What kind of anime are you in the mood for?
Puella Magi Madoka Magica is usually my goto suggestion. Short of that I would suggest Shin Sekai Yori if you want something that will keep you thinking afterwords (*some* people find it a slow burner though), Clannad or Anohana if you want a feels trip, Watamote or Welcome to the NHK for a good comedy, Fate/Zero or FMA:B for something a bit more action packed but still with a great story.
I finished FMA:B,Ben-to,Last Exile,Fairy Tail,Magi,Cowboy Bebop all in all I really enjoyed all of them. As for what I might be in the mood for? I have no idea, I like comedy,action,horror, dem feels all that stuff is great. Lol I have become a total anime addict as long as it doesn't have bitchy little emo teens piloting giant mechs I will probably like it.