88264 réponses à ce sujet

[Isichar]

All I am going to say is wow to that ending, and the discussion before now makes sense.

Sorry, which ending again?

[Gravisanimi]

Rebellion ending.

 

I'm still surprised my brother didn't like it and complained "It's like they saw that the ending to the series was too happy, then made this movie to make fun of other magical girl anime and ruin everything with illogical decisions"

[Dr.Fumbles]

Rebellion ending.

 

I'm still surprised my brother didn't like it and complained "It's like they saw that the ending to the series was too happy, then made this movie to make fun of other magical girl anime and ruin everything with illogical decisions"

 

Spoiler

I would agree some of it was wrong, but her reasons for doing it were justified. No decision is clean cut. Besides, who is to say what is good and evil anyways. I just want them to start throwing galaxies at each other now.

[CrazyRah]

Rebellion ending.

 

I'm still surprised my brother didn't like it and complained "It's like they saw that the ending to the series was too happy, then made this movie to make fun of other magical girl anime and ruin everything with illogical decisions"

 

I still think torture is a viable option but i'm totally okay with a clean kill because it's your brother. 

 

[Liamv2]

I'm pretty sure the original idea behind PMMM was "people are too happy lets fix that".

[Isichar]

I've heard a number of people claim TRS was much more depressing then the TV series but I have yet to hear exactly *how* it is. I could compare the 2 endings and it seems to me TRS is the less depressing of the two.

[Gravisanimi]

I still think torture is a viable option but i'm totally okay with a clean kill because it's your brother. 

 

*Homu-Homu snip*

 

He refuses to watch Gurren Lagann and Kill la Kill, hates Lady Plutia's voice, and hates "shows that act ridiculous but want you to take them seriously"

 

He needs some help

[Dr.Fumbles]

Are there any other shows that are as messed up as PMMM. If there are, I need to watch them. Also, tell your brother to watch Space Dandy. It is a super serious show.

[Mr.House]

Hating Gurren Lagann, what is this!?

[Isichar]

PMMM spoilers

Spoiler

In the TV series:
Madoka gets wiped from existence and the only person left remembering her is the person who spent years repeating the same month and even gave up on her own life just to save here. Sayaka is dead, Nagisa is dead, QB has no consequences and continues to try and destroy the girls lives for "the greater good"

TRS ending:
Sayaka is alive and happy, Madoka is alive and happy, Nagisa is alive and happy. QB gets what was coming to it, Homura achieves what she's wanted for so long and the system against entropy is still in place.

Seems to me the TV series was far more depressing.

[Liamv2]

A good way to put it is.

Spoiler

The original ending has the sorrow split between multiple people while rebellion has only one person take it all.

[Dr.Fumbles]

Not enough GIFS here.

[LPPrince]

Not enough GIFS here.

 

[Isichar]

A good way to put it is.

Spoiler

The original ending has the sorrow split between multiple people while rebellion has only one person take it all.

Spoiler

Eh I can't say multiple character deaths and 1 character getting their entire life wiped from existence is really better then what happened to Homura in TRS, especially considering that the person who took all the consequences at the end of TRS was happier with that then having the person she devoted her life to save getting wiped out from existence

[LPPrince]

Both endings were interesting. Given what happens to Kyubey at the end of Rebellion Story I was like

 

[Dr.Fumbles]

Yeah. My mind is still twirling from it.

[Isichar]

What happens to QB in TRS is admittedly incredibly satisfying

[LPPrince]

What happens to QB in TRS is admittedly incredibly satisfying

 

I enjoyed that enough that I'd be satisfied with that being the end of PMMM.

[Dr.Fumbles]

I enjoyed that enough that I'd be satisfied with that being the end of PMMM.

 

But but. Throwing galaxies like Frisbees...

[LPPrince]

But but. Throwing galaxies like Frisbees...

 

That's what Kyubey wants, I'd imagine. Screw him.

[Mr.House]

Fricken QB.