Aller au contenu

Photo

Anime and manga discussion thread


88264 réponses à ce sujet

#14051
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Absolutly ;)

 

I myself am never that great with writing big pieces like KoP did or what Chris sometimes does (Unless I really know what I'm talking about :P). So yes, its a wonderful read whenever somebody does something like that :)

 

Exactly. These guys can put what you're trying to say into words perfectly.

 

Me: ARGGHMAHGAAHD The Witcher 2! Politics, ASOIAF! Awesommmeeeee.

 

When what I'm really trying to say is perfectly put in KoP's novella xD

 

And it's even better when they spot things you miss, like Chris' 'social realism' when he assessed Samurai Champloo.

 

Okay, enough ass kissing xD - but yeah, you know what I mean :D

 

I've wrote a few walls of text reviews for some of my favorite games on Steam -- I'll copy paste them accordingly for my Tumblr along with any anime, film or TV-Show I watch from now on. I'll let you know as soon as I got something to show you. Still in process with my Bebop analysis and thanks! :D

 

GOOD! ^_^


  • Milan92 et Isichar aiment ceci

#14052
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 638 messages

Exactly. These guys can put what you're trying to say into words perfectly.
 
Me: ARGGHMAHGAAHD The Witcher 2! Politics, ASOIAF! Awesommmeeeee.
 
When what I'm really trying to say is perfectly put in KoP's novella xD
 
And it's even better when they spot things you miss, like Chris' 'social realism' when he assessed Samurai Champloo.
 
Okay, enough ass kissing xD - but yeah, you know what I mean :D

Well, the funny thing is that sometimes people can't exactly put into words, the reasons why they find a certain game, movie, anime, tv show or book great. If we were to look at games like Metal Gear Solid, from a broader perspective, we'd think the fans would be raving mad. It's stealth game about a guy named 'Solid Snake' trying to save the Free World from a nuclear holocaust caused by nuclear-walking-battle-tank. Add that along with an array of characters with unusual supernatural powers, and you'd think it sounds absolutely insane -- But mix that up with a highly complex plot, with an array of historical accurate events, along with a few fictional ones, mashed together in such a way that you'd be unable to distinguish fact from fiction. We learn to it accept it. Post-modern writers have referred to this as Hyper-realism.
Metal Gear certainly learns towards the post modernist way of narrative at its strongest, with Metal Gear Solid 2, with an overly complex plot, putting the very fabrics of reality into question as the game connects the where the ingenuity was overshadowed by people's disappointment with the change of protagonist.

I think the greatest thing a game, anime or any medium of storytelling can do is provide new fashionable and intuitive ways to tell a story -- In Silent Hill 2, the story is narrated through the monsters, the empty town, your surroundings the notes you find, it's drenched in symbolism, without resorting to distracting cutscenes it leaves things up to the imagination and there's enough to material to work from that you'd be able to offer your own interpretation of the game's plot.

In terms of anime, I think Evangelion did do a lot of stuff for its time and you can argue it didn't do it to a required level of satisfaction. I think that's what's so great about it and the reason why I always compare it to Metal Gear Solid 2 is that they are both mecha, and carry a sort of mixed reception with them, and even to this day people are still discussing its meaning.

Anyway, I think the point I wanted to make was that I always tend to overanalyze things in any narrative that speaks to me on a whole another level. Not in a practical way, but through subtleties like the themes, the subtext and visuals, how it's set up. I try my best to reflect that in my own reviews or analysis or whatever you'd like to call them. Sometimes I generally just want to focus on the characters and how they affect the overall message the developer wants to convey.

Going back to what I said about social-realism. Well, that's how I think you can generally characterize anime as opposed to Westernanimation. I've said it in a few threads before, but anime tends to draw more cordial caricatures of its character, in otherwise fantastical or futuristic settings. Look at an anime like Code Geass. Its setting can somewhat be described as 'the nearest future kind' in alternate history storyline, to provide poignancy points for the viewer, along with fantastical things like supernatural mind-bending powers and mechs. Heck, even an anime like Dragon Ball Z and its predecessor has things plenty of subtext, like references to British Imperiallism through characters like Frieza, and the Saiyan races seems to be partly based on the brutal tactics of Ancient Rome, that would conquer other nations and kill all its residents, so they may replace them with their own people, like Romania.
There's also a more consistent and careful handling on the usage of sound and audio, which is excellent. Heck there are many thingsand I might get into all of it on Tumblr. I'll post some of my Steam reviews in there too :)
 
 
 

GOOD! ^_^

:D
  • Isichar aime ceci

#14053
Clover Rider

Clover Rider
  • Members
  • 9 434 messages

Like how Dragon Ball had that subtext of General Blue being a gay nazi! Tho now that I think about it, I don't think it was subtext! What is subtext anyways?

