184 réponses à ce sujet

[JBONE27]

Personally, I'm planing on intentionally killing Jacob, and inadvertantly killing Grunt and Legion (those are just for me some time, so that I can easily finish my second playthough on my second 360).

[Golden Owl]

I can't even do that with my Renegade....as much as I may dislike some characters, or see them as possible trouble for Shep in ME3, I can't intentionally wipe them out.

[Fidget6]

In all of my playthroughs I always know exactly who I plan on dying for that playthrough and how they'll die. A suicide mission where no one dies just doesn't work for me.

My first canon import for ME3 has the following dead:

Ashley
Garrus
Legion
Grunt
Miranda
Jacob

Modifié par Fidget6, 09 février 2012 - 08:21 .

[mybudgee]

No, just unintentionally

[John Locke N7]

jacob and legion

[Knightly_BW]

Yep. Doing it for RPG reasons or in one case getting rid of annoying squadmates.

My renegade Shep is pro-human and he finished ME2 with only human squad (Jack, Jacob, Miranda, Zaeed and Normandy Crew).
My looser Shep will finish game with only Garrus and Legion (he will loose his LI Tali just like he lost Ash on ME 1)
My main will kill Tali and Jacob on my current final run. (Don't like them and I can't bear being squadmates with Tali on my main again)

I am very excited to see how each one will play due to different choices in game (like selling Legion to Cerberus, handing out base to Cerberus or leaving Grunt in his tube).

[ItsFreakinJesus]

On my last playthrough, I purposely killed off Thane, Samara, and Zaeed. Kasumi died, too, but I fixed that via the save editor.

[jeweledleah]

everyone, at least once.

for science.

however, both my semi canon imports have everyone who can be saved - alive.

[KotorEffect3]

No I am a perfectionist when it comes to the SM. Though in 1 playthrough I did sell Legion to cerberus.

[Fidget6]

KotorEffect3 wrote...

No I am a perfectionist when it comes to the SM.

Boooo, that's no fun.

[Fidget6]

ItsFreakinJesus wrote...

On my last playthrough, I purposely killed off Thane, Samara, and Zaeed.

Glad I'm not the only one who plans out who he's gonna kill ahead of time. 

[instantdeath999]

I think the first time I play ME3, I'm going for the happy, optimistic ending; everyone gets out alive. On subsequent play throughs, I may go for a darker story.

[Han Shot First]

I got everyone through alive on my first and canon playthrough.

I would have preferred it if I had a few casualties along the way, as I think that makes for a more dramatic, interesting, and realistic story. But I can't metagame squad mate deaths particularly if it comes at the expense of making Shepard and incompetent combat leader. The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Hopefully in ME3 some squad mate deaths occur even when Shepard makes the right tactical decision, or even because of it.

[BloodyTalon]

I sorta got Conrad killed.

[ItsFreakinJesus]

Fidget6 wrote...

ItsFreakinJesus wrote...

On my last playthrough, I purposely killed off Thane, Samara, and Zaeed.

Glad I'm not the only one who plans out who he's gonna kill ahead of time. 

I only did it on my last game because out of the files I'm carrying over, I only have one game where people died.  I needed another.

[Juha81FIN]

Even on regular missions when my squadmembers died I would have to load again, I have propably used medigel only once. I never went so far as to kill anyone of the squadmembers intentionally, for me it would be like I had failed somehow, gameover. When I have to choose Morinth over Samara in renegade playthroughs... it's a sick choise but I can deal with it.

Modifié par Juha81FIN, 09 février 2012 - 09:03 .

[instantdeath999]

Han Shot First wrote...
The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Not necesserily; I think the death of the squad leader when sealing the door is quite dramatic.  I actually thought that Grunt, Thane and Zaaed would have made decent squad leaders, though the game apparently disagreed.  It can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, rather than a tactical blunder.  

Still, first playthrough I'm going with everyone alive, since I want to see everyones potential role in ME3.  

