Wow, I just finished Sword Art Online. It was pretty great. I don't play many MMO's, but this was a good representative of how people act online and how many rpg's are. It was very fun to watch, the animation was great from something by A-1 pictures. Kirito is called the black swordsman, I think this is a berserk reference. Also, Kirito is a very well developed character and I like how the game explores how a gamer would act if they were stuck in a virtual world for years.
Asuna herself is a well written female character. She turned from a helpless girl to a skilled player. Her relationship with kirito was very realistic. If a real person was stuck in a game for years and they don't know how to escape so they found love.
There are a lot more good things I could say about this series. I'm really looking forward to season 2. I might wait till it gets dubbed though.
Meh, the first half of the first season and the second half of the second season were pretty good, but not good enough to make up for the middle half of the series IMO.
While the series does have some cool action sequences, generically likable characters, and an occasionally engaging storyline, it also has a lot of problems. The first one to become apparent is how short the character arcs for all of the characters who aren't Kirito and Asuna are. A few episodes after Kirito meets them, they just stop developing and melt into the background. Do you remember who Lisbeth, Silica, and Klein are? I don't either. I had to look them up. You won't remember who Suguha is long into Season 2 either.
Over time, girls who Kirito has been nice to start to follow him around and do absolutely nothing relevant to the plot. A collective that superficially resembles the harems of other animes, but only exists to fill space on the screen. I challenge anyone who reads this to name a way in which their role differs from that of the dinosaur George Lucas added to Mos Eisley in the 1997 version of Star Wars.
The second problem with the series is that Kirito is such a Mary Sue. Foolishly, I tricked myself into thinking it wasn't going to get any worse after the big bad told Kirito that he had given him the ability to dual wield because he was the specialist snowflake in the virtual world, but it did. In the Alfheim Online arc, it turns out that virtual reality mumorpuger players can convert their avatars to work in other games, so they can keep their stats. I'm not saying it necessarily would have been a good thing if Kirito had to grind in Alfheim, then it would have been even longer before the only consistently interesting character in the series could be rescued. But the show's creators seem to be afraid of handicapping Kirito in any meaningful way. He has to be the best at everything he ever does with no practice at all. And in season 2
And of course, his sister falls in love with him.
The third problem is that Asuna doesn't get to do anything in the middle half of the series. She was easily the most likable character in the series, and it was much harder to tolerate all the bad parts of Sword Art Online without her.
The fourth problem is the show's infantile portrayal of rape and sexual harassment. It was bad enough when Silica got attacked by that one plant monster, Evil Dead style. I mean seriously? What were the game developers thinking? Who thought that giving the monsters this behavior was a good idea? Why would anyone want to play a game in which you can get raped by the trash mobs? But then, it gets even worse when Asuna gets attacked by literal tentacle rape monsters, and then molested right in front of Kirito. Up until this point, Asuna had been one of the strongest characters in the series, but she got reduced to a macguffin for Kirito to fight over with rapists.
Having the female characters getting molested by the villains right in front of Kirito is just a really cheap way to get an emotional reaction out of the audience, and is indicative of the studio's creative bankruptcy.
My god, why do I keep watching this?