176 réponses à ce sujet

[K_Tabris]

Admittedly, playing a renegade is fun. My favorite Shepard is a renegade.  I love watching her blaze through the game, without a thought or consideration for some of her actions (while others, are carefully calculated, but that is another topic).

However, as much fun playing a renegade can be, some choices available seem very out of place, or too cold, and incredibly awkward.

My top five are:

1) Executing Shiala
2) Punching the reporter
3)Sleeping with Morinth
4) leaving Zaeed behind on his loyalty mission
5) electrocuting the Batarian on Garrus' recruitment mission


What are your top five?

[exskeeny]

I personally think that electrocuting the Batarian is the epitomy of the renegade actions. In one callous execution you instantly help your own cause.

[SNascimento]

I don't think any of those are out of places.

[Hjklop]

how was electrocuting the Batarian out of place it gave a good tactical advantage anyway..
1)killing Shiala
2)punching the reporter
3)telling the maintenance guy there was a bomb
4)cutting off the council
5)giving TIM the collector base (ohh edgy)

[Dave of Canada]

1) Shepard taking bribes, any bribes at all.
2) Calling out the Asari hostage taker as being a stripper (instead of intimidating her... which is what the paragon option is)

[mineralica]

In no particular order:

1. Forcing sedative on Talitha EDIT: or killing her. Never killed her, forgot about existense of such option
2. Sending crew on SM back without escort
3. Selling Legion to Cerberus
4. Punching reporter
5. Killing colonists on Feros

Modifié par mineralica, 05 février 2012 - 06:01 .

[Feanor_II]

1 Killing the Colonists on Feros
2 Sleeping with Morinth
3 Accepting any bribe

[Dave of Canada]

darkness reborn wrote...

Its more fun to wound the hostage.

John Shepard: "Your forgetting something (forget name).... I WAS a  Spectre to!"
[Shots hostage]
Fun Times!

That's what I do if I don't have the points for the first option (sounds absolutely sinister for a "paragon" option, especially if you killed the Rachni and the Council).

[ratzerman]

1: Punching the reporter in ME1
2: Punching the reporter in ME2
3: Executing Shiala
4: Saving Morinth
5: Handing Veetor over to Cerberus

[Hunter of Legends]

Mine would be
1. Roughing up Mouse
2. Letting the salarian die
3. Letting the stranded girl die on Jacobs LM
4. Saving Morinth
5. Not liking the AI on your ship.

[wirelesstkd]

I think, in general, a lot of the dialogue options really cross the line. It fine to be a dick when talking to a Batarian slaver, but when dealing with your own crew you shouldn't be so harsh. But the things that Shepard says to his crew should have him losing loyalty before he ever gets it. It's nuts.

I suppose action that really springs to mind for me as out of place is in convincing Harrot to crush Ken. "I shall crush the Quarian child." Hilarious line, but overly evil.

Interestingly, I think some of the actions shouldn't be "renegade" specifically. Electrocuting the Batarian on Garrus' recruitment is one of them. Doing that weakens the gunship for later battle. Another example is in the same mission when you have mech in your sights and you snipe it. How is that considered "renegade" ??? It's coming to kill you. And it's a mech. It you don't snipe it there, when the cut scene is over you sill have to kill it. Sheesh.

[TexasToast712]

 Batarians are scum. I felt no remorse in electrocuting him to death with a cattle prod.

[Bleachrude]

wirelesstkd wrote...

I think, in general, a lot of the dialogue options really cross the line. It fine to be a dick when talking to a Batarian slaver, but when dealing with your own crew you shouldn't be so harsh. But the things that Shepard says to his crew should have him losing loyalty before he ever gets it. It's nuts.

I suppose action that really springs to mind for me as out of place is in convincing Harrot to crush Ken. "I shall crush the Quarian child." Hilarious line, but overly evil.

Interestingly, I think some of the actions shouldn't be "renegade" specifically. Electrocuting the Batarian on Garrus' recruitment is one of them. Doing that weakens the gunship for later battle. Another example is in the same mission when you have mech in your sights and you snipe it. How is that considered "renegade" ??? It's coming to kill you. And it's a mech. It you don't snipe it there, when the cut scene is over you sill have to kill it. Sheesh.

Another one is letting the krogan talk and talk and TALK.

You're going to have to kill him ANYWAY so why is it renegade to kill him earlier?

[Chewin]

darkness reborn wrote...
Its more fun to wound the hostage.

John Shepard: "Your forgetting something (forget name).... I WAS a  Spectre to!"
[Shots hostage]
Fun Times!

Makes more sense to me if he says "I'm a spectre too". What does it matter if Shepard was a spectre?

Or am I missing the bigger picture?

[Dave of Canada]

Chewin3 wrote...

Makes more sense to me if he says "I'm a spectre too". What does it matter if Shepard was a spectre?

Or am I missing the bigger picture?

He says "was" if he isn't reinstated.

[Chewin]

Dave of Canada wrote...
He says "was" if he isn't reinstated.

I know that. I'm just arguing that it doesn't make sense him saying he used to be a spectre imo.

[JoeLaTurkey]

I've never been okay with killing Talitha or Shiala.

[Barquiel]

Killing Shiala
Punching Khalisah al-Jilani
Killing Rana Thanoptis
Refusing spectre reinstatement
"Let the council die"

[Dave of Canada]

Chewin3 wrote...

Dave of Canada wrote...
He says "was" if he isn't reinstated.

I know that. I'm just arguing that it doesn't make sense him saying he used to be a spectre imo.

Oh, being tired made me read your post differently. >.<