Aller au contenu

Photo

Checkmate! - The Samantha Traynor Discussion Thread [Updated 5/28/12]


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
3345 réponses à ce sujet

#926
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages
2 thumbs up Valorefane Dragonwinter

ChurchOfZod I agree. They should of had femshep start removing her clothes while walking to the shower

#927
Rikketik

Rikketik
  • Members
  • 585 messages

ChurchOfZod wrote...

I'm sure this has been covered already nut I just saw it for the first time and had to post.

A bra? In the shower? Really?

A game that allows humans to have their heads turned into must or their bodies into bloody chunks has a full grown woman take a shower in her underwear. Riiight.

I think it's understandable from BioWare point of view, especially after the controversy the first Mass Effect game generated with its sex scenes. But I agree that it does look strange.

Then again, Traynor wanted to seduce Shepard. She could've showered naked, but maybe she thought lingerie was more enticing. I can't blame her.

#928
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages
I really should figure out how to change my forum handle because "Valorefane Dragonwinter" is just too gorram much to type. -.-

Thanks, guys. :D I'll probably tweak it as time permits. RL is kinda sh!t atm, so I've a major case of writer's block going on. That bit has been sitting on my PC for months and I just finally decided to post it and see what peeps thought.

#929
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages
*Sam walks alongside her Girlfriend, Shepard, after noticing a few people looking at them weirdly*

Sam: have you noticed people have been staring at us lately?
Shepard: Yes, Sammie, i have.
Sam: Why are they looking like they never seen a lesbian couple before
Vega: yo, Lola. hey there Checkmate.
Shepard: James do you know why people are staring at Sam and I weirdly today?
Vega: you mean, you ladies did not post the video on the extranet?
Sam: What video?
Vega: well, someone posted a video of you two being...intimate earlier today and...
Shepard: LIARA!!!! YOU BETTER TAKE THAT VIDEO DOWN THIS INSTANCE OR I WILL TEAR YOU APART! THEN THROW THE REST OF YOU OUT THE AIRLOCK!!
*Shepard storms after liara. Samantha follows right after her*

Modifié par draken-heart, 11 juin 2012 - 03:18 .


#930
MugenJustice

MugenJustice
  • Members
  • 198 messages
Nicely written, Valorefane Dragonwinter.


I didn't really have a problem with Sam showering in her underwear (sure, it would've made much more sense if BioWare implied that she was naked, and tastefully covered it up. I'm thinking...lots of steam). I had more of an issue with Shepard strolling into the shower, fully clothed. Again, like themikefest said, it would make (a lot) more sense if Shepard was shown shedding her clothes on the way to the shower.

#931
Flyers215

Flyers215
  • Members
  • 256 messages

Rikketik wrote...

ChurchOfZod wrote...

I'm sure this has been covered already nut I just saw it for the first time and had to post.

A bra? In the shower? Really?

A game that allows humans to have their heads turned into must or their bodies into bloody chunks has a full grown woman take a shower in her underwear. Riiight.

I think it's understandable from BioWare point of view, especially after the controversy the first Mass Effect game generated with its sex scenes. But I agree that it does look strange.

Then again, Traynor wanted to seduce Shepard. She could've showered naked, but maybe she thought lingerie was more enticing. I can't blame her.


According to my brother, Liara's romance scene includes a bare chest, so I'm not sure how Traynor being naked would spark any controversy that Liara doesn't.

Also, I'm not a big fan of nudity in video games (or movies for that matter).  I usually feel that it is just used to show skin rather than have a purpose.  The strange push and pull of showing skin and going out of your way to avoid showing skin could easily be avoided by camera direction.  In the context of Traynor's romance scene, it's very bizarre that she would shower fully clothed.  As BioWare, the scene could've just depicted Traynor showering from the neck down.  When Shepard walks over into the shower, she could block the viewer's line of sight from seeing anything as she holds Traynor up against the shower wall.  Shepard should also disrobe to some extent rather than just going into a shower with an N7 hoodie on.  It takes away from the natural feel of the scene to show them showering in clothing.

Traynor could've also done what one of my ex-girlfriend's did.  She could take the shower while Shepard & Traynor talked and then walk out of the shower in a robe or towel after Shepard says "Oh, she's interested *sexy face*".  As Shepard sits in her chair, Traynor could walk over to her, stand in front of Shepard, and remove the towel/robe while the camera views Traynor's back.  This would avoid showing off any of Traynor's goodies while maintaining a more realistic scene.

P.S. Great piece, Valore.  I really enjoyed that.  I'll write another one sometime.  It's been a while since I've been working on an original Mass Effect piece with my own character.