[bucyrus5000]

Jacob
for the prize

[Kidd]

I'm planning on letting several characters die on my final Shep. Don't know who dies where exactly and why (only know how to make sure nobody dies), nor do I want to know. I'll see what happens =) Hopefully that character's LI won't die, but hey, if it happens then it happens. Tragedy is what I'm going for in that playthrough any way x)

[bucyrus5000]

instantdeath999 wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...
The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Not necesserily; I think the death of the squad leader when sealing the door is quite dramatic.  I actually thought that Grunt, Thane and Zaaed would have made decent squad leaders, though the game apparently disagreed.  It can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, rather than a tactical blunder.  

Still, first playthrough I'm going with everyone alive, since I want to see everyones potential role in ME3.  

I was thinking my 1st run through I should try without importing ME/ME2 saves to see the game from the newbs perspective.

[instantdeath999]

bucyrus5000 wrote...

instantdeath999 wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...
The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Not necesserily; I think the death of the squad leader when sealing the door is quite dramatic.  I actually thought that Grunt, Thane and Zaaed would have made decent squad leaders, though the game apparently disagreed.  It can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, rather than a tactical blunder.  

Still, first playthrough I'm going with everyone alive, since I want to see everyones potential role in ME3.  

I was thinking my 1st run through I should try without importing ME/ME2 saves to see the game from the newbs perspective.

I don't know, they seemed to actively punish you for that in ME2.  I think one of the best parts of the series is the continuity, too.  

However, it could be cool to do the newbs perspective first, and then see it with an imported file, to see how much truly changes. 

[bucyrus5000]

instantdeath999 wrote...

bucyrus5000 wrote...

instantdeath999 wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...
The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Not necesserily; I think the death of the squad leader when sealing the door is quite dramatic.  I actually thought that Grunt, Thane and Zaaed would have made decent squad leaders, though the game apparently disagreed.  It can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, rather than a tactical blunder.  

Still, first playthrough I'm going with everyone alive, since I want to see everyones potential role in ME3.  

I was thinking my 1st run through I should try without importing ME/ME2 saves to see the game from the newbs perspective.

I don't know, they seemed to actively punish you for that in ME2.  I think one of the best parts of the series is the continuity, too.  

However, it could be cool to do the newbs perspective first, and then see it with an imported file, to see how much truly changes. 

that is what I was thinking. So I can make informed changes to my playthroughs, based on things I like. Conrad or no conrad? Old LI or fresh LI? Wrex or no Wrex...

Modifié par bucyrus5000, 09 février 2012 - 09:14 .

[Fidget6]

bucyrus5000 wrote...

instantdeath999 wrote...

bucyrus5000 wrote...

instantdeath999 wrote...

Han Shot First wrote...
The only way to lose squad mates on the suicide mission for Shepard to either make tactical blunders or to not prepare adequately for the final battle.

Not necesserily; I think the death of the squad leader when sealing the door is quite dramatic.  I actually thought that Grunt, Thane and Zaaed would have made decent squad leaders, though the game apparently disagreed.  It can be seen as a heroic sacrifice, rather than a tactical blunder.  

Still, first playthrough I'm going with everyone alive, since I want to see everyones potential role in ME3.  

I was thinking my 1st run through I should try without importing ME/ME2 saves to see the game from the newbs perspective.

I don't know, they seemed to actively punish you for that in ME2.  I think one of the best parts of the series is the continuity, too.  

However, it could be cool to do the newbs perspective first, and then see it with an imported file, to see how much truly changes. 

that is what I was thinking. So I can make informed changes to my playthroughs, based on things I like. Conrad or no conrad? Old LI or fresh LI? Wrex or no Wrex...

Well, if ME2 is any indicator, a no-import game will have no LI and no Wrex. 

[Sikelcell]

I've been working on my ME2 save for a few days now. I still have a long ways to go, but I'll be mulling over the idea of killing Jacob. Probably send him in the vents. He wanted to go anyway...

[DayusMakhina]

I have, all my deaths were intentional.

Soldier - None
Vanguard - None
Infiltrator - None
Sentinel - Tali, Thane, Legion (was sold), Kasumi, Zaeed
Adept - Miranda, Jacob, Mordin, Garrus, Grunt (never let out of tank), Jack, Tali, Thane, Legion (was sold), Kasumi.
Engineer - Garrus, Grunt (never let out of tank), Jack