 

general-blue.jpg

 

The world may never know.


  • eroeru et Isichar aiment ceci

#14054
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 638 messages
I'd argue that his appearance resembling a Gestapo officer is probably just a reference -- Subtext is a term for the underlying meaning behind what is being told, portrayed, through words, pictures and have you.

#14055
Clover Rider

Clover Rider
  • Members
  • 9 434 messages

lol The whole Red Ribbon army was a big joke off the nazis, so yeah. Right down to the leader wanting a magic dragon to make him taller, just like Hitler.

 

And I guess the world knows what subtext is now. The world thanks you.


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14056
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 638 messages

Well, in retrospect, you spend most JRPGs trying to murder Hitler's many incarnations with different names, occasionally being  the mortal physics-defying-Son-of-Zeus, or maybe it's generally Satan - What the's difference, eh? It can definitely be applied to some anime too.


  • Clover Rider et eroeru aiment ceci

#14057
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Look at an anime like Code Geass. Its setting can somewhat be described as 'the nearest future kind' in alternate history storyline, to provide poignancy points for the viewer, along with fantastical things like supernatural mind-bending powers and mechs.

 

So what you mean here is the contrast between realism and the fantastical? How it blends together to create a unique image whilst keeping its subtext strong and clear?



#14058
CrazyRah

CrazyRah
  • Members
  • 13 286 messages

There's nothing I love more than reading other people's analysis on narrative and characters. And Chris is very good at putting these things into words.

 

Hell, I've linked Knight of Phoenix's 'Politics of the Witcher 2' about a dozen times here. It's a freaking fantastic read on an awesome game ;-)

 

The "Politics of Witcher 2" is not only fantastic to read from the sheer amount of quality in it but also how extensive and easily explained everything is. Always a blast to read information like that regardless if it's about a game, a book or some seriously awesome anime! 


  • Il Divo aime ceci

#14059
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

The "Politics of Witcher 2" is not only fantastic to read from the sheer amount of quality in it but also how extensive and easily explained everything is. Always a blast to read information like that regardless if it's about a game, a book or some seriously awesome anime! 

 

I know! <3

 

Especially if you're a Song of Ice and Fire nut like I am and loooove medieval intrigue. Man, brutal politics is the best politics xD


  • CrazyRah, Milan92 et Isichar aiment ceci

#14060
CrazyRah

CrazyRah
  • Members
  • 13 286 messages

I know! <3

 

Especially if you're a Song of Ice and Fire nut like I am and loooove medieval intrigue. Man, brutal politics is the best politics xD

 

Crazy and brutal, it's almost like poetry but with lots of blood and death. Poetry but better!


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14061
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 638 messages

So what you mean here is the contrast between realism and the fantastical? How it blends together to create a unique image whilst keeping its subtext strong and clear?

Right -- I think, what makes it easier to accept the fantastical and supernatural is by blending in the factual, bits and pieces of history or traits we find in ourselves.


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14062
Isichar

Isichar
  • Members
  • 10 125 messages

tumblr_n3fs0wtXf61sk6x9qo1_250.gif

 

This seems relevant to the current conversation, just don't ask me how.

 

Now excuse me, I need to lay down seeing as how this cold (which I only got as it started warming up :pinched: ) is turning my brain to mush


  • CrazyRah et TheClonesLegacy aiment ceci

#14063
CrazyRah

CrazyRah
  • Members
  • 13 286 messages

tumblr_n3fs0wtXf61sk6x9qo1_250.gif

 

This seems relevant to the current conversation, just don't ask me how.