Modifié par Flyers215, 11 juin 2012 - 03:52 .


#932
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages
Thanks for the feedback, everyone.  I'll try to work up some writing oomph in the near future to flesh it out a little better.

Found this on tumblr in the meantime courtesy of komichameleon:  

Posted Image

Modifié par Valorefane Dragonwinter, 11 juin 2012 - 05:54 .


#933
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...

I really should figure out how to change my forum handle because "Valorefane Dragonwinter" is just too gorram much to type. -.-

Thanks, guys. :D I'll probably tweak it as time permits. RL is kinda sh!t atm, so I've a major case of writer's block going on. That bit has been sitting on my PC for months and I just finally decided to post it and see what peeps thought.



don't change it. Thats what makes you unique

#934
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages
i may end up going for Kelly Chambers in the end, if only due to the fact that she is the only chance of a happy ending for lesbian Shepard. i still like Traynor, but the ending makes it difficult/impossible for a relationship between the two working out.

Modifié par draken-heart, 11 juin 2012 - 02:24 .


#935
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages
How sad is it that I get all :o:lol::happy::D:):kissing:<3:wub: when Alix Wilton Regan replies to one of my tweets?  LOL

#936
MugenJustice

MugenJustice
  • Members
  • 198 messages

draken-heart wrote...

i may end up going for Kelly
Chambers in the end, if only due to the fact that she is the only chance
of a happy ending for lesbian Shepard. i still like Traynor, but the
ending makes it difficult/impossible for a relationship between the two
working out.


I do not see why Kelly is the only chance of a happy ending, and I do not see why you think the ending makes it impossible for Traynor and Shepard...?

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...

How sad is it that I get all :o:lol::happy::D:):kissing:<3:wub: when Alix Wilton Regan replies to one of my tweets?  LOL


What was said?

#937
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages

MugenJustice wrote...

draken-heart wrote...

i may end up going for Kelly
Chambers in the end, if only due to the fact that she is the only chance
of a happy ending for lesbian Shepard. i still like Traynor, but the
ending makes it difficult/impossible for a relationship between the two
working out.


I do not see why Kelly is the only chance of a happy ending, and I do not see why you think the ending makes it impossible for Traynor and Shepard...?


i do not know, based on the fact that all tech was based on what the protheans left, which in turn was left by the reapers. it would take years/decades/centuries for Shepard to find her beloved Traynor again, and then it might be too late. at least with Kelly, if the endings are real (which they most likely are ,sadly) Shepard would have her love interest nearby and could visit her whenever...

#938
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages

MugenJustice wrote...

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...
How sad is it that I get all :o:lol::happy::D:):kissing:<3:wub: when Alix Wilton Regan replies to one of my tweets?  LOL

What was said?

Just talking about a random 80's song.  hehe


draken-heart wrote...
i do not know, based on the fact that
all tech was based on what the protheans left, which in turn was left by
the reapers. it would take years/decades/centuries for Shepard to find
her beloved Traynor again, and then it might be too late. at least with
Kelly, if the endings are real (which they most likely are ,sadly)
Shepard would have her love interest nearby and could visit her
whenever...

I'd go for Liara over Kelly, if Traynor was out of the picture.  But I think (fingers crossed here) that Bioware is gonna pull their heads outta their collective arse and fix the ending.  If Shepard lives, he/she will be able to reunite with the LI and have lots of cozy time.

Modifié par Valorefane Dragonwinter, 11 juin 2012 - 04:03 .


#939
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages
^ if femshep can't get back with sam, then why have the relationship in the first place. It would be unfair if other LIS can be reunited and not sams

#940
Flyers215

Flyers215
  • Members
  • 256 messages

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...

I'd go for Liara over Kelly, if Traynor was out of the picture.  But I think (fingers crossed here) that Bioware is gonna pull their heads outta their collective arse and fix the ending.  If Shepard lives, he/she will be able to reunite with the LI and have lots of cozy time.


I like the ending and hope that they don't change it.  Shepard died like a true hero and it was time for her story to end.  It'd be nice to reunite with Sam and the gang, but not everything has a happy ending.

#941
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages

Flyers215 wrote...

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...
I'd go for Liara over Kelly, if Traynor was out of the picture.  But I think (fingers crossed here) that Bioware is gonna pull their heads outta their collective arse and fix the ending.  If Shepard lives, he/she will be able to reunite with the LI and have lots of cozy time.

I like the ending and hope that they don't change it.  Shepard died like a true hero and it was time for her story to end.  It'd be nice to reunite with Sam and the gang, but not everything has a happy ending.

