'm OK with Rin and Archer taking center stage, but everyone being represented as characters is something I hooe the show manages to grasp.

[Mr.House]

It mostly has to do with the fact that most of Shirous arguments in Fate will be not happening UBW(and can't for very good reasons) While Saber does reach closure, it is vastly different then how it happens in Fate and Zero has nothing to do with how she comes to her closure in UBW(it has to do with her time with Shirou and Rin). To change that stuff, you will be changing why she does a certain action near the end and that can have a massive negative impact on the overall story of UBW.

 

The Fate route can be said to build up and continue what Rider kept telling her in Zero(even thought the VN came out first, Riders words in Zero work well with the Fate route) If they wanted to do this, they picked the wrong route, even with added scenes, the only way to make UBW and her closure work with what Zero built up for her would be to change big key scenes and by doing that, you are changing parts of UBW and I am against it.

[Mr.House]

Aye, I see this being the case as well. Sure I like more Saber, but I am more concerned that she won't be much of a character and whatever she did and felt in Fate Zero will be ignored.

I'm OK with Rin and Archer taking center stage, but everyone being represented as characters is something I hooe the show manages to grasp.

Like I said, it does, but for Saber it happens very late for key reasons. For most of UBW the focus is on Rin, Archer, Shirou and Caster. The other thing is her character dev in UBW and her closure is from her times with Shirou and Rin, not because what happen in Zero(which is the case with Fate) Thus if they wanted this to be a "proper" continuation of Zero for Saber, they picked the wrong route big time.

 

New scenes and such can not change this unless they change it themselves and that will ****** off alot of people.

 

That is why Saber is a secondary character. She still has a big role, but it happens much later.

[Mr.House]

Just saying,

Spoiler

now a ton more people are gonna die cuz she can't shoot a menace to society, just like with Makishima. Yeah, rah rah, execution isn't justice, I don't want my colleague to have blood on his hands, which may be true, but it's a necessary evil. That she isn't willing to accept that is part of who she is, but there are consequences for that.

Maybe it'll be a good thing if Togane succeeds in clouding her hue a little bit.  

Least Akane was doing stuff instead of just standing there like an idiot like a certain inspector....

 

Each week, Mikas naivety keeps getting trampled on and I'm loving it.

[Chewin]

It mostly has to do with the fact that most of Shirous arguments in Fate will be not happening UBW(and can't for very good reasons) While Saber does reach closure, it is vastly different then how it happens in Fate and Zero has nothing to do with how she comes to her closure in UBW(it has to do with her time with Shirou and Rin). To change that stuff, you will be changing why she does a certain action near the end and that can have a massive negative impact on the overall story of UBW.
 
The Fate route can be said to build up and continue what Rider kept telling her in Zero(even thought the VN came out first, Riders words in Zero work well with the Fate route) If they wanted to do this, they picked the wrong route, even with added scenes, the only way to make UBW and her closure work with what Zero built up for her would be to change big key scenes and by doing that, you are changing parts of UBW and I am against it.

Can't comment much since as I said I don't know how UBW progresses narratively. I'll just have to experience how the show develops regarding this issue and whether I find it favorable or not.

[Mr.House]

As a matter of fact he is, in a very broad manner of speaking. 

This is why Akane made that mistake, dam Ko day dreams.

[CrazyRah]

I dream about Ko all the time.

 

The stuff that goes in my dreams would even make Japan cringe.

 

Not much can beat dreaming about Ko, that incredible man!

[Some Geth]

G Gundam sickens me.

[bmwcrazy]

Delicious sea cucumbers.

[Liamv2]

EWWWWWWWWWW

[Vroom Vroom]

I don't think you could pay me to eat one of those... 

[Vroom Vroom]

Google thinks I'm a sicko.

Remember that other requirement I was talking about to post in this thread?  

 

I'd say it's a toss-up between the two of us in terms of how many servers the FBI has dedicated to us. I'd say that the FBI has at least 3 warehouses filled to the brim with servers dedicated to me, I'm guessing the case is about the same with you, maybe even more (4's a pretty sweet number, but I am working for lucky number 7. I won't be happy with anything short of 7 warehouse filled with information about me and my "suspicious" searches ). 

 

Spoiler

[CrazyRah]

Remember that other requirement I was talking about to post in this thread?  

 

I'd say it's a toss-up between the two of us in terms of how many servers the FBI has dedicated to us. I'd say that the FBI has at least 3 warehouses filled to the brim with servers dedicated to me, I'm guessing the case is about the same with you, maybe even more (4's a pretty sweet number, but I am working for lucky number 7. I won't be happy with anything short of 7 warehouse filled with information about me and my "suspicious" searches ). 

 

Spoiler

 

Indeed, you're not doing it right unless they got a special section named just after you!

 

 

Extra big section!