 

Now excuse me, I need to lay down seeing as how this cold (which I only got as it started warming up :pinched: ) is turning my brain to mush

tumblr_n4vxpngPLC1sktq9uo3_250.gif 

 

GET BETTER! Lay down and beat the life fibers out of that cold and just own it! THAT'S AN ORDER!


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14064
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

tumblr_n4vxpngPLC1sktq9uo3_250.gif

 

GET BETTER! Lay down and beat the life fibers out of that cold and just own it! THAT'S AN ORDER!

 

SOME PMMM MUSIC WILL HELP WITH THE COLD!

 

 


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14065
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Right -- I think, what makes it easier to accept the fantastical and supernatural is by blending in the factual, bits and pieces of history or traits we find in ourselves.

 

Awesome! I feel all warm and fuzzy I got that right :D

 

 


Crazy and brutal, it's almost like poetry but with lots of blood and death. Poetry but better!

 

Nothing warms the heart more than seeing your favourite family outplayed in a single night <3

 

P.S

 

Listened to the bloody PMMM OST for 30 mins...

 

Now I have a huuuuuuge urge to binge the movies.


  • CrazyRah et Isichar aiment ceci

#14066
Isichar

Isichar
  • Members
  • 10 125 messages

P.S

 

Listened to the bloody PMMM OST for 30 mins...

 

Now I have a huuuuuuge urge to binge the movies.

 

I'm constantly struggling with my urge to binge them all, even to just watch TRS repeatedly. I've lost count on how many hours of my life have been dedicated to TRS so far, but I can easily say I've spent more hours on that movie then any movie I've ever seen before. The only reason I resist the urge to binge it again is I know the buildup will make it all the sweeter when I finally rewatch it <3 I can get pretty gushy over a series but this one turns me into a raving fanboy like no other.

 

I got a new phone yesterday. My new ringtone?

 

The background to my phone?

2012-11-02-538952.jpeg

(I also ordered a wall scroll for that exact same image)

 

I even got a little clock widget that has chibi versions of the girls in different poses/outfits depending on the time of the day.

 

My largest regret with buying this phone? I can't find a PMMM phone case online anywhere.

 

Sometimes I start to think its a bit much, but that usually ends with me watching more scenes from TRS again.

 

tumblr_n4vxpngPLC1sktq9uo3_250.gif

 

GET BETTER! Lay down and beat the life fibers out of that cold and just own it! THAT'S AN ORDER!

 

Sir yes sir! (I actually just woke up)

 

I'm not normally a Nonon gusher but I think I can make an exception for you Rah

 

tumblr_mxf0zvT5cq1shof9bo1_500.gif

 

 

 

P.S. Chris do you do a personal blog? If not you really should (I'd read it)


  • CrazyRah aime ceci

#14067
CrazyRah

CrazyRah
  • Members
  • 13 286 messages

I'm constantly struggling with my urge to binge them all, even to just watch TRS repeatedly. I've lost count on how many hours of my life have been dedicated to TRS so far, but I can easily say I've spent more hours on that movie then any movie I've ever seen before. The only reason I resist the urge to binge it again is I know the buildup will make it all the sweeter when I finally rewatch it <3 I can get pretty gushy over a series but this one turns me into a raving fanboy like no other.

 

I got a new phone yesterday. My new ringtone?

*snip*

 

The background to my phone?

2012-11-02-538952.jpeg

(I also ordered a wall scroll for that exact same image)

 

I even got a little clock widget that has chibi versions of the girls in different poses/outfits depending on the time of the day.

 

My largest regret with buying this phone? I can't find a PMMM phone case online anywhere.

 

Sometimes I start to think its a bit much, but that usually ends with me watching more scenes from TRS again.

 

 

Sir yes sir! (I actually just woke up)

 

I'm not normally a Nonon gusher but I think I can make an exception for you Rah

 

tumblr_mxf0zvT5cq1shof9bo1_500.gif

 

 

 

P.S. Chris do you do a personal blog? If not you really should (I'd read it)

 

Yaaaaaaaaay!  <3

March on, beat the life out of it! 

Nonon and i will totally be prepared with an almost endless supply of gifs and images as support

 

tumblr_n5yebfvRu21rkmjxwo5_250.gif


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14068
Isichar

Isichar
  • Members
  • 10 125 messages

Yaaaaaaaaay!  <3

March on, beat the life out of it! 