I wouldn't have had a problem with Shepard dying if it wasn't for the whole last ten minutes.  Worst. Writing. Ever.  You don't introduce a completely new plot in the last portion of a story, it's just horrible writing.

And there is no way IN HELL that Shepard would've taken what the little Starbrat said without questioning it like s/he did.  That's so out of character, it makes my brain hurt.

That's why I think Bioware has something up their sleeve.  They've never written such utter nonsensical crap before, why would they start now? 

#942
Rikketik

Rikketik
  • Members
  • 585 messages

Flyers215 wrote...
According to my brother, Liara's romance scene includes a bare chest, so I'm not sure how Traynor being naked would spark any controversy that Liara doesn't.

Also, I'm not a big fan of nudity in video games (or movies for that matter).  I usually feel that it is just used to show skin rather than have a purpose.  The strange push and pull of showing skin and going out of your way to avoid showing skin could easily be avoided by camera direction.  In the context of Traynor's romance scene, it's very bizarre that she would shower fully clothed.  As BioWare, the scene could've just depicted Traynor showering from the neck down.  When Shepard walks over into the shower, she could block the viewer's line of sight from seeing anything as she holds Traynor up against the shower wall.  Shepard should also disrobe to some extent rather than just going into a shower with an N7 hoodie on.  It takes away from the natural feel of the scene to show them showering in clothing.

Traynor could've also done what one of my ex-girlfriend's did.  She could take the shower while Shepard & Traynor talked and then walk out of the shower in a robe or towel after Shepard says "Oh, she's interested *sexy face*".  As Shepard sits in her chair, Traynor could walk over to her, stand in front of Shepard, and remove the towel/robe while the camera views Traynor's back.  This would avoid showing off any of Traynor's goodies while maintaining a more realistic scene.

I think I actually saw one of Liara's nipples during the romance scene, although it was only visible for a second. So okay, maybe BioWare did include some nudity, but I think they just want to play it safe most of the time.

And I think the first romance scene with Traynor would've been a lot better if they did it as you describe in your post. Although I wouldn't let Shepard sit on her chair and Traynor removing the towel herself. Instead, Shepard should walk up to Traynor, kiss her and remove the towel herself. The screen can then cut to them lying on the bed, smoking a cigarette.

#943
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages

*Sam walks alongside her Girlfriend, Shepard, after noticing a few people looking at them weirdly*

Sam: have you noticed people have been staring at us lately?
Shepard: Yes, Sammie, i have.
Sam: Why are they looking like they never seen a lesbian couple before
Vega: yo, Lola. hey there Checkmate.
Shepard: James do you know why people are staring at Sam and I weirdly today?
Vega: you mean, you ladies did not post the video on the extranet?
Sam: What video?
Vega: well, someone posted a video of you two being...intimate earlier today and...
Shepard: LIARA!!!! YOU BETTER TAKE THAT VIDEO DOWN THIS INSTANCE OR I WILL TEAR YOU APART! THEN THROW THE REST OF YOU OUT THE AIRLOCK!!
*Shepard storms after liara. Samantha follows right after her*


Liara: okay, i got the video off the extranet, but whoever posted it covered their tracks well, i could not find a source.
Shepard: WELL KEEP LOOKING, WHOEVER POSTED IT KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT PRIVACY!!
Sam: Shepard my love, calm down
Shepard: CALM DOWN! YOU SHOULD BE GETTING UPSET! OUR PRIVATE LIFE IS JUST THAT, PRIVATE!!!
Sam: Dear, i am angry, but shouting is not going to help the situation.
Shepard: right, sorry, i just lose my cool when things like this happen.
Sam: it is alright. now, lets get off this ship and go somewhere nice. you could do all sorts of things to me then...
Shepard: Dear i love the way you think...
*Shepard and Sam leave to spend some time together*

Modifié par draken-heart, 11 juin 2012 - 08:48 .


#944
Valorefane Dragonwinter

Valorefane Dragonwinter
  • Members
  • 346 messages
Sums it up pretty well about the ending, in my opinion. I know I was full of WTF for the last twenty minutes of the game.
Just me randomly ranting.  :pinched:


Posted Image

Modifié par Valorefane Dragonwinter, 11 juin 2012 - 10:02 .


#945
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages
[quote]Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...

[quote]Flyers215 wrote...
[quote]Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...
I'd go for Liara over Kelly, if Traynor was out of the picture.  But I think (fingers crossed here) that Bioware is gonna pull their heads outta their collective arse and fix the ending.  If Shepard lives, he/she will be able to reunite with the LI and have lots of cozy time.
[/quote]
I like the ending and hope that they don't change it.  Shepard died like a true hero and it was time for her story to end.  It'd be nice to reunite with Sam and the gang, but not everything has a happy ending.
[/quote]
I wouldn't have had a problem with Shepard dying if it wasn't for the whole last ten minutes.  Worst. Writing. Ever.  You don't introduce a completely new plot in the last portion of a story, it's just horrible writing.

