88264 réponses à ce sujet

[eroeru]

That was exactly my point. He should have played it safer.

Or rather, if I were to project my "shoulds" he shouldn't have started, or at least he'd stopped.

[Some Geth]

Like I said, Black Haired Light went from genius to foaming idiot out of nowhere.

Light did play himself into into a corner, but it was boring and stupid the way it happened. There was no thematic edge to anything that happened at the end. Light got outsmarted and then died a ridiculous villain.

Light did need to die, but the way it happened was stupid.

Modifié par Some Geth, 03 mars 2013 - 10:59 .

[eroeru]

I should probably need to read the manga to understand Geth better.

[eroeru]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

I don't think he necessarily should've stopped. What he was doing was bad, but a lot of good was coming from it. What, a 80% drop in crime and stop to war? That's pretty good.

It was bad in principle. And believe it or not, smart people act on principle more than you think.

It's impossible to go against the whole world, and methodologically and philosophically really iffy to judge, moreso with a death sentance.

If Light were in this sense more "smart" (i.e if I'd project my maybe more personal "shoulds"), then he would have needed to look for a way to enhance his cognitive capabilities with some sci-fi device in order to be able to process all the info needed to pass massive death sentances (to take into account the various effects), and in succession he would have either found out that it's impossible to make such wide-scale decisions and effect-analysis for a person and would not have killed anyone (the more probable option me thinks) or found out this impossibility and started killing most people on Earth, out of sheer cynicism for humans.

Modifié par eroeru, 03 mars 2013 - 11:19 .

[Some Geth]

In the manga Light did not die on a set of stairs.

He just died in the warehouse like an idiot. So Near and the readers could laugh at him I guess?

Light's profile if he was written into like a character profile would describe him as a sociopath, but the way he acts changes from sociopath to Snideley Whiplash.
If Light thinks he's Jesus, why does he do all those awful stupid evil grins. Like when he stares down at dying L, it should be this sort of "Justice is done" look. Not MWAHAHAHAHAHA.

Plus there's incongruity of when Light loses his memory and the way he acts then and every other time.

Light never acted like that before the Death Note, and not at first. He was always sullen and seemingly sociopathic. Nothing about his change to IM A GOOD GUY was credible.

Light should have at least been like Michael Corleone.

Hell Michael Corleone is a perfect comparison. Michael even "wins". He remains Don, and crushes all his enemies. But he loses everything he cared about in the process and dies alone and unhappy.  

Would Godfather 2 (or 3 if you want to count that) have ended well with Michael flailing on the ground dying?  Naw, than Godfather would be Scarface, and we'd be deprived of quality cinema.

Modifié par Some Geth, 03 mars 2013 - 11:21 .

[eroeru]

In real life, the scenario Some Geth had in mind would fit. Yes he could easily not be caught.

Yet Death Note is a more out-there world and balanced accordingly. As far as I know from the anime, all behaved to a good logical pattern.

[Sajuro]

Except that it seems to me that the only person Light cares about is himself.

[Jaison1986]

I think his main fault was letting his ego get the better of him. The smart thing to do would be writing the names on the death note quietly on his room without letting anyone see it. That's what I would do anyway. But then again, the series wouldn't have much to tell if Light kept an low profile.

[eroeru]

... Wow!

[eroeru]

Sajuro wrote...

Except that it seems to me that the only person Light cares about is himself.

An uninspired and sad life nontheless - all in all...

Not to mention the inevitable moral tension which would prolly build his sociopathy into maniacal behavior. In other words: he would have turned considerably insane by doing what he was doing, no matter if there's a super-police on his trail or not.

Modifié par eroeru, 04 mars 2013 - 02:38 .

[ThePinkFoxx]

So I've been re-watching Tiger & Bunny lately, and I gotta reaffirm it's definitely in my top 5. Out of curiosity though, has anyone else here seen it? The few I've mentioned it to haven't even heard of it and for a 2011 release, I thought it was rather well known?

[Muneakira-Yagyu]

l heard of Tiger & Bunny recently as they were a 2013 release over here, l got the first season and preordered the second (both blu-ray). But l haven't watched it yet as l am middle of watching another anime.

Modifié par Muneakira-Yagyu, 05 mars 2013 - 02:10 .

[RedArmyShogun]

Gentlemen, gentlemen. This Convo Bores me. So I leave you Chinese Electric Batman..

Also I'll watch T&B sometime once I finish other things like...five torrents, Sketdance..kill me baby, wow I have alot of things to watch.






Also SG you might like this

Modifié par RedArmyShogun, 05 mars 2013 - 03:34 .

[Some Geth]

lol

[RedArmyShogun]

I don't know why, but I laugh at this picture and its list.

[RedArmyShogun]

Double post and some shameless self promotion on my part, I'm making AMP Anime Motivational Posters, so if you want me to make one for yah just send me an image, these are ones I made on request so far. lulz, gives me something to do.

http://social.biowar.../albums/1330517