88264 réponses à ce sujet

[Mr.House]

Mami is 14/15

The other 4 are 13/14

 

Spoilers about Homura

Spoiler

Because of all the timeline jumps though, Homura is extremely old mentally since he retains all those memories and such

[Isichar]

 

Poor Nagisa always gets left out of the group gushing.

[CrazyRah]

Just how old are they Rah? I have yet to watch it so know very little about it.

 

Around 14-15 

 

[Mr.House]

Some Bebe!

 

[Liamv2]

Mami is 14/15

The other 4 are 13/14

 

Spoilers about Homura

Spoiler

Because of all the timeline jumps though, Homura is extremely old mentally since he retains all those memories and such

 

Spoiler

I've wondered this before. Does this make Homura a loli?

 

Yes it's a stupid thought.

[xAmilli0n]

Thanks Mr.House, anyways all these debates now have me interested I swear to watch PMMM is it? In its entirety Tis, my sacred oath.

 

Hopefully you enjoy it. The movie Rebellion is also a must watch after you finish the series.

[Mr.House]

Heck Rebellion it self is worth it just for Bebe. Such a great breakout character.

[Isichar]

Madoka really needs to lay off the drugs..

 

...Seems she's not the only one

[Mr.House]

Ah crap, I did forget about Bebe in the ages. Bebe is 11 and super adorable.

[CrazyRah]

I'm sure I will enjoy it. I like shows that mind **** you and play with what you consider right and wrong.

 

PMMM/Rebellion really did that with me. Even wrote a smaller novel about it a good amount of pages back and even today i still am not exactly sure how i feel about so many things i before thought was rock solid and that's one of the things that made me adore PMMM. It screwed with me and i liked it!

 

[Liamv2]

*snip*

Madoka really needs to lay off the drugs..

*snip*

 

...Seems she's not the only one

 

Don't do drugs. Drug's are bad mmkay.

[Some Geth]

I love this Kyubey moment in the best JoJo video ever made.

[Mr.House]

Also I do recommend rewtaching PMMM/Rebellion after you finish it, not right away since you will probably be recovering from all the feels. But rewatching the series will make you realize alot of stuff.

 

[Fidite Nemini]

I would argue against that.

 

Psychopaths can go decades without being treated because they know how people should act, how they should show emotions and empathy, even subconsciously.

 

QB doesn't have empathy, he knows it is something that humans value so he plays the part to make magical girl candidates more comfortable.

 

By the way, the next post I make in this thread is probably going to be an analysis of the conflicts in the ideologies of Kyubey vs. Homura vs. Madoka and the innocence conflict of Homura vs. Mami.

 

 

Psychopaths simulate empathy.

 

But Kyubei isn't simulating to work for the greater good, or is it? So if They want to make the universe better for everyone, it means they can empathize. There is no point in simulating empathy and to, for no personal reason other than to simulate, work for a greater good. Unless of course They just like doing the extremist actions that would benefit said greater good and the latter is simply your excuse to go *drumroll please* undetected as the genocidal psychopath They may be.

 

Which is the point we come full circle and back to my original assessment that I'm inclined to believe They aren't doing it for the greater good, but to another means, like personal amusement via wiping out planets without anyone blaming you for it because greater good and all that.

[Isichar]

PMMM/Rebellion really did that with me. Even wrote a smaller novel about it a good amount of pages back and even today i still am not exactly sure how i feel about so many things i before thought was rock solid and that's one of the things that made me adore PMMM. It screwed with me and i liked it!

 

 

Exactly!

 

Plus you understand the awesomeness that is Kyouko

Sure, she may make a mess of things by showing up, but she's just so damn lovable X3

[Some Geth]

We only say that to make fun of people who say that tho.

[Liamv2]

You two play arguing is so adorably kawaii. 

[Isichar]

Psychopaths simulate empathy.

 

But Kyubei isn't simulating to work for the greater good, or is it? So if They want to make the universe better for everyone, it means they can empathize. There is no point in simulating empathy and to, for no personal reason other than to simulate, work for a greater good. Unless of course They just like doing the extremist actions that would benefit said greater good and the latter is simply your excuse to go *drumroll please* undetected as the genocidal psychopath They may be.

 

Which is the point we come full circle and back to my original assessment that I'm inclined to believe They aren't doing it for the greater good, but to another means, like personal amusement via wiping out planets without anyone blaming you for it because greater good and all that.

 

Do you think that maybe your views on right and wrong are maybe just a bit too black and white? QB's logic is definitely to an extreme, and the extreme is never good, but you should be able to some extent see the merit in it's argument even if you disagree with it.

 

Spoiler

The whole point of Madoka's final decision is that she finds a balance between QB's logic and the value that the girls emotions and lives hold. I think part of the stories main theme is her realizing that things are not so black and white and that sometimes compromises have to be made to some extent, but in this case she was the one willing to pay the price