Raanz wrote...
Although there were more romance options in ME2, I enjoyed the ones from ME1 just a tad better. I guess the "payoff" to me seemed a bit more engaging then in ME2.
I would also support a bit more "love" for the female Shepards as well. Maybe their short list is misleading as I'm only referring to FemShep's options with "human" partners??
Maybe a FemShep player could address this issue better/
I agree with you on both points. ME1's payoff had more impact behind it. The slowly increasing personal tension, the buildup, the "let's break the rules" scene, and the pillow talk after. In ME2, it was a bit more mundane, and the "PRESS F AND HOLD TO CONTINUE" made snuggling a lot less fun than it might've been.
As to FemShep... well, ManSheps have Ash, Liara, Jack, Miranda, Tali, and Kelly; FemSheps have Kaidan, Jacob, Garrus, and Thane. But it's truly not the numbers, it's more about the quality. Only Kaidan and Thane receive a real romantic development; with Jacob and Garrus, it's more sex-oriented, and in a weird way that gave me the creeps. With Jacob, you're the cougar/pervy boss; with Garrus, it's more a friends with benefits with a turian kind of deal. I have the impression that both Miranda and Tali, their counterparts, were executed in a more fulfilling way (though I think almost everyone wished for more content with the characters in ME2 than there actually was.)
When it comes down to it, I guess Ash/ManShep was my favorite het romance in ME1, Jack/ManShep was my favorite in ME2, and Thane/FemShep was my favorite female Shepard pairing (Kaidan having no competition in the first game.) Yet, he still suffered from Carth syndrome--not that I wanted him to have no past, but it feels like a weird double standard when we receive the dead perfect wife and angsty son subplot as many times as we have, whereas a dead perfect husband (Khalid the dweeb from BG does NOT count) and angsty daughter that's still in the picture as a sidequest? Never happened (correct me if I'm wrong). Even worse when he recalls every one of his memories which could come back to haunt him at any time. Eventually it's like, "can't anyone ever just be divorced?"

So, yeah. Though I'll definitely play through and romance Kaidan and Garrus, whom I hear get a fairly large amount of content in ME3 and may well make me love the idea of them with Shepard again, I could stand to see another good male option for a FemShep. Vega looks promising there. He's not the type I tend to ogle IRL, but he's got a great voice and personality and I think there will be an interesting tension, assuming they go that route with the character.
Raanz wrote...
Playing as a female Shepard, I had a very
tough time with romancing anyone. Probably not due to story or choice,
but just because I had no motivation to do it. 
I was lucky, I think. I made my first ManShep to be the kind of guy I would want to set up a good female friend with in real life, and then Ashley and Jack turned out to be the kind of female characters that I just loved and wanted to see happy. Especially Jack, after all she went through. So romancing her was more about seeing Jack find love with someone who wouldn't hurt her than anything else--and I felt like on my first playthrough, I could get to a satisfactory understanding/friendship with Miranda and Tali, but not Jack; she pushes you away. Romancing her was therefore also a little bit about better understanding a character I loved, in a way that only seems to come out in the romance, where she doesn't shut you down as if you don't care about her even though you've never hit on her.
With my FemSheps who romance males, because I'm a female heterosexual, it feels a bit more personal to me than the other playthroughs, I must admit. But the others... I've still learned to enjoy them by knowing who that Shepard is and working out their preference for the LI in my head. It then makes me happy to see the characters come together, like the pairings in novels, tv, and movies do.
With Thane, I first experienced what others probably felt in romancing Liara. I found the thought of getting close to a fairly exotic alien character to be novel and enjoyable. Weird, but not in the unpleasant sense. But I'd love to romance Feron because he has a personal connection to Shepard, he has beautiful coloring, and he's just so clever and wry and I love his voice. (Uh, not to gush or anything, heh.) Really, even if Thane can be saved, and I will take the option if I can, I'd still like to know what it's like to romance a drell without memories of a near-idyllic love.
Modifié par Wynne, 25 janvier 2012 - 12:32 .