Nonon and i will totally be prepared with an almost endless supply of gifs and images as support

 

tumblr_n5yebfvRu21rkmjxwo5_250.gif

 

You can never have too many gifs. One must be prepared to have one ready for any situation that might arise on the internet

 

1d6.gif

Just like Nonon ^ she's got an outfit for any situation :D


  • CrazyRah aime ceci

#14069
Giga Drill BREAKER

Giga Drill BREAKER
  • Members
  • 7 005 messages

WRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY



May
maybe its because I'm drunk but JOJO
 



#14070
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

WRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY



May
maybe its because I'm drunk but JOJO
 

 

 

128925608331.gif

 

 

tumblr_mghzp6dYGW1ry9vkao1_500.gif

 

iyYYZIf13KyF2.gif



#14071
Giga Drill BREAKER

Giga Drill BREAKER
  • Members
  • 7 005 messages

WWWWWWWWRRRRRRRRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY



#14072
Isichar

Isichar
  • Members
  • 10 125 messages

Anyone else watching Akuma no Riddle?

 

I want to like it, I really do, but it's making it just so difficult for me at times. This show has to have the worse case of plot armor I've seen in a long time. Maybe it's just that GoT, PMMM and SnK have raised my standards for that type of thing.

 

Spoiler

 

I really hope the last 3 episodes pick up a bit more



#14073
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Anyone else watching Akuma no Riddle?

 

I want to like it, I really do, but it's making it just so difficult for me at times. This show has to have the worse case of plot armor I've seen in a long time. Maybe it's just that GoT, PMMM and SnK have raised my standards for that type of thing.

 

Spoiler

 

I really hope the last 3 episodes pick up a bit more

 

If it doesn't tear your heart and stomp on it, it's not worth watching xD

 

But no, I really haven't watched it. But let us know what you think when it's done.


  • Isichar aime ceci

#14074
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Okay, so Binbougami ga! (Good Luck Girl) was an freaking amazing 13 episode comedy.

 

IT EVEN HAD A DEATH NOTE PARODY IN IT!

 

 

It's a great thing the manga is completed, it's definitely going to be on my list. I might even stop Soul Eater because atm it's really just boring me.

 

They used the word 'beautifulness'

 

I mean... wtf -.-

 

So I've watched a romance/comedy anime (which was really adorable btw.) A comedy anime which was hilarious...

 

Gonna give Rin a go now :-) Happy Milan? ;-)



#14075
Isichar

Isichar
  • Members
  • 10 125 messages

If it doesn't tear your heart and stomp on it, it's not worth watching xD

 

But no, I really haven't watched it. But let us know what you think when it's done.

 

It's currently ongoing with 3 more episodes left so it will be a couple more weeks before then.

 

I'll write something up on it when I'm done with it, though don't expect it to be as well written as some of the stuff you've seen from Chris. I'm thinking it will be somewhere between a 5/10 to a 7/10 depending on how the next few episodes turn out. I like the tone and some of the concepts in the show but nothing particularly grabbed onto me or pulled at any of my emotions. The entire situation just comes off as ridiculously contrived at times and not entirely well explained.

 

Basically you get this girl in a classroom were everyone else is assassins and trying to kill her, whoever manages to do it will get whatever wish they want (why theres a classroom like this is completely lost on me, the story has not really explained that yet..) Instead of doing the smart thing and walking up to her and stabbing her in the throat they usually go to absurd roundabout methods to take her out and it usually ends up failing because the plot said so. What's worse is just how stupid the girl who they are trying to assassinate can be. Despite knowing that everyone is trying to kill her she still puts herself in terrible situations just because an assassin told her to do something like come to a tea party or going out late at night to search the library for a haunted book.

 

Each episode deals with a different assassin and each assassin has a different story and theme that it goes into, which is a good enough concept imo, just not amazingly well executed on many points.

 

The last episode had a scene that felt so contrived that it would have been like watching a terminator get taken out because a little girl threw a stick at it and it just happened to hit its weak spot for critical damage.. all suspension of disbelief is just gone. It's too bad this weeks assassin didn't realize Haru had mastered the ancient and deadly art of SIDESTEPPING AN ATTACK.. I mean how could one plan for such a devious and incredibly powerful technique :rolleyes: