117 réponses à ce sujet

[Herewegoagain]

1. Noveria
2.Virmire

Bad
1.mako missions
2.Jacob LM( boring as "F")

[celuloid]

Best:

1. Noveria
2. Virmire
3. Ilos+endgame
4. Lair of the Shadow Broker
5. Samara's loyalty mission

Worst:

1. Collector ship (Prothean's fate mentioned in one sentence and never again)
2. Derelict Reaper (missed opportunity to learn something more about the Reapers, Legion should be introduced far sooner along with other squadmates, forced Collector boarding afterwards)
3. Mute planet-side missions
4. Fetch quests
5. Scanning planets

[Barquiel]

Best...

Lair of the Shadow Broker
Feros
Noveria
Ilos/Citadel
Kasumi's LM

Honourable mentions: Samara's LM, Bring Down the Sky

Worst...

Grunt's LM
Garrus' LM
Firewalker missions
Arrival

[SyyRaaaN]

Best:

1. Suicide Mission/Collector Base
2. Tali Recruitment
3. Legion LM
4. Ilos
5. Virmire

Worst:


1. Jack Recruitment
2. Jack LM
3. Feros
4. Thane LM
5. Firewalker (Should put this on top, but 2 lazy)

[tetrisblock4x1]

Noveria because role playing
Mordins loyalty
Lair
Overlord
Sovereign

And for the bad

collecting crap on random mako worlds
launching probes
jacobs
Therum
the mission to become a spectre because it was potentially an interesting centrepiece of the whole ME story given the sidequest treatment. I wanted more, but it wasn't a bad mission.

Modifié par tetrisblock4x1, 28 janvier 2012 - 12:31 .

[Rogue-Element]

Best,

- Lair of the Shadow Broker > Revealing the Shadow Broker, interesting missions and fights.
- Virmire > Great sense of urgency and risk.
- Feros > Very solid with an unexpected turn of events.
- Collector's Base > Great final mission with the exception of the final boss.
- Recruiting Tali > Very enjoyable fights + sun mechanic.

Worst,
- Arrival > Great idea, poor execution.
- Overlord > Out of the way and forgettable story line.
- Recruiting Thane > Lineair and predictable.
- Recruiting Grunt > Lineair.
- Firewalker > Uninspired filler missions.

Modifié par Rogue-Element, 28 janvier 2012 - 12:38 .

[Vapaa]

From best to worst

Best

- Suicide mission (choose wisely or you'll have losses, brilliant !)
- Lair of the shadow broker (great combats, chase scenes, Liara)
- Tali: treason (half/shooting, half talking, lots of infos about Quarians)
- Noveria (non-linear, and tough choices)
- Collector ship (first half so silent and calm *shivers*)

Worst

- Jacob LM (linearity not even hidden, debriefing at end...wut ?)
- Feros (the Mako part, the final boss: run and gun)
- Firewalker (linear, mindless shooting.....meh)
- Therum (linear, final boss, volcano world)
- Pinnacle station (piece of junk)

Modifié par Vapaä, 28 janvier 2012 - 12:37 .

[wolfsite]

Best:

- I Remember Me
- Mordin Loyalty Mission
- Conrad Verner ME2 mission (Even if it is a little glitched for Paragons)
- Project Overlord (Battle music alone makes it awesome)
- Garrus' Loyalty Mission


Worst: 

- Advanced Mako missions  (Have no problem with the Mako until really steep mountains come in)
- Rachni Bonus Missions  (Tend to feel a little Slow)
- Jacobs Loyalty Mission (Not exactly bad but it loses more from replays than other missions)
- Satellite Recovery Mission  (Side mission in feros Sector, felt mundane)
- Joker's Run  (First time it was interesting but repeat plays lessen the experience.)

[sevach]

Top
1. Battle of the Citadel, no further reasons needed.
2. Noveria, it just felt very RPG like, multiple paths, a lot of story.
3. Virmire, a lot of story, awesome mission all around.
4. Recruit Archangel, Intro to the merc bands (you will be seeing them a lot), a lot of action, a lil bit of sabotage and reunion with my buddy.
5. LOTSB on Illium, great intro, a Spectre, Azure (lol), cab fare and all around great action.
Mentions to Stolen memory (very rpg feel to it as well), Mordin's and Tali RM and Khalisah al Jilani.

Bottom
1. ME1 side missions, painfull.
2. Therum, you spend most of the time on the Mako, get out... done.
3. Firewalker, really Bioware? to add insult to injury you can't save while in the stupid thing.
4. Recruit the Warlord, feels like a lifetime...
5. Arrival, no RPG feel at all, just action.

Some LM are also pretty iffy but not enough to make the list.

[jcraft]

Best:
1. Lair of the Shadow Broker
2. Suicide Mission
3. Ilos/Battle of the Citadel (simply whole epilogue of ME1)
4. Recruitment missions on Omega (Garrus, Mordin)
5. And basically all main story missions from ME1 & ME2 and all loyalties & recruitments from ME2 (also Overlord, Zaeed, Kasumi & Arrival).

Worst:
96. N7 assignments from ME2
97. Firewalker missions
98. Uncharted Worlds from ME1 (nice vistas but boring missions)
99. more Uncharted Worlds from ME1 (boring)
100. even more Uncharted Worlds from ME1 (so damn boring...)

And special Piece of Crap of the Decade award goes to the Pinnacle Station DLC.

Modifié par jcraft, 28 janvier 2012 - 01:06 .

[Patchwork]

Best:
Ilos/the Citadel
Suicide Mission
Garrus' Recruitment
Feros
Mordin's LM

Worst:
N7/Side Missions in both games were both dull and or repetitive.
Main Illium Missions
Grunt's Recruitment
Laira's Recruitment
Freedom's Progress

[Aaleel]

Best

1) Virmire (Wrex moment, Ashley/Kaiden decision, Sovereign, Hold the line Speech, scenary, all around awesome)
2) Ilos/Battle of the Citadel (music, setting, Vigil, last dialogue with Saren, walking on the outside)
3) Lair of the Shadowbroker (multiple settings, secret of SB revealed, old school car chase through city)
4) Noveria (Asari commando fight, Rachni decision)
5) Overload

Worst

1) Thane's Loyalty Mission (Moving to next position, moving to next position, was just boring)
2) Jacob's Loyalty Mission (Just boring, the whole absentee father stereotype)
3) Firewalker missions (Pointless)

[SouthernNUFC]

Best:

• Suicide Mission (I loved the way the whole squad was involved and the choices you made had an effect on the outcome. Only problem was it was too easy to get everyone to survive)
• Ilos / Battle of the Citadel (Talking to Vigil was great and I loved the end cut scene)
• Lair of the Shadow Broker (Probably the best DLC I;ve ever played for any game. Great story, dialogue, and scenery)
• Virmire (Having to make a choice between two of your squadmates was not something I expected to happen when I played it for the first time but it really added to the mission)

[goofyomnivore]

Love:
(1) Noveria - The best experience of Mass Effect I've had yet. I'd say it is one of my favorite gaming experiences period. I love that damn planet/mission.
(2) Lair of the Shadowbroker - I wish all the companion specific missions could of had this quality. Great combat, interaction, etc.
(3) Dossier: Assassin - Great pacing from the ride up to the towers till Thane's grand entrance. Excellent combat as well.
(4) Virmire - Dialogue with Sovereign, Saren and of course the 'big choice'.
(5) Ilos/pre-Ilos - Locker scene, Anderson punching Udina, fast forward to speaking to Vigil and the urgency of getting to the Relay to stop Sovereign and Saren. The atmosphere of the planet really captured the spooky feel too.

Hate:
(1) Stolen Memory - Kasumi is a sweetheart, but her plan makes no goddamn sense. Plus the combat is buggy as hell for me, specifically the boss fight. I was left scratching my head often when it came to this mission.
(2) Suicide Mission - Combat is easy, final boss is a laugh and the consequences for your 'leadership' make very little sense. However the whole mission makes little goddamn sense from the very start till the end.
(3) Firewalker - Hammerhead sucks. No 'saving', nuff said.
(4) Therum - Just meh all around. I always do this mission first just to get it out of the way.
(5) Horizon - Questionable writing and the combat is a bit grindy.

[LegionMan]

Best (no real order)
Legion's LM (oh hey, it's actually a morally grey decision for once!)
LotSB
Ilos/Battle of the Citadel
Virmire
The N7 string of missions involving the Blue Suns/Batarians that ends with choosing between saving the spaceport or the civilians (okay, I'm cheating on this one)

Worst
Horizon (if only for the horrible railroaded dialogue at the end)
The Idenna mission (no i don't want to attack dumb AI varren like that)
Eclipse Cargo Mission (at least until I figured out to just Cain all three YMIRs at the start)
Firewalker Geth Combat (that thing barely get scratched and KABOOM)
For that matter, any Firewalker mission that wasn't in Overlord

Modifié par LegionMan, 28 janvier 2012 - 02:23 .

[Murdario]

top5

1. illium half of lair of the shadow broker
2. virmire
3. recruit thane
4. jacobs loyalty mission
5. talis loyalty mission with legion in the party

bottom 5

1. the rogue ai in moon mission
2: arrival
3. project firewalker
4. noveria
5. any unc mission

[Il Divo]

Note: This is restricted to main quest + loyalty missions, not side quests.

Best
1. Noveria.
2. Suicide Mission
3. Overlord
4. Thane's Recruitment Mission
5. Battle of the Citadel

Worst
1. Therum
2. Investigating Saren
3. Grunt's Recruitment
4. Horizon

I can't think of a fifth one I really disliked.

[Aimi]

Best
1. Dossier: Thane
2. Lair of the Shadow Broker
3. Suicide Mission
4. Dossier: Tali
5. Kasumi: Stolen Memory

Worst:
1. Noveria: Geth Interest
2. Feros: The Thorian (as distinct from Feros: Geth Attack, which was okay)
3. Dossier: The Convict
4. Race Against Time: Final Battle
5. Thane: Sins of the Father

[ProtoMan 2.0]

10 Best:
Lair of The Shadow Broker
Suicide Mission
Virmire
Battle of the Citadel
Haestrom
Bringing down the sky
Legion: A house divided
Recruit Archangel
Kasumi: Stolen Memory

[Volus Warlord]

Best:
1.) Samara recruitment... FEAR ME!
2.) Garrus recruitment
3.) Horizon
4.) Joker hobbling around the Normandy
5.) Derelict Reaper

Worst:
1.) Anything with the stupid Hammerhead
2.) Samara LM
3.) Thane LM
4.) Jack LM
5.) Moridin Recruitment

[Ryzaki]

Top 5

1. Vigil
2. Chasing Saren up the Citadel
3. Thane's recruitment
4. Legion's loyalty
5. Tali's loyalty

Bottom 5

1. Virmire (I didn't find the arbitrary sacrifice X or sacrifice Y compelling since I wanted to off both X and Y)
2. Eden Prime (too long and the only characters on it were characters I didn't like)
3. Freedom Progress (Just bleh)
4. Jack's Recruitment (Didn't like being forced into it and breaking a prisoner out of jail isn't something I find enjoyable. Plus Kuril is a pain in the ass to kill)
5. Overlord (I hate the hammerhead).