And there is no way IN HELL that Shepard would've taken what the little Starbrat said without questioning it like s/he did.  That's so out of character, it makes my brain hurt.

That's why I think Bioware has something up their sleeve.  They've never written such utter nonsensical crap before, why would they start now? 

Bioware has been very quiet about any thing  to do with ec(not sure if good or bad)and no rellease date yet, I do also beleive they may have something big up their sleeve.

#946
Flyers215

Flyers215
  • Members
  • 256 messages

Valorefane Dragonwinter wrote...

I wouldn't have had a problem with Shepard dying if it wasn't for the whole last ten minutes.  Worst. Writing. Ever.  You don't introduce a completely new plot in the last portion of a story, it's just horrible writing.

And there is no way IN HELL that Shepard would've taken what the little Starbrat said without questioning it like s/he did.  That's so out of character, it makes my brain hurt.

That's why I think Bioware has something up their sleeve.  They've never written such utter nonsensical crap before, why would they start now? 


I really didn't have a problem with it other than the part with the Normandy.  Everything else was explained and made sense.  Shepard was told that she had to make a choice, so she did.  The end.

Either way, we'll both just have to wait and see what BioWare's cooking up in Edmonton.

#947
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages
draken-heart. nice.curious who the culprit is?

#948
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages

themikefest wrote...

draken-heart. nice.curious who the culprit is?


may have it be EDI, she seems like the type to mess w/Shepard in a friendly-i-love-you kind of way. or Liara to get back at Sam for Taking Shepard off the Market.

#949
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages

draken-heart wrote...

*Sam walks alongside her Girlfriend, Shepard, after noticing a few people looking at them weirdly*

Sam: have you noticed people have been staring at us lately?
Shepard: Yes, Sammie, i have.
Sam: Why are they looking like they never seen a lesbian couple before
Vega: yo, Lola. hey there Checkmate.
Shepard: James do you know why people are staring at Sam and I weirdly today?
Vega: you mean, you ladies did not post the video on the extranet?
Sam: What video?
Vega: well, someone posted a video of you two being...intimate earlier today and...
Shepard: LIARA!!!! YOU BETTER TAKE THAT VIDEO DOWN THIS INSTANCE OR I WILL TEAR YOU APART! THEN THROW THE REST OF YOU OUT THE AIRLOCK!!
*Shepard storms after liara. Samantha follows right after her*


Liara: okay, i got the video off the extranet, but whoever posted it covered their tracks well, i could not find a source.
Shepard: WELL KEEP LOOKING, WHOEVER POSTED IT KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT PRIVACY!!
Sam: Shepard my love, calm down
Shepard: CALM DOWN! YOU SHOULD BE GETTING UPSET! OUR PRIVATE LIFE IS JUST THAT, PRIVATE!!!
Sam: Dear, i am angry, but shouting is not going to help the situation.
Shepard: right, sorry, i just lose my cool when things like this happen.
Sam: it is alright. now, lets get off this ship and go somewhere nice. you could do all sorts of things to me then...
Shepard: Dear i love the way you think...
*Shepard and Sam leave to spend some time together*

The finale-part one is here.

Shepard: Liara, you said you found out who the culprit is for the video.
Liara: Culprits, actually. But yes, i have.
Sam: so who posted it?
Liara: ..., Joker and EDI may have done it as a joke, since it was posted from the bridge from Joker's electonic mail account.
Shepard: WHAT?! I THOUGHT EDI CARED FOR MY PRIVACY!!!
Sam: Shepard, dear. *squeesing Shepard's hand*
Shepard: You are right, sorry.

*Three minutes later*
Joker: huh? oh, hi Sammie, Commander, what's up
Sam: you know very well what's up Lieutenant Moreau. *glaring at Joker*
Joker: but i-what i meanis-oh fine. yes, EDI and i posted that vid of you two onto the extranet.
EDI: it was only meant as a joke, and to help you  two become more of a couple
Shepard: You know what i do to people who mess with me Joker...
Joker: oh [joker's favorite curse word] *Shepard punches Joker in the face, giving him a black eye. then breaks his legs*
Sam: *while walking away* Wasn't that a little excessive, dear?
Shepard: Maybe....

Modifié par draken-heart, 11 juin 2012 - 11:57 .


#950
themikefest

themikefest
  • Members
  • 21 635 messages
^nice. Whats to be done about edi?